New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

What is the ideal set of chisels?

Posts

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#26

The truth is...

Bob Hackett

The closest anyone ever comes to answering this is actually answered by the folks who decide what happens to all your stuff once you`re gone. you`ll find it on whatever inventory list they make up.

The answer based in reality is that even if you have the capabilities to make your own chisels you will always end up with odd, mismatched stuff you just love to use hidden in drawers so their presence won`t mess up your displays of cool tools.

What I think you`re looking for is a one shot deal where you buy a "set" of chisels that fulfill all your needs and you`ll never have to buy another chisel for the rest of your life unless you wear one of the set out. That just ain`t gonna happen so you might as well face it now. :(

Here in the real world ( picture that popular fantasy bad guy meme with his fingers pressed together and snide facial expression now) "One does not simply BUY a set of chisels". All serious WWers (alternately known as tool collectors) BUILD a collection of chisels and other tools that never match and continues to expand until the day we can no longer drag ourselves out of bed and into the shop.

Welcome to our world.

I d like to suggest you embrace the idea of electicism, it`ll make this particular journey far less painful. :)

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#27

Chisels different in some aspect

Tony Wilkins

I'm doing my best to buy only what I need and not knee jerk purchasing every cool tool. Chisels, however, seem to be a different animal - excepting the 'specialty' chisels such as corner, swan, etc. It seems difficult to come up with a need based purchasing scheme since a lot of what I see says to base certain operations of the size of the chisel.

Oh, and I'm not opposed to having a mismatched set.

Point taken on sharpening and that's definitely an area I need to work on.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#28

Ergonomics

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Whatever chisel you chose needs to feel good in your grip. Shapes and sizes of chisels, especially the handles will fit in your hands differently. Chisels become extensions of our hands. They must feel comfortable to best achieve that relationship.

Tom

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#29

agree

Bill Tindall

I have come to accept that this property is most important. Which leads to the result of not buying a set of chisels. Buy one of a couple of kinds and then buy more according to preferences.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#30

data to the contrary

Bill Tindall

"One of the advantages of the chisel is that it is a cheap tool when compared to the investment of most power tools and shop machines."

Thankfully one doesn't need to buy sets of table saws.

;)

Japan Woodworker:

Kamaji paring chisel $507.65

Ohkubo forge chisel set $1548.75

bragging rights- Priceless

Who buys this stuff!

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#31

I have never encountered such a case

Bill Tindall

"base certain operations of the size of the chisel."

I choose a dovetail size then choose a chisel to accommodate it, for example. You will be looking at the drawer for the life of the cabinet. It needs to have dovetails that please you, not the chisel.

Go buy some inexpensive set out of the LV catalog and then go build something. The "best" chisels I ever bought were a set of "Blue Handles". They taught me what I don't like in a chisel so that I could then buy what suited me. The Blue Handles were easy to resell.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#32

My usage habits are about like Bill's...

John in NM

I have a variety of sizes of black handled Sandvik's that a used tool store was selling in the 1990's. They were cheap, all around $6, and are some pretty nice steel. Sizes I use most are 1/4", 3/8", and 1/2". I do use the wider chisels some, but mostly just for hinge and plate mortises or sharpening pencils.

The other thing I've found is that dedicated chisels like paring chisels, fishtails, mortise chisels, etc all make their tasks a little easier, but you can still use a plain old bench chise to do it all with perfectly acceptible results.

I even once turned one of those Sandvik's into a fish tail, only to find I didn't really use it at all.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#33

Marples Blue Chips?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Maybe you are referring to Marples blue chip chisels? If so, then that would be a good example of how chisels can be a matter of personal experiences and tastes.

I still have my first set of chisels...a set of Marples Blue Chip. I also have a set of LN chisels and my favorites...a large set of Tasai bench chisels.

While my Tasai chisels are my staple users, I still use my blue chips every now and again. They are not as fine as my Tasai, but I dare say they still serve me well for some tasks.

Tom

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#34

Re: Marples Blue Chips?

TomD

I remember when Robert Majors of Mahogany Masterpieces referred to Blue Chip chisels as good only for opening pain cans. What rot. They are fine for many things, and one would never need a better set if one worked not too nasty domestic hardwoods. That said, one does not have to travel far to find better steel. The format is entirely usable, though I prefer stouter transitions.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#35

Re: data to the contrary

TomD

"Japan Woodworker:

Kamaji paring chisel $507.65

Ohkubo forge chisel set $1548.75

bragging rights- Priceless

Who buys this stuff!"

I don't have a 500 dollar chisel, but I have two pretty expensive sets. That said one can buy a pretty fancy set for what some table saw guys routinely pay for a dado set. Forrest wants 330 for their dado set. That will get you 6 lie nielsens.

While I don't think any of the hacks over here need Japanese chisels at the higher level, and I have some concerns about the "tourist grade" tools. I don't think we are really in a position to criticize people who dedicate themselves to making better tools, as we dedicate ourselves to oddball furniture upgrades. Who needs dovetails?

