New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

Posts

Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#1

Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

Ron Harper

Chris has posted an interesting blog here

blog.lostartpress.com

It deals with technical competence and design. I would be very interested in hearing from some of you on this topic. Derek has already weighed in on the Schwarz's site.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#2

As a hobbiest I shoot for both.

Chuck Nickerson

The problem is we don't know much about teaching design.

Teaching design is even harder in a blog/Youtube environment.

I have high hopes for the Tolpin/Walker book which is coming from LAP.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#3

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

david weaver

Sort of a retread of discussions that have already been had on here several times, and the misguided views that create a lack of ability to spot a piece of well designed furniture exist right on the front page (in regard to the apple piece shown below).

But I would rather talk to warren or george wilson about design than listen to a survey that says new students want perfect joints. Who cares what new students want? I don't say that to be rude, I say that because where else would anyone take an account beginners and novices as opposed to just knowing what the experienced answer is?

It is another good example of what warren described (paraphrasing) where these classes are not populated with anyone who is going to become a furnituremaker. The blogs are written for the same group and constantly rehash either forum traffic or information that is unsuitable (due to its consistent steady state in novice minutiae) for anyone willing to read on their own.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#4

Sort of scary

Ron Harper

I think we agree sgain

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#5

Amen to this "novel" inisght

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Well, this discussion nicely follows a discussion we recently had and the quote about building for other woodworkers. What he discloses is, and has been, obvious to anyone that examines Period furniture.

Personally, I have never built anything "flawless" nor do I strive to. "Good enough" gets more stuff made, and I have a long list. I doubt almost anyone making a living at making stuff strives for perfection either. Customers won't see it, appreciate it or most important pay for it. I think 100 years from now in Antiques Road Show the experts will quickly spot the amateur built pieces by the stress on hidden perfection. My daughter had an art teacher that lectured, while critiquing their work, that only Da Vinci was perfect.

What is acceptable will vary with the person. For me if a mistake or flaw is obvious to the casual observer, like the huge knots in the apple chest on- chest, I won't live with it. If it is a structurally insignificant dovetail gap on the inside of a drawer I am not concerned by it.

For some it seems that making stuff is a reflection on their person. They feel they would be a lesser person if a dovetail joint in the back of a drawers shows a gap to small to affect strength, yet readily detected by another woodworker. I have news, the repair is readily detectable to another woodworker and non-woodworkers don't care, if they notice at all. Yet if a leg is too frail, drawers poorly proportioned or grain matching amiss many will notice even if the surface preparation and joinery are perfect.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#6

disagreement

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

"It is another good example of what warren described (paraphrasing) where these classes are not populated with anyone who is going to become a furniture maker."

I know instructors at College of Redwoods and a former instructor at North Bennett and they have disagreed with your statement. COR maintains a list of former students and many have become professional woodworkers. Ditto North Bennett. Just like in any major, some students don't pursue their major upon graduation for a variety of reasons but this is hardly a reason to presume they didn't start out with an aspiration to become a professional woodworker.

I have no doubt that the COR students are mentored to strive for both perfection of design and execution. As a judge of a COR design competition for a grant I can assure you that some of the students have made great sacrifices to pursue their dream of becoming professional woodworkers. While you may not prefer what they design the western galleries are able to sell them for more than the target estimate on the apple piece.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#7

Re: disagreement

david weaver

Fill in the blank here:

______ make up more students in woodworking classes per year than ______

Your two choices are

* young aspiring furniture makers

* middle age individuals looking for an escape

Which individuals do you suppose make up the classes of:

* paul sellers

* garrett hack

* peter follansbee

* roy underhill

* chris schwarz

?

most of the modern furniture that I've seen is pretty forgettable, and though I won't be alive to tell, I doubt it will stand the test of time. Combinations like purpleheart and curly maple, etc, with stuff like unneeded curves and wedged through tenons is pretty nasty.

Even that said, I doubt the few classes that do exist of people who think they will and who actually will make commissioned originals for a living (without teaching sharpening classes, or other such local goofery to supplement income) would confuse technical perfection as being more important than design.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#8

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

TomD

False dillemna. Why does one have to choose. In what sense is a design particularly a classical design when they had no problem teaching it, technically perfect but badly designed. I look at a lot of drawers, etc... These are not pieces in museums for whatever trumped up reason. I don't see bad joints. Unfinished backs is a different issue. Dining room tables do not have unfinished backs, It is a mater of the intended use, and placement.

