New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Lee Valey hand plane fence

Posts

Lee Valey hand plane fence

#1

Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldman

I bought one at a woodworking show; it's used to keep the plane square to the edge of a board. It's nothing more than a flat metal strip held on with strong magnets and projects 2 1/4 inch below the plane sole. My problem with it is that I can't simply hold the board in the side bench vice if the width(height) of the board is less than 2 1/2 inches or so because the bottom edge of the fence hits the bench top. Aside from using longish clamps across the top of my bench, is there some simple way to hold a not-so-wide board upright so I can use this gizmo? My bench is the very traditional WoodSmith type with a fairly large side vice and an end vice with bench dogs. (It's not so stable to try to hold the board between bench dogs.)

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#2

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

TomD

I would freehand it. But an edge dog (page 108 in the Landis book) is designed to hold a piece with an angled end dog, over the side of the bench. But the same gizmo rigged to hold it flush would work. Also regular dogs with a piece of wood clamped to create side support.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#3

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

John Pappas

I'm curious...why not use a traditional shooting board? I rig up a fence when I square up long wide boards that are too long for my shooting board, but for most parts I use the shooting board.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#4

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

Jim Ritter

Turn everything upside down. Clamp the plane in the vise and push the board over it as if it was a power jointer. I do that on occasion if the piece is small enough.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#5

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

cstanford

Narrow boards are best edge planed on the benchtop, not in the vise.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#6

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

cstanford

I think you'll find this article helpful:

http://www.woodworkersjournal.com/Main/Articles/Skill_Builder_Ian_Kirbys_Planecraft_7233.aspx

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#7

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldmqn

For boards longer than the shooting board.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#8

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldmqn

But its for boards longer than my shooting board.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#9

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldmqn

So what's the best way to hold a board, say three feet long, 3/4 inch thick and 2 1/2 inches wide --with the 2 1/2 dimension perpendicular to the bench top -- on top of my bench. I find that when I clamp it between dogs using the end vice, then, when I start planing it, it's not so stable. Tends to rock sideways a bit.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#10

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

roger lance

Probably between dogs is the best solution....if it becomes unstable, you have a bench issue.....a possible method would be to clamp the board in a Bessey-like K-body clamp and then clamp the K-body to the bench.....


hope this helps.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#11

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

John Pappas

Again, a shooting board. I have a shooting board that is 4' long. It handles most furniture components that require a perfectly square edge. It is held between bench dogs, the plane lays on its side and the edge is easily squared up.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#12

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Roger's suggested one possibility. Another, if your benchtop is flat and if you have a way to clamp the board from the back (like, say, holdfasts), is to treat your bench as a shooting board: clamp the board down, with a thin* spacer below it and held back slightly, and set the plane on its side. This works, obviously, only if you have a plane with a flat side to the body (and, also, isn't a rabbeting design). For precision work, you could set the spacer against your layout line on the board: when the plane contacts the spacer, it stops cutting.

*The spacer should be thick enough to raise the board being planed so that the cutting iron's cutting across its full thickness; but it needn't be more than that.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#13

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

CStanford

Plane into a shop-made stop with a V cutout.

Sign up for a trial membership and download this:

http://www.finewoodworking.com/how-to/article/holding-your-work.aspx

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#14

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

CStanford

You can trap it in a clamp or dogs like others have suggested but the goal is to have the board loose so you can check it easily for edge square to face, etc.

You actually can plane a board like that against a simple stop. You can't go about it willy-nilly and you must be in balance and have some skill with the plane.

Read the Kirby article and the Hack article.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#15

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Eliot

Planing this without a fence is really the way to go. It takes a little practice, but with the aid of a small square to check progress it quickly becomes a point-and-shoot exercise.

Sometimes, however, one needs a quick way of ensuring that you are working with square. Two planes come to mind that will substitute for the jointer-plus-fence. The first is to use a moving fillister and fence, such as a Record #778 or a Stanley #78. The fence on these is shallow, but enough to ensure you are planing square. The other plane is a side rabbet plane. Again, it is just to return to square, and not a jointer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#16

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Eliot,

Putting a fence like that to work, especially with a heavy metal plane, requires using a lot of force from the side to hold the plane square to the work (see LV's instructions). So if you use dogs on top of the bench, you'll also need a supporting board clamped against the offside of the work to take the side loading.

You could use some variation of edge dogs, as Thom suggested, but there you'll need support clamped under the work, so the work doesn't slip from top loading.

In truth, the fence you bought has only specialized use--many everyday operations aren't suitable for it. If you're doing a bunch of long, wide, heavyish boards, which can be held in a vise, it could speed things up.

But to do everyday jointing task--like drawer bottoms, dust panels, jointing boards for a desktop or case side--all involved in making a piece of case goods, you really have two good options:

1. Learn to freehand edge join with the board held vertically, either in vise, or on the bench top pushed into a birds mouth (V shaped), or on the bench top against a plain stop (birds mouth is better for edge jointing IMO).

2. Do what John Pappas said twice: get the plane on its side and shoot the edge. Once you do this, you'll wonder how you ever got on without it! You can make a shooting board for this purpose. Or if you just want to try it, you can easily clamp a prototype setup to your bench top--sheet of plywood with a straight stick clamped on top to serve as a fence, with the work butted up against the straight stick and protruding over the edge of the plywood. Get your jointer on its side, and plane the work, letting the jointer just ride against the edge of the work. Plane from the middle of the work initially and gradually extend the length of the stroke to full length. This is like falling off a log, sets up and takes down quickly, and works on thins up to 4/4 or even thicker (just make sure your clamping is tight).

