New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Forum question, please take a look

Posts

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#26

No

Warren in Lancaster, PA

No. The two great strengths of this forum are technical discussion of hand tool use and history of hand tool use. These two topics are related and maybe inseparable. There are more than a few cherished responders to this forum who have not posted their work. I think there are other sites that function more as show and tell forums.

If someone has involved the forum in discussions of construction and technique for a certain project, it is appropriate and enjoyable to see the end product on the forum. There is also a Shop Shots column for those who are interested.

On other sites I have seen tool makers post high quality photographs of their current work asking for "feedback". I am thinking feedback means orders. Professionals have enough clout without using the forum to enhance their reputation. It sometimes seems that guys pick a project for its appeal to a forum, or its ability to enhance their status on the forum.

Even on this forum there have been discussions about some technique and one person posts a picture of some of his previous work in order to bolster his arguments. He may be thinking "I showed him!", but this has a way of cutting off discussion. It is hard to respond without putting the guy down. Are you supposed to say "That's a fine photograph, but the woodworking is not that great"?

One last thing. If someone is trying to learn a historical trade in their spare time and without the benefit of a good master, the progress is rather slow. Learning to operate a rip saw takes a lot more time than learning a table saw. Just learning to prepare stock in an efficient manner is a tall order. Such a person might have good insights on technique, but not much to show in projects.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#27

You must be describing the SAPFM Forum

Bill Tindall

I once belonged to this organization. I thought the Forum would be of great use. I wasn't. It took a half hour just to wade through the multitude of Forum subcategories. Over time some went weeks without activity. A post there might never be discovered. I suggested consolidating categories but change was not embraced by the organization. I dropped membership because the organization was not delivering any benefit.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#28

Re: No

Bill Tindall

If the question was asked "what are you working on" and someone responded with a picture of some board that they had skillfully cleaved with a rip saw I would be interested in hearing about the achievement. I might make a mental note that this would be a person to ask a sawing question should the need arise.

Personally, I find the work of others inspirational. If "Kees can do it (I think) I can do it" so I go try it. Many times this path leads me to a new skill.

As far as criticism of a result, that is how one improves. The main factor that has improved my furniture is to see other's furniture. Other's work or criticism establishes a standard that otherwise would not be available.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#29

Re: Forum question, please take a look

Curt Putnam

As usual, I was not clear. The categories I suggested were for Bill to include in the weekly title.

If you do this stuff as a hobby it means that weekly progress can be insignificant from a pictorial standpoint. For example, I'm currently gluing up subpanels, which when flattened, will be glued up into larger panels. Not very exciting in either words or pictures. If we wait for only completed projects the pics will be thinner than if process and technique shots are also included

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#30

Re: Forum question, please take a look

William Duffield

Sure, sometimes a suggested subject can turn "I don't have anything to talk about" into an "Oh yeah! I did accomplish something this week that we might find interesting." I haven't been visiting the chat room on Tuesday evenings (partly because of a configuration problem, which I think I've fixed), but maybe Stephen can comment on how his suggested discussion subjects have influenced the direction of the discussion. If I understand human nature, I'm sure other items have come up that proved to be useful and interesting, while thinking about the announced subject at least served as an initial stimulus. It seems as if I tried moderating the chat a while ago, but didn't feel I was very successful at it.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#31

Yeah, probably

James Watriss

In general, I will support and appreciate anyone who wants to take the time to post/start a WGO (What's Going On?) thread. And I think it's something that's healthy for a forum environment. But I see no need to codify anything.

In general, I like the idea of seeing what people are actually up to, and hearing about how they did it, as long as it's relevant to the topic at hand, namely using hand tools. I don't think adding more structure helps, and I certainly think the notion of a completely separate board for the topic is excessive. Forums have a fair amount of anarchy by nature. It's problematic, but it's easier to live with that than to deal with trying to subdivide and classify discussions.

(egotistical rant)

I think Warren makes some really good points. But I also think that if I read one more abstract, meandering thread, extolling the virtues of (pick a kind of) planes to a new guy, that I'm going to lose my mind. There are only so many times I can re-read the same discussion, and I'd be more in favor of putting up some sort of wiki/ editable FAQ section than another board. I think it's easier to learn, or to expound on a topic when there's an actual context involved, and that it's easier to pay attention. Contextual discussions seem to do more to keep the board engaging than abstract ramblings. For me, it marks the difference between talking about something, and just talking... or talking to parrots.