I think the question of what one would like to produce is one thing, I probably spend more time asking myself where I want to end up, what I am shooting for. Which when I was more into it was definitely technically perfect stuff. I don't have that much problem with the idea of saying that you can make nice pieces without yet being technically perfect, and that these pieces can "fit in". Beginners should not be held to unreasonable standards, but it is equally false to suggest that the standards of a beginner are somehow as good as it gets.

If you want to turn out shoddy work, go for it, but don't expect to be taken too seriously as having mastered your trade, just because someone before you turned out a pieces with bad joints also. There are pieces out there with good joinery. If you look at some craft like guitar making, where admittedly the joinery is simpler for the most part. Perfection is the only acceptable standard. And beginners, on their first pieces, turn out professional looking, if not sounding work. For some time now there has been an attempt to dumb down furniture making so everyone can have self-esteem, no mater what they make. And it should be seen for what it is.

Here is a pic of the first dovetails I ever cut, and you can see I didn't do a perfect job from the veneers. But about half of them fit... That was 1978 ish... The gear today is a lot better, but it takes practice regardless.


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#9

Re: disagreement

TomD

You are picking schools that purport to train professional woodworkers, as opposed to craft classes which are more like whale watching. NBSS I had always assumed was a professional course. What kind of work people there find is another mater. Taking a course, and working in the field, often politicized stats, is only a first step. The thing is whether they are working as the craftsmen they were trained to be, and that seems doubtful for most. Museum or craft council work does not count.

COR, is a weirder example. Krenov himself said he was an amateur, and wrote all his major works to support people who were amateurs like him, or in his case impractical. I was disappointed when he got swept up in the COR experience and became a commercialist out of sympathy. Which was doubtless an appropriate thing for him to do. But one of his greatest contribution to me (and I assume many others) was the suggestion that amateurs could do as good or better work than professionals, which is absolutely true. They can certainly do better work than most professionals, and should. But they can also do better work than any professional.

In his last book, it was clear that he thought that commercial viability was still a work in progress...

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#10

Re: Amen to this "novel" inisght

jack curtis

Da Vince had great difficulty persuading paint to stick, thus was always experimenting. Got it right often enough for us, I guess; but I'd love to hear what his clients would have said. I doubt he even chased perfection.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#11

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

that is an example of what I mean by good enough

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#12

Ooooops more disagreement?

Ron Harper

I can agree with you that some of the modern stuff is unredeemably ugly. But whether or not you like Krenov's stuff, it will endure for a very long time. Krenov was indeed an artist and like Maloof ( in a very different way) he painted with wood. Some of his stuff is too stark for me, but some of the revered period stuff is way too foo foo for me. I find a big difference in seeing the beauty in something, and wanting it in your home. Does that make any sense?

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#13

in answer to your question....

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I have another. How many classes do you have a first hand familiarity with?

I answer your question with the following background: I know a current instructor at COR and a former instructor at North Bennett and we have discussed the program and students at each place. I have already answered with regard to these students.

Then there are the short classes of an hour to a week. I have attended but a few of these. Most were focused one day classes except the week at the Headley shop- specific joinery(Bird), use of the skew(Cook), Federal inlay (Latta), Krenov joinery(Finck), Federal Wall cabinet(Headley), French Polish(Floyd).

Between everyone and the great majority of the students in these classes were aspiring woodworkers with a passion to make stuff. They were there to learn targeted skills. Some were current professionals, most were amateurs. In my case a piece of furniture (or more) resulted from each class.

Additionally, there are people in our club that attend classes. Each falls in the category of aspiring woodworkers with a passion to make stuff.

As an example of the sort of work one of these students does I offer this example, from among a score or more I could choose......


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#14

yes it does

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

"I find a big difference in seeing the beauty in something, and wanting it in your home. Does that make any sense?"

Over time I have come to appreciate most of the Period furniture but little of it would fit my informal life style.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#15

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well said Tom.

Keep in mind that the topic chosen by Chris for his blog was designed to create discussion - it is the equivalent to"bevel up versus bevel down" and "honing guide versus freehand". The couching of topics in this manner draws out extreme responses.

The danger of encouraging perfectionism is that it may scare away those for whom the task appears too daunting. Yet downplaying build quality also has obvious limitations.

