We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Recently a post was made asking about what people were making. The response was quite a surprise. The diversity and number of wood related projects was amazing and some resulted in extended discussion. The talent hanging out here is tops. Apparently it took the question to kindle the response. As a result some have asked whether such a question should be a regular feature.
1. Should a question of this nature be a regular feature?
2. If yes, what should the question be- "what are you making", "what are you working on", "what have you made", whatever?
3. If yes, how often- monthly?
4. If yes, who will ask the question- I will if there isn't a better choice.
I think for the overall good of the forum, anything that increases people showing things that they are making....is a good thing. You could start by presenting the question monthly....make it more frequent if necessary.
I think it's a great idea. It's a good thread starter for one thing. Bi monthly would be good. If you don't mind doing it you should start it. I don't think it matters how you ask. Change it every time,or not. As long as people know what you are asking.---Jack
I think a monthly question as to what we are working on, or just made is a terrific idea. Pics are always an added attraction, and I have found picresize.com that Ellis recommended recently to be very user friendly and has enabled me to post a couple of pics without any real hassle.
[For those who aren't familiar with the allusion, search YouTube for the Tom Waites song by that name.]
I'm not sure how to guess how often to try to kick start these old geezers (present company excluded, of course). I've noticed they are quite good at puns, so you should find lots of help with catchy titles, if you want to mix it up.
You may have to experiment with the timing. Maybe try to correspond to when in the course of the week or the month the forum is likely to gets the most views. For those statistics, you'd have to ask Ellis.
And you are the one who should ask the question, because everyone has already been conditioned to expect in-depth and pertinent posts from you on interesting subjects.
If at any time you find you can't do it (you're too busy with lambing season or something) ask someone to be a "guest columnist."
Sounds like a great idea...but how about mixing it up now and then? Maybe a look back at favorite projects or a topic where someone could get help with thier future/dream projects? And I agree that anything that generates positive dialogue is a definate asset.
Though I have a great interest in hand tools, it is very rare for me to build with them exclusively. I would suggest posting the thread on the messages board as well as this one. If people will tolerate construction photos, I should have some glacial progress to report every couple weeks
Not only that, but I'm not always building something worthy of posting. For instance, this past week I was on night shift but I managed to replace the rectifier on my 30-year old Goldwing. No woodworking content there. Today I am fixing a bow back chair for our HR gal, but it is certainly not worth repeating.
A look at topics discussed here would reveal that quite a diversity can generate interest. Thankfully this site has never been picky about what is posted.
I'll agree, Zen and Motorcycle Maintenance would really be stretching it.
However, this could be just the vehicle for quick tips, shop fixtures, and other seemingly trivial projects and progress that one would never consider starting a thread of their own.
As an example, I'll follow this with a reply on a shop fixture I knocked out last night that might solve the same problem for someone else (a problem they might not even know they had), or that might lead to a discussion on alternate joinery methods.
Another potential example might be the method you used to fix the chair. Sometimes the fix is obvious, but sometimes not to everyone who is called on to fix a chair, and I suspect we are all asked to fix chairs all too often. Effective techniques are often worth sharing. Usually, fixing chairs is frustrating and not much fun, for a number of reasons. Often, it's because I'd like to find the guy who "fixed" it last time and punch him in the nose for making my job so much more difficult that it needed to be. I need all the help (or at least, moral support) I can get.
Your's is a great idea. I think bi-monthly would be a nice frequency. I love to see works in progress, or works finished.
It just crossed my mind that the Shop Shot section could be useful in stimulating discussion and addressing techniques involving an incredibly diverse range of successes, numbering in the hundreds. Mybe one chosen at random each couple weeks.
My brother often finds old tools out in Silicon Valley and gives them to me as Christmas presents. He's not much of a hand tool user, but his heart is in the right place. Often the tools he sends me are beyond redemption, and not even worth the postage. On my dirty bench is a pile of "planes" and "chisels" he has sent me. Sometimes there is a jewel in the rough. What I found in an anteek store in San Jose that he dragged me into is another story. One of the chisels was worth restoring. It is a 7/8" Greenlee paring chisel, and it now hangs on the rack between my 3/4" and 1" Lie-Nielsens. He found me a miter box that works well, after I had it sharpened and fixed up the handle and made a couple of other minor improvements. The object of this post, however is the bucket-O-rust saw vise he found me. Surprisingly, it also works pretty well. About all I've done to it is knock off some of the rust, lubricate the joints and slip a piece of 1/4" clear flexible tubing into the back jaw to hold the saws when it's open.
