New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

What is the ideal set of chisels?

Posts

What is the ideal set of chisels?

#1

What is the ideal set of chisels?

Tony Wilkins

I went back and read an article from Adam Cherubini's Arts and Mysteries blog entitled "Nicholson the new Roubo". Linked: http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/arts-mysteries-blogs/is-nicholson-the-new-roubo

A phrase from that piece got me wondering: "It also has a very helpful list of what was and was not available. Were there such things as one inch tanged mortise chisels? The answer is no. What about 1/8″ socket chisels? No again. What emerges is that these different sorts of chisels probably had specific uses. They weren’t simply different versions of the same tool..."

As I build my currently scant set of tools, phrases like this intrigue me. This coupled with what he wrote in the article "What's wrong the the 'standard' set of chisels?" Linked: http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/arts-mysteries-blogs/whats-wrong-with-the-standard-set-of-chisels

I had asked a question about the second article a while back and had a good debate after. So as a newbie to woodworking and hand tool wood working this leads me to a question...

What is the ideal set of chisels for building furniture by hand?

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#2

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

roger lance

Tony....many will offer an opinion on this....I'd say that an ideal set of chisels is one where you use each and every chisel....you have a definite need and function for each chisel to make the things you make....and, of course, the ergonomics, sharpening characteristics, edge retention,etc etc are all good....probably not the answer you are seeking....but some advice as you claim "newbie" status: go slow on purchases; buy a tool when you need a tool; buy quality; and buy from a company with a good reputation. If I were starting out, I'd get a Lee Valley catalog and stick with them as much as I could....you will be on a very good path.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#3

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

Tony Wilkins

Thanks Roger. That is indeed what I intend to do. I already have a Blue Spruce 1/2 and a Japanese Massahige 6mm. I figured there would be about as many opinions as answers and that is good. I wanted to hear the reasoning for the answers to help inform me as I get the best chisel as the need arises.

What caught my attention on this article is how it flies in the face of the 'get a base set of bench chisels' advice that I see most often. Since I see firmer, pairing, dovetail, bench, mortise, butt, etc chisels just in the western world it gets to be a dizzying array of choices. Getting a bench chisel that can adequately do most jobs is the 'easy answer' but I'm wondering on the jobs that you all are doing if it would be the best for you at this point in your woodworking journey.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#4

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

roger lance

Tony....woodworking is a great activity....it offers the chance for pride, satisfaction, creativity, etc etc....but the world of tools is endless....there is always some other tool to get, some product to buy, on and on....you can not outfit a shop for every eventuality....to have a tool for every thing that "might" benefit from having that tool....its endless....and yet people fall into this....take workbench building/design: people are often persuaded to build a bench that is capable of clamping work of extremely large size, shape, etc....yet for 99% of the work they do, a much simpler bench would clamp and hold their work very well....so they have built something for that event that turns out to be very rare in their woodworking....and for some, may not occur at all....now this is perfectly fine, a person has every right to make whatever bench they want and to be proud of what they have made....but we are now satisfying needs/wants that are beyond simple function.....and I guess that too is part of an "ideal" set of tools because sometimes just owning some tool that you hardly ever use can be satisfying....I admit sometimes I just go into the shop, sit quietly, look around, and feel better.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#5

Sharp ones

John in NM

We often over-emphasize the idealness of our tool kit and loose sight of the fact that a person can do tremendous and sophisticated tools even with a very limited tool kit.

Its like what an Aussie I used to work with said when ever anyone asked him what was his favorite beer -- answer: the one in his hand.

The ideal chisel is the one sharp and available for use when you need it.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#6

Doesn't exist, no such thing.

James Watriss

At the end of the day, it's a pointy metal stick. Your ability to use it effectively and efficiently is the most important feature, but that's something you develop on your own, the price for that is time and effort. Brian Boggs started with screwdrivers.

I got started like many others I knew, with Marples Blue chips. They did 99% of what I needed, and gave me a lot of sharpening practice, which everybody needs, period. It's a skill that never stops getting better.

I did move on to Pfeil, and then L-N chisels for a while, and currently, a set of decent Japanese chisels. At the end of the day, they're pointy sticks, and they're not magical, any of them.

Don't get too crazy about it, Excalibur does not exist. Buy decent chisels that don't break the bank. Buy specialty chisels if you need them, not before. You can still cut mortises with bench chisels, and cut dovetails without 'dovetail chisels.'

