New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Lee Valey hand plane fence

Posts

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#26

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldmqn

To be fair to the Lee Valley salesman, I asked first about such a plane; but he suggested a less expensive solution was this simple fence. I should have thought about the width-of -board problem or a making a longish shooting board.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#27

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldmqn

Thanks, really useful answer.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#28

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

John Pappas

Keep it. You might have occassions where it works well for the task at hand. As I said, I have a makeshift fence that I clamp to my plane and it gets used from time to time. ie. a very long board...longer than my shooting board.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#29

I misunderstood the situation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I thought we were talking about using a shooting board in which case the shooting board provides the straight reference. What you describe makes perfect sense when using a long plane to straighten an end or an edge.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#30

On employing this fence

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Maybe a use for it would be "training wheels". Don't rely on pushing the fence against the lumber so as to orient the plane, but rather, practice planing while keeping the plane sides parallel to the board face (we are edge planing here) and use the fence as a visual aid to judge if the plane side is parallel, or not.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#31

Long grain shooting board

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

My understanding of a long grain shooting board, and what I actually do, is let the plane ride the edge of the work. So in that case, it's the plane's sole that is the reference.

Now there are situations, and Frank D. from Montreal brought one out recently, where someone might want to plane a long-grain edge right back to the fence, so that the fence is providing the reference.

Maybe Bill has uncovered a good discussion: Talking about long grain shooting now, not end grain shooting. Do you folks out there let the plane ride the work? Or do you plane the work back to a fence?

Wiley

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#33

Re: Lee Valley hand plane fence

William Duffield, between the York and the James

How long have you had the fence? If it's not the tool you need, you might consider returning it. Lee Valley's return policy is more than fair, and is good for three months.

You might justify this to yourself by considering that maybe their representative just didn't ask you the right questions. I'm sure Rob Lee would be happier if you returned it, especially if you replaced it with a tool you were completely happy with, than that you continued to hold onto something from them, and it continues to make you unhappy.

I wouldn't consider this fence to be a "gizmo". It's, as someone else mentioned, more like training wheels, to be used to get a job done while learning the skills that make its continued use unnecessary. Like training wheels, it will eventually just get in the way, and impede further progress. If you had arrive at that place, then, like training wheels, when you removed it, selling it on the used market would be more appropriate than returning it.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#34

craigd

Re: Here's how I do it

craigd


Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#35

Re: Lee Valley hand plane fence

CStanford

Not on the Cohansey any longer?

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#36

William's Burg

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was able to spend time with Sir William earlier this week, between the York and the James.

Warren, between two branches of Muddy Creek, tributaries of the Conestoga.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#37

Re: Here's how I do it

eliot feldman

I've gotten some excellent advice about planing. but the problem remains that I can't use the 2 1/4 inch fence on a board less wide that that. The set-up you picture has a board that looks to be about 6 inches wide. What would the picture look like for a 2 inch wide board -- and with the plane fence on the plane?

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#38

A bill of goods

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't know what you were told when you bought this fence, Eliot, but I hope deception was not involved. The September 2012 Lee Valley catalog, page 72, states:

Planing a square edge on a board requires a jointer fence, whether you are using an electric jointer or a hand plane.

I suspect this was written out ignorance rather than an attempt to deceive, but in any case it is not true. I cannot imagine any serious craftsman using such a device, and I cannot imagine any serious school teaching its use to beginners.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#39

Re: A bill of goods

eliot feldman

Nobody sold me a bill of goods, really. My problem, simply, is that after I take a board off the power joiner, I like to plane it by hand. Sometimes I can't seem to get it just right and actually have to go back to the power joiner to start over. Obviously, after a bit of this, I begin to loose too much width of board. So at a woodworking show in Timonium, Maryland at the Lee Valley area about a month ago , I showed some interest in a plane that has a built in square ( I don't what they are called; apparently serious woodworkers use it for something similar.) A really nice fellow from Lee Valley suggested that a less expensive solution was to purchase their magnetic fence. It's beautifully made and cost something like $40 or $50; so I went for it. (I like the Canadians from Lee Valley.) I THOUGHT I was good at planing and , believe it or not, I painstakingly made a Japanese Kana that I often use. (That plane, of course , if wooden, so it has nothing to do with this Lee Valley fence.) What I see here from obviously more experienced hand people , is that I had just better practice more and forget about the fence. That's what I'll probably do. (I wonder what Lee Valley has to say about all this.) I will say, however, that I know that when you plane an edge by hand, a good practice is too use your (other) hand under the sole of the plane and against the board to actually ACT like a fence. So.... why disparage using an ACTUAL fence that is exactly 90 degrees to the sole?