(/rant)

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#32

Re: You must be describing the SAPFM Forum

William Duffield

Maybe, picking on other forums was not a good idea. :( I should note that different forums have different business models, and restrictions on forums that survive by advertising revenue have to be different than those which are designed to serve the needs of members who pay dues to belong to the organization, or to forums which charge for all access to the unique information they have created or added value to.

Yes, the SAPFM forum can be a bit frustrating at times, but it was not the one I was throwing stones at. With the SAPFM forum, my work-around is to start with the link at the bottom of the page, in the forum Stats box and click on "view the most recent posts on the forum", which is presented in chronological order, and then follow the threads from there. I'll discuss your problems with Micky and Bob the next time I see one of them. Maybe I could suggest general access to the thumbnails that are posted on the forum, but continuing to restrict access to full size images to members. To me, the restrictions they have in place on access to furniture plans, and the member directory, and the P4A database are completely reasonable.

There are other forums with some rules I find much more unreasonable, but harping further about it here won't fix anything, and would probably just make people angry, so I'll drop the subject.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#33

Re: Forum question

roger lance

I belonged to a woodworkers guild for a long time and it was my experience that maybe 10-20% of the members made things and made presentations of what they were making....the rest of the group sat quietly, asked the occasional question, made some comments now and then....I (and others) often wondered if many of the guild members even had shops or were they just content to get out of the house once a month and talk with other guys about woodworking....maybe its just the nature of a group....some show and tell....many like to comment and discuss....whatever, woodworking is a big tent....there are all kinds of people with all kinds of interests and all kinds of approaches to the subject and doing work....for this forum, I believe in the KISS principle....less structure, more presenting of what you are doing....building a piece of furniture or rehabbing a tool for the collection....the more people who are encourage to show what they are doing, the more interesting the forum.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#34

Re: No

William Duffield

Because we have these strengths is no reason to discourage development of other strengths. Striving for a medal in the biathlon is no reason to discount anyone's desire to participate in the pentathlon.

I don't understand how posting a photo (or even a video) discourages further discussion any more than a verbal rebuttal. I think the problem is that some people mistake a discussion which should lead to enlightenment as an argument to be won and lost. That sort of attitude needs to be discouraged, or redirected elsewhere.

I also find "show and tell" posts, like Shop Shots, to be less than useful, either for the poster or the viewers. Maybe someone will write an app that will automatically post an "Ataboy!" or "You go, girl!" in response to every one of those. If I post a photo of my work, whether a tool or an end product, please comment on it, without pulling any punches. It's the only way I'm going to get better. I might be able to respond with reasons I built it the way I did, and I might even be able to provide insights into how I messed it up, so that others here may learn from my mistakes. But it would certainly be better for everyone involved if someone who has more experience than me pointed out a better way to do it that prevented the errors (or the less than optimal or less than elegant choices) I made.

If someone who is building tools for sale asks for "feedback" on a woodworking tool he has built, that's a perfect opportunity for Ellis to ask him to buy some advertising. That keeps the lights on at WoodCentral, and it keeps the lights on in the toolmaker's shop. You can always post high quality photos here, too, but Ellis won't archive them for you. Asking for feedback on a piece of furniture, OTOH, isn't going to help anyone sell that furniture to someone who visits this forum. I don't think that's what we're here for.

Other than these minor points, I agree with you.

Maybe we need to post a caveat: "If you build it, they will come…and take it apart and put it back together for you." If for any reason whatsoever, that is not what someone wants, there should be no perceived stigma whatsoever in deciding not to post completed works or works in progress, or even preliminary designs. If there is anything about anyone's work that they want to keep private, we respect their right and privilege to do so. This is not an AA meeting, or a confessional, or a mystic cult where you are expected to drink the Kool-Aid.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#35

Re: Forum question

William Duffield

I keep hoping that they are hoping for inspiration, and I keep hoping that we are eventually going to be able to give it to them. In the meantime, I keep studying Roy Underhill's most important work.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#36

Actually no, haven't been there in years...

John in NM

Though I've still kept up a SAPFM membership just for the yearly magazine. The forum did always strike me as too slow, so I never participated much.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#37

Yes Yes and Yes

Ron in Kokomo

This site is called Wood Central carrying the idea that maybe it is for woodworkers. The Hand Tools Forum suggests that some guys are doing considerable woodworking with hand tools. What could be more natural than sharing the occasional photo and comments to indicate how we are doing?

