New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

more questions and problems chopping mortises

Posts

more questions and problems chopping mortises

#1

more questions and problems chopping mortises

Bill Tindall

1. How do you all hold down the piece to be mortised? This is the arrangement I came up with. Note vertical stick to be used to aid keeping the chisel parallel to the board face.

2. I have chopped mortises before but never with this difficulty. It is difficult to get the chips pried out and the chisel binds when it is cutting deep. Because of the way the frame will be coped I loose the depth of the mortise by the depth of the molding on the inside of the frame, in this case 3/8". So, I felt I needed a 1 3/8" deep mortise to wind up with 1" deep mortise after the molding is cut away for coping. That last 3/8" is a bindy. Even a bevel chisel binds in the bottom. It is like trying to move a nail driven into the wood.

I wanted rift cut for framing what I hope to be a showy panel. In fact the lumber is exact quartered. I am wondering if it is the grain orientation that is giving me fits. I am close to throwing in the towel and heading to friends house with his industrial sized hollow chisel mortiser.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#2

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

CStan

Your problem is that silly pig-sticker mortise chisel. I mean it. I can't stand those things - they are too wide front to back. I had one for a grand total of a week. Had the exact problem you're having. Picked up my Sorbys and problem solved.

Use a proper sash mortising chisel (you are basically mortising in sash-sized workpieces anyway) and all your problems will be solved. You need the kind that are one or so degrees off kilter - a parallelogram shape when viewed head on.

The whole thing looks too overwrought. I use two handscrews - one around the piece being mortised, another to clamp that handscrew to the bench. Your guide piece is too tall IMO but that's more a matter of taste. The one I use is a little wider and less than half as long as the one in your photo.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#3

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

CStan

Your guide piece is too thick as well as too long. Use a piece of 3/4 pine or a nice piece of stable plywood.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#4

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

david weaver

I use only one hold down. If i'm worried about the work piece, I'll put a piece of pine between the work piece and the hold down. If the hold down seems to be loosening, then I just tap it.

My vertical references are on the wall behind my bench if I'm using them. so that they don't slow down the work or get in the way.

If your chisels are square profile, this might be one instance where you'd want to buy a chisel.

Unlike charles, I like pigstickers, a 5/16ths pigsticker is just about my favorite chisel in the world, but it doesn't really matter what the chisel is (bevel edge chisel is also fine) as long as it doesn't bind in the mortise.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#5

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't know if you are copying something specific, Bill. In the 18th century a high percentage of mortises like this are through mortises. The advantages include not having to go deeper than half the width of the stile, being able to push the waste through once everything is loose, and straighter mortises because the far end of the mortise is right on the far side, sort of self correcting.

Your mortises actually look pretty tidy. Getting the waste out in an efficient manner takes some skill and experience. If you are chopping with the bevel facing the excavated area, you might want to turn the chisel around. Also think finesse rather than brute force. If you pound the chisel to the point that it absolutely will not go any deeper, you might be rough on the edge and contribute to the sticking problem.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

just a thought

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

is it possible that the handscrew is putting pressure on the sides of the mortise making the chisel bind?---Jack

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#7

If it were me, and I could make a.....

roger lance

pizza as good as what you did.....I'd be at my friend's with that industrial sized hollow chisel mortiser with a just made pizza and some cold drinks. :D

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#8

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Your set up is different to the picture I posted earlier ...

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/1/md/read/id/457149/sbj/like-this/

In this it is easy enough to loosen the screw and remove the stretcher, and then replace it so as to continue chopping.

Further, the choice of chisel is personal. No doubt any chisel can be made to work. My vote goes to the oval bolstered type, particularly in hard woods, as they have real authority compared with thinner chisels. For contrast, Paul Selers has recently been blogging about using his Blue Marples for chopping mortices.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#9

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

Mark Hennebury

Hollow grind lap and polish the sides of the chisel. Gives minimum surface contact area and if you do a really good job, you will kind of make a four sided chisel with razor sharp edges, so the sides will shave the sidewalls of the mortice.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#10

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

On question 1, I hold that stick down with one clamp. I always set a 9" or 12" engineers square beside and at right angles to the stick being mortised. And look at that maybe once. But what I mostly do is what one does in sawing: look with both eyes so that you have a stereo view of the whole scene spreading away from the point of action, and visually equalize the angles on either side of the vertical chisel--the angles that the chisel makes with the top edge of the stick as it stretches out on the far side of the chisel. By looking at the scene as a whole, you can detect very fine differences in angle on either side of the chisel. Warren's advice of keeping some distance and staying in line with the work, helps tremendously with seeing the whole picture, so you can visually equalize angles. In your case, I would dispense with the vertical piece of wood, and just use the depth gauge stuck in the far mortise--that is a highly useful reference with no parallax error. But still I prefer visually equalizing the angles on either side of the chisel.

