New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Tool needs

Posts

Re: Tool needs

#26

Re: Any of us of course...

cstanford

Read the whole progression of posts and you'll understand.

Re: Tool needs

#27

You can't hurry skill....

roger lance

no you just have to wait....

skill don't come easy....

its a game of give and take....

you can't hurry skill....

you just have to wait....

you gotta trust, give it time....

no matter how long it takes....

Re: Tool needs

#28

Re: Good heavens!

cstanford

Lucky for you they're mostly pictures -- you won't have to exert yourself by having to read. Having to sound out each word under one's breath can be awfully fatiguing I'm told.

Re: Tool needs

#29

Re: Good one, Charles ....

Bruce McCrory

No, it's Bill's fault. He did the original post. ;)

Re: Tool needs

#30

Re: Tool needs

Tom

"Steve Hamilton could make perfect dovetails with a hack saw"

Anyone can make perfect dovetails with a hack saw, who can otherwise make them. A hacksaw is better than 90% of the saws out there, and "all" of the saws available pre Independence. Japan aside, which is reasonable enough since most of the saws sold around here were crosscut Dozukis until about the same period. Just be careful, the blade of a hacksaw can get very hot. It is also my preferred tool for freehand cutting frets on a guitar.

I copied the tool list off the college of the redwoods site when it first came up. Of course the shop there has most of the power tools one needs, and their approach has it's limitations. But it still serves the purpose of a minimal list.

I prefer hammer veneering to other methods, for one offs. It's fast, easy, and better long term. I had the advantage of picking up vac veneering before it was known in woodworking circles since boatbuilders got onto it a long time before furniture guys. But I rarely see the need for it for household sized projects. It is fun though. I guess that is part of the trap. Both are exciting, which is a consideration beyond the practical.

Another thing is the whole skills thing. There are a lot of very minimally talented very good professional woodworkers out there. They do one thing well, and quite possibly by the most expedient and least skilled way. As an amateur I buy tools to try them out and "master" them. There isn't much practical utility over the short run to that. And as long as it may take to set up a business and get a following, if ever one does, it is normally a short run thing, compared to 40 years in a hobby. It is like fly fishing, I have tied and exhibited a lot of different flies, but a lot of fishing trips only see a wooly bugger hit the water. It is good to know why one isn't fishing the other hundreds of flies one carries, which is a product of a wider experience. Two people in the same river fishing the same fly may be having a completely different experience over the whole thing.

One of my first jobs was retail in a climbing store. In the 70s, people in climbing stores were most likely to try to talk you out of a purchase, they were so commercially adverse. I remember one truth telling pep-talk the manager gave us in which he affirmed that the people who come to our shop actually wanted to buy stuff, and we weren't really doing them any favour protecting our integrity and pushing them out of the store. I overheard some Harley guys at a gun store say that he had just spent 6K on chrome doo dahs for his bike. I pretty sure it probably didn't add anything positive to the look. Imagine what you could get for 6K even at a place like Japan Woodworker, etc... And it would be a lifetime purchase. The longer you put it off, the less time you have to use it.

All that said, there is a certain level of toolage that takes over one's life in a non-positive way. And I long since reached it. I wonder what the next level is. I suspect it is something like the whole heap shifts and crushes one...

Re: Tool needs

#31

Re: Good one, Charles ....

roger lance

"Wind them up and let's see who spins the fastest!"

Turns out, it was Charles with 11 posts in a row. That's got to be a new record.

Re: Tool needs

#32

Oh, please, can we calm down here?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Trading ideas, and criticisms of each other's ideas moves the conversation forward. Demonstrating that you can up the personal harshness levels doesn't.

Re: Tool needs

#33

Fettling a new tool more trouble than it's worth

GolfSteve in Calgary

At some point fettling a new tool is more work that just doing the job with your existing tools.

Once I reached that point, my tool acquisition phase ground to a halt.

Re: Tool needs

#34

Re: Good one, Charles ....

david weaver

Derek could give us a clinical analysis. There's probably enough for a diagnosis just in that one stretch.

Re: Tool needs

#35

Re: The harley guys...

david weaver

..My first job, another employee was boasting to me that they had spent more on accessories than they spent on the bike.

Unless there's something I don't know, most things return dollar for dollar at the highest rate when they are stock or left close to stock.

Actually, it took me a little bit of time to figure out that they were boasting, not being in the harley crowd, I mistook the comment for them saying they spent more on repairs than the cost of the bike, but that wasn't the case at that time.

Re: Tool needs

#36

Re: And there's more...

david weaver

...you have to do something with the old tool, or put it somewhere. I usually make my call based on whether or not I want to go to the effort to sell another tool, which is a multi-step process (though one I can usually do when I'm too tired to work wood, anyway, or when kid duty has me tied away from my shop).

I am to the same point you describe, though there are gobs of tools I'd like to make.