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#7

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

TomD

I normally find myself more likely to disagree with Adam, than otherwise. In this case I mostly agree. The chisels I use the most for cabinetmaking, in the standard sizes are the 1/4, 3/8, and the 1/2" I believe that narrowly spaced chisels below the 1/2" mark are more useful than the large ones, that see little use. That said, I am not too sure what the big deal is about owning a few surplus chisels. Costs, yes, I remember that constraint vividly, but other than that I do not see the issue with buying a set of 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, and one inch, then populating the lower ranks as actual requirements dictate. If the seller you are using sells individual chisels at the same price as sets, then I would buy the smaller chisels first if you like. If you are building racks, you may want to scope out the actual ones you ultimately want.

The thing where you want to be careful is that Adam is still playing in the playhouse with his little friends. If one wants to recreate the ye olde cabinetshop, in which people worked in conditions, and on projects that are not necessarily typical of the modern world, then one has the luxury of a script and Haiku like limitations. Around here I may still make my own planes, and a small chisel may be ideal, and I may set a strike plate in a doorset, and want a wider chisel. Never loose sight of the fact that the arts and mysteries column resides in a far more representative popular magazine. Unless historical re-enactment is your particular thing.

I just finished watching Cosman's video on chisels, and he recomends 3/16, 1/4, 3/8, and 1/2 half. I am down with that. I forget the mortise chisels he recommends, but I think you can get by with but you need the half sizes of the stock you typically work: 1/4, 5/16, 3/8, and 1/2.

I have found the tester chisels I ordered end up stranded with little purpose, they did save me from buying a few lower end Japanese tools I did not like. Getting into a good quality set you really like as soon as possible will save you money.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#8

Stephen Shepherd

One of each kind and size.


Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#9

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

My first couple of chisels were the really poor quality plastic handled Stanley and Buck that are still sold at the big box stores. I actually still have them and they serve their purpose now as demolition chisels. In that capacity I don't hesitate or wince at using one of these tools where I will hit a nail or even concrete. The next "set" of chisels was a collection of vintage miss-matched chisels culled from the bottom of bins at swap meets and antique fairs. I was well on my way to completing that set with a price limit of $2/ea when was seduced by a particularly sexy 1/4" wide mortise chisel made by stiletto which set me back $5. This set was mostly bevel edge and included just about every size. I had foolishly passed on some undoubtedly superior tools because they were tanged chisels and I had formed the incorrect opinion that socket chisels were superior and therefore what I wanted/needed.

Not too long after completing and restoring this set I started my apprenticeship in patternmaking and over the next few years my tool opinions were turned upside down. T he work was different and required different tools. As such I ended up with a set of long paring chisels and a set of long cranked necked chisels, all of which were tanged. Almost all were better steel than any of my other miss matched socket chisels and more to the point I learned that with a good ferule they were more secure in the handle and easier to mount in a new handle.

For the past 10 years I have been making more furniture than patterns and of the 60 or so different chisels and gouges I own the one I use the most is a 1" bevel edge of medium length. I use it for chopping mortises, cleaning up shoulders of tennons, fitting joinery and cleaning up dried glue. I use it because it holds an edge better than any other chisel I own and I tend to use just the one chisel. I own an impressive collection of tools but I have gravitated to using fewer and fewer different tools as a way being more efficient in the shop. I find it faster to learn how to use a part of the wide 1" chisel to do something a narrower tool might be better suited for rather than walking back and forth to my tool box and constantly changing tools.

I suppose I spent a lot of time and money acquiring a collection of tools to make me a better woodworker and now I have the one tool that actually does make me a better wood worker, experience.

Robin

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#10

Can't be answered by us

Bill Tindall

The references you provided clearly illustrates the perils of advice like you are requesting. What you need depends on what you do.

As I understand it Adam builds stuff using only hand tools with his interpretation of Period techniques. His motivation seems to be to explore the use of hand tools in a historical context. Contrast this situation to someone that can remove wood with a table saw, jointer, router, mortising machine.....you get the picture. Will Neptune did a class where he did all kinds of joinery used in case work, tables and chairs and used three chisels for it all. Then there are the tool collectors. They might strive for every new tool that has a specific function, or every old tool that can be collected. The frugal get by with the least tools they can live with, buying something only when there is no alternative. Amount of money you are willing to devote to woodworking is a major factor. The list goes on, and on.......

If you are buying new tools you can't go wrong to buy what you need when you need it and the best quality you can afford. I seldom see quality used chisels for sale. If you are striving for old tools best to buy any quality chisels you find when you find them. This is the only useful advice I can offer.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#11

Professional tools

Bill Tindall

I typically find that a professional furniture maker has fewer tools than I do, and I don't have many. Keeping with your thought, the experienced woodworkers can accomplish a task with a less than optimum tool for that task. Who ever said "the best chisel is the closest sharp chisel" (to paraphrase) got it right for the woodworker focused on building stuff. However, it is to be acknowledged that the primary motivation of some woodworkers is not making stuff. Their results may differ.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#12

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

Tony Wilkins

So am I back to getting the basic set of bench chisels and learning to make the work for the broadest set of applications?

