New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

more questions and problems chopping mortises

Posts

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#51

Re: Traditional chisels

CStan

Don't get lost. The fact that there are a lot of them around and at what appears to be close to full design length might be indicative of something rather different than what you are asserting.

There are a lot of Stanley 55s around with full length cutters too.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#52

Re: Traditional chisels

david weaver

There's quite few that are short, too. There are a lot of long and short chisels of all kinds.

But the fact that most heavy chisels are close to full length, even if they are sash mortisers or firmers, may suggest that they aren't generally abused in use.

I've got so many, I'll never go through mine, especially given that I usually pull a chisel across an 8000 grit waterstone 4 or 5 times after each mortise and do nothing else. It'll take eons to work through a chisel in its length that way. presumably the users of those chisels before the days of belt sanders and power grinders, were looking for ways to prolong the lives of their chisels, especially when one or two of them would've been a day's pay.

I just don't believe they weren't used on cabinet work. But it doesn't really matter what was used for what, like everything else, if I can use it with good effect, then why should I convince myself I can't? I keep my small mortisers to make tools, and my square sided sash mortisers...well, I keep them for no good reason. I should get rid of them.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#53

Re: Traditional chisels

CStan

I simply don't care for them. When I look at one vs. the mortise I need to *usually* chop, they simply don't look like the appropriate tool. Everything about a sash mortiser feels right for the mortises I chop - the scale of the handle, steel, the whole bit.

I can't figure out what I'm supposed to do with all that handle and all that steel for a quarter inch wide mortise.

As Richard Jones said - it does seem like over-egging the pudding. Really probably should have left it there. I've said nothing that explains it any better.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#54

Dark Ages

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you walked into any ironmonger in England up until WW2 and asked for a Mortise Chisel you would be handed a large, oval handled tool.

Joel, you talk about the late 19th century and early 20th century like some kind of golden age of hand tools. I think of this period as the Dark Ages for hand tools. Mortising machines surfaced around 1800 and were continuously improved during the 19th and 20th centuries. I really wonder just who was using mortise chisels in the early 20th century. I would be much more interested in a mortise chisel from 1785 than 1935. Today we read catalog descriptions of mortise chisels like withstand abuse or vigorous mallet blows, ultimate bashing, heavy duty use, et c. To me this does not sound like cabinetmaking.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#55

Grain direction

wilbur

Hi Bill,

First thing, I usually just use a single clamp or holdfast to hold a workpiece in which I'm chopping a mortise. For checking how square the ends are, I'll use a small adjustable square. For whatever reason, I'm pretty good about keeping my mortise chisel vertical. It's probably just practice.

After reading through the things you've ruled out as possible problems (chisel geometry, etc.), my bet is that it's the particular piece of wood that you have. If you look at the Peter Follansbee or Paul Sellers videos on mortising ( http://youtu.be/N1bo6NVYCc0 and http://youtu.be/q_NXq7_TILA , respectively) that were recently posted on YouTube, you'll see that in both demos, the grain on the side facing the camera is straight, as if the boards were rift or quartersawn on that face. It's a little hard to tell from your photo, but from your description and what I can see in the photo, it looks like your problem board has its grain oriented in the opposite direction: with the face grain on the side, and the mortise being chopped in the quartersawn face.

The reason this is important is that when mortising, the chips will easily fail along the grain lines as you chop and "pry". (I use "pry" in quotes because I find that if things are going well, I do very little prying when chopping my mortises.) In the case of both of the above videos, the chips break up quite easily along the straight grain lines. If the grain is oriented the other way, you may have a harder time getting the chips to break apart in the same way, and instead of getting out of the way, they just get stuck in place. In that case, the chances go up of your chisel binding.

The picture I included hopefully shows this in a manner more clear than my description.

I have two ways of dealing with this when it happens to me. First, I'll stop and resharpen the chisel. I'm not sure exactly why this works, but I think that a cleaner cut will jam the chips down less, which will decrease the chance of the chips binding. The second is to take a thinner chip when chopping. Usually I'll move along the mortise an 1/8" at a time. If I go for a narrower chop, that often takes care of the issue.