Bottom of the mortise....I think what you've got is not a problem with grain, but rather you're in the business of overcoming a mismatch between the chisel geometry and the mortise geometry. If the stick you're mortising is 3/4" or so, then the mortise length appears to be roughly 1-1/2" (by 1-3/8" deep), and the chisel body looks to be 3/4" deep as well. Particularly as the hole gets as deep as it is long, the aspect ratio is turning against you quickly, and there's not much room to maneuver a chisel which is using up half the length of the mortise when it's held vertical, and more than that if angled even a little. Not much room to maneuver for cutting, and even less for excavating waste.

You've said the chisel is getting stuck like a nail in the bottom 3/8". That can only be because there is no place for the waste to go. Seems like the rate-limiting step in every mortise is how long it takes to make a place for the waste. That's why I prefer making a deep V with the first few licks. So down to cases, for that bottom 3/8", take your chisel and cut a modified V, sinking it down say a 1/2" for good measure. The chisel body is so deep, I think I would do this near one end (rather than in the middle), with the bevel facing inward on the first vertical strike, and thereafter with the chisel back facing the starter hole you're cutting, both to complete the asymmetric 'V', and then to walk the chisel 1/8" at a lick away from the V, slicing off an 1/8" of end-grain down to the bottom of the hole, and levering it free as you go (it'll bust loose as you lever). I suggest doing this with the chisel face in the lead as you lever, hence you want the chisel face looking toward the hole you've cut, so that as you lever you've got the chisel face in the lead shearing the path. [There is a 5 degree relief on each side of the chisel, so if the bevel side is in the lead as you lever, then the bevel side may want to trap and wedge some waste against the mortise sides, rather than shearing the sides clean. You'll of course experiment to see if this is the case--maybe it won't. But using the face (back) for shearing the sides as you lever is good mojo.]

Well, I'm doing guesswork and talking beyond what I know--because you're the guy with the chisel. No question you'll figure out better than I can how to dig out the rest of the hole, but what I'm really trying to say is to get that first divot dug out immediately--after that you're just slicing end grain and breaking it off into the hole you've made. If you excavate a bit deeper than 1-3/8", you'll save yourself having to screw around trying to scrape the bottom and dulling a tool doing it.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#11

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

CStanford

The problem with the 'pig sticker' chisel, in this context, is that it is nearly as wide (front to back) as your mortise is long. This IS a job for a sash mortise chisel whose geometry is designed to cut relatively short mortises such as the ones you are cutting. The pig sticker style has been hawked as the be all and end all, one tool for every mortise, the 'correct' chisel, the 'one you can wail on,' all of which are total absurdities. This sort of thing is rarely true with regard to any tool and it certainly is not true here.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#12

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

CStanford

... if you have a problem with turbulent grain another problem with these chisels, given they are almost as long as the mortise you're trying to cut, is that you're caught in a do-loop - you don't have enough wriggle room to re-register the chisel to come at the bad grain from a slightly different direction.

I think your immediate fix would be to bore out the rest with a brace or just use a firmer to finish up. I have straight sided firmers which are good for a situation like this but you can get it done with a bevel edged chisel if that's all you have.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#13

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

Sgian Dubh

Bill, as others have alluded to, I think that big lump of a chisel is too big for those small mortices you're cutting. For something as small as those mortices I'd be more than happy to put the piece of wood in the vise, or clamp it down on the top of the bench perhaps with a holdfast or an F/G/C cramp, and putter away at it with even a bevel edged chisel. Having said that, a firmer chisel would be better, and better again might be something like a sash mortice chisel. And, yes I know, some people may suck hard on their cheeks with the idea of abusing a vise by using it to hold wood whilst morticing, but I admit I've never been a purist woodworker.

I think that big pig sticker thing is over egging the pudding-- I've always thought they're better suited to digging the garden in the autumn than being used for chopping mortises in lighter examples of furniture, ie the sort of chests and things I'm aware that you build. I think those pig sticker things are useful if you're doing large stuff, like traditional green architectural woodwork, barns, church work, etc when big pieces of green oak and so on make up the framework. (Having said that, Mafell chain mortisers are even more efficient for knocking out 5"- 6" deep mortices, but that's for another forum, ha, ha.)


