New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

Posts

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#26

Re: Help me understand

Patrick Gibbons

My sister was an art teacher in the public schools up until last year after which she retired. In a certain class she has always had her students do a self portrait. For probably over 25 years, every year, a certain number of students would draw themselves in an anime style. My sister would ask, "Does your nose really look like that? Two lines coming to a pointy angle? Are your eyes that big? Where do they really go on your face?" After the anime fixation was broken, originality stepped in. She would always try to show them what artists were trying to do. She showed me how Rembrandt made some things that really looked impressionistic though we tend to think of the Old Masters as realistic. Picasso did a few things in the Cubist style. He also could create like a Rembrandt. Warhol was a student of Thomas Hart Benton for a while I believe. Anyway, I've seen some of his student pieces that had that look. My point is good artists may prefer a certain style but they can do it all when necessary. But if all art is anime then judgement is not needed much by the artist.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#27

Re: Help me understand

John in NM

I suppose I just find the question posited by the blog post to be a bit contrived. In attempting profundity, he's instead missed the interesting question - how to teach elements of design to students of probably widely varying abilities of eye in a very short workshop.

I suppose also, it strikes me as he's dissing his students a bit.... them guys who are so misguided as to think that technical perfection is the be all and end all of their woodworking aim. I find it a bit hard to have much respect for that, though it is only an impression, nothing more.

The teacher, of all people, should know that technical classes are structured this way by those who present them. The point of these classes that seem to be his livelihood is to teach technique to those who want to learn technique. The students are eager to get their hands on some wood and tools and start doing something.

Once that urge is tamed, they will start thinking about design and proportion, and might then really get something out of a class focused purely on design with little or no shop time. In an apprentice sort of program, design might come first, and that might be for the best.... when the student is a paying customer, the classes are probably best tailored to hands on first because that's what the client seems to want.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#28

I thought I read

Ron Harper

Chris pointing out something that Economacki found out after quizzing a class in design, which surprised him a little, and accepting some degree of responsibility for the focus on the mechanical at the expense of the art.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#29

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#30

I'm done


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#31

Re: Then you might want to reread that, Ron

TomD

There is also something rich about Economacki bringing this up, though we don't really know where he was going with it. Bridge City Tools. Let me say it again. Bridge City Tools. And I say that with respect for the work he did cleaning up the machine square neighbourhood, and his insights into stuff like the Jointmaster. But... Bridge City Tools. I think one could pick any direction and run with that.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#32

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#33

Insight

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I am seeing that there are a number of ways to interpret the Blog. Personally, I had overlooked the source of the topic-Bridge City Tools. It my go to place for tools priced well beyond their function. It is not hard for me to imagine that a follower of this company would choose precision above all else, especially if the question was framed to favor this choice.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#34

Who reads a woodworking Blog?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Occasionally I am pointed to one, read it, and never return to the site again. I never thought about why till this thread evolved. Upon reflection, I don't read Blogs because they are seldom a source of useful information on how to make stuff. However, they are clearly a source of something for some.

That got me to thinking that woodworking can be both a way to make stuff and/or a life style. It should have been obvious given the number of people that have gravitated to this inexpensive part of the world to pursue a lifestyle that can be supported by small scale woodworking, pottery, and other crafts. These sorts of people proselytize their life style and I suppose Blogs are yet another means to reach their audience.

Woodworking techniques are like engineering and science. Arguing about the engineering details of assembling something, be it a bridge, a drawer or the Higgs Boson detector have, since science and engineering were invented, been fair game. Criticize the way Klause cuts dovetails and nobody gets upset at the end of the day even though the engineering discussion could get passionate. Criticize Krenov's touchy-feely approach to making a place to set a vase and his followers will get their shorts in a permanent knot. And so it might be with Schwartz and his benches and tool boxes and insights on design and execution. These are lifestyle issues only remotely related to a place to store your socks and best left uncommented on.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#35

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I thought Ron had made a useful original post, provided you give it the latitude that we customarily give all subjects raised here--the latitude to go sideways a bit, maybe twist the question a quarter turn so it gathers interest. Ron left it open-ended...