By all means run a Whatch Doin. Thread

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#38

Re: Yes Yes and Yes

TomD

even the thread here did not draw out that much. It isn't as though anyone has been stopping one from posting stuff. I think a regular thread could be a good idea, just as we have regular calls for ides of, and tuesday topics, a gentle reminder kind of thing. But I don;t much care for long build alongs since I rarely learn much and don't really feel I can say much that won't sound negative if I was trying to be constructive. so they tend to be conversation stoppers, yet then one finds someone refers to them elsewhere, or spins off a topic,so it just becomes more to read, and often seems to have a commercial intent around here.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#39

Forum philosophy

Bill Tindall

I found Badger Pond (forerunner to WoodCentral) when I was trying to learn more about improving my skills at making more complex furniture. I have stayed with the Forum because participation continues to teach me useful information. (just when I thought there was nothing left along comes Kato, Kawai, Weaver and Kees. It took all four to motivate me to try it, with success)

The very things that you don't like are the things that I value in learning from this Forum. For me detailed "how to posts" are the best part of the Forum. Posts of stuff made or done provide perspective on the relevance of the teacher to my needs and interests. Critique of what is demonstrated again adds relevance for someone wanting to learn, especially if the skills and interests of the critiquer are evident.

Both amateurs and professionals have a valuable role in teaching. If I am looking for the most reliable joint, for example, advice from a professional that has many joints out in the market place, or someone experienced with antiques, will be my most trusted source. As far as how to make the joint, the professional's approach my not be best for a beginner. The professional's approach my involve more skill or experience than an amateur can muster. In this case the technique taught by an amateur may be more suitable, even though it may be more time consuming or involve more equipment or crutches.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#40

Re: Forum philosophy

TomD

"I have stayed with the Forum because participation continues to teach me useful information. (just when I thought there was nothing left along comes Kato, Kawai, Weaver and Kees. It took all four to motivate me to try it, with success)"

That is an interesting example, because there wasn't much new about that source, or anything new about the technique, and in fact people had passed over the same information here, and in print many times. It takes being in a receptive frame of mind, to need the item one finds, for it to stick. So i suppose it is good that there is endless repetition available to all of us, so that we can get the memo eventually.

"The very things that you don't like are the things that I value in learning from this Forum. For me detailed "how to posts" are the best part of the Forum."

Obviously how to posts are the lifeblood here, what I am less sure about is buildalongs. Derek is one of the few who does these, and his presentation is at the level of a national magazine, but I have little interest in the how to part of them because I know how to make stuff, and own completely different tools than he does. So for me, I would rather see specific how two things, and show and tell things separately. Possibly the best I know of this is Velosalon, were each week people post what they have been doing in their shop. There is basically zero commentary in response, which seems a little odd, but it does accelerate the pace of the posting. Also most frame guys are pros of a sort, so it would be rude to say too much.

www.velocipedesalon.com/forum/f15/

" Posts of stuff made or done provide perspective on the relevance of the teacher to my needs and interests. Critique of what is demonstrated again adds relevance for someone wanting to learn, especially if the skills and interests of the critiquer are evident."

I'm not sure I liked that part. I would rather have the idea with as little claptrap as possible. The info on breakers you eventually had to penetrate your prejudice against all things Japanese woodworky to find stuff that had been out there forever. It will take a huge amount of additional work to produce Derek level posts of work completed, when someone may actually have come across something useful whether they have a highboy to prove it to your satisfaction or not. Much of the best info I have come across comes from cross training in other fields. When I know a field has a technique that 10 000 people use, but some expert in woodworking tells me is impossible, like say heat treating with an OA torch, then that says something. In my case, I like diamond sharpening things, but have had poor luck on durability, so it was great to have input from lapidary types. I also find machine shop info interesting, though I am not yet convinced it was accurate in all respects. But none of these crafts have highboys to show

"Both amateurs and professionals have a valuable role in teaching. If I am looking for the most reliable joint, for example, advice from a professional that has many joints out in the market place, or someone experienced with antiques, will be my most trusted source."

I've noticed that, and it seems to lead to a lot of mistakes. I normally assume people around here are telling the truth. If they say that throwing their wood in the sauna gave brilliant results, I would note that. If someone else says their 2 million dollar wood kiln is great, I am not really sure for a variety of reasons why I would care.

" As far as how to make the joint, the professional's approach my not be best for a beginner. The professional's approach my involve more skill or experience than an amateur can muster."

Assuming we are talking apples and apples. Most professionals have less skill than amateurs, I have taught both. The factory is designed to use people with no skill at all. If one is talking about paid hand tool types, then it can be true. Though in the time and with the effort you seem to have expended since Badger Pond went toes up, one could easily have learned several crafts to pro level.

