New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

Posts

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#26

Re: Horse Butt Abrasive?

William Duffield

There were these "Furniture Guys," Joe L'Erario and Ed Feldman, on WHYY (PBS Phily) several years ago, whose expertise was renovating curb furniture, and also doing lots of humorous skits. On one episode they made the statement, "Roy Underhill could build a house with a rock!"

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#27

Re: Have you raised horses......

William Duffield

I suppose it depends to a certain extent on on which side of the mountain the horse was raised.

I was almost thrown by the horse butt at first

Be thankful you weren't thrown by the horse. :D

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#28

Re: I was wondering about the time thing...

CStanford

Over the years, Schwarz has made some comments I found to be more than just little inconsistencies with my own experience using hand tools. A plane iron in O1 won't last an hour. It would crap out in pine, before an hour. Of this, I'm quite sure. I'm assuming that he and I must have vastly different definitions of both 'sharp' and 'serviceable' though I've always considered myself to have a fairly laid back approach to "sharp" and sharpening in general. Well, maybe not it turns out.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#29

Re: I was wondering about the time thing...

CStanford

should have said: 'more than just a little inconsistent...'

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#30

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#31

Re: "And the Emily Litella award goes to... "

William Duffield

I have to disagree with Ron. The review has some serious problems, not the product being reviewed, but the review itself. The on-line review is much abridged, compared to the full page, three column exposé in the magazine. Derek has already provided us with the link to the research pages, which are also well worth reading and studying, and which kind of belie the “Top Secret” epithet. Is the implication that Rob Lee is somehow trying to hide something from his potential customers (or, completely understandably and prudently, just from his competition)? If you are going to grind it, and need to know what’s in it, ask him for the SDS. However, considering the quality of all the Veritas products, I can’t imagine why you would need to grind it.

The gratuitous "Until now" is really easy to miss buried under a lot of initial negativism. You have to force your way through the whole first column of caveats, before Chris begins to reveal the real advantages of the new steel. One might think Chris has been studying Fox News' techniques of hiding the facts in amongst a bunch of innuendo and editorial opinion. Either that or he was having a really bad day.

The review must be read very carefully to separate the facts (all positive) from the opinions (mostly spin), and a lot of readers aren’t very good at that. It makes one wonder if he has a hidden agenda. Obviously, this development is not going to make it easy for Lie-Nielsen, Ron Hock and IBC (Whose Pinnacle blades are currently on sale and some on clearance at Woodcraft).

I’m looking forward to Bill’s review.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#32

Re: I was wondering about the time thing...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I think your experience pretty much parallels my own. At the end of 30 minutes or so, even my Hock irons need a touch-up. But then at that point so do I. :D

I was also referring to my ability to keep planing for an hour. Maybe when I was 20 years younger, but that ship is beyond the blue horizon.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#33

Re: The power of flour -- silica, that is

david weaver

I wonder if food grade diatomaceous earth could be substituted. It's also sharp little bits, not as hard, and the food grade stuff doesn't contain a whole bunch of crystalline silica.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#34

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop  *LINK*

William Duffield

It appears the Schwarz has initiated a multi-front smear campaign against the promoters of high-tech tool steels, invoking the likes of PETA and the tragedy of liposuction.

It's difficult to believe this is just coincidental. :D :D :D


The Case for No-kill Mutton Tallow

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#35

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#36

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#37

Re: I don't know about food grade

david weaver

that I don't know. I have heard of people supplementing livestock with it, on the assumption that it has some mineral content. But I don't know how many people actually do that.

I read somewhere, some permaculture site or something of the sort, that food grade DE doesn't have crystalline silica but that the stuff not certified for food use had a huge % of crystalline silica.