It's main problem is that (unlike Joel's, which is brilliantly designed to be screwed to a board and dropped into your shoulder vise) this one was designed to be attached to the top of a picnic table or sawhorse. Whenever I wanted to use it, I had to find a 2x4 to interface between the saw vise and one of my bench vises. And when I put it away, I had to adjust the thumbscrew again to attach it to a shelf bracket where I hang my saws.
The solution to the problem was simple. I built a T-shaped bracket, with an overhang on one end, out of some scrap poplar. The saw vise screws to the cantilevered end of the horizontal component, and the bench vise grips the vertical component while the bottom of the horizontal component is supported on the top of the vise chops.
The saw vise is now more or less permanently attached to the fixture, and the two holes allow it to be hung on two shaker pegs that I drilled and glued into the front of the shelf where I store it. Even though the shop is a kludge, I prefer shaker pegs to 10d nails for hanging stuff.
The joinery used to make the fixture is the second issue. Being lazy, I used two 10x50mm Dominos (loose tenons), because I have the machine, and its setup is relatively easy (compared to most power tool solutions) for one-off joints. I did have one minor problem, and a lesson to teach, but that's for another forum.
There are a few other hand tool methods that come to mind that might even have saved me time. What would you have used?
-- A stopped groove, maybe secured with brads (a la Norm Abram)?
--A through tenon, maybe wedged?
- -A stopped sliding dovetail, maybe tapered?
--A wider top board, so you could move the clamping position to one side, avoiding the need to stop the groove or the dado.
You might be right. I check the sighting, then the "tailed" list, then indulge the neanderthal. 'Bout all the "loading" my attention span can handle. If what folks were doing was an ANOTHER list I'd probably miss it. Then I'd miss a new gag or trick.
I've seen one forum that has so many subsections that some only get posts once a month or less. People tend not to check them because nothing is ever going on. Frequently, people post in the wrong sub-forum simply because there is some overlap and they don't realize there are 20+ more to choose from (really, the place is a bit absurd in it's "organization")
Might be worth considering if the sheer number of "what we're working on" posts becomes so large as to clutter up other topics.
David, I agree. All I want to do is see - or hear - what others are interested in or what they are up to. Preferably forumites would post pictures of their work .... and I do not care whether this is predominantly hand- or machine orientated - I am more interested in the ideas and passion and design - the conception of the work - than how it is ultimately or partially resolved. Handwork is a bonus.
I do not visit any other forums on WoodCentral. I have come to think of the Handtool forum as our little "club", where we come together owing to sharing the spirit of handwork. It is unlikely that there are more than a handful on this forum that do all their work with handtools alone. I certainly use power tools, such as in the preparation of the raw material, and I do not see a need to apologise for this. I see no need for others to feel that their work is less than it is for using non-handwork.
There is a great need to encourage members here to post work. I love WC for the intellectual discussions, but do believe that we miss out on the actual woodwork. The recent thread demonstrated that there is much more happening than most are generally comfortable/confident in posting details about. Most of us here are relative beginners. There is always someone who knows more. The only way that we can convince others to post work is post all manner of work - tools we build (large or small, complex or simple), furniture builds (in part or complete), and plans for critique.
The ones I make aren't much like a stock for a Mauser or Model 70, those are much more labor intensive even if the action is bedded (thus avoiding a lot of hand fitting). Most of mine involve more pattern cutting with a router table, using aluminum patterns - which wouldn't apply to a lot of stocks. The real trick is simply trying to make something by any means available, then realizing what a pain in the neck it is and figuring out an easier method.
If you study the traffic on the Photo forum, you will note that its traffic has steadily, and significantly declined since it was created. The same thing happened with the design forum that people asked for a while back. It has disappeared. It is very difficult for a new forum, especially one whose scope is very narrow, to reach and maintain critical mass. We have to be very careful to not distract our users with management minutiae, so that they forget to read and contribute. I think it is best to let the forum software present new threads and new posts to us whenever we visit the fora we are used to, and leave it to us to select the threads and posts we want to read, based on whatever criteria we prefer, be it title, author, number of responses, whether there are pictures attached, etc.
The most important things are to:
-figure out how to keep peoples' interest, so that they want to contribute;
-figure out how to attract new readers, and encourage them to contribute.
When I look at "competing" forums, several practices annoy me no end:
-too many subfora on too many obscure subjects;
-stickies (mostly useless), that you have to wade through to get to new content;
-The requirement that you register before you can post a message;
-The requirement that you register before you can see any pictures or other linked content;
-requiring that you log in before you can see any pictures or linked content;
-prohibitions against posting references to other fora;
-People who won't give you even their first name, nor even a clue as to where in the world they are located*.
Enough ranting and pontificating, it's time to get back into the shop, make some more sawdust and take some more pictures of stuff I'm working on.
*Everyone knows where the Cohansey is, or at least how to find out, right?