New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

Posts

Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#1

Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

Bill Tindall

The latest Popular Woodworking has a review of Veritas PM-V11 plane blades. The steel seems to be damned with the faintest of praise, but we should not be surprised. The first paragraph sets the pejorative tone of the review. "So called super steels", who has ever heard M2 and the like called "super steels? "Even worse, you have to buy fancy equipment to even get a serviceable edge". Really- a few bucks worth of diamond powder and a $60 fixed diamond plate rates a fancy equipment.l Lee Valley showed that even M2 could be effectively sharpened with the proper water stone. Most consider water stones not fancy. If anyone as lazy and cheap as I am can effectively sharpen M2 or even M4 then it is not a difficult thing to do unless one insists on doing it with one hand tied behind their back and a foot stuck in Arkansas.

But, why would anyone who feels that "edge life doesn't impress me" bother reviewing a steel whose only possible benefit over carbon steel would be longer edge life? Is it surprising that someone unwilling to forsake century old sharpening technology would be unimpressed with new steel technology? I simply can not understand why anyone would consider a steel different from carbon steel and then refuse to consider more modern sharpening technology.

Popular Woodworking should have found someone not stuck in the 19th century to review the steel. But then, without some quantitative means of assessing edge life a review of this steel is worthless. Most are not going to care how it behaves on a soft ARK stone. Does the edge last enough longer to warrant a premium price? If the performance is there a way to sharpen will be adapted by those interested in longer edge life.

I think Lee Valley needs to get meaningful quantitative data published. Not data under abnormal planing conditions on MDF but data on North American hardwoods under typical planing conditions are required, A2 vs PMV11.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#2

I thought his review was positive

roninkokomo

I think a lot of folks misunderstand what he is trying to say. Tool companies are like golf equipment companies. They must continue to produce the "hot new thing" to stay in business. Chris just suggests a careful cost/ benefit analysis before buying in to the hype. I use oil stones and a strop. I am willing to accept that you may have found a better way to hone that produces an edge keener than I can produce. If so, good for you.. But it is a distinction that makes no difference to me. My irons are as sharp as they need to be. So, I really do not need a better iron. That is a big part of the between the lines thinking in Chris's anarchist viewpoint.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#3

My 2 cents

James Watriss

Is a setup with diamond powder and cast iron lapping plates fancy?

To some folks, yes. Fancy, newfangled, or downright arcane to anyone who doesn't spend too much time in online forums.

Back in the normal world, where many of us came from, our now-normal things weren't really on the menu. They're things we looked for and found.

In truth, I think the really relevant point was that he had such good results with Arkansas stones. That's the norm I grew up with. And it was EASY: 2 stones, in fitted wooden boxes, some mineral oil, and a rag, tucked in a drawer in my bench.

Water stones made more mess. I used diamond paste on MDF, and later acrylic, because my iron shapton lapping plate had gone out of flat on me, and I didn't want to worry about that with diamonds. MDF and acrylic are cheap and disposable, but not robust. And while going through the diamond grits took more time, I was happy with the final polish.

After a while I regressed to water stones. And since then, I've been wanting to go back to fewer, oily stones, at the bench for convenience and speed.

I'm with you on the edge life issue. I'm a fan of M2 and M4 because they take such a keen edge, hold it well, and aren't a bear to sharpen like D2. But even Konrad Sauer ultimately went back to high carbon for his planes because it was fast and easy to sharpen, and he was therefore more likely to do it. And honestly, I've been getting back to that myself. The faster, easier sharpening job is more important than the ultimate edge holding ability. That, to me is the selling point.

I feel like people drifted towards harder or more exotic alpha-numerical steels because they promised less maintenance. But I've watched a lot of novices struggle with sharpening because those steels are harder to sharpen. I'm not really interested in claims of longer immaculate edge life: I'd rather it be easily maintained.

In the end, though, while I liked what I heard, I agree that the review was dubious. It sounded more or less like it performed like high carbon, and sharpened like high carbon... But costs more.

So... I'm left with the impression that I should buy high carbon blades, if the performance is roughly equivalent. Lacking data, and possessing the array of steel that I currently do, I'll sit this one out and watch to see what happens.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#4

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

None of this makes sense to me, but then I have not read the review and the details involved. I do not even know who wrote it.

To lump PM-VII in with "super steels", such as 3V, M2, M4 and D2, with regard the issue of sharpening completely misses the reason for PM-VII's conception. The whole point of PM-VII is that it offers a long lasting edge with the same effort and materials used to hone A2.

There is no extra expenditure for sharpening materials if you can already sharpen A2 steel. For your money you get a significantly longer lasting edge, around twice as long as A2 - I have been using one for 12 months now and can attest that this is a fact. What's not to like about a longer lasting edge, especially when you work with abrasive timbers? Did the reviewer evaluate this area?