There are just so many levels here that I do wonder whether we actually see our work as others do? (And, for that matter, whether we see the work of others for what it really is?). I consider myself very much a beginner compared with many, while there are some who see my work as advanced - I probably am in comparison to their stage of development. For the experienced designer my meagre design efforts must appear immature, but at my stage I am happy as I don't know any better. By "design" I include wood choice, build proportions and constructional decisions. As my eye grows I see how the work may have been done differently. The opinion of students, as used by Chris, has limited value.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#16

Re: Ooooops more disagreement?

david weaver

I have never really read that much about krenov, and other than some quickly made planes and a typical stand that doesn't have much interior space but has really long legs, and looks like it would tip over faster.

But I was talking more about a lot of the gallery furniture that you'd see in a typical urban area.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#17

A good reminder...

John in NM

Of why I don't follow blogs like this.

It is a silly question - Schwarz's, not Ron's.

Why on earth would anyone assume that it's one or the other? Why would a student who makes fantastic joints be unable to make a well proportioned, artistic design? I simply don't see the two as mutually exclusive, lots of people can execute a fine design in a technically adept way (no one does perfect). Lots of other people execute ill proportioned crap badly. Lots of people are somewhere in between.

What an odd way of looking at the world....

'Course, I don't think a whole lot of Economaki either, I doubt any of you will be surprised by that.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#18

I wish you guys lived in my town

Ron Harper

I could sure learn a lot from you.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#19

Outstanding furniture requires both.....

roger lance

technical competence in its construction and great design.....this piece appears to possess both IMHO.....this piece may be a reproduction or an original.....either way, its a fine example of woodworking artistry (and I have my suspicions of who might have made it).

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#20

Re: A good reminder...

CStanford

Students are being sold woodworking instruction, i.e., how to cut joints and process materials into a finished product of *usually* another's design. It never occurs the the vast majority of even serious hobbyists to start their journey by taking instruction in art and design. Some are lucky to already have that sort of background - Garrett Hack has a degree in architecture, Sam Maloof in graphic design. There are many more examples. A lot of artists gravitate to wood as their chosen medium and the decorative arts as their chosen genre. These folks tend to be the names we all recognize. A lot of retirees and weekend warriors just want to be able to cut gapless dovetails on the rectilinear project du jour -- work basically indistinguishable in design from the latest offerings from "K-Wal" (if even that stylish), other than for the hand-executed joinery -- the proverbial six month long bookcase project.

Tage Frid related that during his apprenticeship the days were spent in the shop and nights were spent in drafting and design classes. I believe this how the British programs are still organized but perhaps not as intensely and of the quality they were back in the 1970s and earlier.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#21

Very well said, Charles.


Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#22

Re: A good reminder...

Kevin Adams

As a follow up, please see the new post at Lost Art blog by George Walker on design.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#23

That is more or less my point too...

John in NM

Though you spelled it out more clearly.

A person working for a custom shop will be building to a supplied plan.

An apprentice will be working at the direction of his mentor.

A hobbyist has commercial plans, magazine plans, or if ambitious, un-planned pictures to work from.

Unless a student is taking a class in design, he is likely working from a supplied plan of some sort, even if it is a bit more general than one would find in a commercial shop.

I think the easy availability of reasonably good designs to copy (excuse me, be inspired by :D ) is part of the reason for the over-focus on technique. In many cases, a person only needs to know what they like and what they wish to reproduce.

The other thing that I have noticed - customers often do not buy original designs, even if they are very good. By and large, the paying customer wants something that looks like something they've seen before. This is a lot of the reason that we find those who do succeed with largely original stuff to be so impressive.

The shop I used to work for did entirely un-original work IMHO. It was good stuff, but every motif of any kind was borrowed from somewhere. Almost everyone selling custom furniture does this, they have to or starve. Original i

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#24

Help me understand

Ron Harper

How could you use a reading of the blog I referred to as a reason to take a shot at The Schwarz.

I do not get it.

Re: Provocative Lost Art Press Blog

#25

Re: Help me understand

roger lance

Psychologists classify people according to the basic orientation that people have for guidance and direction in navigating life:

Traditionally directed people look to the established values of the past....social institutions....religions....etc....for their signals on how to live.

Other directed people look to their peers, significant others, or the current culture for their guidance in life.

Inner directed people evaluate life and make judgements/decisions based on what they believe and value.

This is a rather simplistic way of classifying people (and I probably did a poor job of it); but, it is useful and does explain differences of opinion somewhat.