New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Glue joint problem

Posts

Glue joint problem

#1

Glue joint problem

Ron Harper

Fellow craftspersons

As many of you know, I am back at woodworking after a ten year hiatus. I have worked wood for more than 25 years. I have never had a glue joint fail ( that I know about) till now. I have switched to doing almost everything with hand tools. I am making an Arts and Crafts bedside table. Top is cherry requiring three boards, two glue joints. Last weekend one of the joints failed. I was stunned. I go thru the troubleshooting checks and honesty requires me to admit that while the joint was tight on the face of the panel, the edge was not square. OK ... My bad. In the past i prepared all my glue-ups with a power jointer and took off the tiniest shaving with my 608 to remove jointer marks. Squareness was not ever a problem. OK , a learning experience. Square it up . Re- glue. Check other joint ... Appears tight. Tonight while chamfering edges other joint fails, and the one that I had reglued failed. Titebond liquid hide glue. Before my hiatus, I used hide glue almost exclusively, but it was my own homebrew in a glue pot. I have not got that set up yet.

Galoots, the joints that failed tonight were square and plumb. I work in a basement shop. Temp is around 67 degrees. In all cases, joints were left in clamps more than 12 hours.

I am perplexed

Ron

Sent from Xfinity Connect Mobile App

Re: Glue joint problem

#2

Re: Glue joint problem

Curt Putnam

What's the expiration date of the glue?

Re: Glue joint problem

#3

Could not find one


Re: Glue joint problem

#4

Re: Glue joint problem

R Payne

There are simple tests to determine if liquid hide glue is still good. I've read of them, but as I use hot hide glue, not liquid, I can't give any details on them without searching first. I figure you can search as well as I can.

ron

Re: Glue joint problem

#5

Re: Glue joint problem

TomD

Well here are four common problems:

Contamination, presumably not an issue. But theoretically a lot of war on you plane could cause a problem.

Bad glue, generally if you put a small amount on your fingers and press and separate them several times, you will feel a bite, and the glue may not be perfect, but it will not come apart in the minor use you are reporting. also just test some small blocks or something you are totally sure of.

Over or under clamping. You should see that the joint comes apart and the glued surfaces are bare and did not split or break, at least for the most part. Or if you did not use enough pressure, the wood will probably not break much, and there will be globs of glue on the joint.

The joint was not mechanically perfect, gaps, or in theory, it could be too perfect surfaces.

So some of these things could arise from the layoff, and some from the change in tools.

Re: Glue joint problem

#6

I will test glue for tackiness and report


Re: Glue joint problem

#7

craigd

Re: Glue joint problem

craigd

I had a similar thing happen - I was given a QS red oak desk my great grandfather built and was able to break apart the three board top with my bare hands, the desk was built with hot hide. I don't know the cause but I'm guessing poor workmanship.

Hide glue is susceptible to starvation, where as PVA glues aren't, so over clamping is a possibility.

I have a bottle of TightBond hide that is over two years past best-used-by and it is fine (I did a glue up as a test and couldn't break it with a hammer).

Re: Glue joint problem

#8

Re: Glue joint problem

Bill Tindall

what did the failed joint surface look like

Re: Glue joint problem

#9

Re: Glue joint problem

Patrick Gibbons

It was not uncommon to tongue those joints to add more glue surface when hide glue was more commonly used. I would presume your experience was not an uncommon occurrence and better craftsmen than you and I got the same results.

Re: Glue joint problem

#10

Re: Glue joint problem

Ron Harper

Glue on both sides. Wood OK

Re: Glue joint problem

#11

Re: Glue joint problem

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I am not familiar with Titebond liquid hide glue but I use hot hide glue exclusively and it sounds like bad glue or over clamping. For edge gluing boards I usually don't use any clamps.

Robin

Re: Glue joint problem

#12

Hypothesis

Bill Tindall

Bases on your observation.....Insufficient clamp pressure. You didn't squeeze the excess glue out of the joint.

Re: Glue joint problem

#13

Glue testing

Bill Tindall

Glue of any kind relies on the glue being tough. The way to achieve tough is for the glue to have a high molecular weight. When hide glue goes bad (Titebond liquid hide has been known to last a decade with good storage) it is because bacteria have chewed on the protein and broken it into smaller pieces (lowered the molecular weight).

What makes a glue tough also enables it to be pulled into "strings" which is why the rubbing between fingers test is a good indicator of good glue, or not good glue.

There is another test that takes longer but is easier to interpret. Spread a thin layer on some paper. Let dry and flex. If it can be flexed without fracture it means the glue is tough and hence good as an adhesive. If the dry film is brittle it means the molecular weight has broken down and it has lost toughness.

I store my liquid hide in the refrigerator. The stuff I bought in 2009 is still fine.

Re: Glue joint problem

#14

Re: Glue joint problem

Todd Nebel

When in doubt throw it out. The glue that is. If there's no date on the glue bottle I date it with the purchase date and if not used up in one year it thrown away. Glue is cheap compared to the time and other materials put into a project. Good board preparation and clamping should be straight forward. I suggest ripping the boards down to get rid of the old glue, buy new glue, and resume.

Re: Glue joint problem

#15

I disagree

Bill Tindall

What ever gets done needs to be directed toward identifying the failure so it does not happen again. Of the possibilities the glue is the least likely, especially if it does not smell like something rotten (bacterial eating the protein). It is easy to accuse the glue for that is trivial to fix. But if the technique is at fault buying new glue just postpones the problem to another day and $10 was wasted.