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#40

Re: Here's how I do it

TomD

"I've gotten some excellent advice about planing. but the problem remains that I can't use the 2 1/4 inch fence on a board less wide that that. The set-up you picture has a board that looks to be about 6 inches wide. What would the picture look like for a 2 inch wide board -- and with the plane fence on the plane? "

Go back to my first post in this thread, you just need to dog the board right at or slightly over the edge of the bench, and back it with a bracing board that is lower than your 2 inch board. If you did a lot of styles, or something, you could make a piece of wood that fit between your dogs with a hooked forward edge, and it would allow you to cycle a lot of identical pieces.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#41

Re: A bill of goods

TomD

"What I see here from obviously more experienced hand people , is that I had just better practice more and forget about the fence. That's what I'll probably do. (I wonder what Lee Valley has to say about all this.)"

Here is a tip: When a ton of people here tell you how easy something is, it is normally because it is easy and they did not have to practice a ton. You will not get people to move to serious practice, there has to be a "trick" and even then it will take 5 years to get anyone to try it. So if you get a lot of people saying it is easy, it is really easy.

"I will say, however, that I know that when you plane an edge by hand, a good practice is too use your (other) hand under the sole of the plane and against the board to actually ACT like a fence. So.... why disparage using an ACTUAL fence that is exactly 90 degrees to the sole?"

That isn't the same thing, the fingers are really only there to create a balance point, or a registration to a curved blade, etc... There is no real fencing going on. However, if the fence you have works for you, that should be enough.

Lee Valley is so responsive they have brought out a bunch of things to help average woodworkers. Unfortunately, occasionally, the tech side jumps ahead of their best efforts. Bevel up planes are a real good, but the new info on breakers is running in a contrary direction. And the same thing on jointing, Charlesworth's excellent video hit like a ton of bricks, and became a religious document for a few years. I don't think people care all that much about fences since that came out. For a while there, curved blades were all the rage, though that is just one of many approaches.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#42

craigd

Re: Here's how I do it

craigd

What would the picture look like for a 2 inch wide board -- and with the plane fence on the plane?

As others have suggested, the bench top is the fence, ie the bench becomes a shooting board. So, remove the fence from the plane and attach the plane to the fence/bench and you can joint any width you can clamp. If your plane isn't square (most Stanleys aren't), skew the iron with the lateral lever to get a square cut. Or shim the side of the plane.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#43

The practical solution

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have never become proficient at edge planing, probably because I am too impatient coupled with the fact that there is no need to be.

"My problem, simply, is that after I take a board off the power joiner, I like to plane it by hand."

Case 1 preparing for edge gluing. In spite of what some believe there is no practical need to hand plane an edge after power jointing. The vast majority of panel preparation is done straight off the power jointer which demonstrates this fact. If you like to anyways, then practice for a few hours, or tens of hours or whatever, until you are proficient at not screwing up edges by hand planing them. There is no shortcut to this proficiency that I know of. Personally, there are other skills I would rather spend my time learning.

Case 2 removing machine "finish" from edges. For things like door frames where the edge will show I often first plane the edge as an alternative to sanding with a coarser grit. If the edge gets off a fraction of a degree it doesn't matter, where as it matters a lot in panel preparation.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#44

You were not sold "a bill of goods"......

roger lance

you were sold a metal fence that attaches to a metal plane at 90° with magnets....and this fence is only an aid to edge jointing 90° edges....you have not said that it does not work.....or that it is poorly made....indeed, the fence appears to do its job.....you should have realized its limitations below 2 1/4" and be willing to accept responsibility for your having a problem at that point....be just as fair to Lee Valley as you'd like them to be fair to you.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#45

Re: You were not sold "a bill of goods"......

