Re: Chisels different in some aspect
TomD
"I'm doing my best to buy only what I need and not knee jerk purchasing every cool tool."
There is nothing wrong with spending big bucks on tools. Overall probably works out better, if you aren't going to starve at some point. I have spent a ton on tools, and I don't regret any of it, really. Of course like any other decision it could come back to haunt you... Relative to your current situation, it would help to know whether you have severe financial constraints, or are anticipating, buying a lot of fancy tools, just gradually. I started accumulating, not collecting, tools about 1980. On that time frame anyone can end up with a fantastic collection. People don't seem to want to say they want to buy the expensive stuff, because one gets an avalanche of great advice to the contrary. But if this was a Harley site, you could splash out 6K on chrome, and nobody would bat an eye. Conversation need a certain structure, and on tool sites, cost on of the few things we all see the same way, but in reality, most of us are spending a lot of money on tools, or time explaining why we don't, or will be spending a lot in the future.
" Chisels, however, seem to be a different animal - excepting the 'specialty' chisels such as corner, swan, etc. It seems difficult to come up with a need based purchasing scheme since a lot of what I see says to base certain operations of the size of the chisel."
I think that is a smart point, but not really at issue. What makes sense is to size your dovetails to your chisels. In the past they probably did this, so an ancillary benefit is that you may arrive at a more authentic spacing, if you base them on the tools. But that does not mean that you can't also be guided in your tool purchase by pin sizes. It walks both ways.
If you had particular projects in mind, you could buy chisels for those, and then drive on later. In the absence of letting your immediate needs dictate, you can buy the standard 4 chisel set, and add more latter. But that mostly makes sense if you intend to get all the sizes at some point.
"Oh, and I'm not opposed to having a mismatched set."
This is a really bad idea. Matched sets are a fundamental ergonomic principle. I could play golf with a totally mismatched set of chisels but if I was moving in any direction towards improving my set of clubs, matching would be the best bet.
Interesting point in golf is that sets are matched in at least three ways 1) personal preference consistency (look, features set); 2) performance matched (yardages, spins, trajectory, etc...); 3) matched to the person as far as swing consistency is concerned (spine, kick point, etc...).
There is probably a similar series of things style, performance, and technical fit in chisels, we are a long way from that with current products that are sold on looks, steel performance, and features, there is no attempt to really match the human element. Chisels have a long way to go.