New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

Posts

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#26

Re: 18th c, inlay cutter

William Duffield

I don't understand how the one illustrated by Roubo would work. The blade is too long, and the tighter the radius, the wider the groove it would cut. That's why the cutter developed by Steve Latta and Lie-Nielsen has only two teeth.


Perhaps Roubo hadn't actually used the illustrated cutter, and therefore got it wrong?

I've posted these before. They are a modern implementation, by Chuck Bender, of an old idea. These have only one tooth.



Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#27

We get it, but . . .

Bob Lang

we didn't think use of the term "typical", in the sense of that being the most common method applied. That was why we added the comment to Bill's winning trick.

Bill came up with a cool method that works, if the pattern is graduated along with the heights of the drawers. But as Bill states, other methods were used to develop patterns in other pieces.

We take our history pretty seriously, and we strive to get things right. We understood the method Bill presented and liked it well enough to publish it and award it a prize. It comes down to scholarship and semantics. One of several methods really shouldn't be termed "typical".

Bob Lang

executive editor, Popular Woodworking Magazine.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#28

Re: 18th c, inlay cutter

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I'm sure that they had various cutters for these tools. I think you would want different cutters for different width inlay at least. This particular tool had a long beam so maybe this cutter was designed for large radii. I would not want a long beam for a 2 inch radius cut. I think the exciting thing about Roubo is that, like Nicholson, he was a real cabinetmaker, not just an editor or encyclopedist. Roubo did engrave some of the plates himself , but not this particular one.

My point is that 18th century workers were not stupid. It is not reasonable that a guy would make a dozen tools of different radii. They did have the knowledge and the capacity of making an adjustable tool, as shown by the Roubo plate.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#29

Re: 18th c, inlay cutter

William Duffield

I agree with every one of your points. My nit-picking comment was only intended to note that the illustrated configuration, because of the selected short radius and selected long cutter, would give less than optimal results.

I'll be seeing Don Williams on Thursday, so I'll ask him about his translation of the description of that tool and the process Roubo described to use it.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#30

the dividers tool has problems

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

After scratching something over 100' of troughs I gained a bit of prospective on the task. The strength and ergonomics of the tool is important to the control one will have and how quick the trough can be cut. The LV tool and the fixed radii tools Steve makes that preceded it have important features that soon becomes obvious whilst cutting an arc. They provide a secure place to hold the tool such that the point stays engaged, the tool can be comfortably swung in an arc and the considerable pressure required to quickly cut the trough can be brought to bear on the cutting tip. Cutting an arc with a tool optimally designed for the task takes seconds. Making the fixed radius tools that Steve makes can be done quickly. Hence, it is not an onerous task to make a tool fixed to any radius desired. Steve has a bucket full of them.

If you are not into making tools, and have the money, the LV tool is even better. In fact, I borrowed a second tool for the drawers. Having two cutters fixed to the two radii for each drawer had some subtle but significant advantages in the precision of the cuts. Cheap as I am if I make another drawer I will buy a second LN tool if I can't borrow one.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#31

Re: We get it, but . . .

William Duffield

I'm nit-picking again, but perhaps the point of confusion is that there is more than one definition of "typical".

You are right. It is important to point out that the technique Bill describes was far from universal. However, if you examine the two chests illustrated in Margaret Schiffer's book, Furniture and It's Makers of Chester County, Pennsylvania, plates 127 and 168, you will see that their designers solved the proportioning problem in different ways, both dissimilar to Bill's method, but also not typical in the strictest sense of the word.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#33

You seem to be missing the point

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

My objection was to the editor's statement about the graduation of pattern height with drawer height. Was it typical to scale the height of the pattern or not, irrespective of how the height was scaled? There is no question the chest on plate 127 was scaled to height. I spent a morning measuring it on March 22 and have the arc radii in a notebook. Griffith studied 200 pieces of Chester Co furniture and I quoted her conclusion in a statement above. Unless PW can provide evidence to counter these facts we can conclude scaling was typical. I have made no claims as to what technique was used to scale so this topic is not part of my discussion.

Why is this detail important?

Some strive to be period correct in making furniture. If it was typical to scale a pattern by ascending drawer size then that is what should be done unless one is copying a piece that wasn't. Alternatively, what looks best? Knowing that there are two options, builders can look at examples of scaled chests of drawers and the one that isn't and reach their own conclusions.

Scaling is trivial with the variable radii scratchers available so there is no disincentive or effort to do it. It is not trivial using a router template. These facts could color one's preference.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#34

Re: Scaling is trivial with CNC also...

TomD

CNC is seemingly very popular, when I return to CNCzone, after a brief absence there is a note saying there are a million new posts...

One advantage to CNC in this case is that the shapes are trite, so one can't complain that the design process would be compromised in CAD, as is often the case more generally.

Also the cuts are pretty trivial which means a cheap CNC could do it, with minimal hp, and just 2.5D.

