New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

Posts

O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#1

O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

Bill Tindall

This post relates to a question buried in a post below. I thought it best to start the discussion as a separate post. If we come to some agreement on the facts and conclusions I will write it up for the Articles section and we won’t have to go through this exercise again.

Background “facts”. Does anyone have data to disagree with these “facts”?

Three steel properties are relevant to woodworking. Abrasion resistance is the resistance to the wearing away of metal by the metal rubbing against the wood. Hardness is a measure of the resistance of the metal to deformation(bending). Toughness is a measure of the resistance to fracture if the metal is stressed (chiping).

Toughness and hardness are determined by the composition of the steel, how it is manufactured (for example powder metallurgy) and heat treating. As a rule heat treating to higher hardness results in lower toughness. See this link for a more comprehensive discussion of these concepts. http://www.crucibleservice.com/eselector/general/generalpart1.html

I have examined the dulled edges of several kinds of chisels with an "industrial quality" microscope and come to the following conclusion. Chisels used for chopping or paring out dovetail waste (force perpendicular to grain) get dull either by the deformation of the frail edge, or, this edge dulls by microscopic chipping. See pictures. (distinguishing chipping which results in loss of metal vs bending which doesn’t is best done through changing the focal plane of the microscope. These differences are less apparent in a single image)

M2 Chipping


Carbon Steel (O-1 type) bending (Sorby)


CPM 3V at Rc58 bending


In contrast, dulling through planing is a result of abrasion. Chisel dulling occurs with a much shorter exposure of steel to wood than is the case for dulling when planing. Hence, abrasion(loss of metal) is irrelevant in chiseling. (Abrasion is likely a dulling mechanism in carving but I have not studied this topic to confirm this speculation.)

Discussion. The most durable metal for a chisel will therefore be one that can be made hard to resist bending while retaining toughness to resist chipping. Abrasion resistance is irrelevant. The properties of abrasion resistance, hardness and toughness are tabulated on steel company web sites which will enable one to compare the expected performance of chisels and plane irons made from these metals. For example, M2 is typically heat treated to be very hard but at this hardness it isn’t tough. Hence, the typically hardened M2 chisel edge chips (see Picture1) Japanese chisels, due to their extreme hardness, are prone to chipping. Carbon steel (O-1 type) bend severely if not hardened to a high value (Picture 2) When heat treated for maximum toughness (Rc58-60) chisels made from CPM 3V chisels dull only by deformation as is seen in Picture 3. Others have found that CPM 3V performs better when heat treated to higher hardness with some sacrifice in toughness. Tabulated steel properties would predict that O-1 is potentially a better steel chisel than A2 because it is tougher at high hardness. The better abrasion resistance of A2 is irrelevant to chisel dulling and it makes a chisel made from this steel more difficult to sharpen.

Indeed there are numerous reports of A2 chisels chipping. To mitigate this effect manufacturers recommend that A2 chisels be ground at a more blunt angle than is the case for O-1 chisels. When a manufacturer recommends grinding a chisel made from A2 at a more blunt angle than O-1 it is an admission that A2 is an inferior steel for chisels. (does anyone have any data to suggest A2 is superior in any way to O-1 for a chisel ?)

There are hundreds of steel products available. We can expect that there are steels that would be even better for chisels than O-1 or CPM 3V. Data available to date suggests that Lee Valley is offering such a steel for chisels, PMV11. Other steel products offering exceptional toughness at high hardness can be readily found on the steel web sites. Many can not be forged which precludes the popular socket design. Tanged chisels can be made from readily available bar stock.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#2

Chipping and folding

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My data disagrees with these "facts". My chisels wear like plane irons, no chipping or folding. They are all low or no chrome steels.

A few weeks ago I visited a colleague who makes high quality reproductions and took a 30X loupe along. When I took out my loupe and told him I wanted to see the chisels he uses to cut dovetails, he was quite embarrassed. He said they are junky chisels and they are all dull. He had an old set of Marples blue handles. They were all very slightly dull, but no chipping and no folding. He had never looked at a chisel under magnification.

Of course a chisel that is way too hard will be brittle and chip, and one that is way too soft will fold at the edge. What I think happens is that as a person gains experience he is gentler on the tools and the window between what will chip and what will fold widens for him.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#3

but are all O1 steels the same?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

There is a slight fallacy in your premise. You set up the discussion by categorizing the three main types of steel.

