Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
I thought Ron had made a useful original post, provided you give it the latitude that we customarily give all subjects raised here--the latitude to go sideways a bit, maybe twist the question a quarter turn so it gathers interest. Ron left it open-ended...
The Economaki dichotomy was design or technical proficiency. There it is, the tyranny of 'or', trying to force a false choice. What if we talk of design and technical proficiency, as a number of commenters in this thread have done. Indeed, one doesn't have to look far to see that it takes an enormous amount of technical proficiency to even be led to think about design choices.
Hmmm, how shall I design my high boy? Well, that presumes one can make a high boy, and few are going to get past the issue of how to make the moldings. Let alone the problems of carving a cow-hocked leg, or how to attach same to the carcase. Or how to carve the finials, or make that arching facade at the top.
How shall I design my secretary? Gee, how do they install those diagonal or even curving muntin bars, and cut the glass to fit?
I'd like to make a simplified Federal table. Hmmm, how do you make that rope pattern stringing? Or get those cock-beads to match as they wrap around from drawer top to drawer side. And hammer veneering...
Isn't it a fact that to think about design, you have be able to think about the curved line, rather than the straight line. Think about making curved or serpentine drawer fronts, and dovetail them; you have to be able to think about varying the molding to be typical of a period (and find a guide which matches moldings to periods); think about making Queen Anne legs and finials; think about how to join a carcase, where the outer surface and ornamentation suggest little about how the thing is actually stuck together.
I am concluding, in responses to Ron's original question, that design + proficiency is not only desirable, but rather you have to have quite a bit of technical proficiency to get beyond the straight line, and you have to have mastery of numerous skills to approximate the design of high-period furniture. In short, our design thoughts are limited by our technical proficiency.
Wiley