New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

Posts

Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#1

Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

Phil

Just playing around with a LN LA Jack and a cobbled together sort of shoot/shooting board. For shooting cherry end grain (lets say 3/4 stock maybe a couple of inches wide): how heavy a cut would you typically take: in thousandths of an inch (lots of references say "light cut", "very light cut" etc.). I'm trying to quantify this dimension.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#2

easy answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

take as heavy a cut as you can push the plane through, which will depend on sharpness of blade, thickness, wood species and mass of plane.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#3

Respectfully beg to differ

Ron Harper

I would rather take 4 very light passes than try to hog it off in one pass. I feel more in control and I think the end grain appreciates it.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#4

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Tak

TomD

I think it is less about how heavy, and more about how you get there. Start light, deepen the cut, then when you reach a point where the performance is suffering, back off the plane. Or don't take it that far in the first place. One of the bad things about metal planes is that most of them have significant backlash in adjustment of blade depth. If you get to a point where you have to back off, then it may be best to overshoot to the low side and come back up to performance, once you reverse course you loose control of the depth of cut, in some situations, since you are pulling the blade, not pushing it, and the blade can settle to a lower position than you put it into. With poorly designed mechanisms you may not be able to control the placement regardless of how you come at it.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#5

Re: Respectfully beg to differ

Phil

Over the years, I've gotten into the habit of measuring shaving thickness when I first set up a plane after honing the blade. I'll usually set it up for what I call a light cut in long grain, around 2 thousandths. When I get the iron positioned for a full width cut that is even across, I'll adjust it for the work I'm going to do. I was wondering if folks are taking a couple of thou cut, or maybe a heavier cut around 5 thou perhaps? Again, just trying to quantify what is common practice.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#6

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Tak

Mark Hennebury

Your really asking the correct question but in the wrong place. Ask the wood and the plane... they will give you a better answer,

skew works best for end grain.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#7

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Tak

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

that's what I was trying to say. If the cut is too light you are wasting time and needlessly dulling the blade. Too heavy and it will bog down, chatter, etc. Damned if I ever measure a shaving. Even if I did it would vary with wood, plane, sharpness, etc.

If I am shooting an end it is to fit the piece somewhere or square it, not for show. So if the plane cuts that is all I am looking for to declare success. Somebody looking for a show surface might have other metrics.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#8

agreed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you are not in control, the plane is chattering, then the cut is too heavy. If you are taking 4 passes when 1 would be acceptable you are wasting time and needlessly dulling the blade, which might be irrelevant, or not.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#9

Re: Respectfully beg to differ

TomD

I don't think there is anything wrong with measuring shavings, and in particular the outer edges to see if the blade is square. Not for everything, but a good check.

The problem here is that often you get only crumbs depending on the wood. The plane itself is a potent measurement tool so one can be sensitive to that also.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#10

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Tak

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Phil,

Like everyone says, it all depends. However, I'll answer the question so you have another data point.

I had never mic'ed an endgrain shaving before you asked. Right now, I'm using one of two planes--a 50-degree-bedded C&W 22" try plane, and a C&W 40-degree-beveldown 14" mitering plane (called a strike-block plane). Both have straight blades. Both pretty sharp, and I didn't bother to touch them up.

Shaving 1/2" sugar maple, I found 2 thousandths to be a light shaving; 4 thousandths to be pretty much the sweet spot; and 7 thousandths heavy. Like Ron Harper, I'd rather take three or four light shavings than one heavy one, and for the same reason he gives--control and I like for all handtool work to have a poised but relaxed feel, leaving something in reserve if needed.

Shaving 4/4 soft maple, again 2 thousandths felt light; 3 thousandths is what I would prefer, and I didn't try for a heavy shaving.

Wiley

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#11

Well, I don't care ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

if I need to take a few extra shavings. I'd rather have to re-sharpen the blade than recut a piece of wood because it is now too short or the end has blown out/spelched.

When shooting, you are not removing much wood - otherwise you'd be using a saw instead. So take your time.

Some endgrain is brittle, some is crumbly. Be careful.

Regards from Ottawa (off to Vegas)

Derek

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#12

Re: Respectfully beg to differ

Phil

Crumbs, thats it. One of the motivations for this question. At around .002 I'm getting crumbs. If I dial it back to get around .005, I get full shavings. I just was not sure if my iron was sharp enough, or if I was expecting the impossible: full shavings at .001/.002 thou. Maybe thats the holy grail of end grain shooting?

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#13

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Tak

Phil

Bingo! Thats what I'm talking about. I was trying to take too big a bite ( I think) and was having a difficult time getting the plane to pare through the wood. Iron was just sharpened and shaved arm hair nicely, as well as paring end grain piece of pine I had in the vise, so I believe its "sharp enough". With these data points, I should be better able to dial in the "sweet spot". Here the caliper I use: gee I thought everyone measured shavings?????? :)


img

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#14

The need is another variable

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In my mixed power/hand tool shop I may employ a shooting board differently.

The most common need I have for shooting the end of something is to square it when it isn't. Drawer sides are a good example. I don't fret perfect table saw cuts any more. Any tiny deviation from square gets planed away. The added benefit is better visibility of the scribe lines, which is not insignificant. My objective here is to get the end square with as few passes as possible, especially when I have two dozen or more ends to square. I set the plane to take as heavy a cut as it will without chatter or stall. This cut on 3/8" poplar can be much heavier than Wiley's ideal . On the other hand, on a case side the material may be 7/8" walnut. An "ideal" setting for a drawer side would hopelessly chatter or stall for this task.

