Re: Traditional chisels
CStan
George Ellis in Modern Practical Joinery (joinery in the British sense) in his comments on a line drawing of what we call the 'pig sticker' says as follows:
"The Mortise Chisel, figure 5, is made abnormally thick to prevent bending when levering out the core of mortises. As its name implies, it is solely used for producing mortises Widths from 1/8 in. to 5/8 in., advancing by 1/8 in."
"The Sash Chisel, figure 6, is a lighter form of same with a nearly parallel stem, used chiefly for the narrow mortises required in sash bars."
My only comment would be that I've certainly never come close, anywhere close, to bending or breaking a sash mortise chisel in any size mortise I've ever cut with them. One would have to leave a solid quarter inch uncut at the ends to lever against to get that sort of force going. I just don't see this as good technique. Might be quick, but quick is not always good.
I still like the 'sash' style the best which may be solely due to me not having enough gumption to work in a way that would require all of the extra thickness and stoutness provided by a pig sticker. I just don't pound or lever the chisel that hard and don't otherwise see any advantage to the extra width of these chisels.
I wonder if it's a point worth noting that as hand methods gave way to machines in England it appears that the sash chisel was the only one to survive - to remain in continuous production. That seems important and seems to be a commentary, at least, on what remained in demand by hand workers. Or, am I honking up the history?