New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

Posts

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#51

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#52

Bully for you David

mark hennebury

I see nothing wrong with what David has said;

If you are going to voice your opinion then you should expect that it may be challenged and you may have to defend it; that's what forums are about.

As long as we stick to discussing the topics, and don't get too personal, i don't see any problem.

a persons internal dialogue can get pretty mixed up, voicing it on a forum gets your some perspective as others respond. You may learn things you didn't know, be confronted with points you hadn't considered, and maybe see things from a different point of view.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#53

Re: Since I'm basically an inner directed individu

TomD

I'm willing to believe the limits work in your case. If you say so. I'm addressing the broader issue, from cavemen forward, and I still don't buy it.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#54

Re: I think Wiley meant

TomD

Obvious does not mean right, or the only answer. It seems equally obvious that people wanted to design something and found the means, personal or otherwise to do it. Pretty much the march of human progress there in a nutshell.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#55

Re: Interesting and useful reframing

TomD

""As has been hinted at in this thread, it is probably easier to teach someone to cut accurate joints than it is to make a designer out of him.""

If so, cutting accurate joints is a subset of woodworking while, being a designer is the whole thing in design. Is it easier to teach someone the whole craft of cabinetmaking, than to be a designer? Normally the professions like medicine are thought to be harder than, say cabinetmaking, because one has to first learn so many things, like math and reading and writing. But learning to be a doctor, or a cabinetmaker, or a designer, they all take about the same time discretely.

Having self-taught myself design I think it is actually easier in some respects than woodworking. Tonight I knocked off a money belt for my daughter who is going on a school trip. I have never owned or made one before, so I came up with some ideas, threw it together, some of the stuff worked, some of it didn't. The next one will be professional grade. And that is very often the case. The first stab often has a few problems, the next one is often very good. The problem, as with most of this stuff, is people either don't have the temperament, cash or, time (or so they say) to do the trial version.



Same evening I was working on a Duke holster design, and two Baritone Uke designs. The Uke designs will come out better than professional grade, because the pro version of the particular instrument I am designing are terrible, and yet plan sales seem viable as lots of people have a set out there. You would think professionals would minimally familiarize themselves what the designs there are making are about.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#56

Yes, but only because you called me a wuss.

jack curtis

Otherwise, I'd have dropped it. This is the problem with bullies: they seem to think they can call others wee-weed, wusses, and the like; but if the response is a little name calling in return, they feel they can attack with impunity. How dare these wusses call "me" a bully?! I do not accept that.

I'd really like to return to woodworking education now, Mark.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#57

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#58

Re: Outright Endorsement

david weaver

David, I find your posts to be the most interesting posted on this forum. For the sake of some of us, don't change anything. :)

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#59

Re: Sort of scary

david weaver

Bound to happen, could be worse, I have lucid thoughts once in a while!

I did have an ear infection on friday, and didn't know it, though. Otherwise I would've just concluded that finding the secret in the dirt (hogan's words about where you solve your problems) is worth more than 150 bloggertainment entries - and not commented at all.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#60

Very well said Wiley


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#62

Leo Cuellar

Agreed!:D

Leo Cuellar

:D

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#63

Re: You misunderstood the satire

jack curtis

Since when is it satire to label a poster's concerns "wee-weed?" That post of yours shouted out that only your concerns were of value. That's not satire, that is puerile and bullish. I've seen this many times, but I've never encountered such a disparaging way of saying it. Usually people just say they don't consider a concern important. Also not particularly useful.

I, too, appreciate your posts, at least the ones that aren't excessively laden with words written for the sake of hearing yourself talk; but when you or anyone else expresses disdain in such terms, I find it difficult to say nothing. It doesn't matter to me how many say you're OK and valuable, which is not foreign to my opinion; but what you said to Ron is bullying plain and simple, albeit not physical.

I've never been bullied, so until a month or so ago (a dog park idiot chased a dog just to kick him and I found myself face to face daring him to try it again, fortunately he backed away), had no idea how I'd respond. Now I know.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#64

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#65

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#66

Re: That was not what I called satire

jack curtis

And yet you still excuse yourself? Just because you were bullied doesn't mean you have to pass it on so others have poor experiences. And you blame me for being thin skinned? I'm not, not a bit; although I do have a certain sensitivity when others seem harmed.

How about a real apology instead of I'm sorry if I offended you, which was not my intent, but neither was it not my intent, if you can understand that. It's so difficult to imagine others at a distance through this medium. As in real life, some 'click' better than others, some 'get' one another better than others and perhaps this is where problems begin and arise. , a non-apology if I ever heard one.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#67

Re: Upon further reflection, ...

jack curtis

And this from the man who promised me the last word several messages ago? I didn't consider the dog kicker a personal triumph, more of a lucky escape that the couple of other guys there applauded. That actually embarrassed me more than anything else. But I couldn't let that hot head kick dogs with impunity. It had to be done. That's all.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#68

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#69

Enough


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#70

Re: Upon further reflection, ...

david weaver

Next time, get your camera phone out and take a video and send it to the humane society and the newspaper. It'll go further in protecting the dogs.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#71

Re: Outright Endorsement

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I agree with David W. wholeheartedly. David B's participation has brought only good things to me, including his recommendation on the Upton tea. And I could cite many others, involving fret saws, fret saw blades, sources for silver, files, techniques for managing hide glue + marquetry, and several others that escape me right now.

Strongest endorsement for David.

Wiley

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#72

Re: Outright Endorsement, x 2