Doug fir bench tops
rononkokomo
Got one?
How do you like it?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Doug fir bench tops
rononkokomo
Got one?
How do you like it?
Re: Doug fir bench tops
Michael Donaldson
I am in the process of making my first bench. I am using Southern Yellow Pine. I was going to use Douglass Fir, but the SYP was not that much more expensive, and it's a lot heavier and a lot more dense.
I have heard of a few people who have Doug fir tops and they really like them.
Re: Doug fir bench tops
Robin Corell in Atascadero CA
I have a small bench that is old growth doug fir with nice tight growth rings. I have no idea when it was cut but the resin was set long before it came to me. It is a good bench but nothing like a good hard wood bench.
Robin
Re: Doug fir bench tops
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
My grandfather's workbench was Douglas fir. Some Doug fir is highly splintery - his was. Some is finer grain and as close as you can get to a good hardwood from a conifer; a benchtop from that would be a nice one.
Re: Doug fir bench tops
craigd
I have one made from lower than construction grade 4x4s. Works great. The one problem I've had is the leg vise has compressed the top about 1/8", I've since lined it with leather for a fix. I might inlay a chunk of maple or some such.
No, but mine is no showcase, either.
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I don't quite know what wood my bench is made from, other than to say it is "white wood" with not very distinguishable grain, probably cheap-ass pine or some such. I'm certain it's not fir of any sort. I made it from construction-grade 2 X 4's glued face to face and planed the top flat. It's no beauty, but it's been that way for the last 28 years. It's heavy, 3.5" thick and serves me just fine.
Re: No, but mine is no showcase, either.
Patrick Gibbons
I've been wanting to build a new bench for about three years now. I wanted to use slabs without laminating, or at least very little. my first choice was SYP. The pine tends to warp as it dries whereas Doug fir will check more and warp less. For that reason I'll probably use Doug fir for the top. Doug fir is softer than SYP. Peter Follansbee's benchtop is made of white pine. Check out his blog for more info. I know it's not an exact answer to your question but it's some more info to consider. Chris Schwartz taught a class last year where Doug fir was the wood used for bench building. He has more info about it on his blog.
My 3-year old bench top if from DF.
Chuck Nickerson
8' long, 2' wide, and 4" thick; Roubo-style. My pieces are clear, cut from 20 ft 2"x12"s.
Because of the growth rings it looks a bit tarted up, but after the sap set (18 months) it's been a great bench.
Re: Doug fir bench tops
wilbur
Yes.
Love it. Would do it all over again if I had to.
Hated it...
John in NM
Had one at a shop I worked for, after years of use it provided many splinters, usually under the finger nail. I'd spend the money on hardwood personally.
fir vs hardwood, ASH is a practical choice.
Bill Tindall
One should be able to get 8/4 poplar for less money than clear fir. I could buy clear maple for less than clear fir in these parts.
My bench is made from poplar and it has done fine for 25 years.
Ash would be another good choice. It is currently very cheap. We moved our industrial customers to ash form maple when maple prices skyrocketed and it worked fine where abuse was involved.
Holdfasts in Poplar?
Curt Putnam
Having asked in another forum, I was convinced to go away from poplar as a benchtop. Most compelling reason was that holdfast holes soon crumpled when actually used with holdfasts. Your experience?
Haven't bought the wood yet so quite interested.
Re: Holdfasts in Poplar. Restoring Dog Holes
William Duffield
Liriodendron is still tougher than Pseudotsuga, and it has no tendency whatsoever to splinter. If your holdfasts are improperly sized, or just roughly made, and do eventually wear out your most used dog holes, there is an easy fix. Buy some 1" or 1-1/4" maple dowel stock (or turn it if you have a lathe), drill a 3/4" hole through it, lengthwise, drill a hole matching the diameter of the dowel in the bench where the blown out dog hole needs to be replaced, and glue in the maple insert. Take a caliper with you when you shop for the dowel stock to make sure it's properly sized. Since your hole won't have a center to guide the drill bit, you'll need to drill a hole in a guide block and clamp it or hot melt glue it to the bench top to get the drill bit started. Most of your dog holes probably won't get enough wear over your lifetime to ever require refurbishing.
Re: Holdfasts in Poplar. Restoring Dog Holes
roger lance
Or better yet, just build the dog hole strips/strips that have the holdfast holes out of maple to begin with.....if not the entire top.
my experience
Bill Tindall
Mine sure as hell didn't "soon crumple". Can you imagine poplar being worse than the fir and pine that many use successfully?
But if I intended to work at the bench hours a day and build dozens of pieces of furniture where these holes would be significantly stressed from use, and was concerned, I would use Ash or Maple. The piddly extra cost amortized over thousands of hours or dozens of furniture pieces would become insignificant.
Re: Holdfasts in Poplar. Restoring Dog Holes
William Duffield
Of course. I'm a firm believer in the efficacy of quarter sawn, glued up, rock maple tops. Make the front six or eight inches 16/4, drop to 12/4 for the remainder of the front half, drop to 8/4 or 6/4 for most of the back half, and go back to a 16/4 strip for the last couple of inches of the rear. You can even skimp on these dimensions and it will still work, as long as the thick front strip is at least as wide as the depth of the jaws (from the nose to the front threaded rod) of your biggest hand screw.
the long view....
roger lance
that's right.....over time the higher cost of maple or ash becomes insignificant.....especially if you will not be having to deal with splintering or other problems that have been mentioned about fir or other construction grade lumber.....I realize that I'm blessed to have hard maple so available in this area.....they don't give it away but I turn to its use frequently.....you will also have a good hardwood supply in your area....whatever it is, spend some money on the top and use lower grade woods for the base.....in the long run, quality pays.
I am convinced.
rononkokomo
Hardwood top likely maple
Re: I am convinced.
roger lance
Ron....you will not regret that decision....I strongly recommend that you also read "The Workbench Book" by Scott Landis.....a tremendous resource on bench building....take your time....and plan out every detail....those wood screws are special.....nothing wrong with you having a special bench.
Good advice.
rononkokomo
I have built a pretty nice bench. I just have a major case of Roubo fever. I will repurpose my current bench and put my Moxon vise on it and use it for sawing joinery, bench hooks, shooting boards, etc. I do have the Landis book and will make sure to review it as well as Derek 's log of his bench build and a lot of the Schwarz's stuff. I am still in Limbo till SWMBO and I figure out whether we will move to a smaller home. I really don't want to have to move a Roubo the size I hope to build out of a basement shop. Should have Firm decision in a couple of months.
Re: Holdfasts in Poplar. Restoring Dog Holes
CStanford
A little epoxy 'finish' to dog holes before being put to use vastly extends their useful lives. Run it in there thin, the goal is to get a little surface penetration, a molecule or two will do. Thin 5 minute epoxy works fine.
Re: Holdfasts in Poplar. Restoring Dog Holes
William Duffield
That's a good idea, Charles. I should have done that when I put dog holes through the particle board behind the veneer of an oxymoronic solid core door.