I have a strong preference for O1 and as fond as I am of Addis tools I have an E.A. Berg that puts all my other tools to shame when it comes to holding an edge. I own upwards of 60 different chisels and gouges made by probably a dozen different manufacturers over at least 160 year range. I find it hard to believe that I only have one O1 tool that was hardened to the perfect Rockwell hardness which leaves me to the conclusion that not all O1 is the same and that in fact the range in quality is so great that you can't objectively have a discussion about tool steel just by category alone.

I realize you have to start your discussion somewhere but it seems premature to discuss a comparison of the different steels when there is some doubt that all of one category may not even have the same wear characteristics.

Robin

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#4

Re: but are all O1 steels the same?

TomD

Robin, it is possible that people who sell O1, are playing hard and loose with the facts for various reasons. Just speaking speculatively. But in my case I can't think of a more branded and uniform steel. It all comes from the same company, in the same wrapper, with the same heat treat instructions. And it is cheap and plentiful.

My problem with Bill's exercise is that personally I have no knowledge of whether all the suppositions he puts forward are true, and I bet that goes for a lot of us. So I can't ante up on any of that stuff. I don't see there being any hope that everyone will agree, and we can sink this subject once and for all. What I do know is that Bill comes to a different set of overall conclusions relative to edged stuff, and in general over-simplifies. So I am not likely to come along for the ride when I know what is at the end of it. Certain rational people will tell you there is not difference between a Lada and Mercedes, or that second hand vehicles are a better deal than new ones, there may be truth in these ideas, but there is also a dismissal of reality.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#5

OK by me to limit the Universe

Bill Tindall

This discussion most targets someone needing chisels who is either going to buy or make them. As a practical matter if I need a set of chisels in the next 10 days I need to buy new ones. So, I am happy limiting any comparisons, implied, imagined or otherwise that you wish to make to chisels currently offered for sale that are advertised to be O-1 or A2 steel. I will trust that current manufacturers are buying quality steel properly labeled and heat treating it under carefully controlled conditions according to steel manufacturers recommendations, which will yield similar results.

That said, I didn't intend to compare anything in my post other than dulling mechanisms. I reread my post and I didn't compare steels so it is unclear what your objection is. If among your experience with 60 chisels you have some data on A2 vs O-1 within the limits enumerated above these data would be helpful to someone buying a chisel. Your experience or opinions for a chisel that can't be bought and delivered in reasonable time isn't relevant to this discussion. Chisels that are not advertised to be A2 or O-1 are similarly not part of the discussion.

So to restate the objective of the discussion, O-1 seems to be an inherently better steel for chisels than A2. Manufacturers sharpening recommendations seem to support this premise. Does anyone have data on the topic?

As I have stated before, I have come to believe that chisel steel isn't very important once it meets some minimum level of performance. Its owner does need to be able to sharpen it. It is the ergonomics of the chisel that are most important.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#6

The photos--state of use of the chisels

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

Thanks for a thought provoking topic! Could you remind us what was done to or with these chisels before taking the photos--what state of use are they in?

Reason I ask: I wonder whether anyone working at a bench uses a chisel to dullness. I suspect many people will be retouching them as they go, without losing the rhythm of what they're doing, and before they show any signs of dulling. Of course, I may be wrong......

Wiley

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#7

Re: OK by me to limit the Universe

TomD

"So to restate the objective of the discussion, O-1 seems to be an inherently better steel for chisels than A2. Manufacturers sharpening recommendations seem to support this premise. Does anyone have data on the topic?"

What constitutes data?

What I would consider a dead end would be something like this:

- Bill's experience indicates O1 is king, or steel matters less than design. (I am pretty good with that)

- We scour the universe of academic articles and find one on geologist's rock hammers that determines A2 is better than O1, and given that experts who have never made and used chisels, none the less can prove the failure modes at the edge are the same as on wood, we therefore prove conclusively for the benefit of newbies that A2 is the better steel.

- We all return to the bench to sharpen our various O1 chisels

One scientific approach would be a market survey of what chisels sell most to newbies, and that newbies in tests find the most satisfying to use. Possibly combine that with a survey of pros, so the advancement path is clear. That would be social science.

We already know steels that are better O1s than O1, white paper steel for one. These are industrial steels and there is no reason other than cost why US manufacturers can't make US chisels out of similar steels to our preferred specs. That would strike me as scientific also. There is nothing all that scientific about endless tests of kludgy western steels when eastern steels are better. Something that has been recognized in the knife market (long tradition of cutting tests, performance tests, and competitions + 100x the makers in competition with each other). It is as though we are trying to find the best big wheel mountain bike to win a time trial in the Tour de France. Does one really need a big scientific test to prove that mountain bikes are not the right approach, could one not just guess, then apply all the science we can afford to reviewing the road bikes? The answer here is obvious: O1 if you sharpen by hand; A2 if you sharpen with power; and something from the east if you can find a format and price point that you like. This is basically what every scientific test in the mags has shown, for 30 years.