The Economaki dichotomy was design or technical proficiency. There it is, the tyranny of 'or', trying to force a false choice. What if we talk of design and technical proficiency, as a number of commenters in this thread have done. Indeed, one doesn't have to look far to see that it takes an enormous amount of technical proficiency to even be led to think about design choices.

Hmmm, how shall I design my high boy? Well, that presumes one can make a high boy, and few are going to get past the issue of how to make the moldings. Let alone the problems of carving a cow-hocked leg, or how to attach same to the carcase. Or how to carve the finials, or make that arching facade at the top.

How shall I design my secretary? Gee, how do they install those diagonal or even curving muntin bars, and cut the glass to fit?

I'd like to make a simplified Federal table. Hmmm, how do you make that rope pattern stringing? Or get those cock-beads to match as they wrap around from drawer top to drawer side. And hammer veneering...

Isn't it a fact that to think about design, you have be able to think about the curved line, rather than the straight line. Think about making curved or serpentine drawer fronts, and dovetail them; you have to be able to think about varying the molding to be typical of a period (and find a guide which matches moldings to periods); think about making Queen Anne legs and finials; think about how to join a carcase, where the outer surface and ornamentation suggest little about how the thing is actually stuck together.

I am concluding, in responses to Ron's original question, that design + proficiency is not only desirable, but rather you have to have quite a bit of technical proficiency to get beyond the straight line, and you have to have mastery of numerous skills to approximate the design of high-period furniture. In short, our design thoughts are limited by our technical proficiency.

Wiley

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#36

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I am reminded of the comments about my entry in the jewelry box competition. One judge said something along the lines that since I was entering something approximating a reproduction that the technical execution needed to be flawless. The implication was that if the design had been original (what ever that means) technical flaws would have been of less significance.

Most amateur woodworkers do more or less reproductions. Given the above philosophy, the only way to excel with this perspective with a reproduction is with flawless execution. Hence, the emphasis on this facet. If we change the "or" to "emphasis " a discussion of the thought makes more sense. Clearly design and execution are never mutually exclusive as literally proposed.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#37

Thanks David

Ron Harper

:D

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#38

OK. Another tack

Ron Harper

Assume you have finite time ( we all die) and finite resources, it would, to me appear to be very prudent to prioritize their use. For the purpose of this discussion, I say that something needs to be worth building before I commit to it my time and wood from my stache. To me "worth building" means design. Does it suit a need? Does it improve the aesthetic of its surroundings? Is the material used to make it appropriate for its function? And also do I have reasonable expectations of being able to do the work required to bring the design to life?

My options? Copy a proven design, or create my own original or modification of someone else's design. Many factors will influence this decision. Not the least of which is a huge herd instinct found particularly in the male of our species. Another factor is that a huge percentage of us on this site have not been educated in ways that would prepare us to be designers. As has been hinted at in this thread, it is probably easier to teach someone to cut accurate joints than it is to make a designer out of him.

Having said all this, I can understand the choice to always work from plans drawn by another. However, to do so is to miss the thrill of seeing your own idea take shape. I have done a couple of original pieces. No, I will definitely not submit them to this crowd for review. They were fairly accurate statements of where I was at the time. They were wonderful learning experiences.

I am 67 years old. I am not sure how much time I have to learn to be a designer, but I am going to keep at it.

Being a primarily hand tool guy really doesn't change the scope of what I could do before, it just changes the way that I do it.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#39

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

Sgian Dubh

"One judge said something along the lines that since I was entering something approximating a reproduction that the technical execution needed to be flawless. The implication was that if the design had been original (what ever that means) technical flaws would have been of less significance."

