That is more or less my point too...
John in NM
Though you spelled it out more clearly.
A person working for a custom shop will be building to a supplied plan.
An apprentice will be working at the direction of his mentor.
A hobbyist has commercial plans, magazine plans, or if ambitious, un-planned pictures to work from.
Unless a student is taking a class in design, he is likely working from a supplied plan of some sort, even if it is a bit more general than one would find in a commercial shop.
I think the easy availability of reasonably good designs to copy (excuse me, be inspired by
) is part of the reason for the over-focus on technique. In many cases, a person only needs to know what they like and what they wish to reproduce.
The other thing that I have noticed - customers often do not buy original designs, even if they are very good. By and large, the paying customer wants something that looks like something they've seen before. This is a lot of the reason that we find those who do succeed with largely original stuff to be so impressive.
The shop I used to work for did entirely un-original work IMHO. It was good stuff, but every motif of any kind was borrowed from somewhere. Almost everyone selling custom furniture does this, they have to or starve. Original i