New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Lee Valey hand plane fence

Posts

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#51

P.S.

Larry Barrett

Eliot, your idea is a good one and will also work, but has a drawback in that the fence on your plane will be against the 2x4 (or 2x6) as opposed to being against your board, so you may not end up with a 90* result. Better to have the fence on your plane against the side of the board you are planing.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#52

Re: P.S.

eliot feldman

I thought of that, too. Figure I just have to make the rabbet very square to the board. Can't do what I just described and have the fence against the good board because the hold downs would get in the way. Remember that the board I want to plane is not wide enough to clear the fence.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#53

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

eliot feldman

Hi Larry,

For some reason, I got your expanded explanation via my email but not here. Anyway, now that I fully understand your suggestion, which is the best one, if someone (me) is hell bent on doing it this way, I will try it exactly as you suggest. It's just what I had in mind but without any need for the hold down clamps.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#54

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

TomD

"THE KEY IDEA IS THAT THERE ARE NO TWO-SIDED CLAMPS HOLDING MY BOARD BECAUSE THEY WOULD GET IN THE WAY OF MY BOARD WHICH HAS LESS WIDTH THAN THE DEPTH OF THE PLANE FENCE!"

Are you going into production making guitar necks or something, or is this a one-off need? Cause... This does not seem that big a deal to fixture and generally worth all the discussion if we are just talking about a piece or two. Would it really be worth the clutter to have a jig for this?

"I know that some experienced people here disparaged the idea of a plane fence , and I see where they're coming from, but these same woodworkers all love shooting boards."

I do have a shooting board, it is one of my few jigs. Mostly it is the end grain shooting I do. I also do guitar tops, sometimes. One thing is that I have edge joints 7 feet long to do, most of those boards are either narrow enough to go into a shooting board, or when glued up need something entirely different. I am not going to shoot the 8 foot or 6 foot side though.

"Well, isn't a plane with a fence more or less a kind of portable shooting board set -up?"

So yeah, morally a fence is a fence, though I don't think that is most people's issue with it. They rightly believe it is a no brainner to do freehand. The two most prominent cases are no brainners. If you think about it, in the cluttered tool market of today, or in the past, side fences are not that common, in the situation I think you are engaged in. Point in fact the LV device is an aftermarket deal, they sell what? Two LV jointer planes, and no fixed OEM fences?

"I believe a consistent criticism of what I'm trying to do would encourage planing with NO aids, including shooting boards. As soon as you allow a shooting board, then why not a "portable" shooting board?"

Well again, "morally"`, that is correct. But practically I don't see it as being about cheating, or whatever. If you think of table saws, they are very similar in cross-cut mode to a shooting board. But there is not a portable version (or really an equivalent to the TS rip function in a shooting board). There are portable saws, and today (due to the popularity of sheet goods, we have the plunge units). But what is a popular format in the table saw, does not translate into a popular format for the hand held saw, we have a freehand version, we don't have a hand held fenced version for the most part. My point is just that the practicalities of given formats are based on deep analysis of how these formats work. In metal working we have vertical bandsaws, and horizontal bandsaws, but not so much in woodworking (there are massive horizontal resaws). In metal working we have vertical auto feed bandsaws, and hand held bandsaws. But what works in one geometry, or material does not automatically translate into popularity in another. But you are free to experiment with the tool you have, it just has to satisfy you. However, people who have swung both ways are in a better position to evaluate merits or even what is easiest to do, than people who are locked into one way of doing things.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#55

Re: Lee Valley hand plane fence

William Duffield, between the York and the James

I was in Colonial Williamsburg last week, at a conference. This week, I'm in Florida. I'll be back on the Cohansey next week.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#56

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

William Duffield, between the York and the James

For a sticking board you might not have to rebuild every time (although lots of pros have no problem making a new custom one every time they need one), you might find a useful idea or two from the modular sticking board I posted early in November. You can find it if you do a WoodCentral forum search using my last name and "sticking" as the key words.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#57

Re: Long grain shooting board

TomD

Yes.

About the only long grain I shoot are guitar tops. In that case they need to be zero spring because the aspect ratio of the planks is such that they do not bend. You are dealing with 1/8" by 8 by 20 say. It can't be sprung. So with a straight edge on the shooting board, one simply shoots the line straight. One does not use the sole as a reference, since that geometry leads to concavity.

What I actually do, though, shame, is I made a wooden jointer that has the cut of an ultimate smoother, this allows me to use the sole as a reference. However, that would still lead to some spring, and surfaces to be joined are too smooth. So the final pass is with a sandpaper plane on the shooting board. The results are so perfect that I rub joint them, and they grow together without any clamps. I have forgotten to mark the centre line on occasion, and been unable to find, it which is bad because you know when you build the guitar that the bookmatch will show and needs to be precisely centred. It was almost frightening, like being lost in the woods.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#58

Re: Lee Valley hand plane fence

CStanford

No place like home.

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#59

Re: Long grain shooting board

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Great example, Thom! Gonna think about your methods for some 1/8" veneer strips, roughly 5"x 34" to be joined for the interior of a writing desk top. I have a 30" jointer with tight mouth to use. Alternative is to plane back to a reference fence, and then I don't think the plane length matters?

Do you find it's more precise to do the two guitar back halves one at a time, rather than doubled? Maybe if you double up, it's more hassle to get them registered together?

I am really struck by your statement that the two planed edges are too smooth or slick to be joined well, and that it works best to give them a little key from the sandpaper. Are you rub jointing the two halves with hot hide glue or what?

