Re: A bill of goods
TomD
"What I see here from obviously more experienced hand people , is that I had just better practice more and forget about the fence. That's what I'll probably do. (I wonder what Lee Valley has to say about all this.)"
Here is a tip: When a ton of people here tell you how easy something is, it is normally because it is easy and they did not have to practice a ton. You will not get people to move to serious practice, there has to be a "trick" and even then it will take 5 years to get anyone to try it. So if you get a lot of people saying it is easy, it is really easy.
"I will say, however, that I know that when you plane an edge by hand, a good practice is too use your (other) hand under the sole of the plane and against the board to actually ACT like a fence. So.... why disparage using an ACTUAL fence that is exactly 90 degrees to the sole?"
That isn't the same thing, the fingers are really only there to create a balance point, or a registration to a curved blade, etc... There is no real fencing going on. However, if the fence you have works for you, that should be enough.
Lee Valley is so responsive they have brought out a bunch of things to help average woodworkers. Unfortunately, occasionally, the tech side jumps ahead of their best efforts. Bevel up planes are a real good, but the new info on breakers is running in a contrary direction. And the same thing on jointing, Charlesworth's excellent video hit like a ton of bricks, and became a religious document for a few years. I don't think people care all that much about fences since that came out. For a while there, curved blades were all the rage, though that is just one of many approaches.