It is not clear to me that what people lack is skill or 50 new ways to do the same thing. They need to learn some fairly simple things well without sidestepping fundamentals at every turn. Pro techniques are fundamentals learned well, in a coherent way. They are within the grasp of virtually anyone, otherwise there would be no way of ensuring apprentices would make the grade.

" In this case the technique taught by an amateur may be more suitable, even though it may be more time consuming or involve more equipment or crutches. "

Mostly that is the need to complete projects one is not ready for, without having learned the basics. That is OK, and I can dream of 10 crutches a minute, I enjoy the creativity of it. The fact of doing ambitions projects without regard to where one is in the craft is why people don't progress. It is an interesting fact that almost anyone can build almost anything with enough crutches and how-to information, but at the end of 10 years, or whatever, they are still dragging themselves along the floor on a piece of plywood with casters on in, when they could have learned to walk.

People will make very rapid progress if they actually try to practice fundamentals, but they don't. In the seven years of an apprenticeship, much of it would have been labour. One could master the basic skills which amount to layout and plans reading, sharpening, and cutting, planing, and sawing to a line in a few weeks or months. Then after that one would not need the crutches, though they are always useful as workarounds for tools one does not have. Of the basic skills the layout and strategy stuff is probably harder for the jigs etc... guy, so that would be a wash.

In the last 10 years or so, a huge number of people have gotten the hand tools bug, and seem to assume they should be able to do it. And in many cases are pursuing it at a far higher level than the pros of the past. Which just goes to show that what people primary lack is the permission to do this stuff. Once it is assumed as routine, nobody will understand how we ever doubted it.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#41

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Forum question, please take a look

#42

Re: Something perplexing

William Duffield

That observation leads to some deep philosophical questions. Is woodworking perhaps the epitome of the crafts? If so, why? And why do all the fine arts departments hold painting in such high esteem? Maybe that's why we find the painting of saw plates so abjectly disgusting.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#43

Re: Something perplexing

John in NM

Well, not to take anything away from woodworking, but I haven't found the same as David. For me at least, I don't think my woodworking would be at a significantly different stage without the other crafts. Come to think of it, I'd probably be further along, having wasted no time on all that other stuff :D

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#44

Why settle?

Bob Hackett

Unless you get outside your comfort zone you`ll never know what you`re truly capable of. Even if you don`t excel at something there is a lot to be said for examining where and why your present limitations exist and how you might surpass them.

I became a metalworker because my father was both hyper critical and a woodworker. I found he knew next to nothing about metal so that`s the direction I went. Later, after I was out on my own, I realized that wood, metal and stone can and do compliment each other. I also realized that an average metalworker usually doesn`t make enough to farm out work to high end woodworkers and stone masons so I either learned to do it myself or did without.

Like David, I saw early on that there was a lot of overlap and what worked in one trade had applications in others. The biggest and brightest light that went on for me was that if I could envision an idea and understand the steps to get from raw material to finished product then, with the skills I learned in other trades, I was no longer limited by the tool and hardware selection offered by others. My work (and many friend`s work) took some big leaps forward once I realized there are effectively no limits if you understand your material, have the skills and can make the tools and hardware yourself.

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#45

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Forum question, please take a look

#46

Re: …the Fallacy

William Duffield

Reductio ad absurdum:

The specialist learns much about a few things, while the generalist learns a little about a lot of things. Either way, you're doomed. You learn more and more about less and less, until you know everything about nothing, or you learn less and less about more and more until you know nothing about everything.

…ducking and running :D

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#47

Re: …the Fallacy

roger lance

Can't argue with that !! :D

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#48

Perhaps I've misunderstood

John in NM

I took the perplexing part to be that some find the practice and knowledge of other crafts to enhance their woodworking - and I took that to mean that skills learned in say, welding, may somehow be applied to woodworking, but that skills learned in woodworking did not likewise enhance other crafts. That is the part I say I've never found to be the case - the sole exception for me is perhaps lessons from lapidary work being applied to sharpening wood tools.

Now if the question concerns mixed media designs, then certainly, steel and stone may be nicely worked in to wood furniture. But in that case, there is no perplexing aspect to it, wood may easily be worked into metal craft as well, substituting a nicely burled piece of walnut for a set stone as just one example. Is a table with a steel structure and just a wood top more a welding project or wood project?

Re: Forum question, please take a look

#49

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Forum question, please take a look

#50

That was clear then...

John in NM

No apology necessary :D

I honestly haven't seen this perplexing situation then, but it could be that the whole thing is so subjective that I may not notice it when it does happen.