I only use it to kill bugs. But it sure feels like it would make a great buffing material - it's soft and very fine. But that's no guarantee that it wouldn't cloud up every surface it touched.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#38

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop

megan fitzpatrick

Derek,

I'm not going to wade into the discussion - but I wanted to let you and other WoodCentral folk know that we post the printed tool reviews online in full - so you needn't wait for your issue if you care to read it (it's on page 2 at popularwoodworking.com/oct12)

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#39

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop

CStanford

Both Stanley and Record sold HSS cutters to the Australian and New Zealand markets in their heyday. Kunz offers HSS cutters as well and has done so for years.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#40

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#41

Re: And now I take it back the other way...

William Duffield

I stand corrected, and apologize for misleading people. The print and on-line articles now appear to me to be identical (except for trivial stuff like typeface and number of columns).

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#42

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Megan. I think that I will wait for my subscribed copy to arrive. I am sure that this is a storm in a teacup, that Chris has been misinterpreted. He is not inclined to be inconsistent.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#43

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop

david weaver

Making one is an option. even the kunz irons are expensive, but if you are going to use them with frequency, they will be worth the cost. There will not be many people who honestly sharpen one of those with thrift and wear it down to the adjuster.

It might be easier to learn to braze a mujingfang iron, though, they are about $12 if they can be found, and incredibly tough.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#44

Re: I don't know about food grade

Michael Brady

Christopher Schwarz has a response to this thread in his blog, if you are interested in reading the author's comments about his review of the powdered metal technology that is being introduced by Lee Valley. I don't blame him for being peeved about the tone of the initial post that appears above. How that poster interpreted the review to be "damning with faint praise" is beyond me. Most of the other posters seemed to get the drift of what was being said by Mr. Schwarz.

Every noted person in every field will have a group of detractors. I don't hang on every pronouncement from CS, his publishing venture, or PW magazine....far from it. There needs to be room for disagreement, but snarky negativism only makes a person look foolish.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#45

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#46

Re: Michael, could you link to Chris' response?

Michael Brady

Link to original post:

http://blog.lostartpress.com/2012/08/22/holy-cow-you-people-confuse-me/

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#47

Re: Michael, could you link to Chris' response?

William Duffield

Chris has two blogs, one at Lost Art Press and the other at Popular Woodworking.

http://blog.lostartpress.com/

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog

He writes prolifically, posts lots of photos, and gets lots of comments, so posts often scroll rapidly off the bottom of the page. These blogs are probably the first thing I read every morning (Sometimes, I go here first.)

The pertinent article is here:

http://blog.lostartpress.com/2012/08/22/holy-cow-you-people-confuse-me/

I have not commented to the blog post, for two reasons. First, because I don't think Chris has tried to appreciate what the problems are that we perceive and have identified. Both he and Megan have advanced degrees in the language arts, and both should have taken courses that address the ethics of journalism, and the differences in the standards which should be applied to reporting, editorializing and advertising.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journalism_ethics_and_standards

Second, I do not want to get involved with some of his fanboys who immediately descended to character assassination on everyone who commented on this thread. One of them labeled us all "cretins." Most impolite, not to mention irrational, IMHO. Another calls the new steel "magic," perhaps because has never read or can't comprehend any of Bill's dissertations or links to scholarly metallurgical articles on the different types of dulling, and also dismissed all the data on L-V's PM-V11 website as meaningless. Chris hasn't chastised either of them, in fact he gave the second one an "attaboy" and a really dumbed-down, but factual, explanation, albeit without any numbers. I could elucidate on some of this guy's observations, but judging from his comments, that would apparently be an exercise in futility.

You could almost call me a Schwarz fanboy, as I own several of the books he has written, and most of the books he has published, and I read them all. I will buy the next three he is working on as well, because they will provide valuable information that I can use. I've read The Scarlet Letter (I mean The Anarchist's Tool Chest) three times, cover to cover. Popular Woodworking is the only general woodworking magazine I read regularly, and that is due mostly to Chris's editorial leadership over many years.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#48

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#49

Bill's mumness *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm pretty sure Bill is MIA in Atlanta at the IWF tool show, where he was going to be buying one of the PM V11 chisels at Lee Valley's booth (with his name on the package).


IWF and Bill's new chisel

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#50

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)