New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

more questions and problems chopping mortises

Posts

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#26

Re: All assumptions incorrrect

joel moskowitz

Wow - oh for four. Then I am perplexed.

Chop straight down in any wood the chisel will get stuck (always - it's the goal). (working for the end of the chisel away from you forward) Then pulling back both breaks the waste and because of the trapezoid loosens the chisel against the sides - push forward and out to clear the chips and pull the chisels out. Repeat . Never has a chisel been seriously stuck for me. So I have no idea what's happening in your case now. (although I would grind them with a longer primary bevel )

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#27

Re: All assumptions incorrrect

CStan

It's probably a little burl of grain, an aborted knot, or some other turbulence that's causing this (along generally with the chisel which I'm on record as not liking). Your problem is that you can't work around that section, come at it from a different angle, perhaps because the size of the chisel (now that you are deep in the mortise) is preventing it. The chisel is too crowded in the mortise and not leaving you many options with regard to repositioning it.

If you have a sash mortise chisel see if you can work around this. If not, just try a regular bench firmer - bevel edge or otherwise. My guess is t

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#28

Traditional chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We are the only seller of traditional English Mortise chisels in the US

Your chisels appear to be several times as thick as the mortise chisels in the Seaton chest. Do you know of anyone who sells chisels like those bought by Joseph Seaton? Your firmer chisels are likewise several times as thick as those in the Seaton chest. Where can we get the kind of chisels the Seatons used?

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#29

Re: Traditional chisels

CStan

Why would you want them? They have not been deemed authentic by a 21st century toolmaker. ;-)

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#30

Re: Traditional chisels

joel moskowitz

On the Mortise chisels I think ours are about the same as the Seaton Chest. I have a Law mortise chisel (same maker as Seaton) and it's a beefy mother.

On Beveled edge the whole point of beveled edged chisels was to allow a thicker body with thin edges. So naturally our drop forged chisel are heavier than the Seatons ( the design is about 70 years later). We do stock a roundback "dovetail" chisel which is hand forged, short and thin. It's also a little flexible and because it's hand forged you get the edge retention of a lot longer than a drop forged chisels - approaching the best of the Japanese chisels). They are my favorite of the chisels we stock and what I actually use. But the roundback style is essentially a downmarket version of hand grinding from before bevels were machine ground. It takes real skill to hand grind the side bevels of a bevel edge chisel and because the hand forging is slightly irregular they could not be machine ground and Ashley Iles just doen't have enough hand grinders free to do it.

Barry Iles and I have discussed making actual 18th century style chisels, I know there is a market and I am hoping the chisels will see the light. It's harder than you think.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#31

Something whacko with the wood

Bill Tindall

I set up a cherry piece and had no problem with excessive bindiness in the size mortises I need. I think this piece of walnut wood is related to what Chinese finger traps are made from. I can just push the chisel into a finished mortise and it takes two hands and much effort to pull it back out again.

The chisel penetrates fine, chips break free fine, I can lever the chisel easily, but the chisel, even a Two Cherries bevel chisel, just locks up in the bottom of the mortise. Also, it takes some force to get the broken-free chips out .

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#32

Re: Something whacko with the wood

joel moskowitz

I guess I have been lucky never to run across some wood like that (and I use walnut for almost everything I have ever built).

Of course whatever extra labor you needed to exert to get the chisel out of the joint, think of all the money you will save on glue.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#33

Re: Traditional chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

On the Mortise chisels I think ours are about the same as the Seaton Chest.

I can't see how you might think this. You told Bill that "real mortise chisels" might be 3/4 thick at the bolster, but five of the eight Seaton mortise chisels have a maximum thickness of 1/4 or less. Here are the measurements that Peter Ross provides for the eight Law mortise chisels.

1. Width .135 Maximum thickness .115

2. Width .195 Maximum thickness .165

3. Width .215 Maximum thickness .175

4. Width .254 Maximum thickness .200

5. Width .285 Maximum thickness .250

6. Width .342 Maximum thickness .305

7. Width .400 Maximum thickness .345

8, Width .485 Maximum thickness .430

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#34

Re: Traditional chisels

joel moskowitz

The measurements you quote are the width at the cutting edge vs the width at the back. (which is why they vary) Showing the trapaziod. For the depth or thickness of the chisel they only show one sample chisel and they don't specify where on the chisel the section was taken - although you can infer it from the middle of the chisel. the 5/16" chisel ? ( .35) is 9/16:" thick about halfway up the shaft.

My own Law mortise chisel - which I have in my hand is 9/16 " size and at the top of the bevel a good 5" from the bolster, the chisel is 3/4" thick and tapers to 15/16" at the bolster.

the big difference between early 19th century mortise chisels and late 19th century mortise chisels (aside from fitted handles) is that the earlier style - and you can see it in the SEaton dimensions the cutting edge narrows as you go up the shaft to the bolster. That makes the chisel even easier to use but near impossible to make by machine (this is in addition to the basic trapazoiald cross section). This style of chisel also gets slightly smaller as the chisel is ground.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#35

Re: Traditional chisels

joel moskowitz

While we are on the subject. (I happen to have my Law chisel in my lap as I write and It's possible that it's never been used. The handle wasn't professionally put on, but that would be common as lots of chisels were sold unhandled and it might not be a replacement.)

