New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

Posts

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#51

Re: Thank you, Bruce. I'm much relieved...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I think a misreading is a good explanation. However, The Schwarz's writing style was not as straightforward as usual. My bet is that he didn't want to come across as a shill for LV's new mystery metal.

Equally confusing for me is that Bill is/was an early proponent for CPM 3V for chisels, and, that being the case why would he be skeptical of a similar product? But that's just me, and I'm not trying to ascribe motivation at all. Well, that and I'm on night shift and Saturday is my first day off in three weeks. I'm a bit punchy.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#52

Re: Thank you, Bruce. I'm much relieved...

John in NM

Bill wasn't skeptical of the metal, but of the review itself. I have to start rotating shifts again in October :(

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#53

Good heavens...

John in NM

One has to wonder why he did not simply clarify here. I can only suppose we are not a polite bunch :D

Oh well, such is the nature of internet forums and discussions.

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#54

As a feed suppliment

John in NM

Food grade DE is used primarily to prevent caking in feed, being inert yet absorptive of moisture. Some add it as a dewormer as well, though I've never seen clinical evidence that it does anything that way. The shape of the diatom husks, and the nature of the silica itself is kind of important when it comes to use as a pesticide, so the "food grade" stuff may not be sharp enough to do any good at expelling pests.

Diatom morphology is a vastly complicated field as there were/are many different varieties - it was as close as I recall paleontology getting to "interesting" though :D

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#55

Re: As a feed suppliment

William Duffield

Well, I learned something new and interesting. I had thought diatom skeletons were made of calcite (like chalk, and Tums, and clam shells and oolite), but now find that they are silicates. This makes them much more abrasive than I had imagined, like bamboo and horsetails, whose subtle defense against being eaten is to wear out the teeth of the chewers (and our saws).

Re: Odd review of Veritas PMV11 plane iron in Pop Wood

#56

Re: Diamonds are expensive

TomD

OK not really. But to the extent that the plates available commercially and from the PM-whatever supplier are expensive. There are cheap alternatives, but they don't necessarily work for a variety of reasons. I think back to when a day off split my two weeks vacation into 1 week and some days, and a lot of people with a day off would not know where to go to get some cast scrap, and in big cities one would burn up a lot of gas getting there, etc... Some of the expedient solutions like old planes may not be pretty enough for some.

Then there is a new useless method of sharpening invented for our use every day. A lot of people who might be serious enough to want to try some new method have been bitten so many times in the past that they will assume diamonds are just another partial solution at best. Some people are very resistant on space in shop reasons. Never stops me, but then I can't find anything.

Then you have the majority who are clearly sharpening challenged, and for whom poor sharpening chops are a major barrier. So anything new is not a thing they want in their sharpening lives.

I am still curious, and don't expect to learn, whether this stuff is seriously where the market is going, or just some cost of maintaining credibility in the tools wars, so that one can occupy the high wear easy sharpening space conceptually, though very few will care in reality. As we have seen with the breakers, stuff can change in an instant, the market has become very mobile and change on direction away from simple tools to gouges, or molding planes, whatever, could quickly change everything.