You are probably looking at 250 for the electronics, and the rest would be stuff people already have, in many cases. The software and general awareness is the big ramp up, but once one has that, one can apply CNC to a lot of aps... Or so I am told... :)

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#35

Re: You seem to be missing the point

Chuck Bender

Bill,

I can tell you from first hand experience (I'm a period furniture maker and restorer working in Chester County for over 30 years) that scaling was not "typical". Several recent examples I've had in my shop were not scaled nor did your premise of R and 2R hold true. Their radii proportions were not direct multiples of the smaller radius. In particular on two examples they were, in fact, closer to R and 1.8R and R and 2.2R (too may "ands" for me...hopefully I didn't confuse anyone). While your method of determining the radii and scaling can be found in examples, I certainly would not without further research call it typical. Lee Ellen says the inlay patterns were enlarged to fill the space but she does not address the methodology nor the actual proportioning. She is a friend and I will contact her to discuss the method you describe. I will happily post the finding of my discussion with her.

Glen Huey is in my shop this week teaching a class on a project that is inlaid with line and berry. We spent yesterday examining, at Winterthur, the original piece. This piece in particular has no pivot points for a compass tool. It appears, and the conservators at Winterthur agree, the line and berry inlay may have been done "freehand". Yet another example with which I've had first hand contact that doesn't fit your model. I'm not saying your method isn't valid, it's just I seem to be coming across a sufficiently significant number of pieces that don't follow it that I'd hesitate to make any sweeping statements.

Even with Lee Ellen's research for her dissertation, there is still much to discover about design and layout (tooling, woods used, etc.). I'm sure she'd be the first to say her work was a beginning and by no means definitive. Your methodology is quite intriguing and causes me to wonder if it may have been employed by one or more specific shops/craftsmen much the way it seems the use of 1/32" stringing appears to be limited to a single (or possibly a small group) craftsman. In my experience the stringing in the majority of pieces I've examined tends to be something between (and closer to) 1/16" and 1/32"... but this is the topic of a completely different subject.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#36

Refocusing the discussion on the topic

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

My discussion topic is whether the patterns were typically scaled to drawer height, or not. It would be less confusing for the bystanders if we stayed on this topic and not confuse the discussion by refuting claims I never made as to the details of how they were historically scaled. In this discussion I am referring to the "scaling" of pattern to drawer height, NOT, the scaling of major to minor radii in the pattern.

The signature 8 drawer chest at Winterthur (whose compass points can be clearly located) as well as the chest at Chester County Museum are indisputably scaled to drawer height. Furthermore, Griffith in her discussion on drawer fronts, page 45 of her dissertation, states that the patterns were enlarged [scaling]to accommodate increase in drawer height (actual text quoted in previous post).

This issue is of sufficient importance that Griffith made it a part of her research and her conclusions are part of the published record on this topic. If her results and conclusions are flawed then they need to be corrected. Living in TN and only having the opportunity to have ever measured two chests of drawers I obviously have nothing to contribute to resolving this disagreement other than apparently discovering that there is one to be resolved. I hope that those that have access to data will continue this research and come to a conclusion to be published somewhere to get the historical facts correct.

I will add one insight. A furniture maker deciding whether to scale of not will be faced with how much labor will it be to scale. Scaling involves a minimum of two scratcher radii for each drawer size. For the "diamond" and "serpentine" centered patterns scaling is trivial with a variable radii scratcher or a selection of scratchers of various radii. For a shop limited in scratchers, for example a shop making only one decorated chest or just beginning this work, the labor to make the scratchers to do 4 or 5 different drawer sizes could have been prohibitive for the client's budget. In contrast the shop that made the 8 drawer Winterthur chest could well have been unlimited by scratchers or budget. Hence, to scale or not, could have, in cases, been an economic consideration where in other cases there was the opportunity to make it an aesthetic decision. (Just speculation)

If you would like to continue this interesting discussion of line and berry decoration we could discuss the aesthetics of scaling in a new thread as well as some puzziling observation I made on line width on the Chester Co Museum piece.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#37

Clarification

Alex Y

Bob and Bill,

There seems to be some miscommunication here.

Bill, in your "rebuttal" post, you mention Griffith's dissertation "referenced in my article". On page 14, I see that referenced in the editor's note to your article. Is that what you meant, or was that reference edited out of your original article for publication?

Bob, I appreciate the semantic distinction between what you said in the editor's note, "the pattern didn't typically graduate" and "the pattern typically did not graduate". But in the absence of a claim by Bill that such graduation was typical (which I do not see on page 14 of my copy; only that he wanted to do a graduation on the piece he was building), I'm afraid that distinction was lost. I certainly read the editor's note as if it were saying "it was atypical for the pattern to graduate". If the intent, as your post implies, was to say that both graduated and non-graduated treatment of the pattern was common in this style, why not say that, rather than to say one of the two alternatives was not typical, leaving the impression that the other was?

In your post, you say "one of several methods really shouldn't be termed 'typical'". I don't think Bill did so, and the wording of your editor's note left the [apparently unintended] impression that ungraduated patterns were typical.

Just feedback on how one reader read that comment.

Love the magazine!

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#38

Re: Clarification

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

The thesis referenced is Griffith's. The editors moved this reference from my article to their reply which I have no objection to.

And....you hit the nail on the head.

Re: Popular Woodworking....Bill Tindall

#39

Re: Clarification

Alex Y

And....you hit the nail on the head.


Good. I always worry about hitting my thumb when I enter a discussion like this one. ;)