PS on testing
Bill Tindall
When we glue up a panel it is normally then trimmed to size. I always break the joints on the trimmings to test the joint strength . This simple test provides feedback for technique and materials.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
PS on testing
Bill Tindall
When we glue up a panel it is normally then trimmed to size. I always break the joints on the trimmings to test the joint strength . This simple test provides feedback for technique and materials.
Glue test this morning fail
Ron Harper
No tackiness between the fingers of the Franklin Liquid hide glue.
Just for the heck of it I tried the same test on a bottle of Old Brown hide glue recently purchased. I did not warm it as the instructions say to do. Almost instantly tacky.
Looks like a bad bottle of the other glue?
Re: Glue test this morning fail
Ron Harper
No strings at all with Franklin liquid hide glue
question
Bill Tindall
No strings means the protein has been degraded. What is the history on this bottle of glue? If it is new Franklin would be interested in knowing about it. If not new its storage history would be good to know.....and avoid. While they publish a 1 year shelf life, under typical conditions it will remain good for years.
I'll be testing my hide glue before use....
roger lance
with this simple tacky test....and I'll be trying some of the Edwards Old Brown Glue....just an aside: Edwards built a very interesting and unique bench which is a combination of a Roubo and Scandinavian....perhaps someone might post it for discussion.
Re: question
Ron Harper
Less than a year old. Stored in my basement at around 65 degrees ambient temp. Almost no exposure to significant light.
Re: question
Bill Tindall
call Franklin customer service. They will be interested in finding out what happened to this bottle. They will need the small faint numbers printed on the bottle near the top which will tell when it was made, and batch number.
If the protein is degraded the viscosity of the stuff in the bottle will be vastly less than the other product you used. (must be assessed at the same temperature).
Re: PS on testing
TomD
I do that too, though it is a bit like the guy who picks up the insanely sharp tool that doesn't belong to him and wipes his finger over the edge. I sure don't expect there to be a problem.
Re: Glue joint problem
Paul M.
I've been playing with hot hide glue lately, and was dismayed at the short open time available to get the pieces together and clamped up. I had some bad joints when I tested them.
Then I discovered the same lesson Tom mentioned. Heat is your friend with hot hide glue. Make sure your workpiece is nice and warm first.
I got a cheap hotplate and I have a couple of large wrenches that I keep on the hotplate as heat sinks. When I want to glue a guitar brace to the soundboard, I take a hot wrench off the hot plate and put it on the soundboard where the brace will go. I take the brace and put it on the hot plate. Wait a minute or so and both the brace and the soundboard where it will be adhered are toasty warm which makes glue ups with hot hide glue less frantic and very successful. I'm getting very strong bonds now.
Re: Glue joint problem
Bruce McCrory
... I wish I had your subtlety for humor, Ron.
Misleading
CStanford
Have fun defending an indefensibly bad product. Franklin Liquid Hide Glue is a crapshoot product.
Re: question
CStanford
We talking about Franklin? It's still sold in a totally opaque dark brown bottle, isn't it? I don't think light can get through.
Re: Misleading
William Duffield
I also had some joints using Franklin liquid hide glue fail just last week. The rack I built was caught between a motorized wheel chair and an elevator door. The failure wasn't really the glue's fault, but it gave me an opportunity to examine the joints. Both surfaces of all the failed joints had glue on them. One beech tenon failed, but the rest just pulled out and the rock maple parts and the rest of the tenons showed no wood failure at the joints or in the mortises. I tested the glue on Friday. It is newer than the expiration date, and it passed the pinch test. It was down in the thirties in the shop Friday morning, so I had to warm up the bottle of glue in my glue pot to get it into a liquid state for the test.
I redesigned the rack and put it back together with West System. It spent the night in the kitchen curing. I'll reinstall it today.
Re: Misleading
Bruce, a MN Galoot
Have you had that sort of failure before, William? How about similar results with Patrick's glue? Yellow glue?