A lot of those could be bought, but I'm not satisfied with the cost of buying, because my own personal labor rate as a substitute is pretty high - especially considering that building tools is pleasant.

Re: Tool needs

#37

Moses Yoder

Re:I could, with a coping saw and chisel

Moses Yoder

You didn't put any limitation on time.

Re: Tool needs

#38

Re: The harley guys...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

What I find interesting about the Harley thing is that there's another, older Harley tradition that minimizes flash. Some years back, I saw a pretty well perfect expression of that tradition when we were on vacation in the mountains. Flat black paint, simple black leather sidebags. The only shiny thing on the whole bike were the oil slicks from the various leaks on the mechanicals, and even those were kinda dusty. I personally found it far more attractive than the chrome wagons.

Re: Tool needs

#39

Re: The harley guys...

Tom

+1, though it a well known approach and so manipulated just as much as the chrome. I bought a set of chisels that had the hammer marks left in. They were much straighter, and less tourist than another much prettier set I was originally drawn to, but I still knew I was being played. I guess that is part of the fun.

Re: Tool needs

#40

Re: not so

Tom

CNC is like running a printer to make a letter. If you did the design on the computer, which makes sense if one is using a plan, then the CNC part is an obvious thing. I am constantly irritated by the fact that I have the code in the machine, but can't get it out. I do hate routers though.

Do people want it, maybe not. But it's hand made by modern standards I am guessing. :)

Re: Tool needs

#41

Re: Any of us of course...

Tom

I think one difference with woodworking is that it is after all a lower art form. The expectation is that one could be world class at the execution end of it, if one underwent an apprenticeship. And the raw material for that apprenticeship is a mater of heredity. A pianist is another mater entirely. A few great ones are born every generation, and many others can reach a decent standard, but it is still a far more difficult thing than woodworking. Some people seem to lack a knack for music, but anyone can learn to saw a straight line.

Re: Tool needs

#42

Re: Tool needs 

Kees

This is one of the first woodworking projects I made, with most of the tools used in the process. I must confess to have borrowed a router for the panel grooves.

Since that little box I aquired a "few" more tools. But when working on a project I probably only use a tenth of all the tools I own. In other words, being a tool hoarder doesn't increase your productivity. You only loose time on tool maintenance. But who said this hobby is about productivity?


img

Re: Tool needs

#43

Re: much prefer...

david weaver

...the older bikes, especially without all of the stuff. I do really like those, though I'm not much of a motorcycle guy. English, american, whatever, the old bikes without all of the gingerbread look cooler, all the way down to the valve covers that look less modern and more genuine.

I'd bet most of the folks who buy piles of chrome wouldn't be able to do much work on their own bikes, though, and the older ones probably require that.

I do understand the business side of it, though. You have to sell the bikes to the people who have money, and give them what they think they want or they'll take their money and go to someone who will.

Re: Tool needs

#44

A furniture maker and his tools ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

While it is infinitely more inspiring what Eugene Landon did with his tools, he certainly had a few ...


... including a couple of Holteys, amongst many others ..

This is from FWW Issue #174 ..


As far as I am concerned, it is not about having many tools. Whom am I to say what one should or should not have? It is not even important what you do with them. It's just a hobby.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tool needs

#45

Re: Fettling a new tool more trouble than it's wor

cstanford

Yup.

Re: Tool needs

#46

Re: Good one, Charles ....

cstanford

Roger, I would have posted the actual pictures all in one post but this surely must be the most cumbersome forum on the internet for posting pictures, antiquated comes to mind. At one time I had a "profile" that would have allowed this (maybe?) but I can no longer access it for some reason - bad password or whatever. Too much bother to create another.

In retrospect, I should have posted all eleven or so LINKS as a list in one post using tiny URL or something similar.

The posts were simply a reminder of what was possible a couple or three hundred years ago and how much those efforts are valued in today's currency.

That's all.

No intentional new 'Woodcentral record' or clinical diagnosis needed, maybe just different forum software or a link to another link, or why bother next time.

Re: Tool needs

#47

Re: A furniture maker and his tools ...

Kees

Wow, what a shop!

Never show this to a beginner. They might be too humbled to ever start working wood.

Re: Tool needs

#48

Re: Good one, Charles ....

roger lance

Charles....my apologies for my comment....just having a little fun with the situation....contact Bill Houghton about your profile/password....he should be able to help you with that....and people said that anyone here could make that furniture, well I confess I'm not up to it....I'm a practitioner of the KISS principle for good reason.

Re: Tool needs

#49

Disagree

Ron Harper

Recently began to play a guitar. Takes a little bit of manual dexterity and some desire. The same two ingredients required to become a cabinet maker. Want to and the perserverance that want to produces are the keys to both.

There is a level that cannot be learned. It is achieved through pure talent. A good coach can produce very good basketball players out of young men with some desire. Only God can produce LeBron James.

Re: Tool needs

#50

Bingo