I'll wait until my mag comes out to comment on the review. All I can respond to are the comments here, which are second-hand.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#5

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#6

yabut

Bruce, a MN Galoot

James W says "So... I'm left with the impression that I should buy high carbon blades, if the performance is roughly equivalent."

I didn't get the impression that the performance was roughly equivalent. He states at the end of his write-up that it lasts a lot longer between sharpenings than high-carbon steel. [And Derek's experience, which is not referenced in the article and thus is not fair game for critiquing the article, is that it lasts twice as long between sharpenings] If it lasts longer and is as easy to sharpen as traditional high-carbon steel, that would seem to be a pretty good selling point to someone who is looking for the next best thing or is teetering on the edge of a decision.

I've steered clear of a bunch of alternatives because they require new sharpening regimens and equipment. Unlike a lot of WWers, I am loathe to spend a bunch of money I don't have on a new line of stones just to sharpen the new chisels or blades. I want to be able to use what I already have.

LV's new steel is not enough for me to replace my Bergs, but it is enough for me to pick up a replacement plane blade made of this new whiz-bang stuff.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#7

Re: And the Emily Litella award goes to...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thank you David. I went to Chris' blog in the link you supplied. In this he stated ..

But to be candid, edge life doesn’t impress me terribly. As long as I’m not sharpening the tool every hour, I’m OK. What I really care about is sharpenability – how easy the tool is to sharpen – and how keen an edge it takes. On this front, the PM-V11 is a real champ.

In fact, the biggest surprise came when I tried sharpening the PM-V11 on my oilstones. It was exactly like sharpening high-carbon steel. The soft Arkansas bit right into the cutter and turned a burr with ease. The hard and translucent Arkansas stones did their jobs quickly and easily. Honestly, if I didn’t know better, I would have sworn I was sharpening high-carbon steel.

The highlights are mine.

Firstly, these are statements with which I wholly agree. No one will want to use a long-lasting steel, no matter how long it lasts, if they struggle to re-sharpen it once it dulls. This is the attraction of O1 for so many. Chris is noting here the ease of sharpening PM-VII on really basic equipment.

The second point is why there should be such a variance between this review (June blog) and the one Bill cited (in the latest Oct PW mag I understand, which I have yet to read). It draws the opposite conclusions to that above. Is this really what has been published in the forthcoming (to me) PW mag?

Discombobulated in Perth

Derek

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#8

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#9

Re: "And the Emily Litella award goes to... "

CStanford

"As long as I'm not sharpening every hour..."

I don't know what sort of steel he uses but it already sounds like super steel to me. I can get 30 minutes of continuous use out of a plane cutter made with O1 and that includes Hock. Now, I'm damn tired after 30 minutes of continuous planing and appreciate the break.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#10

Re: My 2 cents

CStanford

I think the rap on using abrasives whether they be paper or loose grits is that they represent an ongoing expense, hassle of reordering, etc. Just too much thought and too much "process" for some who think it all should be, and can be, easier.

It is possible to keep edges honed, as history has proved, with a one-time investment in stones.

I think that practically the only thing the internet has added to the equation is that the 'new normal' is changing systems umpteen times, sharpening as practically an end in itself, the advent of the sharpening 'wonk,' jumping on every new fad and gadget that comes along, and that sharpening is right up there with wood purchases in use of dollars.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#11

Re: And the Emily Litella award goes to...

CStanford

Very well said.

I don't think that a dry, boring, and clinical fisking of tool steels is Schwarz's style. Some people have an innate need for that sort of thing but a lot don't. I think Chris usually writes for the second group of folks.

I could be wrong, though. Probably am.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#12

Question about North Bennett

Bill Tindall

I spent some time with Will Neptune. He talked like using fixed diamond plates was something the school evaluated and adapted some time ago. He spoke of a joint project with DMT to evaluate their product when it was introduced and the result was successful. The question is, what is the current situation at the school regarding sharpening with diamonds?

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#13

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop

david weaver

I have a bias, a pile of tools bias, so I could easily write off their efforts because I"ll probably not buy anything V11.

BUT, it hasn't been hard to sharpen high speed steels for a very very long time, and it hasn't been expensive to do it for a long time, either.

Grinding is where some extra time comes in vs. carbon steel, but the overall sharpening/grinding vs. working time for a plane with a high speed steel iron is so skewed in favor of the HSS that it would be nice to see such a thing recognized sometime as a matter of time spent planing.

The more abrasive the wood, the bigger the difference in edge life.

planing tests in MDF and chisel tests hammering a chisel as hard as you can possibly hammer it into the side of a stick don't tell us that much.