TomD

I did not see him complain about it, he is just asking whether there is a way to plane when the height gets low. And it is a reasonable thing to ask when on considers all the stock there is in cabinetmaking around, say 1 3/4". I think there are options for him, so I really don't see why this thread has exploded. Simple problem simple answer.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#46

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

Mark Nowicki

To get a square edge with a cambered blade the position of the blade in relation to the work is important, not whether the plane is held square. You have to be able to move the plane away from the higher edge, and only the central position will give a square edge.

Maybe not a bill of goods, but a gizmo, a gadget, or victory of technology over common sense.

Don't try to make it work, there is no point.

Mark

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#47

Re: You were not sold "a bill of goods"......

eliot feldman

I agree completely; I have no problem with Lee Valley; I like them. I didn't think it through.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#48

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

Larry Barrett

Here is a suggestion. If you have a table saw, start with a 2x4 that is as long as the board you are wanting to plane. With the 2x4 vertical, cut a notch in it so that the width of the notch is a little less than the width of the your board, and the height of the notch is a little less than the height of your board. Put the 2x4 in your vise, and place your board in the notch. Put a flathead screw in the notch near the end of the 2x4, to act as a stop. You should now be able to plane your board with the fence on your plane.

Not a very practical suggestion, since it would have to be modified every time you wanted to plane a board with different dimensions.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#49

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldman

I'm having a little trouble figuring what you mean, exactly. But your kind of response is what I was hoping for all along. And I have an idea that I believe is similar: I thought I would start with a wide enough board (e.g. about six inches), and as in your example, the same length( or even longer) than the one I want to plane. Then I would cut a rabbet along its entire length about the same thickness as the one I want to plane ( it doesn't matter much) and in such a way that my board would fit into the rabbet and still stick up( perpendicular to the bench top) a little. Now the difficult part: I had in mind using a couple of those hold down clamps that screw into a base and hold down a board when the lever is pulled up. These would be screwed into the six inch board just below the bottom of the rabbet. Then my board would sit in the rabbet and be held tight against the six inch board by hold down clamps. The six inch board goes into the vice, it's sticking up about four inches, my board is held tight in the rabbet and it sticks up( proud) from the six inch board a little. The hold down clamps are on the right hand side below my board holding my board tight in the rabbet. Now the plane fence is on the left hand side, and I can push against it from the left( which is what you're supposed to do) as I plane with my right hand. THE KEY IDEA IS THAT THERE ARE NO TWO-SIDED CLAMPS HOLDING MY BOARD BECAUSE THEY WOULD GET IN THE WAY OF MY BOARD WHICH HAS LESS WIDTH THAN THE DEPTH OF THE PLANE FENCE! I know that some experienced people here disparaged the idea of a plane fence , and I see where they're coming from, but these same woodworkers all love shooting boards. Well, isn't a plane with a fence more or less a kind of portable shooting board set -up? I believe a consistent criticism of what I'm trying to do would encourage planing with NO aids, including shooting boards. As soon as you allow a shooting board, then why not a "portable" shooting board?

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#50

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

Larry Barrett

I thought I would start with a wide enough board (e.g. about six inches), and as in your example, the same length( or even longer) than the one I want to plane. Then I would cut a rabbet along its entire length about the same thickness as the one I want to plane ( it doesn't matter much) and in such a way that my board would fit into the rabbet and still stick up( perpendicular to the bench top) a little

This is what I meant by a 2x4 (or a 2x6) with a notch - you've described it better. Except, you are thinking of orienting this board in your vise with the rabbet on the right side so you can clamp your board. It will be simpler, and require no clamps, to have the rabbet on the left, the same side you are planing from. The rabbet should be such that your board, when placed in the rabbet, sticks up a little above the rabbet, and is proud of the rabbet on the side a little. This way you can plane the top of your board and the fence will be against your board.

When you plane your board, you are exerting both downward pressure and side pressure. The rabbet restrains the board in both dimensions so you should not need any clamps.

To restrain your board from being pushed to the left as you plane it, put a flathead screw in the rabbet near the left end of the rabbet, with the head of the screw sticking up.

This is the same idea as a sticking board that others have described. You can place this one in your vise, instead of using dogs on your bench.