New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Glue joint problem

Posts

Re: Glue joint problem

#51

Re: hide glue cleanup;  Stephen Shepherd

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Lars,

My experience (others' mileage may vary) is that I have to scrape to be sure that yellow glue squeeze-out is all up. This is true whether I get it up still wet, or after it solidifies, pre-finished or bare (again, others' mileage may vary). For this reason, I find it sensible to be a lot more careful and sparing of yellow glue application in situations where squeeze-out will wind up in corners and such--I don't view this as an advantage, either.

As for hide glue, I make wet rag passes til I don't see anymore, on fresh rag or on the wood, and call it good. That works. At a molecular level, I'm sure there is still thinned glue down there somewhere, but it doesn't cause ghost images or form a resist layer--it's effectively gone. With yellow glue, I scrape to be sure it's all gone.

Would love to hear from others on this subject--this is just my experience.

Wiley

Re: Glue joint problem

#52

Re: panel vs joint gluing

cstanford

You kidding? LHG still has more tack than PVA (at least OBG does).

Unless one is production gluing panels and using an RF setup to dry the PVA, LHG is a perfectly fine choice for gluing panels which the vast majority of hobbyists and small shop professionals leave in clamps overnight regardless of the glue used. Glue 'em up and work on something else.

Re: Glue joint problem

#53

Re: panel vs joint gluing

cstanford

And if you need to process panels in a hurry hot hide glue is unbeatable.

Re: Glue joint problem

#54

Hobbyists maybe...

John in NM

I don't know about vast majorities, but the couple small shops I worked for did not have the time or space to leave glue ups over night, unless of course the glue up was done late in the day. We left them in the clamps for maybe an hour, then took the piece out and put it aside until it could be run through the sander. Ideally the putting aside was over night to allow the area around the glue joints to shrink a bit, but I remember sanding tops the same day as glue up.

If I had LHG on hand I wouldn't hesitate to use it for tops and panels. I've used hot HG on small panels and tops, though I'd probably chicken out if I was thinking of using it on a big one.

Re: Glue joint problem

#55

Re: Hobbyists maybe...

CStanford

I've had as many as fifteen panels in clamps leaning against a wall in a one and a half car garage and had room for plenty more. And this was a time when I was fully tooled up, too.

Don't know where you worked but it must have been damn miserable with so little space. That, or it never dawned on anybody that glue ups don't have to be horizontal the whole time. Walls are your friend.

Cheers.

Re: Glue joint problem

#56

Re: Hobbyists maybe...

CStanford

And I could probably have put another twenty panels in the storage loft - simple gable roof garage with some old two by material nailed across the joists.

My only real limitation were clamps. I filled up the Plano racks then routinely put ten or so more in pipe clamps along the wall.

Re: Glue joint problem

#57

Wasn't lack of space...

John in NM

We had 5 builders in both those shops, all working on at least one piece. The idea of tying up resources over night when un-necessary would have been laughable in both workplaces. One shop in particular was more furniture oriented, and we averaged roughly 6-10 glue ups per week there, maybe 2-3 times that if we had two guys working on pieces with a lot of panels.

It may be quite feasible to do as you describe when you have one or two builders, but it simply doesn't fly in a more production oriented shop. As I said, I have no idea which scenario makes up the vast majority of small professional shops, but I rather suspect it's the kind I worked in.

Argue all you like, I'm just saying it doesn't add up in my experience. Your experience is without a doubt different than mine, perhaps we ought to leave it at that :D

Re: Glue joint problem

#58

Re: Wasn't lack of space...

CStanford

Thanks for the mild chuckle - twelve to twenty panels a week is not production anything. I could get twenty panels in clamps by quitting time with a bunch of Sears equipment running on 120 volts: contractor's table saw, a lunchbox planer, and a 6" jointer. Maybe by mid-afternoon break.

If that sort of volume was "tying up resources" (or anything even close) something was terribly amiss.

Were these being processed by hand?

Re: Glue joint problem

#59

Troll elsewhere, I'm not biting today 


Re: Glue joint problem

#60

I see.  Thanks.


Re: Glue joint problem

#61

Re: You both suck, what about RF drying 


Re: Glue joint problem

#62

Re: panel vs joint gluing; rubbed joints

Patrick Gibbons

Common shop practice for panels when hide glue was the norm was to rub joints till tacky, put aside for about two hours and then the joint was strong enough for most handling. No clamps were used and one didn't need to wait overnight. I am referencing Bernard Jones, The Practical Woodworker. Sounds to me to be as fast and easy as any more modern glue.

Re: Glue joint problem

#63

Re: You both suck, what about RF drying

CStanford

I have a hand-held unit gathering dust. Used it back in the day. Wanna buy it?

Re: Glue joint problem

#64

Re: panel vs joint gluing; rubbed joints

TomD

That works with modern glues, that is how I glue up soundboards using white glue, or titebond. But it requires a perfect joint, no spring. That is partly due to the proportions of soundboards which are about as still as a granite plate.