I do agree to get the glue issue resolved. Either test it with one of the testing methods or do a test joint and break it apart. I like to test with a lap joint made by face lapping two about 1" wide pieces of wood with the ends sticking out. Apply glue and squeeze together in a vice. One to two inches overlap is fine for the task. After a day of cure put one end in a vise and bash the other. There should be substantial wood failure.

Next I might try edge gluing a short piece where I was positive I got a good mating joint. After preparing the joint hold the pieces together up to a light and be sure there are no gaps that can not be readily closed with clamp pressure. Glue, cure and test strength. Again there should be substantial wood failure.

If this test passes then either the board's edges were not prepared precisely or the clamp pressure was too light to bring the boards together and squeeze out the excess glue.

I don't believe you can starve a joint with a liquid glue from too much pressure and the folks at Franklin agree. The liquid glues are simply too viscous to entirely flow out of the joint. Only two molecular layers of glue molecules are sufficient to make the strongest possible bond.

Or......what is the moisture content of this wood? If it is above 10% then glue cure time gets longer, and at 12-14% it can be way longer, like days.

Another thought, how long was the joint open before assembly? If the humidity is low 5 min could be too long.

Re: Glue joint problem

#16

Re: Glue testing

TomD

I have a bottle of Titebond liquid hide glue I have been saving for something special. Turns out to have an expiry of 04 06. I put a film between my fingers and separated repeatedly. I just kept bitting harder, and there were lots of little strings between my fingers. It smells fine. It is either too cold or old to squirt out of the bottle, for now.

I am dubious on the cracking glue thing for three reasons (though I assume Bill got it directly from tech)

1) Flexible is not what you want with wood, you want hard, and hard can crack

2) even glass will not crack when it is thin enough. So unless one is controlling for thickness I don't see how that test is meaningful

3) It sounds like how they make the stuff harden it off and grind it up. Surely how they make shellac, not so sure with the glue.

Re: Glue joint problem

#17

Not likely.

Ron Harper

If i screwed up it would more likely be overclamping. I really do not think that is it. Di not have time to rest today. More news tomorrow.

Re: Glue joint problem

#18

No shop time today

Ron Harper

Life intervened. Hoping to do the tacky test tomorrow. If it tacks, I am prepared to assume operator error. I really have trouble believing it is a clamping issue. I been at this a while. I had moderate glue amount in the joint and had pretty uniform squeezeout when I clamped..

Kind of a mystery because the last joint that failed after 24 hours in clamps was indeed without gaps anywhere.

Ron

Re: Glue joint problem

#19

Re: Glue joint problem

TomD

I learned this technique for doing soundboards which is basically a rubbed joint technique, with a few minor differences. It uses tight bond classic white glue. Which is a lot of luthier's choice, if not using hide glue. LMII might be better. But anyway, it is an amazing method the joint grows tighter, and you can't starve the joint since it is not clamped, and the joint is so invisible in a soundboard that one has to mark the end of the joint or one can loose it altogether, even though one has the board ends to consider.

One thing I noticed over 30 years of watching woodworking TV, is that I have repeatedly seen people who use liquid hide glue pre-heat the wood prior to using the stuff. It is not hot glue, but it seems to work better with heat. I am talking here about factories and pros that show up from time to time on TV. There is a Brian Boggs video on youtube were one can see this. One thing people may miss with hot hide glue is that it was often really slapped on so that the overage would keep the film one was actually going to glue up with warm. Sometimes the excess squeeze-out could be peeled off and dropped back in the pot.

Re: Glue joint problem

#20

Re: No shop time today

Bruce, a MN Galoot

the tacky test is the only one to get you someplace. I have a bottle of Franklin liquid hide glue that's pushing 2 years old and it works just fine. There is a bottle of Patrick's out in the shop that's older than that and still fine. Now if I could only find that bottle of Jameson's. :D

Personally, I suspect short clamping time. My experience is that it does take 24 hours. I never stress a hide glue joint before that.

OTOH, the other day I glued up a little panel for a box using Titebond II, and the joint failed, but I know darn well whose fault that was.

Re: Glue joint problem

#21

The missing Jameson's...

John in NM

Maybe that's related to the Tighbond II joint failure :D :D :D

I'm amazed at the long drying time you and others mention. Dry as it is out here, it never even occurred to me that hide glue might need more than an hour in the clamps. Not doubting, just amazed :D

Re: Glue joint problem

#22

Re: The missing Jameson's...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It's the liquid hide glue that takes time to set, in my experience. Hot, not so much. I don't like to stress joints prematurely with the stuff, because after I've put a lot of work into putting something together, I don't want it going asunder.

And MN is very dry in the winter (well, not as dry as NM or AZ), but summers are very humid in the southern part of the state. I don't do much gluing in the winter because my shop isn't heated, so I don't have much experience with that.

Re: Glue joint problem

#23

Interesting...

John in NM

I just use hot hide glue or tightbond, so that explains it.

Re: Glue joint problem

#24

Re: No shop time today

Bill Tindall

I am finding it difficult to understand how a joint can totally fail and fail with just handling forces on the panel. I would expect substantial wood failure even with simply forcing the surfaces together by hand. I for sure would not proceed building anything until this mystery is resolved.

Glue that didn't gain through cure, or lost by decomposition, all its strength would explain the result, but that seems improbable. Preparing a test lap joint with dry wood where there is no question that the surfaces are mated would eliminate some possibilities and may indeed indite the glue, or curing conditions.

Re: Glue joint problem

#25

Re: Glue joint problem

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was taught to use hot hide glue in 1966. It is much easier to learn than throwing a baseball or writing with a pencil.

In 1983 I bought a harpsichord kit and a bottle of Franklin's Liquid Hide Glue came along with the kit. I used the glue a few times, had some failures, and threw the bottle away.