As to guides, eg set squares and bits of wood set up perpendicular to the edge being morticed, I've never found them much use really as you end up trying to watch too many 'markers' and can't really use any of them effectively. I just watch the long edges of the chisel and see how they relate to the edge of the wood being morticed. It seems to work well enough for me, but may not suit everyone.

I suppose there's one technique I use for morticing that may be useful to you. I start the job by holding the flat side of the blade near the tip with my thumb-- 1/2" - 3/4" up from the tip. The index and middle finger of the same hand go around to the back side-- the ground and sharpened bevelled side. This way the flat side of the blade faces me. I rest the middle finger of the chisel holding hand on the wood as a means of pivoting the blade tip to the precise position where it's needed and then whack the chisel handle with the mallet. I just keep sliding my middle finger along the wood, in the same direction as the long orientation of the mortice, and pivoting the chisel tip in and out and whacking until I've created a suitable hole. Once I've got a decent sized mortice started I can change my grip to grasping the handle of the chisel and using the existing hole to guide it and belt away and lift waste out as I go. I don't know if the technique I've described will be useful to you or not, but it might. Slainte.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#14

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

joel moskowitz

Your major issue is that unless your chisel has a trapezoidal section it will ket stuck in something that deep. another problem that has been pointed out that te clamp is squeezing the wood and making your clearance problems worse. I do similar size mortises with mortise chisels all the time. (it's about the size of my demo mortises). Not a big deal.

As for the folks who prefer sash mortise chisels their best use is for shallow mortises for windows - they are not usually trapezoidal and they can get stuck. Especially in harder wood. In the US English Mortise chisels were imported solely for the use of cabinetmakers, actually the very few cabinetmakers who didn't have mortising machines. After about 1860 the overwhelming percentage of American furniture was made in factories or powered shops and they used mortising machines.

In the UK mortise chisels were sold in 16ths of an inch increments from 1/8" - 5/8" for use in furniture making and door making. Larger sizes were made until about 1840ish - construction styles changed and various mortising aids were invented.

The Quality of Mortise chisels dropped in the England after about 1890 and by WW2 only a few sizes were even listed in catalogs. since you could not buy English mortise chisels new schools mostly used sash mortise chisels and a generation of training was lost. Ray Iles started up production in 2004? but we are still playing catchup.

In Europe the Oval Bolstered Mortise chisel never took off and crafts used either imported English tools or more likely what we call Heavy Duty Sash Mortise chisels. These chisels are supposed to be trapezoidal, but the handles are huge by comparison. They have always felt crude in my hands and I have never owned any or used them seriously but obviously in Europe and American cities with large Continental European populations they were popular.

In Japan they use what we would call a sash mortise chisel, but it's rather small. Since they use them primarily for screens and other small shallow work on soft wood they are shorter, sharper, but easily damaged in American style mortising.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#15

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

CStan

Be all that as it may (I think some of what passes for tends to obfuscate and frustrate rather than illuminate, perhaps since it often seems to flow through filters I sense are not unbiased), I'll never be convinced that using a mortise chisel pretty much as wide from front to back as the length of the mortise you're trying to chop represents correct tooling for the job at hand. Logic tells me this as well as experience with both kinds of chisels. I don't have any doubt that one can contort a workaround, but that's all it really is.

Before the pigstickers became available new, it's amazing how convinced new tool dealers were that the good 'ole "sash" mortice chisels, the only ones in current manufacture and being offered new at the time, were the 'correct' chisel for basically all furniture mortises. Now, it appears, the pendulum may have swung too far the other way.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#16

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

CStan

I've never been able to reconcile the length of older 'sash' morticing chisels with the assertion that they were for shallow mortises only (I can buy it for Japanese chisels, they're shorter). And beyond that, I don't know, for sure, if they were always called 'sash' chisels by their contemporaneous users. This could simply be another of the many examples in all endeavors where a generic term comes to stand for all sorts of thing of the general class. For instance, in Memphis, where I live, most every soft drink in a can is called a Coke. Orange Coke, Grape Coke and on an on. It's not as bad as it once was, but in the 1960s growing up it was a universal phenomenon in the entire South. Mama, I want a grape Coke. Nobody called it Nehi, even though it was clearly printed on every bottle.