The Sheffield Key lists three different qualities of Mortise chisel. Mortice Chisels, Best Joiner's ditto, and Best Cabinet ditto. I don't think anyone has a clear idea of the differences and if they were just length or finish. Later catalogs also list the different grades but there is no clear explanation of the difference except maybe length.

The Key also lists socket mortices chisels and underneath that Cast Steel Joiner's best but again there is no clear idea of the differences.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#36

Re: Traditional chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I'm sorry I misquoted the measurements, but I still feel that the Seaton chisels are considerably lighter than what you quote. The largest chisel is 11/16 at the bolster and the thicknesses of the chisels diminish as widths decrease. The smaller chisels are nowhere near the 3/4 thick you talk about

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#37

Re: Traditional chisels

joel moskowitz

I am not sure where you got your "The largest chisel is 11/16 at the bolster" I don't see it in the book. Can you point me in that directio.

The dimensions that Ray used for his chisels all come from historic models with small changes because of manufacturing.

Narrow sized chisels are slightly smaller all around but they still are pretty thick.

On the other extreme my 1/8" mortice chisel - (I can't read the logo - or rather I can't find it in any reference I own and it's partially obscured ) is pretty early also. 9/16" this at about the center of the shank and a solid 3/8" or so where the bevel begins and 5/8" at the bolster. This is of course the tiniest size (but very very useful) and all the other sizes are bigger. These are all pretty big thick chisels. And that's what gives them their strength.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#38

Re: Traditional chisels

david weaver

If they were wrought iron, how could they have been much thinner without the threat of a workman bending them?

I am not that interested in what the right answer is in this case, but I do wonder if the seaton chest had such thin mortise chisels, why aren't there several examples of such things around?

There are examples of chisels from not long after around, and all I've seen have been pretty heavy just below the bolster.

I've never had a great preference for one type of chisels over another, but I have several of the RI chisels, as well as some sash mortise chisels, and a set of miyanaga japanese mortise chisels. I like the RI chisels a lot, even in smaller mortises. I do like the miyanaga chisels, too, but prefer them for very small work like cutting the mortise in a saw handle - which as all other mortises, I could do with anything.

I don't see a great need for 18th century exact mortise chisels with as much as is on the market now. Someone who is seriously strapped for cash could just buy the narex mortise chisels for a price that makes it senseless to even think about making them.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#39

Re: Traditional chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The 11/16 measurement is on page 57. I think that mid 18th century mortise chisels are lighter yet. My experience is that for deep mortises a thick chisel is more work, because it clogs up the exit. A 1 inch deep mortise might make a nice demo, but most 18th century mortises are considerably deeper. Bill Tindall's mortises ought to be a lot deeper than one inch.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#40

Re: Traditional chisels

joel moskowitz

thanks - it's pretty consistent with the smaller sizes - and 11/16 is pretty hefty too. These tools are all considerably thicker than wider. Size for size they are slightly lighter than mid-19th century mortise chisels but I don't know if that is a given or just a function of the particular set and grade of the set in the Seaton Chest. a 1" deep mortise does make a good demo - but going deeper is not a big deal. I think you are used to the tool you are used to, they work well for you. I was taught differently and I can make my tools work well for me. Neither version, Modern or Seaton mortise chisel is as light duty as your average sash mortise chisel, and neither has a giant handle like the European HD sash mortise chisel.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#41

Possible "bindy" explanation

Bill Tindall

The lumber I am using for the stiles is perfectly quartered. The stiles were cut from the outside of the tree(board) where the lumber was clear with fine growth rings . The practice piece (if one hasn't chopped mortises in a while some practice seemed prudent) was left over and was from near the center of the tree. In fact, upon examining the practice piece I see that I am penetrating the mortise into what would be "juvenile wood", early growth wood at the center of the tree.

When a tree seed sprouts it will stand the best chance of surviving if it heads to the sky quickly. The tree is programmed to make wood cells that will get it tall quick. After a few inches of diameter growth the cell structure changes to cells that make the tree stronger and stiffer but slower growth in the vertical direction.

Typically we don't experience working with juvenile wood. The center of logs is typically "boxed out" at the mill and the center section sent to the pallet factory. When I have dried lumber that contained juvenile wood the juvenile wood usually fractures during drying so it must shrink a lot.

