Refocusing the discussion on the topic
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
My discussion topic is whether the patterns were typically scaled to drawer height, or not. It would be less confusing for the bystanders if we stayed on this topic and not confuse the discussion by refuting claims I never made as to the details of how they were historically scaled. In this discussion I am referring to the "scaling" of pattern to drawer height, NOT, the scaling of major to minor radii in the pattern.
The signature 8 drawer chest at Winterthur (whose compass points can be clearly located) as well as the chest at Chester County Museum are indisputably scaled to drawer height. Furthermore, Griffith in her discussion on drawer fronts, page 45 of her dissertation, states that the patterns were enlarged [scaling]to accommodate increase in drawer height (actual text quoted in previous post).
This issue is of sufficient importance that Griffith made it a part of her research and her conclusions are part of the published record on this topic. If her results and conclusions are flawed then they need to be corrected. Living in TN and only having the opportunity to have ever measured two chests of drawers I obviously have nothing to contribute to resolving this disagreement other than apparently discovering that there is one to be resolved. I hope that those that have access to data will continue this research and come to a conclusion to be published somewhere to get the historical facts correct.
I will add one insight. A furniture maker deciding whether to scale of not will be faced with how much labor will it be to scale. Scaling involves a minimum of two scratcher radii for each drawer size. For the "diamond" and "serpentine" centered patterns scaling is trivial with a variable radii scratcher or a selection of scratchers of various radii. For a shop limited in scratchers, for example a shop making only one decorated chest or just beginning this work, the labor to make the scratchers to do 4 or 5 different drawer sizes could have been prohibitive for the client's budget. In contrast the shop that made the 8 drawer Winterthur chest could well have been unlimited by scratchers or budget. Hence, to scale or not, could have, in cases, been an economic consideration where in other cases there was the opportunity to make it an aesthetic decision. (Just speculation)
If you would like to continue this interesting discussion of line and berry decoration we could discuss the aesthetics of scaling in a new thread as well as some puzziling observation I made on line width on the Chester Co Museum piece.