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#13

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

For a minimal kit I would get 1/4, 3/8 and 1" bench chisels and a 5/16 mortise chisel. For an ideal kit I would get bench chisels from 1/8 to 3/8 by 1/16ths and two or three larger. For mortise chisels I would get 1/8 to 7/16 by 1/16ths.

I prefer forged chisels with nice bolsters and long evenly tapered tangs.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#14

Plato did not write a woodworking book

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

so finding the ideal set won't be easy.

If you work with the tools you have for a year or two, you'll know what you wish you had, and you can buy them.

In ten years, you'll have your ideal set of bench chisels, which you've selected to the work you do and the way you like to work. Then, when someone asks this question, you can say, "Well, this is what I have, but it depends on what kind of work you do and how you like to work."

I concur with others that a couple of small chisels are critical. Warren likes 1/4" and 3/8"; I prefer 1/4" and 1/2". Both of us are right. And a couple of wider chisels are important, too. I prefer 3/4", as the starter width. I have a friend who flat loves his 2" wide chisel; I understand, because I have a wide one that's quite helpful when I'm using the chisel to pare, but in a way that approaches planing. And, for years, I had just a 1/4" mortise chisel, which I used only sometimes. I've got some wider ones now, but can't really speak to their usefulness, because I'm presently devoting my time to carpentry rather than shop work, and mortise chisels are rarely needed for remodel carpentry unless you're remodeling a timber frame house.

Having said that, I return to my first paragraphs. The chisels you've got now (which, by the way, cost more than the first 50 chisels I bought) will get you started. Use them until you get frustrated, and think about how you're frustrated.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#15

More information

Bill Tindall

If you are going to be building casework you will need something to chop the dovetails for case work. The size will depend on the size dovetails you employ.

Ditto drawers.

For locks and hinges you will needs some sized chisel for mortising the hinges and maybe locks. Many prefer a large chisel for this kind of work; others don't.

If doing case work or door frames you will need a mortise chisel or a chisel useful for mortising appropriate for the size lumber you will be using.

A table or bed might require larger mortises. Chairs are another story. And that is about as detailed as one can get without know what you intend to build and the joinery details.

Personally, I could build anything I make with 3 chisels but I do not avoid power tools. I would never get the dozens of parts that constitute a chest of drawers ever made with only hand tools.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#16

A bit of this and a bit of the other.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

The obvious question is, "what do you plan to use the chisels to do?" Only you can define your own needs, although a few answering this question here may alert you to the areas, and the way they in which chisels are commonly used.

For dovetail tails, I go small and so use 1/8", 3/16" and 1/4" most commonly. For pins I tend to go to a 3/4" or 1". All of these have minimal lands to get close into corners, and must be capable of both being pushed or struck.

As chisel blades get narrower, so I prefer the chisel and/or blade to be shorter. Narrow blades are for intricate work, and I like to get closer. As chisel blades get wider, especially for paring, such as tenon cheeks or the sides of mortices, I prefer a longer handle (or longer chisel) as this helps gauge angles. Paring chisels are not struck, so you may need duplicates in the same size, one for striking and one for pushing. There are some chisels that can do both pretty well.

I rarely use a chisel wider that 1 1/2". I just find it too cumbersome. I am happier using a 3/4" or 1".

For morticing the common sizes I use are 1/8", 1/4" and 5/16". The 1/4" is used the most.

There are speciality chisels, such as fishtails for cleaning out dovetail pins, which are extremely useful.

You could get away without a lot of chisels, and work with a minimalistic tool kit. I would say that the difference between a pro and an amateur is that the pro only has what he needs, and the amateur has what he wants. There is no right or wrong in this regard. One of the priorities in work is to reduce overhead expenses, which is not a consideration of the amateur for whom cost may not be a major issue. One of the advantages of the chisel is that it is a cheap tool when compared to the investment of most power tools and shop machines.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#17

@Derek re Narrower Sizes

Tony Wilkins

Interesting comments Derek. Let me see if I am following correctly when you say you like shorter as the blades get narrower. Would that be something like a butt chisel as opposed to a bench chisel? Also, what do you consider narrower (at least enough to make that distinction)?

And I'm afraid I definitely an amateur. I don't wish to be a tool hoarder but as a consistent theme to my questions I want to buy the right tools that will last and perform as my skill increases.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#18

Themes....

roger lance

The experienced woodworkers advise to develop your skills (make things) then buy your "ideal" set of tools. The inexperienced woodworker wants to buy the "ideal" set of tools then develop skills. And so it goes. :D .

