New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

Posts

Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#1

Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

John Pappas

Congratulations on having your write-up on Line & Berry included in the current issue.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#2

Attaboy Bill


Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#4

Congratulations on a well-deserved

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

recognition!

Line and berry is such a distinctive style. Could you enlighten us a bit as to where the style originated. Where are the antecedents? Is line and berry found in the Old World as well.

From what I can gather quickly, there were Finns, Swedes, and English living in the Delaware Valley prior to 1682, when Wm. Penn founded the first three counties, one of them being Chester. Do I understand correctly there was a Welsh District in eastern Chester Co.? And that Lancaster Co. was carved from western Chester Co. in the 1700's?

Please enlighten us as to where this style came from, and is it still being practiced anywhere?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#5

Re:Hats off to you Bill!!!!


Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#6

Welsh settlement

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think that most scholars trace the line and berry motif to Welsh antecedents in the 17th century. In Pennsylvania the Southern Chester County seems to be the center for this style.

The Welsh Tract was in northern Chester County, roughly along what is now the Main Line, with communities like Merion, Haverford, Bryn Mawr and Tredyffrin. It also included a part of Philadelphia County which is now in Montgomery County. The Welsh had hopes for a self-governing area where they would preserve their language and culture, but this did not really materialize. In the late 17th century the Welsh were settling in many areas west of Philadelphia that were not in the tract.

I grew up in Newtown Square (then Chester County), which was settled around 1690 by three Welsh families, but was not in the Tract. The township I live in here in Lancaster County was named for a district in Wales. Yes, Lancaster Co. was once part of Chester, as was everything else to the west.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#7

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

Larry Wyatt

Way t go, Bill! Congratulations!!

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

congratulations Bill

Jack Guzman from Maine

Nice to see "one our own" featured in the magazine.---Jack

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#10

Well done Bill.....but we all really want....

roger lance

to know.....what tools are you going to get for your prize ??

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#11

answers

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

First, I don't devote much time to woodworking history. However, I became smitten by a chest of drawers I saw at Winterthur that was decorated with line and berry and took interest in the technique not to satisfy a historical curiosity but rather to be able to build in this style.

Lee Ellen Griffith did a PhD dissertation on this topic- "Line and Berry Inlaid Furniture" (1988) which is available from UMI, Ann Arbor MI. "Comparison of the PA inlay patterns with documented examples in Wales confirmed the Welsh origins of this tradition", according to Griffith. "Production peaked in the 1740's" in the southern townships of Chester Co.

Of the surviving pieces only three are not walnut- 2 cherry and one cedar spice box. In contrast to the urban furniture, Chester Co. drawers were often made of oak or chestnut. One of the chest of drawers I investigated at the Chester Co museum had oak drawer sides, and another poplar.

All the references I found, including a description for laying out these patterns by Huey in the December 2010 Popular Woodworking, indicated that these patterns were laid out empirically, a daunting task for a chest of drawers of ascending sizes. Some thought and experimentation revealed that these patterns could be quickly and reliably laid out off a center line of a drawer using dividers, a process that takes no more than a minute. I have not seen the final PW article, but I hope it describes this process clearly.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#12

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

wilbur

Congratulations, Bill! I haven't received my issue yet (for some reason, Popular Woodworking takes much longer to get to NJ than other parts of the country), but I look forward to reading your article.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#13

A well deserved congratulations Bill!


Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#14

Laziness prevails

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I was motivated to come up with a better way to lay out these decorations for I didn't have the stamina to do 5 drawers empirically. Huey claimed his router method faster and superior (Dec 2010 Pop. Woodworking) If layout and template making is included I'll bet I can do one of these designs faster and more reliable with hand tooling and do it with the more pleasing 0.030" stringing.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#15

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

TomD

Thanks for the heads up. I look forward to seeing that.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#16

Re: Laziness prevails

William Duffield

I found my issue at the Post Office yesterday morning. It's kind of a shame that PW used all the photos and a full article of Glen Huey's Chester County chest, and only a technical drawing of your work, especially since the work you photographed and posted here on Wood Central is technically superior, and IMHO, your pattern is more pleasing than Glen's. (Glen usually does superb work, so maybe he had a deadline and hurried his line and berry.) I think 1/16" stringing is a little too heavy for the scale of his chest.

From the photos you've posted, it's difficult to see the proportionality of your patterns. Do you have a face-on photo of the finished chest, with all the drawers in place, so the different sizes of your designs can be seen and appreciated?