As I have stated before, I have come to believe that chisel steel isn't very important once it meets some minimum level of performance. Its owner does need to be able to sharpen it. It is the ergonomics of the chisel that are most important.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#8

The photos explained

Bill Tindall

The point that seems to be missed is that the objective of the pictures is to show the kinds of edge dulling experienced by chisels used to cut cross grain. I would not be surprised to find that plane blades planing cross grain suffer these same dulling mechanisms. If your chisel gets dull making one drawer from walnut I will guarantee it is by one of these mechanisms for the chisel has not slid across enough wood surface to experience abrasive wear sufficient to detect dulling by this mechanism.

Another point to make is that these dulling features are on the order of 5-25 microns in depth. You certainly can't see this sized divots by simply looking at the edge. However, with a tough edge such as the 3V one can begin to feel some deformation at the edge as it is getting dull.

But to answer the question, these chisel edges were tapped with modest force to remove a thin cross grain shaving in walnut to simulate the removal of dovetail waste at the base line (where you pare). Any experienced drawer maker would not think the chisel was subjected to any atypical stress in this preparation. As I recall (the pictures are 10 years old) the total shavings removed totaled 5" for each chisel.

From recent experience comparing OMV11 and CPM 3V I would judge that any of the edges in the picture would still pare cross grain for cleaning up a dovetail just fine. A similar, if not the same chisel pictured, did a whole large drawer in this recent comparison and still pared fine. But I would have stroked it some after this exercise to tune up the edge for the next drawer.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#9

Re: The photos explained

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks for the explanation, Bill. I was under the mistaken impression that these chisels had been 'run to failure'. But no, they are photographed after relatively light use (equivalent of trimming sockets on one decent sized drawer side).

So, if I understand, you are saying that (1) these photos show 'normal' dulling modes for each chisel's steel+heat treat; and (2) that these are the only two dulling modes available for tool steel cutting through end grain. Is this correct?

Does it follow that, for any steel+heat treat combination anyone wants to pick, that at some point it will dull in use through folding or chipping, when used to chop or pare end grain?

So which is preferred--chipping or folding? Is the dulling mode even important, or is the important thing how much work the tool will do before it reaches the level of chipping or folding that we call 'dull'?

Wiley

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#10

answers and speculations

Bill Tindall

Thanks for the explanation, Bill. I was under the mistaken impression that these chisels had been 'run to failure'. But no, they are photographed after relatively light use (equivalent of trimming sockets on one decent sized drawer side).........CORRECT

So, if I understand, you are saying that (1) these photos show 'normal' dulling modes for each chisel's steel+heat treat; and (2) that these are the only two dulling modes available for tool steel cutting through end grain. Is this correct?.......SORT OF Either microchiping or folding are the failure modes that are first to occur in end grain wood fiber severing with the chisel steels I have investigated- Sorby, Two Cherries, M2, 3V and PMV11. No doubt at some point, or at some edge angle, abrasion will become detectable, but we are talking feet of wood abrasion to get there.

Does it follow that, for any steel+heat treat combination anyone wants to pick, that at some point it will dull in use through folding or chipping, when used to chop or pare end grain? YES, for those steels I have looked at.

So which is preferred--chipping or folding?.........I don't know what I can say here as I have private data shared from another source. I prefer folding because a tough edge like on 3V can be straightened by a few rubs on a hard smooth stone. I will eat crow and say a hard ARK stone does have some modern utility. Yet, At Rc65 I doubt one will ever see dulling by folding with a Japanese chisel. This culture clearly prefers to avoid folding for the kinds of work these chisels are designed for. I have done no work with Japanese chisels.

Is the dulling mode even important..........I think so. I have personally not done enough work to make a definitive judgement. Others have and note where they decided. Chipping results in loss of metal. I have been told that small chips beget bigger chips. So the edge must be ground back to reach metal to form a new edge. Severe chipping, the kind that one can see, is fatal in my opinion.

or is the important thing how much work the tool will do before it reaches the level of chipping or folding that we call 'dull'? I think we want the hardest steel that will not chip. This assumption has been demonstrated for 3V. It is toughest at Rc58-60 but it makes a more durable knife and chisel at slightly higher hardness, sacrificing some toughness.