Re: Misleading
William Duffield
I've never used Patrick's Old Brown Glue. Usually I just keep the Franklin's LHG in stock for restoration work, for repairing veneer that has loosened. I've only had a similar failure once that I've noticed, with Titebond III, but in that case, both surfaces were covered with a white powder, not the expected yellow glue residue. I used the LHG in this case because I was not sure of the design, and I figured (rightly so) that I needed a glue that was easily reversible. The problem was that the wheel chair is an hour and a half away from my shop, and in use several times a day, so I couldn't bring it back to my shop to fit the walker rack to it, or test it.

This pic shows the initial design. It worked superbly for three months, but it hasn't been driven like Mel Brooks and Paul Newman in Silent Movie. For the redesign, I just changed the ends of the hooks from vertical to 45° so if its wheel gets caught again, the walker will just pop off the rack, instead of tearing the hooks off.
Testing
Bill Tindall
The only sure way to test glue is to make a joint that is not subject to the precision of making the joint, make the joint fail and look for wood failure. To that end a simple lap joint is reliable to make and make fail and look for wood failure. You can not be sure a glue is lacking until this sort of test is done.
Some test results from FWW, July-Aug 2007
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
A pretty extensive test, testing the breaking strength of a range of glues (Titebond 3, Slow-Set Epoxy, Elmers yellow, Old Brown Glue, Moser's hot hide, and a polyurethane) against maple, oak and ipe, and against tight, snug, and loose joints. I found this a very credible test.
Quantitative results. The glue ratings were in terms of breaking strength, so you could see how, for example, the hide glues compared against the PVA's and epoxy for each wood and each joint tightness condition.
More general findings were also interesting:
1. Ordinary yellow glue as strong as the more expensive Titebond III.
2. Liquid hide glue as strong as hot hide.
3. No evidence of 'joint starvation' in the tight joints, for any glue.
4. Epoxy not necessarily on tropicals.
http://www.oldbrownglue.com/pdf/HowStrongisYourGlue_FWW.pdf
Wiley
Thanks, Ron! Recommend 'Old Brown Glue'
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Ron,
You've done a good service for us. No one likes to admit having problems, but we all have them, and they're some of the most useful threads, since 'what goes wrong' is so rarely discussed objectively.
Like a couple of the others here (Roger Lance provided a video), I highly recommend Old Brown Glue. Never tested it--I accept Case Western's glue tests, see elsewhere in this thread.
Here's what sells me on Old Brown Glue, and why I recommend it:
1. Patrick Edwards is the real deal.
2. The lady who picks up the phone down in San Diego sets new records for niceness and attentiveness to your needs. She's not an order taker either, she's in the business and knows what's what. She gets it right. (619) 298-0864
3. She is also fanatic about your getting fresh product. They make only in small batches, so it's not sitting around getting old. The last time I called, she asked me could I wait one day--they had a new batch cooked up, and she needed just a little time to get some into a brown bottle for me.
4. They care.
5. They appreciate your business.
http://www.oldbrownglue.com/articles.html
Wiley
panel vs joint gluing
Bill Tindall
Liquid hide glue has some benefits on joints that slide together. It lubricates the joint and it has a long working time which overall makes assembly go smoother.
For edge joinery the fast tack and short time to gain sufficient strength for working panels makes the "yellow" glues the best choice for interior furniture panels. The long working time and "lubricity" of liquid hide make it the worst choice for this application.
Re: panel vs joint gluing
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Bill and all,
I generally agree with that, and normally use yellow glue for edge joins--the fast tack is useful when doing the clamp dance. Also, cleanup is straightforward on typical edge joins like table tops, desk tops.
However, I feel the terms 'best' and 'worst' are unnecessarily freighted here. 'Worst choice' to me implies 'don't do it'. But we know that many skilled workers always and only use hide glue--hot or liquid--and report uniformly good results. In some cases, repairability is important to people (see Wm. Duffield's post in this regard). The test results I published elsewhere in this thread showed PVA to be stronger than hide against breaking, but all the glues tested--PVA, liquid and hot hide, epoxy--were tremendously strong and suitable for purpose. Only polyurethane raised questions.