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#17

I can help you imagine it

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

This may be the one case in design history where the drawing board was mightier than the free-hand pen. Huey designed his pattern while I constructed mine employing geometry consistent with the compass that would used to cut it in the wood..

I still have not seen the PW so I remain in the dark as to what they finally published. To scale the drawer pattern one starts with the center line of the drawer and the location of the hole for the pull. My and any other pattern is symmetric about this pull hole. Then you make a choice. The pattern can be scaled off the length you want it to be or the height. If it is height then the distance from pull hole to top of pattern is 2R. All the circle arcs then are centered on an x-y grid spaced at R with radius either R or 2R.

(the center point of the "sweep" that comes off the diamond and ends in a berry cluster can, and in my case was moved off the intersections of the r x r grid to position the berry cluster more favorably. Its radius remained R )

If the pattern is scaled to its length then the distance from the pull hole to the center of the last circle arc is 3R on the center line.

For ascending drawer heights I scaled off the drawer height leaving length of the pattern as a dependent variable.

I will get a picture when I move it to a location where I can get a picture. I made the pattern for each drawer end a pleasing distance from the inlaid border at the top and bottom of the drawer.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#18

rebuttal to editor's comment

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I sent the following to the editor. I reproduce it here on the chance that it will not be published.

The editor's note following my line and berry lay-out article states that these patterns were not typically scaled to the drawer height. I disagree.

Attached is a picture of the most famous of the line and berry decorated chests of drawers and it clearly is scaled. I have been up close and personal with the magnificent piece to know but one can clearly see how the pattern gets longer, and hence taller, as the drawers get bigger.

I spent a morning studying another fine chest of drawers at the Chester Co museum in West Chester. What I call "R" progressed 21,34,34,40mm on these drawers.

In Griffith's dissertation, referenced in my article, she states ""As the drawers graduated in size toward the bottom of the chest the inlay patterns were enlarged to fir the space, usually with no changes made or additional motifs added." Several examples illustrate this scaling, for example Figure 102.

The chest of drawers that Huey copied (December 2010) without citing the original (Herbert Schiffer collection and pictured in Furniture and it Makers Chester County PA) is not scaled. The pattern crowds the smallest drawer and fails to fill the space of the large drawer resulting in a less then optimum appearance. In contrast, in this same book the chest of drawers shown in plate 127 is scaled and the result is more appealing.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#19

Bill, if I understand what you've been

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

telling us and Pop Wood, the original makers could obtain each drawer's value for R (actually 2R) directly using a pair of dividers. That is, they could the minute they had the center line and border marked out.

In other words, they didn't need to work with any explicit millimeter value for R, or do any arithmetic calculations to scale up or down. Just extend the dividers until they reached the desired buffer distance from the border--and one-half of that distance is the R for that drawer.

The editor may not get the point of what you've been saying.

Wiley

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#20

Correct

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

In fact I laid out AND scratched the pattern just with two LN scratching tools once the center line and pull center was established. One can achieve the extreme precision required for the intersections this way. I have no doubt that a clever cabinet maker in 1720 would have figured this approach out.

Now, in 1720 they didn't have an adjustable LN scratcher. Likely they had a fixed radius scratcher which cost time to make. So, they would be efficient in establishing the radii of the patterns for each radius could require making a scratcher. The most refined example of line and berry, the Winterthur chest (I have a picture but it is likely copyrighted so I am reluctant to post it) used two different radii for each of the several drawers. In the Chester Co museum example the maker used the same two tools for two of the 4 drawers, a total of 6 scrather radii. There is a spice box in the museum that must have a dozen or more radii.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#21

Fixed radius

Warren in Lancaster, PA

"Likely they had a fixed radius scratcher [in 1720]" What leads you to think this? Have you seen this kind of tool? I can't imagine a worker making such a tool unless he was doing repetitive production work. If a spice box had a dozen radii, I think it more likely they used a tool like a beam compass or dividers.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#22

Re: Fixed radius

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Latta, the contemporary expert in this field, used fixed radius scratchers until LV developed a variable one. If the variable radii solutions you proposed worked better I presume he would have used them....but maybe not. Stop by the shop and see what he thinks.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#23

Re: Fixed radius

Warren in Lancaster, PA

One of my friends has been doing this work for more than forty years. He uses a beam compass made by Ulmia for inlay arcs. These were available here in the United States at least until 1988 or so, maybe they still make them.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#24

Inlay cutter

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Constantines was selling the inlay cutter with variable radius in their 1995 catalog.