We plane hundreds of liner feet of before we need to sharpen and there is no evidence that dulling in planing is anything other than abrasive loss of metal (see Elliot's work). We do a drawer or part of a drawer (inches of travel against and through wood structure) and we touch up the chisel. Clearly something different is going on with cross grain fiber severing. The vastly greater forces to sever wood fibers rather than part them is shown in Kato and Kawai's work. Persumably these larger forces are loading the frail edge of the chisel and something has to give-break or bend.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#11

all O1 is not all from the same factory

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

O1 is anything but branded and uniform and it does not all come from the same factory. Depending on the use and manufacturer the carbon content can vary by over 1/2%. These small differences are why Shefield tools have such a better reputation than say Fulton or Greenlee even though all three used O1 steel.

Robin

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#12

Re: answers and speculations

TomD

"We plane hundreds of liner feet of before we need to sharpen and there is no evidence that dulling in planing is anything other than abrasive loss of metal (see Elliot's work). We do a drawer or part of a drawer (inches of travel against and through wood structure) and we touch up the chisel. Clearly something different is going on with cross grain fiber severing. The vastly greater forces to sever wood fibers rather than part them is shown in Kato and Kawai's work. Persumably these larger forces are loading the frail edge of the chisel and something has to give-break or bend. "

What happens when you plane end grain?

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#13

Re: all O1 is not all from the same factory

TomD

I didn't even realize those makers made O1 tools, and I couldn't google up any info on them. Conversely, every search I did gave the carbon content of O1 as .95%. I have seen a wide range of performance in O1 tools, but normally it was just the HT. That is often the case with cheaper chisels that do not have edge holding.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#14

Re: all O1 is not all from the same factory

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

Hi ,

As a machinist I have cut plenty of O1 in my life. In my experience (and my fellow workers) O1 is far from consistent. There have been times that it can be machined to a good surface finish and others that looked like I've used the dullest/worst tool possible. Don't know why this is, but we say that it is made from "recycled floor sweepings".

Work safe,

George

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#15

The elephant in the room

Bob Hackett

IMO the heat treatment makes all the difference in the world and many times can be far more important that the steel itself. I have lost track of how many times I`ve taken a chisel someone else was about to cast off as worthless for cutting wood then with proper heat treatment techniques had it cutting wood as well as a top of the line chisel.

On a bet one time I took one of these "garbage" chisels and demonstrated how using proper heat treatment techniques it could be transformed into something that could effectively cut ferrous metals. I then used further heat treatment to temper it so it would cut wood acceptably and the user would not have to worry about it breaking into two or more pieces if dropped on the concrete floor.

As Bill is probably well aware, even the exact temp and length of time you hold a steel at heat has a huge effect on the finished product as does what you use to quench the steel in after you bring it up to heat.

A person who is skilled in the working and heat treatment of metal can take items made from the a bar of steel and using only these skills turn that single bar of steel into tools that act and work like completely different animals.

In this regard a bar of "tool steel" is like a tree. It takes some knowledge to see the potential and select the proper type of material. Once you make your selection and have the raw material in your shop the possibilities are only limited by your skills and ability.

While all O1 or A2 from a single supplier may be close to equal that same O1 or A2, like trees cut from the same forest, can either shine of fall short in the hands of a less than experienced and skilled craftsman. Hand a shortfall to a craftsman who knows what they`re about and that skilled person can turn a perceived shortfall around.

I know this post is painting with a far wider brush than Bill would like but I prefer to look more closely at the nature of the beast rather than comparing two individual beasts. Where you see a pet dog, I see a domesticated wolf. Two completely different animals. :D

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#16

I disagree about O1

Patrick Gibbons

Chisels were traditionally made from water-hardening steels, not O1. It is my understanding that water-hardening steel can be tougher at higher hardness, a difference of a few Rc points (say Rc61 for 1095 or W2 as opposed to Rc 59 for O1). O1 is being used more now because of the tendency to deform while hardening and tempering by water-hardening steels and also because it's difficult to get the water-hardening alloys (the W series) in the forms necessary to make chisels. It is also my understanding that Sorby does not use O1. A quick look at the old Fine Woodworking articles on chisel tests will reveal what steel they use. People talk about old chisels being better and these were simple water-hardening steels that were enhanced by good forging techniques. When push comes to shove, a steel's potential has as much to do with the care it is fabricated into a chisel as its characteristics.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#17

Re: I disagree about O1

david weaver

I agree, not much over 100 years ago would be a diemaking steel spec. The new stuff is O1 probably for exactly the reasons you touched on.