I wonder if there was this much resistance to steel in general initially, probably not because professionals were using it.

I probably get about 20 minutes of planing time in medium hardwood with A2, and a little less with good O1, maybe 2/3rds of the A2 time. Most of that time is a heavier cut, I guess, and not much softwood involved. If someone told me I could plane for 40 minutes instead of 20, what would my objection be to that if I was out looking for new tools?

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#14

Re: Question about North Bennett

david weaver

It would seem to me that a lot of the professionals had adopted them.

Someone asked george wilson a long time ago what he uses to sharpen, and he said he uses a diamond hone, a fine spyderco and if needed, some green stuff on a strop. A spyderco works a lot like an oilstone, except it's harder, it's finer and it cuts a wider range of steels. The fine stones are probably a bit tricky to use for a beginner, because they do the same thing an oilstone does - they cut fast if they are lapped, and slow down if they are not.

Anyway, I can't think of anyone who has been more prolific in terms of output in general, quality of output and range of output vs. george, so the notion that tinkering with sharpening stuff is something top craftspeople never do is bunk.

Even paul sellers is entirely onto diamond stuff.

I've talked to george offline about the stuff, not like science project talk, just general talk, and he mentioned that when he was working, he tried every stone available, including barber hones. He even had his workplace stocking american hone company stones for craftspeople (those are barber hones that are not terribly unlike modern ceramic hones, both in how they're put together and how fine the abrasives are).

I still have my oilstones, not all of them, but a lot of them. I like them, but they are practically inferior to a lot of stuff that costs the same amount of money, and the only part of them that was cheap is the hard/soft/india stones. The fine ones are not cheap these days. You can either acquire them with money or time, or if you're lucky, someone will will you a set of the old ones.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#15

Re: Question about North Bennett

James Watriss

The wonderful thing about NBSS is that they're steeped in tradition.

One of the downfalls of NBSS is that they're steeped in tradition.

When I got there 7 years ago, the school was teaching oil stones, and had a huge steel plate with loose silicone carbide for flattening them. One of the stock projects for teaching fundamentals is making fitted boxes to keep oil stones in. I know a guy who graduated 30 years ago-ish, and the main difference is that his box actually holds both coarse and fine side by side, instead of just one stone. It's an exercise to teach about cutting cross grain for waste removal, and using a router plane for the first time. And all things considered, it's not a bad beginner project, which is probably why they kept it.

Some students had discovered water stones, but the majority used their oil stones. Some of those with L-N planes had a hard time learning to sharpen. But vintage Stanley planes are also much in vogue, as all students are taught how to tune them up and flatten the soles. Vintage laminated steel works well with oil stones, and old Stanley planes work really well after that initial tune up...

I was introduced to Diamond paste while working at Woodcraft. One of my instructors didn't know what it was. I liked it because I had a lot of fancier steels, and water stones made a hell of a mess on the bench.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#16

You mentioned grinding

Bill Tindall

While I can now grind a Stanely plane blade, something that sets the low bar for heat sink, at 3600 rpm and an 80 grit rock, I was once terrified to contemplate such a task. I learned to grind on steel heat treated at 1000 degrees where there was zero risk of altering the hardness by overheating the edge. This advantage of the steels like M2 is under sold. Unfortunately A2 and PMV11 do not have this advantage. It could be that if I was contemplating buying an A2 plane blade that PMV11 would be a better choice, but I think that M2 or something similar would be an even better choice.

I would argue that long plane blade life is most important to the occasional planer. Why so? If you are planing a lot you are set up to sharpen, and expect to do so. Hence, sharpening is something that can be planned for and the need does not arrive unexpected or at an inconvenient time.

My planing is confined to fitting stuff and rarely surface preparation. So I take a stroke or two here and there and then don't plane for a while, and then it is another stroke or two. And then in the middle of some assembly the blade dullness catches up with me and I have to stop and sharpen. It is a most unwelcome interruption and one that would be worth a premium to postpone. Something in the range of 50 to 100% longer life would be considered worth spending money to achieve.

When I am dovetailing a bunch of drawers it is a different situation. I know that even with 3V chisels I will need to refine the edge a bit from time to time during the course of several drawers. So I set up to sharpen in the beginning. I hone a bit before I need to for I can predict a "mean time to failure". Frankly, having to hone a bit more with a carbon steel chisel would not be a big deal in this situation.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#17

Re: Chisels vs. Planes

david weaver

I like plain chisels. They are easier than anything else in the shop to sharpen, so doing that doesn't bug me. They don't have to be taken out of anything or put back in when you've sharpened them, they're just there.