My second most common need is fitting something between something fixed, for example a drawer divider. The divider would commonly be 7/8" walnut or other hardwood. Derek, I would not find it possible to take a shaving so heavy on this thick and hard material that I would risk undersizing it due to shaving thickness. I once had to shoot the ends of 1" material and it was difficult setting a shaving thin enough to get the plane to cut smoothly.

My third most common need is adjusting a miter for length and/or angle. In this case I would adjust for a light shaving, probably equivalent to Wiley's ideal for all the reasons he enumerates.

In any of these applications a shaving that stalls or chatters the plane is too thick. Beyond this criteria, the "ideal" shaving can depend on situation. But, to answer what may have been the original concern, end grain is more difficult to cut than long grain, and hence, necessitates a thinner shaving.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#15

The holy grail?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Maybe thats the holy grail of end grain shooting?"

Maybe in a planing contest but not in practical woodworking. The holy grail is removing the precise amount of wood that needs to be removed as quickly as possible with a resulting acceptable surface. I don't build anything where removing 0.005 instead of 0.002 is relevant to success.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#17

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Tak

Mark Hennebury

The backlash issue can be solved by removing the blade adjustment and using a small hammer, gives very precise control and quick adjustment.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#18

P. S.--metal plane datum

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Phil,

Just out of curiosity, I repeated the cut on the 1/2" sugar maple (about 3" long BTW), using an LN 5-1/2 (45 degree angle). Pretty sharp, but not freshly touched up. 45 degree frog.

I liked the 3 thousandth cut the best. 5 thousand felt a little too heavy.

Technique: I don't use a 'running start' with the plane. I get the blade registered in the wood, then pull it through from a standing start.

Wiley

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#19

Re: P. S.--metal plane datum

Phil

OK, more useful information. I think I am getting a better feel for the thickness of cut. Pull the plane you say: interesting. No running start: glad you mentioned that. I've been pushing the LNLAJ: relatively leisurely pace, no momentum brought to bear. I had been wondering if I should be taking more advantage of the mass of the plane (increase velocity)? Is there an advantage to pulling the plane toward you: I push the plane with my right hand (being a righty) and hold the specimen against the fence with my left hand.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#20

Ah, Vegas

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Derek signs himself, "Regards from Ottawa (off to Vegas)"

Let's hope the next signoff isn't, "Derek, in a small cafe outside Vegas, trying to figure out how to get home after blowing the airline ticket on a sure bet."

Years ago, you could tell when you were approaching Vegas by all the guys (never women for some reason) in suits that were once good suits, and now somewhat ragged suits, on the other side of the highway, hitchhiking OUT of Vegas because they had no more to put on the table.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#21

Photo of setup

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Phil,

Maybe it'll help to show the setup. Please excuse the photo, taken in raking light in the morning:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8372859681/in/set-72157632126114344

Setup: The shooting board is a 5/8" thick triangle set into a groove in a doug fir 2x6. Running length of the triangle about 20". The plane is running directly on the bench top. The portion of the 2x6 below the shooting board acts as a cleat; the portion of the 2x6 above the shooting board is the fence. (For 45-degree mitering, I just turn the board over, the cleat now becomes the fence, and vice versa.) A carpet of 220g PSA sandpaper is laid down at the base of the fence, so that the stick to be jointed lays on it and won't have a tendency to slide sideways under cutting pressure.

With this setup, it is natural to pull the plane, because the shooting board cleat is held in a vise. An LV twin screw being used as an end vise--covers the whole end of the bench.

So you can see, there is not much theory involved in pushing versus pulling--it just depends on the design of the shooting board. If I were using a benchhook, I suppose I would be pushing the plane.

As for running start vs. standing start, I want a controlled, even thickness shaving the width of the stick, and I find this more readily done by registering the plane in the cut, then pulling it through from a standing start. But others' mileage may vary :) .

Wiley

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#22

Re: Photo of setup

Phil

OK, I'm not too far off then. I've been using a bench hook with a scrap of plywood underneath to act as the track for the plane. Its got a cleat which is in the face vise. In shooting 3/4 cherry stock, I've yet to get a full 3/4" wide shaving: it seems to be more in the neighborhood of 3/8". I suspect it could be just a subtle adjustment of the iron (which I use a small hammer to accomplish). Here is my setup (this was the proof of principle experiment: when I get the hang of it I'll build the regulation shooting board):


img

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#23

Re: Photo of setup

Eric in Los Gatos

OK, I've got to know. Did you set the pic of (I'm assuming) you and Norm for the ironic effect. Is it possible this is the only way to get him close to a shooting board?

Eric

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#24

What a drive by gloat !!.......

roger lance

A picture of you and "your ole buddy, Norm".....cool.....I've still to met the man and my brother, who has no interest in woodworking, runs into Norm frequently at a grocery where they both go after work on the way home....life ain't fair I tell ya.

Re: Shooting End Grain: How Heavy A Cut Do You Take?

#25

Re: What a drive by gloat !!.......

Phil

Believe it or not, that photo has been in that very position on the left corner of my bench for years. I suppose I should flip the picture around when using planes and such, out of respect :) Seriously, he was the guy that started it all for me (and I suspect for many other woodworkers, hand and power tool alike). With Norm always keeping an eye on me in the shop, I figure I can't go too far wrong.