When I sawed the logs for this walnut lumber I sawed them in a way to yield as much rift and quartered lumber as possible and I didn't trim away the juvenile wood on the edges of the quartered lumber. There may be something about this wood or the fact that the mortise penetrates from typical wood into juvenile wood that is exacerbating the binding in the mortise bottoms. After many inches of practice cuts on this scrap piece I am learning to deal with the binding, which may not be present in the stile pieces. In any case, the mortises are going to get made today what ever the obstacles encountered.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#42

A picture or drawing please

Bill Tindall

From what I gather the "best" traditional mortise chisels had some complex shape that makes them more effective to use. Without a picture or more explanation I can't follow the descriptions. "Thickness" and "width" and tapers are not clear without more explanation of what dimension is called "thickness", etc. Could someone provide a picture or drawing illustrating the shape being discussed.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#43

Re: Possible "bindy" explanation

CStan

Drill and pare.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#44

Re: Traditional chisels

CStan

George Ellis in Modern Practical Joinery (joinery in the British sense) in his comments on a line drawing of what we call the 'pig sticker' says as follows:

"The Mortise Chisel, figure 5, is made abnormally thick to prevent bending when levering out the core of mortises. As its name implies, it is solely used for producing mortises Widths from 1/8 in. to 5/8 in., advancing by 1/8 in."

"The Sash Chisel, figure 6, is a lighter form of same with a nearly parallel stem, used chiefly for the narrow mortises required in sash bars."

My only comment would be that I've certainly never come close, anywhere close, to bending or breaking a sash mortise chisel in any size mortise I've ever cut with them. One would have to leave a solid quarter inch uncut at the ends to lever against to get that sort of force going. I just don't see this as good technique. Might be quick, but quick is not always good.

I still like the 'sash' style the best which may be solely due to me not having enough gumption to work in a way that would require all of the extra thickness and stoutness provided by a pig sticker. I just don't pound or lever the chisel that hard and don't otherwise see any advantage to the extra width of these chisels.

I wonder if it's a point worth noting that as hand methods gave way to machines in England it appears that the sash chisel was the only one to survive - to remain in continuous production. That seems important and seems to be a commentary, at least, on what remained in demand by hand workers. Or, am I honking up the history?

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#45

Re: Traditional chisels

david weaver

Do you think it may be possible that it survived because it was cheaper to produce and there wasn't that much demand for mortise chisels in general when there were gobs already out on the used toolmonger market?

It seems like a lot of what survived in the US is stuff that was cheap to make, not the preferred or best items.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#46

Re: Traditional chisels

CStan

Nothing survived in the US that I am aware of - I'm thinking of British sash mortise chisels. Is there a US manufacturer still making these?

I think we're being told that the pig sticker style is the 'real' mortise chisel (i.e. somebody wanted to bring a 'real' mortise chisel to market). I've still not seen anything offered that supports that assumption. In use, for furnituremaking, I personally don't see any advantage in the greater size. I think we've been "told" that we should be hitting our chisels harder and excavating our mortises more quickly, apparently by applying large doses of levering which these chisels are designed to withstand. Frankly, I find cutting and flicking the waste out works fine. Levering implies tearing uncut or partially cut wood out of a hole, like using a shovel.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#47

Re: Traditional chisels

Joel Moskowitz

You can argue that one can chop mortises with a variety of tools. Of course there is always more than one way to skin a cat. However I don't understand why you say "I think we're being told that the pig sticker style is the 'real' mortise chisel (i.e. somebody wanted to bring a 'real' mortise chisel to market). I've still not seen anything offered that supports that assumption. "

That is a question of nomenclature. If you walked into any ironmonger in England up until WW2 and asked for a Mortise Chisel you would be handed a large, oval handled tool. This is listed and illustrated in dozens upon dozens of sources of catalogs and bills (Seaton for one).

If you did the same thing in the US You would get a similar answer up until about 1850 at which time getting any mortise chisel would be tricky or you might get a socketed version, a European HD sash mortise chisel, or what some catalogs considered the best choice - the English Mortise Chisel. To my knowledge they were never manufactured here.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#48

Re: Traditional chisels

david weaver

I'm getting lost here, Charles.

Are we discussing what historically was used to cut mortises in cabinet work or what you prefer to use?

Everyone is aware that you like to make delicate mortise cuts. I'd imagine everyone here does, too, after maybe the first time they hammer the crap out of a new chisel to see how the edge holds up (i'll admit to having done that, but to do that as standard practice and deal with the noise in combination with sloppy results, that doesn't sound like a pleasant hobby).

I'd be more inclined to believe that oval bolster chisels weren't commonly used for cabinetmaking if there weren't so many around in thin widths with long gradual primary bevels.

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#49

Re: Traditional chisels

david weaver

Scratch my question charles, I'm not that concerned what the answer is since I'm not doing anything historically accurate, anwyay. If I had to bet money, I'd go with what Joel said, but I don't even bet on things I know the odds of.

(i just hate to erase posts, so I'm not going to bother with it, it seems underhanded to erase them unless they are TOS violators).

Re: more questions and problems chopping mortises

#50

Re: Traditional chisels

CStan

All of that handle and all that steel must be for something.

I didn't mean to imply that it was you telling us to hit the chisel harder. I do have a distinct memory when Iles brought these to market that the boards were busy informing us that we could now bludgeon and lever hell out of our mortises. Like the old guys did.