Therefore, I conclude that other considerations than breaking strength may figure in a glue decision. For example, I like hide in any glue situation where cleanup is going to be non-trivial. This includes the joinery gluings you stated, like dovetails, M&T, and certain situations where tongues or whole boards are going into grooves, or multiple tenon joins. Or inlays, especially where ebony is involved, and you don't want to have to sand the ebony. I know, I know, if you're really careful, you can avoid squeeze-out. But I would prefer to see glue, in order to be sure of total coverage, and then have a simple cleanup which will leave no trace or interference with finishes.
In Ron's case, he had made the prior decision to use hide, and my recommendation was in that spirit. Old Brown Glue will be fresh when bought.
Not actually arguing your point, which I think is correct as stated. But to me, the situation is too nuanced for the use of terms like 'best' and especially 'worst', without qualification.
Wiley
I can agree to that
Bill Tindall
I should have used a less perjoritive term for slippery slow curing edge joints.
hide glue cleanup
Lars Parrington
Wiley, would you give a bit more info on how you clean up hide glue squeezout in difficult to access spots? Thanks!
Re: Thanks, Ron! Recommend 'Old Brown Glue'
CStanford
Amen!!!
Re: hide glue cleanup; Stephen Shepherd
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Lars and all,
Short version: clean up squeeze-out and drippings with a moist rag.
Long version:
Liquid hide and hot hide clean up with water, as in a wet (not dripping) cotton rag. In addition, hot hide gels quickly, so in about 20 minutes or so, it gels to a rubbery consistency and you can scoop up a whole intact bead of squeeze-out from a board join with a scraper, say. Then run a rag over whatever is left and you've got it. Some say warm water and some say cold--I use what comes out of the cold tap. But I haven't noticed that it's a big deal either way.
Particularly with liquid hide, I prefer to get up the squeeze-out right away. You asked specifically about getting it out of corners and hard to reach places. What you do with hide glue, is always have a rag pile within reach, so you can get yourself a wet rag anytime you need one. If the squeeze-out or droppings are easy to get at, just pick up a rag in your hand, wet it, squeeze out water so it's wet but not dripping, and wipe. Dig the rag in with your thumbnail if you're getting it out of a skinny little seam of some kind.
But what if it's a drawer you've dove-tailed, and now you have squeeze-out in an interior corner, say where the bottom, side, and back of the front come together in the corner. Take a putty knife--putty knife is best, I think, cause you're not going to mark anything with it inadvertently, and it has just enough flex to work just right--drape the wet rag over it, and get down into the corner. Wipe using new places on the rag, until there's no residue left showing to your eye. It's now clean as a whistle and will not affect finish--you don't need to scrape or sand, which would itself leave a small mess in the corner to be cleaned up. Or, say, if you've dovetailed a case together, or used multiple tenons for joining case sides to legs, and have squeeze out along the join between side and bottom or side and top, just drag the putty knife or screwdriver with the wet rag draped over it, right down the join line, and the glue will come right up. Make two or three passes, using fresh portions of the rag, until it's all gone to your eyesight, and you're done. If you've already done some pre-finishing, it's easiest of all, but the glue will also come right up off of bare wood, in the manner described above, and leave no trace or resistance to finish.
I hurry to add, that our own Stephen Shepherd is an authority on hide glue, and has written an interesting and entertaining book on the subject, which Joel carries at Tools for Working Wood:
Wiley
Re: hide glue cleanup; Stephen Shepherd
Lars Parrington
thanks wiley!
yellow glue can also be cleaned up with a wet rag before it dries, but i've found that it's hard to get every last bit of it off. often i'm left with a invisible smear that only shows up when i go to finish the piece. so, instead of wiping, i usually just let the glue cure for an hour and then scrape it off.
from the length of you last post, i suspect that you are a more diligent glue wiper than i am, but even so i'd guess that you are still leaving behind invisible smears of hide glue. if so, that suggests that a finish can penetrate a thin layer of hide glue, but not a thin layer of yellow glue.
can you confirm this? i.e. have you tried the wet wipe method with yellow glue and had poor results?