I also think the Japanese tools are a great value. Damascus steel knives used to sell for 100 dollars an inch, and while that market is gone, there are still similarly expensive knives, often mass and machine made. The quality of Japanese product, refinement, and historical richness, makes these tools a great value. But one can cut a dovetail with a sharpened cold chisel, Some of them make pretty good working chisels.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#36

Re: Chisels different in some aspect

TomD

"I'm doing my best to buy only what I need and not knee jerk purchasing every cool tool."

There is nothing wrong with spending big bucks on tools. Overall probably works out better, if you aren't going to starve at some point. I have spent a ton on tools, and I don't regret any of it, really. Of course like any other decision it could come back to haunt you... Relative to your current situation, it would help to know whether you have severe financial constraints, or are anticipating, buying a lot of fancy tools, just gradually. I started accumulating, not collecting, tools about 1980. On that time frame anyone can end up with a fantastic collection. People don't seem to want to say they want to buy the expensive stuff, because one gets an avalanche of great advice to the contrary. But if this was a Harley site, you could splash out 6K on chrome, and nobody would bat an eye. Conversation need a certain structure, and on tool sites, cost on of the few things we all see the same way, but in reality, most of us are spending a lot of money on tools, or time explaining why we don't, or will be spending a lot in the future.

" Chisels, however, seem to be a different animal - excepting the 'specialty' chisels such as corner, swan, etc. It seems difficult to come up with a need based purchasing scheme since a lot of what I see says to base certain operations of the size of the chisel."

I think that is a smart point, but not really at issue. What makes sense is to size your dovetails to your chisels. In the past they probably did this, so an ancillary benefit is that you may arrive at a more authentic spacing, if you base them on the tools. But that does not mean that you can't also be guided in your tool purchase by pin sizes. It walks both ways.

If you had particular projects in mind, you could buy chisels for those, and then drive on later. In the absence of letting your immediate needs dictate, you can buy the standard 4 chisel set, and add more latter. But that mostly makes sense if you intend to get all the sizes at some point.

"Oh, and I'm not opposed to having a mismatched set."

This is a really bad idea. Matched sets are a fundamental ergonomic principle. I could play golf with a totally mismatched set of chisels but if I was moving in any direction towards improving my set of clubs, matching would be the best bet.

Interesting point in golf is that sets are matched in at least three ways 1) personal preference consistency (look, features set); 2) performance matched (yardages, spins, trajectory, etc...); 3) matched to the person as far as swing consistency is concerned (spine, kick point, etc...).

There is probably a similar series of things style, performance, and technical fit in chisels, we are a long way from that with current products that are sold on looks, steel performance, and features, there is no attempt to really match the human element. Chisels have a long way to go.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#37

@TomD re Ergonomic consistency

Tony Wilkins

I see and had thought about your point on consistency with the ergonomics of a set of chisels. Going back to what Derek had set about shorter lengths for narrower sizes, I was thinking about matching the Blue Spruce Butt chisels in smaller sizes with the bench chisels in larger sizes. Would this still fit with your point?

As far as spending mega bucks on tools, I'm budgeting a bit every month to buy what I need down the road. Of course, I excuse my champagne tastes by rationalizing support for artisans - Ross holdfasts and dividers, Jeske Chisels, Harrell and Wenzloff saws. BTW, my wallet just screamed in pain as I typed that.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#38

Re: @TomD re Ergonomic consistency

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tony and all,

Tony said, "Of course, I excuse my champagne tastes by rationalizing support for artisans - Ross holdfasts and dividers, Jeske Chisels, Harrell and Wenzloff saws."

On a somewhat related thought, why 'rationalize'? I don't think any of us want to be pure rational consumers. The rational consumer is an economist's abstraction, developed so that theories of market, supply, demand, and price have an underpinning, and can give rise to differential equations and models.

But IME we're not economic animals, except for those who find minimizing the maximum and maximizing the minimum, is pleasurable unto itself. We're mostly social animals, seeking relationships. The life choices we make will naturally reflect our social natures. Every plane, chisel, or saw I pick up, or turn of the vise, brings to mind firstly an association with the person who made it. Larry Williams, Bill Clark, Don McConnell, Konrad Sauer, Chutaro Imai, Yataiki, Mike Wenzloff, Michel Auriou. Dave Jeske. Bill Tindall and Phil and Steve Elliott, with their CPM 3V. Robin Lee and Thomas Lie-Nielsen, who each have gone out of their way to provide me with focussed personal help on a matter that was important to me, yet infinitesimally small in their scheme of things (see, they weren't optimizing either!). I've forgotten what stuff costs, or at least it doesn't come to mind. But I never forget the people, and the many small incidents that bind us together.

Wiley

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#39

Re: data to the contrary

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think that with careful accounting a table saw becomes much more expensive than any set of chisels. A set of chisels will last a professional a lifetime, but a table saw has ongoing expenses, like blades and sharpening and electricity. The saw takes up a lot of floor space. You can't just put it up against a wall between two other machines, it needs footage around it that also needs to be lit and heated.