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#19

Re: @Derek re Narrower Sizes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Interesting comments Derek. Let me see if I am following correctly when you say you like shorter as the blades get narrower. Would that be something like a butt chisel as opposed to a bench chisel? Also, what do you consider narrower (at least enough to make that distinction)?

Hi Tony

Part of the issue is that blades become more flexible as they get narrower. To increase their stiffness (so that they do not feel like a wet noodle), they need to be shorter (unless you increase the thickness, which then would be like using an ice pick).

I find the distinction between bench and butt chisels to be somewhat artificial. They are both bench chisels, generally with blades of equal thickness, only one is shorter than the other.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#20

don't worry about the inclination to hoard

Bruce, a MN Galoot

that will come naturally as time passes.:D Just don't hoard Berg chisels -- they're mine, I tell you!

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#21

Re: Themes....

TomD

"The experienced woodworkers advise to develop your skills (make things) then buy your "ideal" set of tools. The inexperienced woodworker wants to buy the "ideal" set of tools then develop skills. And so it goes. :D . "

I would agree with that, but part of the reason is because the experienced worker has already been there and done that. I would not replace a lot of my fancier tools if the shop burned down. I would make some cheap, and nice replacements. But I also satisfied whatever curiosity I may have had with the earlier purchases, or at least a lot of it. Part of the reason why sophisticated tools do not draw me to the same extent is because I know the exact contrast in results between tools in use, and I also have a long and hard one series of features I like in a tool, and now that I know it I can find it at different price points or executions. And sure, skills wise, so easy when you know how.

Also, there has to be an ideal set configuration at some level. It is a very pertinent question. Most of the reservations about answering the question are also reasonable enough, but there is a basic set, and it does not seem to exist due to the demand of work, as much as for some neat mathematical progression. If there are going to be such sets, and there always have been in my 50 years, then they might as well be as ideal as possible from the perspective of some kind of work.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#23

"need" vs "want,"... Absolutely.


Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#24

Comparing and contrasting to illustrate the point

Bill Tindall

Here is a perfect example of why someone can't provide reliable recommendations unless you intend to build as they do. Derek and I each build stuff but look how much we differ in chisel choices driven by the details of how and what we build......

DC- For dovetail tails, I go small and so use 1/8", 3/16" and 1/4" most commonly. For pins I tend to go to a 3/4" or 1".

BT- I use the middle sizes mostly, the very sizes DC doesn't mention! I don't like wide chisels and have little need for skinny ones.

DC -All of these have minimal lands to get close into corners, and must be capable of both being pushed or struck.

BT- agree entirely. I have no use for Japanese hooped chisels.

DC -As chisel blades get narrower, so I prefer the chisel and/or blade to be shorter.

BT- I prefer all my chisels to be short

DC- Paring chisels are not struck, so you may need duplicates in the same size, one for striking and one for pushing.

BT- I like multitaskers. I don't own a paring chisel.

DC- I rarely use a chisel wider that 1 1/2".

BT- there is only one furniture building operation where I use anything wider than 3/4"

DC- For morticing the common sizes I use are 1/8", 1/4" and 5/16". The 1/4" is used the most.

BT- I use 5/16 the most

DC-There are speciality chisels, such as fishtails for cleaning out dovetail pins, which are extremely useful.

BT- I have found no use for any of these specialty chisels.

Depending on how and what someone else builds their choices may differ as much as Derek and I.

Go forth and build something with a drawer and door and a case and what you need will become apparent.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#25

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

Patrick Gibbons

I've found that advice is not as important as experience and you have to start somewhere to get that experience. My advice is that you get a basic set of chisels and use them. I would tell you to get the 1/4", 1/2", 3/4", 1" Narex chisels from Lee Valley because they are inexpensive and made well. The bevels are thin on the sides and the sizes, according to LV, are imperial, not metric equivalents. Decide what you like and dislike about them, if you find yourself wanting other sizes, shapes, lengths, handle shapes, etc. If and when you get better chisels you'll still use these for rougher jobs and the occasional loaner to the neighbor (it will happen). I would tell you to get one good 1/4" mortise chisel and make every mortise this size. Once the mortise is glued together no one will know or care what size the mortise is. I have 1/16" and 1/8" chisels and a 2" chisel which I use all the time. That's my experience. My last piece of advice is two-fold. Learn to sharpen freehand and sharpen often. This will greatly impact which chisels are best for you. And when you finish reading something that makes you want to go buy a new chisel (or any other tool for that matter) go lay down until the feeling goes away. Six months or a year later if you still want it and it makes sense then maybe you just might buy it. If I'd only followed my own advice.