I also keep a narrower chisel on hand to clear chips when they really get piled up, much like what Paul Sellers does in his video. It's actually a Japanese chisel designed to clear chips from relatively deep and narrow mortises, but the principle of the chisel being narrower than the mortise I'm chopping is the same.


Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#56

Re: Dark Ages

joel moskowitz

Was I not clear? If you walked into any hardware store in England from about 1670 to 1945 and asked for a mortise chisel you would have been handed a English Oval Bolstered Mortise chisel. (probably earlier than about 1670 but I can't think of a reference at the moment)

Yes those big mortise chisels in the Seaton chest are after 1785 but not much changed in 20 years.

I am sorry you think of the later 19th century as a dark age. Some of the work done with those crappy tools was fantastic.

Who was using mortise chisels in England in 1935? just about everyone who was a professional bespoke/ little meister cabinetmaker. Unlike the US shop machinery was nearly non-existent and we have accounts as late as the 1930's of professional cabinetmakers bringing their wood to mill to width and plane at the local lumberyard as they didn't have machines like we did here.

Some shops like the Barnsleys were pretty late to mechanize.

"ultimate bashing, heavy duty use, et c. To me this does not sound like cabinetmaking. "

It is if you are trying to make a living at it. When you get paid piecework at set wages (or less) you learn to work fast. Mayhews interviews with cabinetmakers in the mid-19th century include the cost of replacing tools as they wore out. If you look at production figures and wage and time charts for the 19th century you can see that for furniture, unless a factory is employed with specialized machinery doing many multiples, production times with machines are no faster than production times totally by hand (with the exception of rough sawing wood and milling). ( check the numbers don't believe me ). And the way it was done is by specialization, repetition and learning how to push your equipment.

The equipment you describe for mortising (especially the real early machines) was never used by skilled labor, but by unskilled and semi skilled workers doing simple repetitive jobs.

To put in another way, if one person can chop a mortise in 1 minute and the other person takes 5 minutes, the latter person is working at a considerably lower wage.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#57

you are right about the wood

Bill Tindall

When I stopped practicing on the recalcitrant test piece and got onto mortising the actual stiles they mortised uneventfully. There was something about the test piece that made it act like the mortise sides were springing back on the cut. It may be that something about the grain was not allowing the sides of the mortise to be scraped effectively by the sharp chisel edges. It really was like the tubes you stick your fingers in and then can't pull them back out. I could put the chisel into the bottom of the mortise by hand pressure and then it took two hands and wiggling to get it out again.

While slower, the hand mortises have much smoother walls than when I use a hollow chisel mortiser, a tool that is not trivial to get just right. I will be fitting the double tenons today and molding and coping the joinery. Then its on to my favorite part of wood working, sifting through the inventory to find something just right for the panels.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#58

Re: Dark Ages

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Heavy oval bolster mortise chisels since 1670? Here are Felibien 1676, moxon 1703, Diderot 1769, Nicholson, 1812. I don't see them as being as heavy as 20th or 21st century pigstickers.


"ultimate bashing, heavy duty use, et c. To me this does not sound like cabinetmaking. "

It is if you are trying to make a living at it. When you get paid piecework at set wages (or less) you learn to work fast. Mayhews interviews with cabinetmakers in the mid-19th century include the cost of replacing tools as they wore out.

A few years ago you suggested on this forum that in 1811 a London cabinetmaker could make a small drawer in two hours, but that it might take today's woodworker 8 hours to do by hand. I then made a drawer from rough lumber, glued and sides flushed up in 1 hour 57 minutes. It is faster in batches. Perhaps I should be the one telling about working fast. Finesse is much more helpful than bashing.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#59

Re: Dark Ages

Joel Moskowitz

You are joking of course. Just by scaling up from the handle you can see they are all very very heavy. THe ones in the picture are most probably for timberframes (as Moxon writes in the text) so they would be more square of section than the narrower ones.