Grain direction
wilbur
Hi Bill,
First thing, I usually just use a single clamp or holdfast to hold a workpiece in which I'm chopping a mortise. For checking how square the ends are, I'll use a small adjustable square. For whatever reason, I'm pretty good about keeping my mortise chisel vertical. It's probably just practice.
After reading through the things you've ruled out as possible problems (chisel geometry, etc.), my bet is that it's the particular piece of wood that you have. If you look at the Peter Follansbee or Paul Sellers videos on mortising ( http://youtu.be/N1bo6NVYCc0 and http://youtu.be/q_NXq7_TILA , respectively) that were recently posted on YouTube, you'll see that in both demos, the grain on the side facing the camera is straight, as if the boards were rift or quartersawn on that face. It's a little hard to tell from your photo, but from your description and what I can see in the photo, it looks like your problem board has its grain oriented in the opposite direction: with the face grain on the side, and the mortise being chopped in the quartersawn face.
The reason this is important is that when mortising, the chips will easily fail along the grain lines as you chop and "pry". (I use "pry" in quotes because I find that if things are going well, I do very little prying when chopping my mortises.) In the case of both of the above videos, the chips break up quite easily along the straight grain lines. If the grain is oriented the other way, you may have a harder time getting the chips to break apart in the same way, and instead of getting out of the way, they just get stuck in place. In that case, the chances go up of your chisel binding.
The picture I included hopefully shows this in a manner more clear than my description.
I have two ways of dealing with this when it happens to me. First, I'll stop and resharpen the chisel. I'm not sure exactly why this works, but I think that a cleaner cut will jam the chips down less, which will decrease the chance of the chips binding. The second is to take a thinner chip when chopping. Usually I'll move along the mortise an 1/8" at a time. If I go for a narrower chop, that often takes care of the issue.
I also keep a narrower chisel on hand to clear chips when they really get piled up, much like what Paul Sellers does in his video. It's actually a Japanese chisel designed to clear chips from relatively deep and narrow mortises, but the principle of the chisel being narrower than the mortise I'm chopping is the same.