The most practical thing you can do right now is learn to shoot edges with the plane on its side. Then pick up freehand vertical edge jointing as you go--the basic technique of planing from the inside out is common to both methods.

Wiley

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#17

P. S.  re Jim Ritter's idea

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Jim's idea may be the most practical use of the fence itself. Get the plane upside down in a vise. This would be very quick, particularly for a bunch of thin or short sticks.

Wiley

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#18

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

Guillaume Dery

Make yourself a birdsmouth that you can drop in dog holes. For long boards, you will probably want to have a dog near the end that the board rests against to resist lateral force.

A birdsmouth is simply a v-opening cut into a board (actually mine is arcs, not a straight line V) that holds the board wedged upright. As you plane into (towards) it, the wedging action tightens. I added 2 short lengths of dowel under mine so that I can drop it into dog holes (2 so it doesn't twist on you).

At work right now but I can take a quick pic at home if you are interested.

As an aside, when I started down the hand-tool slope, I too got that fence, although it works as advertised, I would put it with the micro-adjust marking gauge in the category of Veritas products I consider a fail. There aren't too many of those (I generally love and find Veritas products brilliant) but these 2 products get under my skin.

As you've noticed, you can't use your vise to clamp the board to be jointed (unless it's monstrously wide). Also, there are too many variables involved. One assumes that the side of the plane is dead-on 90 degrees to the sole, that the blade is perfectly parallel to the sole and also that it is sharpened flat (no camber) since you aren't able to use the middle of the blade for the cut... Overall it's just too fussy for me and I learned to joint freehand. After redoing the same board umpteen times as my engineer's square revealed that it was a bit off 90, I finally developed some muscle memory and get it right more often than not.

P.S.: If you are gluing boards into a panel, plane adjacent boards together. Clamp them together with the faces outwards and joint them together. Any error in the 90 degrees will cancel itself out when you put them together to do the panel.

Guillaume

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#19

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Plane from the middle of the work initially and gradually extend the length of the stroke to full length. "

elaborate please.....is this operation for a board end or side? why start in middle?

Not knowing any better I start at the near edge.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#20

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

TomD

"

"Plane from the middle of the work initially and gradually extend the length of the stroke to full length. "

elaborate please.....is this operation for a board end or side? why start in middle?"

If you want to work the waste off, and it is generally flat, then start at the far end (near end for pull planes). The reason for that is so you clear a space. If you started in the middle you would end up unable to cut, and in your own way. If you started at the near end, you would work up a ramp.

When you want to establish or maintain flatness without reference to anything other than the plane. You start in the middle (third say), and plane until the plane will not take a shaving. Then you keep extending it. Once you get a whole run where the plane will not catch, you have established flat to the tolerance of the plane and set-up. If you need it flatter than that, you can back it out by working the ends to the middle. But that is sorta a counting strokes thing as the plane will not tell you when you are done.

Power jointer geometry is variable and similar or different, depending on the case. But you can waste starting at one end and just pushing through. If you had a dead flat edge or board, and a hand plane, you can also run the plane end for end, but it takes less to get in the way of the cut since the cut is as much as 100 times less then with the power tool.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#21

Starting in the middle...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

We were talking about planing the edge, and it is to be joined to another edge.

There are times when you can just go end to end--like if the stick has come straight off a table saw. One pass and done. Although even there I would make the first pass in the middle, so that I am certain I have the spring or lack of spring exactly the way I want. Or if you sight down the stick and see it's concave along the edge, then start going end to end.

But I find the least waste motion is just start in the middle. Starting in the middle will work with any stick that has been prepared for joining, lacking only edge planing. And you won't need any diagnostics to see where the lack of straightness is.

Why will it work with any stick? Make one quick pass in the middle--you'll get a shaving or you won't. If you do, keep planing til you don't get a shaving, and lengthen the stroke--repeat til you're going end to end. Go end to end until either the plane blade just scrapes the middle (if you want a shaving-thickness spring), or until you get a full length shaving, if you don't want any spring. But what if you make your quick pass in the middle, and get only air? Then lengthen the stroke until you do get a shaving, and proceed as before.

In sum, you can start at the end if you already know the board is dead straight, or is concave along the edge. But if you start at the end, and the board is a little convex along the edge, it'll stay convex and usually get moreso. If you start in the middle, all contingencies are accounted for and you don't have to break rhythm, just pick up the next stick in the stack and keep going.

Wiley

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#22

Re: Starting in the middle...

TomD

+1, Since 1979. Well explained.

The only minor point I would add is you get one shaving per length of plane sole. Or thereabout. Over a long board that can add up to a lot because the curve carries on. But it works out you can take working shaving for most boards up to about 8 feet, that you would need with an acceptable amount of spring. That is why jointers are 22", or whatever.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#23

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldmqn

This is what I consider a really well thought response -- not that the others aren't. I've pretty much come around to your point of view, anyway. Better to learn how to plane better. I'll still screw around with it though.

( I paid about $50 for it.)

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#24

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldmqn

This usually won't solve the lack of height problem: I need more sticking up than 2 1/4 inchs.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#25

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldmqn

Right. Why didn't I think of making a longer shooting board when the salesman was working on me at the woodworking show? Anybody want a bargain price on this $50 gizmo. It is beautifully made by Lee Valley.