Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood
Bill Tindall
The latest Popular Woodworking has a review of Veritas PM-V11 plane blades. The steel seems to be damned with the faintest of praise, but we should not be surprised. The first paragraph sets the pejorative tone of the review. "So called super steels", who has ever heard M2 and the like called "super steels? "Even worse, you have to buy fancy equipment to even get a serviceable edge". Really- a few bucks worth of diamond powder and a $60 fixed diamond plate rates a fancy equipment.l Lee Valley showed that even M2 could be effectively sharpened with the proper water stone. Most consider water stones not fancy. If anyone as lazy and cheap as I am can effectively sharpen M2 or even M4 then it is not a difficult thing to do unless one insists on doing it with one hand tied behind their back and a foot stuck in Arkansas.
But, why would anyone who feels that "edge life doesn't impress me" bother reviewing a steel whose only possible benefit over carbon steel would be longer edge life? Is it surprising that someone unwilling to forsake century old sharpening technology would be unimpressed with new steel technology? I simply can not understand why anyone would consider a steel different from carbon steel and then refuse to consider more modern sharpening technology.
Popular Woodworking should have found someone not stuck in the 19th century to review the steel. But then, without some quantitative means of assessing edge life a review of this steel is worthless. Most are not going to care how it behaves on a soft ARK stone. Does the edge last enough longer to warrant a premium price? If the performance is there a way to sharpen will be adapted by those interested in longer edge life.
I think Lee Valley needs to get meaningful quantitative data published. Not data under abnormal planing conditions on MDF but data on North American hardwoods under typical planing conditions are required, A2 vs PMV11.