And the more common stuff yet is probably all rubbery chrome vanadium type steel (including sorby tools), or something that air/impulse hardens well. I could be wrong about that, but that's my guess (maybe they have an automated impulse furnace and an automated oil bath quench.

I wouldn't trust anything to be O1 spec unless it was called that. Expect that most really old is water hardening steel, and most newer is some type of chrome vanadium-ish alloy.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#18

Re: all O1 is not all from the same factory

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

It’s been a long time since my apprenticeship classes so I can’t remember all the specs for O1. I do remember that the higher range of carbon content is used for cutting edge tools and the lower range of carbon content is used for tool and die applications. But just like some of the other alloys there is a bit of variability in each batch and I suppose there could even be a bit of variability in the annealing. I do remember that my old shop instructor in apprentice ship class had us anneal the O1 before we machined it, even though it came pre annealed.

Robin

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#19

refocus

Bill Tindall

Nothing you said would I disagree with. Clearly company A buying Chinese steel X and heat treating it without adequate control could be selling a worse chisel than company B that is using an inherently inferior steel Y but buying it from the best source and using the best heat treatment.

I would like to focus the discussion on "choice" which has to do with the potential of a material. If one buys their O-1 or A2 from the best quality source, and has available the best quality heat treatment facility which will make the more durable chisel? We have quality companies use both, in one case in the same company. In this case, LN, it seems that A2 is inferior because it is recommended to sharpen it at a more blunt angle to prevent chipping. What I am asking is whether there is any other data out there comparing these two steels for chisels? We can note that Lee Valley didn't choose A2. That could be another data point. What else?

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#20

Re: I disagree about O1

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I didn't realize that most of the old tool were water hardened. I suppose that might make for a strong case to include W1 in Bills study.

I have a friend that is a decent blacksmith and he swears that one of the reasons the old Japanese and Swedish tools were so good is because those countries lack coal deposits and the smiths forged on charcoal rather than coal. If this is true it is but one more variable to edge holding.

Robin

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#21

Re: refocus

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I think your conclusion that because A2 requires a more obtuse angle that it is there for inferior is false. The manufacturer is providing data about the optimum cutting angle for the tool. That cutting angle may not be suitable for the work you have at hand but it does not inherently make it inferior in quality to a tool with a more acute angle.

Robin

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#22

Re: all O1 is not all from the same factory

TomD

I'm here to learn, but as far as I know, there isn't any range of carbon that would make substantially different HT necesarry. O1 is chosen for tool projects for several reasons, one of these is because it is available in precision ground stock. This is useful for plane blades, and some other stuff, sometimes for chisels depending on design. But for the most part the precision grinding is good for making knives which is mostly where O1 established it's initial consumer acceptance, which seems to be growing. But any way, given the quality of the product I don't believe that they supply it in a wide carbon range.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#23

Don't the manufacturers supply specifications?

Bill Tindall

I would think that one could go to any steel company's web site and find the carbon specification for the product they sell. They certainly have this specification and use it to determine if a batch of steel will be sold with their name on it.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#24

Please explain.....

Bill Tindall

If A2 must be ground at 30 degrees to provide a robust edge while some other steel can be ground at a more shallow angle and provide equivalent edge robustness, how can it be that A2 is not inferior? This fact demonstrates what the data in the steel company's technical literature reveals. A2 is inherently less tough than say O-1. The only attribute that A2 has that is better is abrasion resistance, which is not an advantage for a chisel.

My guess is that companies making A2 chisels presumed that what was good for plane blades, namely abrasion resistance, was good for chisels without understanding how chisels get dull. Lee Valley didn't make this mistake because they studied what was going on first. BTW, the microchipping and folding are clearly seen in the data on their web site. They did not provide enough details of conditions to enable comparisons, but one can clearly see folding for O-1, a combination of folding and chipping for A2 and chipping for M4. The damage to their PMV11 steel was too small for me to see what the dulling mode is.

Given a sufficiently obtuse angle any steel will hold up. That is like a head start in a race, or a handicap.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#25

Re: Please explain.....

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Carbide requires an even more obtuse angle so using your criteria for evaluating steels that would make carbide and even more inferior steel.

The optumum angle of the cuting edge of A2 may make it less suitable for a particular type of tool but that dosen't make it an inferior steel.

Robin