O1 vs A2 as chisel steel
Bill Tindall
This post relates to a question buried in a post below. I thought it best to start the discussion as a separate post. If we come to some agreement on the facts and conclusions I will write it up for the Articles section and we won’t have to go through this exercise again.
Background “facts”. Does anyone have data to disagree with these “facts”?
Three steel properties are relevant to woodworking. Abrasion resistance is the resistance to the wearing away of metal by the metal rubbing against the wood. Hardness is a measure of the resistance of the metal to deformation(bending). Toughness is a measure of the resistance to fracture if the metal is stressed (chiping).
Toughness and hardness are determined by the composition of the steel, how it is manufactured (for example powder metallurgy) and heat treating. As a rule heat treating to higher hardness results in lower toughness. See this link for a more comprehensive discussion of these concepts. http://www.crucibleservice.com/eselector/general/generalpart1.html
I have examined the dulled edges of several kinds of chisels with an "industrial quality" microscope and come to the following conclusion. Chisels used for chopping or paring out dovetail waste (force perpendicular to grain) get dull either by the deformation of the frail edge, or, this edge dulls by microscopic chipping. See pictures. (distinguishing chipping which results in loss of metal vs bending which doesn’t is best done through changing the focal plane of the microscope. These differences are less apparent in a single image)
M2 Chipping

Carbon Steel (O-1 type) bending (Sorby)

CPM 3V at Rc58 bending

In contrast, dulling through planing is a result of abrasion. Chisel dulling occurs with a much shorter exposure of steel to wood than is the case for dulling when planing. Hence, abrasion(loss of metal) is irrelevant in chiseling. (Abrasion is likely a dulling mechanism in carving but I have not studied this topic to confirm this speculation.)
Discussion. The most durable metal for a chisel will therefore be one that can be made hard to resist bending while retaining toughness to resist chipping. Abrasion resistance is irrelevant. The properties of abrasion resistance, hardness and toughness are tabulated on steel company web sites which will enable one to compare the expected performance of chisels and plane irons made from these metals. For example, M2 is typically heat treated to be very hard but at this hardness it isn’t tough. Hence, the typically hardened M2 chisel edge chips (see Picture1) Japanese chisels, due to their extreme hardness, are prone to chipping. Carbon steel (O-1 type) bend severely if not hardened to a high value (Picture 2) When heat treated for maximum toughness (Rc58-60) chisels made from CPM 3V chisels dull only by deformation as is seen in Picture 3. Others have found that CPM 3V performs better when heat treated to higher hardness with some sacrifice in toughness. Tabulated steel properties would predict that O-1 is potentially a better steel chisel than A2 because it is tougher at high hardness. The better abrasion resistance of A2 is irrelevant to chisel dulling and it makes a chisel made from this steel more difficult to sharpen.
Indeed there are numerous reports of A2 chisels chipping. To mitigate this effect manufacturers recommend that A2 chisels be ground at a more blunt angle than is the case for O-1 chisels. When a manufacturer recommends grinding a chisel made from A2 at a more blunt angle than O-1 it is an admission that A2 is an inferior steel for chisels. (does anyone have any data to suggest A2 is superior in any way to O-1 for a chisel ?)
There are hundreds of steel products available. We can expect that there are steels that would be even better for chisels than O-1 or CPM 3V. Data available to date suggests that Lee Valley is offering such a steel for chisels, PMV11. Other steel products offering exceptional toughness at high hardness can be readily found on the steel web sites. Many can not be forged which precludes the popular socket design. Tanged chisels can be made from readily available bar stock.




