New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

Posts

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#26

more refocusing

Bill Tindall

"The optumum angle of the cuting edge of A2 may make it less suitable for a particular type of tool but that dosen't make it an inferior steel."

In spite of the many directions this thread has taken My posts are only about O-1 and A2 steel, and chisels made from these two metals.

To restate: The LN data on recommended bevel angles is data that says that A2 is inferior to O-1 for chisels(presuming the steel and heat treating for each chisel was optimally chosen). This is the only data point I know of that compares these metals without convoluting so many variable as to make the data incomparable (LV data).

Does anyone have any other data comparing A2 and O-1 for chisels?

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#27

WWing algebra

Bob Hackett

I usually have a problem with discussions where someone involved wants to focus on a single section of a much larger picture unless it is agreed that the opening discussion is just a start point and at some point we will zoom out and at least touch on all the variables in order to see and better understand the big picture and how it relates to the real world. Looking at a single factor like one steel vs another steel in WWing is like trying to solve an algebra problem when given only one factor of the equation.

I understand you may be frustrated by the direction many of the discussions you spark take here Bill. I try to remember many times two people can look at exactly the same object yet see something completely different. Someone holds up a chisel and Bill sees the blade yet Bob sees the handle. we are told to focus on the metal involved, Bill sees the edge yet Bob sees the hoop on the handle.

A discussion of the performance of steel in simple tools, like chisels, used in WWing just has too many variables for someone like me to do much of anything except remind folks of points they may have missed or glossed over. I have to ask why we aren`t discussing the mechanics of how a chisel works ( I am enjoying the edge failure part of this discussion) and what we each can do to enhance the performance of the chisels we already own while doing the work we are presently doing.

A properly sharpened Dollarstore screwdriver can and will cut wood, why don`t we just start there? :)

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#28

Re: answers and speculations

CStanford

"What happens when you plane endgrain?"

The board gets shorter by the amount of material removed.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#29

On the utility of focus

Bill Tindall

Suppose, like apparently many customers, you are about to buy a chisel from LN. You are required to make a choice between O-1 and A2. If we focus on providing data on the performance of these metals in chisels these data will be beneficial to the person required to make a choice when buying a chisel. Only Warren provided any data. Apparently no one else has any. I thought Derek might. Maybe lack of any will motivate someone to obtain some.

Secondly, some responders did not focus (or use some other word if you will) on what I actually wrote. In the most recent case, I was not discussing the merits of A2 for arrow heads so to criticize what I said because it didn't apply to arrow heads moved me to try to refocus on what I was writing about if you want to criticize my efforts.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#30

Re: more refocusing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Does anyone have any other data comparing A2 and O-1 for chisels?

Hi Bill

You may recall that I began comparing various chisel steels here about 18 months ago.

There were two articles. In the first I compared the durability of chisels in chopping mode. These included CPM 3V, CPM 10V and CPM M4 for powdered metals, and then a Koyamaichi White Steel and a (vintage) Stanley #750, which is a HCS but I was not sure whether to refer to it as O1 or W1. No A2, so this will not interest you.

Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselBladeTesting-5Steels.html

In the second comparison I added an A2 chisel (Blue Spruce). This article looked at durability in paring mode. To save anyone the effort of reading through the article, this was my conclusion:

"Taken overall, 10V struggled to hold an edge over the duration of the test. I strongly suspect that this was due difficulties in creating a good edge at the outset. This highlights the major drawback in using this steel, and it is doubtful that the average woodworker would see any advantage here. I cannot recommend 10V as a steel for woodworking blades.

In the initial stages the laminated WS appeared to take the sharpest edge, better than any other blade in the test, but it did not hold this as well as the M4 and 3V blades. The latter made up for this by holding a “good” edge longest.

With the memory of the WS’ strong performance in the chopping test, the question is whether the construction of bench/dovetail and paring chisels are similar?

The A2 and O1 blades were almost as good as the WS, really only a little behind. I’d place the O1 fractionally ahead of the A2 in the first 25 strokes and at the end of the experiment. The extra durability of the A2 was not evident in this assessment.

Clearly, the non-PM blades were easiest to get sharp, and this helped in their strong performance early on. While they could not sustain this as well as the PM blades, their performance was not far off the pace, and possibly close enough that many may question whether PM steels are enough ahead of the game to warrant their use."

Of course the same limitations in research methodology are levelled here, that is, using steels that are an unknown quality (some are and some are not). And of course, the context must be retained, that is, not all O1, A2, WS, etc steels are the same. Nevertheless, the results seemed to make sense and reflect anecdotal reports.

Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselParing.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#31

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

Ray

Bill,

Thank you for your many attempts to get back to my original concern- A2 vs O1 for chisels.

Ray

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#32

A survey

Lars Parrington

I don't have any hard data, but I do have some questions that might help focus this discussion around the critical differences between A2 and 01.

1.) If a chisel made from each were sharpened at 30 rather than 25 degrees, which would hold an edge longer when used for chopping? How much longer?

2.) An A2 chisel sharpened at 25 degrees is going to chip...

    A.) Definitely.

    B.) Only if wacked too hard or otherwise abused.

    C.) If the steel or heat treat is sub-optimal.

3.) If you answered (B) or (C) above, would the (ideally made and carefully used) A2 chisel remain sharp longer than a similarly sharpened 01 chisel? How much longer?

4.) Under what conditions would it be beneficial to intentionally sharpen any chisel greater than 25 degrees?

5.) Can you acheive as keen of and edge on A2 as O1? If No, does it matter? If Yes, does it take longer?

Even if you don't have hard data for any of the answers, it would still be interesting to hear your gut-feel, wild-ass-guess answers.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#33

Re: A survey

Lars Parrington

Here's my answers. Almost all guesses. I don't own any A2 tools. So, all except #4 are just based on things I've read.

1.) A2, twice as long.

2.) B and C

3.) Yes, twice as long.

4.) I've observed much better edge life by sharpening to 30 degrees on chisels I'm going to hit with a mallet. I've observed this on a homemade O1 chisel, as well as some chrome-vanadium chisels (narex).

5.) I haven't tried. I use japanese waterstones, and from what i've read i expect it wouldn't be a problem.

Re: O1 vs A2 as chisel steel

#34

Wasn`t trying to be critical

Bob Hackett

I was just wondering why we were limiting the discussion of chisels to O1 vs A2 is all.

Depending on the work being done and the material being used I just feel there might be better options outside those two choices. I believe it was you Bill who had a hand in convincing me of that.

Sounds like we are now further limiting the discussion to chisels made from only these two alloys that are presently being offered by big name manufacturers.

Lead on Bill, I look forward to seeing where this takes us.