But when I'm dimensioning something, it does irk me if I get 80% of the way done with flattening a panel and I have to take the plane apart to sharpen the iron. It's not a big deal, it's probably 3 minutes of time from stopping to sharpening to putting the plane back together and resetting it, but it is an annoying interruption in the work rhythm.

I've never had the problem with carbon steel grinding that a lot of people experience, and it's pretty rare that I refresh a grind in an iron or chisel that I can't put the tool directly on my palm to cool it as I walk back to the sharpening stones. (I use a medium-hard 46 grit brown al-ox wheel).

The HSS can definitely tolerate a lot more heat, but I don't usually have water in a dip cup, so it presents more of a problem with handling for me, which is usually resolved by spraying water on a diamond stone and laying the iron on it as I open the drawer to get a steel plate or a chromium oxide laced strop out.

But none of it is really the problem that anyone pretends it is. Those two touch on two of the most repeated internet farces:

1) you can't grind carbon steel without ruining it at least a little bit

2) high speed steel takes forever to sharpen

Grinding and sharpening either is certainly a lot easier than it is to build and design nice things.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#18

bill, I still owe you...

david weaver

... a picture of my horse butt razor strop, since I sent you that long-winded email a while ago about how some leather is abrasive enough to remove just a little bit of metal.

My clean horse butt strop had just a twitch of gray on it, enough that it could be seen in pictures. It (the reazor) is always washed and wiped completely clean before going on the horse butt, so the abrasion isn't due to contamination.

It is almost a magical strop on razors, I think I could stretch a razor out 6 months with it, whereas cowhide doesn't get the razor as sharp nor does it have the ability to keep me from running for something to touch up the edge 2 weeks after a fresh honing.

Waste of time for tools, but I thought it interesting that someone had concluded that leather did not abrade anything at all, some types definitely do.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#19

Re: My 2 cents: AMENDED

James Watriss

Re-read the review when I got into the shop this AM, and while the review is still very subjective, it does sound like the new steel is a good step forward. And I noticed that he does very clearly say that he thinks this steel is a big deal. And because I've been wanting ease of sharpening with humble oilstones, I can see why.

I mostly dropped A2 a whole back for other steels that had better edge quality or edge life. Some have been rewarding. (HSS, HC, old laminated HC) Others have long edge life and long sharpening times. (D2, S53)

I still remember not being wowed by his write up. But looking back, I think it's more likely that the roots of my reaction were probably more akin to "ANOTHER plane iron? No thanks..." I simply went overboard on trying other steels.

On that note, maybe it's time for me to trim the fat around the shop some more. I think I have a library card catalog drawer full of irons that I've been meaning to make into wooden planes...

So, keep an eye on the benefit auctions page.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#20

Re: Horse Butt Abrasive? *LINK*

William Duffield

I think it works a lot like the palm of my hand, only a bit more effective. :D


Charging the Horse Butt

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#21

Have you raised horses......

Bill Tindall

They spend a significant amount of time on their back rolling in the dirt including a hoochy koochy of the butt. No doubt this is the source of their enhanced abrasive powers over cows, that don't display this abrasive enhancing behavior. And with that insight I am off for a hike on a rare cool E. TN. day in August.

The rest of the week I will be on the way , at, or on the way back from IWF Atlanta. 11 acres of sawdust producing stuff to marvel at.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#22

And the irony to me is this...

John in NM

I never got into waterstones for the same reason a lot of people fear getting into diamonds for sharpening - perception that they are both expensive and confusing.

I would probably feel that way about diamond grit if I hadn't used it in lapidary work for years already.

So to me, the "exotic sharpening" argument has never held water.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#23

I was wondering about the time thing...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I doubt that I've ever planed anything for a solid hour, except using my lunch box planer.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#24

Re: Horse Butt Abrasive?

david weaver

That leads to a new possible comment "you're not a real craftsman unless you use the horse butt strips while they're still on the horse and it's rolling". (it used to be, "a real craftsman can shave smooth against the grain with nothing more than sandy tree bark")

That to go along with the rest of the goofy commentary that comes along with sharpening, or accusations of this or that depending on what you use to sharpen or what kind of steel you prefer. :b

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#25

Re: Have you raised horses......

david weaver

So the silica appears to come from external sources? :b

I think the strips make fantastic strops, and if a relatively smooth section is had in a strip, really fantastic razor strops.

Holtzapffel didn't say exactly that, but the book does say that soft strops are pretty useless as far as razors are concerned. Almost all of the current hanging strops, at least the ones mere mortals can afford are some sort of cowhide.

I was almost thrown by the horse butt at first, it was so abrasive when it was new it felt like it was covered with tiny sand and it would take a razor that had a nice polish or hazy polish and put lines all over the bevel. I don't believe it is getting much more gray now that it's broken in.