I think you are referring to my comments Bill. The competition asked entrants to design and make a jewellery cabinet or box. Whilst a box is a box is a box so to speak yours was a piece heavily derived from a pre-existing spice box, so a major part of your design challenge was adapting those forms, proportions, shapes, mouldings, etc to a new purpose. There's nothing wrong with that; we all do it I think to a greater or lesser extent. In some cases the origin of the design is obvious as in your case.

Designing a new piece of furniture can be inspired by all sorts of things that are unrelated to existing furniture examples. For instance, I'm currently working on a cabinet that was partially inspired by a desire to try and fool the eye, aka trompe l'oeil. You've seen a couple of sketches of it in a thread you started a few weeks ago asking what people were working on. In addition to that its functional capabilities during the design phase were a secondary consideration. True, you open up the front and inside is a white maple interior with some drawers and shelves. But as I said, apart from the maple serving as a visually 'clean' counterpoint to what I hope is a rather dramatic visual exterior, the internals and their function weren't a priority. I really want people to be moved one way or another by first appearances, eg, they love it or hate it, and if they like the exterior they'll hopefully explore inside a little and they might find a use for the internal bits.

Now, none of what I've just written is the only way to approach a design task, there are many ways, but it illustrates that a new furniture design doesn't have to be based on existing pieces, nor does it have be based primarily on functional considerations, as well as other approaches, eg, do I have the skill(?), etc. Slainte.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#40

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

roger lance

Wiley has hit upon a reality of design that I experience which is the design is sometimes influenced by the capacity of my tooling....I have to think my way thru a build....how am I going to do this and with what.....sometimes parts must be dialed back to fit what I can do in my shop....just one of those reality things that also need to be acknowledged.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#41

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

TomD

I agree with much of what you say Wiley, except:

"In short, our design thoughts are limited by our technical proficiency."

We would still be living in caves if that were true. Pretty nearly my first woodworking project back in the late 70s was a canoe. I didn't really have any woodworking ability, though I had hung around with my father, who could make simple things. I can remember the pain of just cutting out the plywood form with a junk B&D jigsaw for which only dull in the package blades were available. I didn't have any idea how to design a canoe. There was pretty nearly zero info on design until quite recently, and only a few typed pages on making. The seminal book Canoecraft came out later. And even then, the designs in wood at the time where mostly time capsule stuff, not technical boats, which is why I felt the need to design my own.

It turned out OK though, and it still gets use today when we are at the cottage.


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#42

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

TomD

Not buying it. Boaz Elkayam once built a guitar with a pocket knife. Or so the story goes... There were pics in the article, and the workmanship was pretty nice.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#43

Since I'm basically an inner directed individual..

roger lance

I don't care if you buy it or not.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#44

Re: Jeez, Ron, ...

jack curtis

As Ellis recently put it in chat, "we tolerate you, David", which sums it up about as well as anything.

Perhaps you don't take this seriously enough? Has it not occurred to you than there's a fine line between toleration and dismissal, when people just find it too hard to tolerate any longer? You still find it necessary, whether simply for your own fun or edification, to disparage Ron's concern as "getting all wee-weed up." Really? Does that make you a superior thinker? A better writer? A bully? Ron's initial reaction to cut out on his own thread rather than sticking around for more verbal abuse seems right to me.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#45

Precisely.


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#46

I think Wiley meant

Ron Harper

A self perceived lack of technical ability will likely create an inhibited sense of design. Seems obvious to me.?

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#47

I doubt David takes anything seriously...

John in NM

If he were ever 100% serious, I doubt we would tolerate him either :D

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#48

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#49

Re: As I see it

jack curtis

I don't think I'm particularly sensitive, although I do try to make it more difficult for you and others to refer to my ideas and concerns as wee-weed by objecting when you do it to somebody else. This is called publicly standing up to the bully.

It may be time for you to consider a minimal amount of empathy. How would you feel if any of us described something you wrote as wee-weed? Honestly, now, what would be your initial response? BTW, many of us do think that, but we're polite enough to say nothing. This is what tolerate means. So how about you tolerate us for a change?

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#50

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)