Much thanks for all the detail,

Wiley

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#60

Re: Long grain shooting board

TomD

Wiley,

"Great example, Thom! Gonna think about your methods for some 1/8" veneer strips, roughly 5"x 34" to be joined for the interior of a writing desk top. I have a 30" jointer with tight mouth to use. Alternative is to plane back to a reference fence, and then I don't think the plane length matters?"

Right, So long as the plane is reasonably flat, and the edge of the shooting board also, then they should run straight, and one could be using a smooting plane for all the difference it makes. One does not need much mo to get through 1/8" wood.

The plane I made for shooting guitar backs was actually based on one that Krenov used (to the extent that I could figure that out, I have never seen one of his jointers in person). I had noticed that many of his jointers were about 18" long, which did not make much conventional sense. Given that a lot of his pieces are small, one answer would be that it was just proportionately scaled down. However, for the most part, Krenov builds in full size pieces. He does not edge joint a lot of planks to make larger pieces. So most of the work he joints is not unlike making guitar plates up since they consist of book matching pieces of wood that would be too stiff to have any spring. Given that, it does not make all that much sense that he would use short planes, since longer planes minimize hollowing out. And I know he was aware of this because I learned the proper use of planes from his video. So the only remaining answer I could come up with was that his planes were set to take smoothing plane shavings, and as such would allow the spring to be minimized. There isn't any sign in his books of shooting gear. However, from things I have seen in mags, there was a lot of long grain shooting going on at the school when their emphasis shifted to marketry. And the one picture I have seen (FWW) shows a Krenov jointer on it's side, with a stack of veneer clamped between two boards, the jointer is being used freehand.

"Do you find it's more precise to do the two guitar back halves one at a time, rather than doubled? Maybe if you double up, it's more hassle to get them registered together?"

I think you could go either way. I do them one at a time. Guitar sides are normally very straight grained wood, and quartered full width. However the edges can run out to a riffed material, and there can be advantages to that. People look at the idea material along the glue line, but really the limber wood at the edges may be providing most of the scope for movement. Anyway, when you get the panels, they often have wain on them, and therefore they can be quite a bit off the ideal point for alignment. I guess it isn't real wain since the joint takes place pith to pith, but that is how the wood sometimes looks. So I try to find the idea growth ring on each piece, then separately plane to it, then I join the plates along that ring. Might sound fancy to a non woodworker, but it is pretty obvious since the lines are very well defined. Since the wood is often 36 lines to the inch, one does have to pay attention, or one looses one's place.

Since the method I use creates perfect joints, and is a no brainer, no skiller, there is no advantage like netting out angle wander as one gets from pairing up pieces when jointing boards. I use that strategy a lot, but it is not better than what I do for guitars, for that scale of work.

"I am really struck by your statement that the two planed edges are too smooth or slick to be joined well, and that it works best to give them a little key from the sandpaper. Are you rub jointing the two halves with hot hide glue or what?"

I do use hide glue and that is where guitar building is headed, it seems. Along with liberal amounts of crazy glue. :). The joining method I have used most commonly for tops and backs is one described by arthur overholtzer. He used white glue, and I use either Titebond Classic, or LMII lutherie glue, which is probably better. I cover a workboard about the width of my top or back with waxed paper, I need to cover the whole board, because while there is only glue coming out of the centerline, if one were to put waxed paper only down the middle, it would cause the center line to peak. Another option is to run a 3/4" rebate down the center of the work board and line that with packing tape. That way the centerline will not even be in contact. One puts glue down one edge and places it on the workboard. One C clamps the top and bottom of this panel so it is firmly held, but not distorted. One runs a bead of glue down the other piece and rubs it up against the first piece until it bites. The only minor knack is to get it to freeze at the same time as both pieces are aligned for height, but this is not normally difficult. One them leaves the piece to dry. The glue pulls it together very tightly, and the joint disappears. If one does not mark a notch at the top and bottom of the joint, it is often impossible to locate the centerline which is bad because the layout depends on it. One might wonder how one could loose the joint, most often it happens if one flushed up the panels, and their upper and lower edges were rough off the suppliers saw, and therefore hide the slight misalignment one could tolerate in such work.

The main problem with this method is that some of the boards are cupped, and will not rest flat on a surface. Then I add a few other small clamps, an sometimes I add weight along the joint. But if one really runs into that problem a lot, one is probably a candidate for a Charles Fox jig.

http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m6a5ncQvUx1rrb31y.jpg

I just love the Overholtzer magic, so I have never bothered to invest the time and space in a Fox jig.

"Much thanks for all the detail"

Cheers!

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#61

Re: Long grain shooting board

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

That's very helpful, Thom! Both on the shooting and gluing topics. Lots of shooting options, and I'll try a couple of them to see what works best.

On the gluing, I'm a little leery of attempting a rub joint that is 34" long, cause my hands can't cover that long a waterfront or gluefront. I think I will use veneer tape to control the vertical matchup (of 1/8 to 1/8 edges), which is critical because I don't want to have to plane 1/32" off both sides of the glue up.

Choice of glue is a tough call, because the workability and grab-time of PVA is just right, whereas hot hide really pulls the two sheets together, but there is no fiddle-with-it time allowed.

What is best about the LMII lutherie glue? I need to go look that up.

Much thanks,

Wiley

Re: Lee Valey hand plane fence

#62

Re: Long grain shooting board

TomD

I don't think it would be worth it to get LMII glue, though it might be fun. It's big deal is that it dries really hard, and for most wood applications hard is good, and will control creep. This is one of the benefits of hide glue also. But Titebond 1 is very good at that. I don't trust the other versions as they have little track record.