The biggest cost is the risk of injury. Check out the cost of disability insurance for woodworkers. Or the workman's compensation tax rates. About one in ten professional woodworkers manages to mangle his fingers in a saw. Maybe someone else pays your medical bills so you think it doesn't matter what it costs. And maybe you would be satisfied with 90% function after four months of therapy.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#40

I talk to my tools.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've forgotten what stuff costs, or at least it doesn't come to mind. But I never forget the people, and the many small incidents that bind us together.


I so agree Wiley.

When you think of it, an amateur woodworker in his/her shop is pretty isolated. Perhaps with just the radio or iPod for company. We reach out for social contact on forums such as WoodCentral, develop cyber friendships, and feel connected across the world. But in reality we would be alone in the shop if it were not for the associations and memories linked to tools.

I have a most wonderful cutting gauge that I treasure because you gave it to me and I think of you each time I use it. I own some amazing chisels that were made for me as a gift by a thoughtful and generous soul. There are more. All are excellent company and make great conversation.

Tony, when accumulating your tools, think of this and whom you want to invite into your family.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#41

Re: data to the contrary

david weaver

For the most part, I think the buyers of those items come from the financial and medical sectors, and probably from the US and europe.

Not from a group of folks who would be worried about the cost of hand tool vs. power tool.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#42

Re: data to the contrary???

William Duffield

Those who run woodworking businesses and already operate table saws should seriously investigate SawStop. I've had customers whose SawStop purchases were totally paid for in a year with their reduction in liability insurance. But, you need to do the math, with your machinery supplier and your insurance company. These were industrial models, not contractor saws.

Also, my SawStop makes a great assembly table. It doesn't take up as much room as your description implies, because it has a mobile base, and can be easily moved around in a smaller space when I switch to ripping from cross cutting and other typical operations I use the saw for. My shop is not climate controlled, so the saw doesn't cost me any additional heating or AC expenses. I have a pull cord on the light fixture that hangs over it, so when I'm not using the saw for one of its multiple functions, I turn off the light.

OK, there can be unexpected expenses. Sunday afternoon, I managed to trigger the brake, for the first time in over four years of operation. I don't put my hand into the blade, so I don't keep a spare brake on hand. I was cutting the binding off of some documentation, so my wife could run it through her scanner, and the binding had a very thin layer of aluminum foil embedded in the tape.

That cost me $70 to replace the brake, $100 to replace a Freud Fusion combo blade, $40 in travel expenses (50¢ a mile and a $4 bridge toll), and two hours of lost shop time to go get the replacement parts, remove the old brake and blade and install the new ones. We might have saved a couple bucks in gasoline if I had taken my wife's Prius, instead of my Scion.

You're not going to activate the brake every time you hit embedded metal with the blade, and in this case I can't really count the retail price of a new blade, because the one I ruined had already been almost fully depreciated by a "carpenter" working for a guy who was doing some home improvements for me. Without my permission, and unsupervised, this gorilla had run a piece of two century old siding, covered with lead based paint and with embedded cut nails, through the saw, removing three teeth and thoroughly dulling all the others.

I get a great shop clock out of the experience. You couldn't make a shop clock out of a ruined chisel. ;)

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#43

Not to mention,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I can't begin to figure how long it would take to rip a sheet of plywood with any chisel.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#44

how do I sharpen the chisels?


Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#45

Re: how do I sharpen the chisels?

Bill Tindall

If you are just starting out I would suggest getting a sharpening jig. As time goes on you can eventually wean yourself from these "training wheels". There are so many choices in abrasives and they all work. Probably the biggest mistake is to not know what sharp looks like and underachieving it, or the other extreme to fret over ultimate sharpening. If there is a club nearby join, find a mentor and rocket up the learning curve.

Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#46

Re: @TomD re Ergonomic consistency

TomD

Probably not, but it might still be your preference. I would probably feel better, if they had a smooth decline in size. I have a set of mini chisels, that I may use as Derek suggests, and I am planing a set of Alan Peters style mini chisels. I was really talking theoretically combined with thinking it would be bad to have a different chisel in every size all over the set. Worst case you will have to buy more chisels.

That is half my chisel racks:


Re: What is the ideal set of chisels?

#47

Bill and Stephen are both right on

RonHarper

If you take the approach supported by Schwarz and a lot on this site, you get a basic set of chisels with good metal and you tune them to do what you need them to do. I have many days where I honestly believe that is what I should be doing.

Then.. I go to an auction, flea market, tool meet, and i see....

On that day I agree with Stephen... One of every size and kind.

I honestly know that I have too many chisels. I really have had some for twenty years that I have honed razor sharp and have never used them on a piece of furniture.. But no.. I am not gonna sell my Chas Buck crank neck paring chisels and if I see the one inch size somewhere, it is very likely to follow me home. You ask good questions, but soon you will realize, that within some pretty broad guidelines, the answers are all personal.