I tend to think this happened to 'sash' mortise chisels and we take the term far too literally now and especially after pig-stickers were reintroduced as a new offering. You know, quite frankly, if I were a tool maker ten or so years ago I wouldn't have come out with another me-too 'sash' chisel offering either (Sorby, et al. had it covered). I would have looked for something not currently available on the market. I'm not saying this was all a bad thing, but let's be honest.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#17

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

joel moskowitz

The mortise in question is pretty long and pretty deep. the one in the picture several inches in one case. the OP is using home made chisels where the geometry isn't correct. Real mortise chisels might be 3/4" in thickness at the bolster but are only 1/4" or 3/8" thick at the cutting edge which tapers in the primary bevel at 20 degrees or so until the secondary bevel so that they aren't thick and cumbersome at all at the tip. A 1" long mortise 1" deep is a snap to chop so is a 1/2" x 1/2 or 3/4". A deep 1/8" mortise is also pretty easy.

A lot of the problem here is that in pursuit of ultra long lasting cutting edges the OP sacrificed the rest of the geometry that makes the chisel work.

We are the only seller of traditional English Mortise chisels in the US. I have always thought in the days when that was all that was there a poor compromise. I put together my set of mortise chisels during trips to the UK in the early 90's.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#18

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

joel moskowitz

Smith's key only lists "mortise Chisels"

Sash mortise chisels were not invented until after the tanged/ ferruled chisel became popular in the 1840-50's. Salaman lists them as " a lighter blade" 8-9" long and 1/8-3/8" wide. used by joiners and cabinet makers for light mortising.

mortise chisels he lists as from 1/4-1" and used by carpenters and joiners for general and heavy mortising. Of course he's wrong in this as 1/8" mortise chisels are pretty common. and sizes bigger than 1/2 or 5/8" aren't used in furniture making at all but are the most common sizes found today. (I happen to have an unused, unhandled 3/4" mortise chisel from way back just for fun. Can't imagine ever having a need for it). a 1/4" or 5/6" mortise chisel is common as dirt in the UK and those sizes are on the small size even for doors.

Retail catalogs have a tendency to garble terminology. Registered chisels for example are now routinely sold under the invented name of "registered mortise chisels" but if you look at the manufactures catalogs you see - Mortise chisel, sash mortise chisel, H.D. Sash Mortise Chisel, Registered chisel, and so on.

Needless to repeat but just about everything can be made to work, it's a question of speed, but the OP problem is that his chisel isn't really either a Mortise chisel or a Sash mortise chisel and his problem isn't about which tool is better or even more appropriate, it's about the geometry of the tool he has.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#19

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

Bill Tindall

The binding continues to be a problem. I can just drive the chisel in the already made mortise and as soon as I get in an inch or so it grabs the chisel. A beveled chisel seems to grab as much as the pig sticker. Given that I can man handle the pig sticker to lever it out I abandoned the bevel chisel which in 5/16' is more apt to bend our break. It is like the wood is springy and gives just enough to "shrink" back on the chisel. Because it is grabby just a hold down was insufficient to resist the struggles with the chisel.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#20

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

Bill Tindall

I am assembling a frame for a framed and panel side to a Chester County chest of drawers. The original has a flat side but I am going to frame and panel my sides. I like the look. I have some nice quartered lumber for the frame and a nice cut to become the raised panels- not to showy, but a nice pattern.

The panel rails are fairly wide because the top and bottom molding covers some. It is one of those situations that one mortise is too long and two result in two short mortises.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#21

Re: just a thought

Bill Tindall

no, it is well away from the issue, but that is exactly like what it feels like.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#22

a compelling thought

Bill Tindall

And that is exactly what I would be doing were I not stubborn and intent on defeating this obstacle.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#23

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

Bill Tindall

My pig sticker will shave sides. In fact I need to be very careful with the prying part so as to not widen the mortise. It is not hollow but it is tapered a bit and the leading edges are sharp.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#24

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

Bill Tindall

Without ever thinking about it much I seemed to have wound up with the same chisel holding as you recommended. It helps me keep the chisel tip precisely positioned against the scribe line.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#25

All assumptions incorrrect

Bill Tindall

1. The chisel is trapezoidal . I can see relief on each side of the chisel when it is buried to full depth. It is not the sides that are binding but the tip and even the tip of a bevel chisel seizes in these mortise bottoms.

2. Now how could anyone chop a mortise back where the clamp is located? The piece of wood is a cut off from stock the real stiles came from and I am using it as a practice piece. I have mortises all over it, of this and that length, but the chopping is going on on the closer accessible end well away from any clamp.

3. The steel for this chisel was chosen for toughness, not abrasion resistance. There is no chance of snapping a tip off for this steel will not fracture even at a Rc60 hardness.

4.If the sides were binding, or if the chisel had shown a tendency to bind other times I have used it your point of it being too deep could have merit. But, the sides have clearance and I have not experienced the grabbyness deep in the mortise that I am seeing this occasion.