New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

Posts

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#76

Re: Where were all you sages back then.....?

TomD

"If the search function works one can find a question I posed on Badger Pond that got a friend and I involved in "better" steel. I don't remember how long ago Badger Pond was active but it has been a while. I asked how come we used long edge lived steel like M2 for jointer knives and not hand tool blades? The response from the experts of the day was, and still continues to be in some quarters, for example Chris Schwartz's Blog, "these steels CAN'T be sharpened to as high a degree as carbon steel". We now have ample evidence, even scientifically validated evidence, that this claim is baloney. Yet the myth persists even today in some parts."

Back in the early 80s I bought my japanese HSS chisels and planes. These were marketed by an outfit that advertised in FWW every issue. Mark distributed the catalog here last week. There were also euro sellers of HSS plane blades, for example, they sold them to handle man made products. LV stocked those. As I have said here about every month since I got here from BP, the opriginal tr12 router I bought had a razor sharp carbine blade in it. TR12s were the plunge router to have. Everyone who bought one could clearly see that the claim the carbides were too big to take a razor edge was baloney. Wood turners have been making their own tools using HSS for decades. These are often stock removal tools. They take a razor edge. They are made, in most early cases, by companies that also made regular chisels etc... Like Henry taylor. LV has been green compounds, replacement grinding stones for bench grinder, for decades. All sorts of people sell diamond stones. Loose diamond was news to me, but not really a game changer, a definite improvement.

Yeah myths are persistent, even though many know they are wrong. The situation is not improved by substituting new myths of dubious veracity.

"The facts are that few were willing to challenge these myths with experiments to reveal the utility of these metals and abrasives. And even today many won't accept the results and even dismiss the efforts to investigate these areas."

This is your blinders showing Bill, you are out there doing, or plundering research, and coming up with new products that have been in the marketplace, and in my shop in some form for 35 years I know of. I live in Canada, we get stuff decades after the US. Your friend Frink was selling HSS plane blades, when, 10+ years ago? Stock removal. When does it end?

"Without doubt in the tool rooms of machine shops the properties of higher performance steels and the means of abrading them was well known. But this information has only recently been infused into the ultraconservative woodworking community."

That is just not true. HSS, even carbide hand tools have been in the home shop for as long as I can remember. Dry grinding, for ever. The woodworking revival started mid 70s. This stuff has been around that long, and probably longer, but I was not interested, so I leave that to others.

" I now have references to using diamonds on tool steels that date to the 1940's. But I never met anyone using this information to make their life easier in a wood working shop until most recently."

Loose diamonds, don't know, but it only recently arrived improved my life. No argument here. However I have sunk a lot of cash into a hole called DMT for a long time. And there are dozens of other products out there from that low quality to stones costing hundreds. I don't know the history of loose diamonds, myself, I learned that here. But I don't actually consider it a game changer for HSS it could be if you are talking hand sharpening only. Never lost any sleep over sharpening HSS tools of very high quality with the regular stuff in the shop. Just not a problem. And nobody selling the stuff who could have sold a lot of diamond ever mentioned it that I recall. Indeed, in the machinist community the skinny is to only sharpen carbide on diamond, and nobody seems fussed about using hard arkansas for HSS. For turning I buff, and the Japanese tools are laminated and come up easily on stones.

So if the loose diamonds are a big recent advance, the ubiquity of HSS in the workshop over the last 30 years goes to show they aren't critical.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#77

Re: more picking on Kees

Kees

Yes Stu has written a lot about these stones on his blog. These "super waterstones" are very fast but also tend to dish quickly.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#78

Re: Proposed amendment to Kee`s post

TomD

"I think there are loads of woodworkers who just don't want to go to diamonds. Either because their current sharpeng system is still going strong. Or just because of not being familiar with it. Diamond sharpening isn't exactly mainstream yet. Good substrates are not readily for sale. I think that could change it, when a big firm like LV would start selling ready made dimand sharpening packages. "

I think LV thinks they are doing that. I haven't had an opportunity to try the product, and probably won't get one.

I don't know how conservative the incoming market is. Most people are not instant replacers, I don't know how long it takes to swing the ship around in a new direction. There are a few things I don't like about diamond, and I may get over these with time. I don't like the fact that sliding on grease I do not feel I have registration. I don't like the dirt part of it. I think I lot of woodworkers are not dirty hands people. It's minimal dirt in the machine shop setting. This is probably just my inexperience showing through, but I don't always know when it is cutting or how much, and when I should recharge.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#79

Re: Inside Joke / story

TomD

"I think you are hopelessly naive if you doubt the significant role consumer psychology plays with regard, especially, to Japanese tools and more generally to the boutique tool market overall.

In fact your denial itself is likely an artifact of consumer psychology."

Same thing with your argument. It's generic, and probably true up to a point. But every product, including the best, has it's marketing. You have become captive of a rather uninteresting, and ill informed argument, and the denial of any other reality is evidence of the psychological prison you have built for yourself. The keys are there in the form of actually doing the work. But to accept that challenge you have to look around and face the fact you are only on the bottom rung of the ladder, not the rhetorical top rung you currently take comfort from.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#80

Re: Inside Joke / story

TomD

"Other than objective edge longevity, which is way overrated IMO, all of this to some degree or another depending on the consumer becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy as soon as the credit card is charged. "

Edge longevity is not overrated if that is what you want. I agree with you that it does not have to be important, depending on work etc... But it is like gas mileage, pretty hard to argue with a higher number. I think most of the Japanese makers know the users of their tools are not really up to it, and that may even be true to some extent over there. But in Japan there are the navy seals of woodworking. (or possibly the tyson chicken workers of woodworking). Guys who work all day, every day. They probably pound out in a minute, or ten minutes what we do in a week. Seriously. Who are you to say that edge retention does not mater?

If you look at video two that Mark put up. Look at the size of cut that guy is getting with his chisel. He is cutting Macassar Ebony. It is a very blue collar scene. Try that with your Bucks.

http://youtu.be/3bYttKDGuko

They do twelve planes like that a day.

It's obvious most people over here don't deserve these tools, but some do.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#81

Re: more picking on Kees

TomD

Some day it will get through that stones wear where people rub them. If one rubs them all over they stay flat a lot longer.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#82

Finck

Bill Tindall

Finck....good example. He lives a short ways away. We introduced David to the new steels and indeed that was about 10 years ago. He offered them for a bit but he and at least some customers didn't like them. Couldn't get them sharp (with what ever they were using, water stones in David's case) Last I knew he quit offering them. Maybe he has revived them again. I don't keep up with what he is selling. He is back in the shop making stuff after some absence.

I don't claim to have discovered or invented anything. I typically reference the sources of what I am teaching.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#83

Re: Inside Joke / story

david weaver

I also noticed that mortise cut in the ebony. I was shocked by the size of the cut he took, but time is money and I know little about the japanese scene, but recall that odate said that being called a slow worker was about as big of an insult as someone could give you in japan.

None of these guys are slow.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#84

Re: Inside Joke / story

Bob Hackett

One of our mottoes (we changed them regularly) at the yacht yard was;

"We may be slow,but we`re expensive".

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#85

Re: Inside Joke / story

TomD

I tried to make a maccasar ebony plane back then. I didn't finish it for a variety of reasons. Stuff is hard. I was wondering if the block was wet wood, he is cutting such large chunks out. But that doesn't sound right. What I remember about watching him was what big moves he made. I remember when he made a bench dog that he just spit it out. That pretty much shocked me at the time. JA's green wood book came out in '79, and for that mater we did sorta do that kind of thing around the farm, but still, I didn't associated it with cabinetmaking or FWW. But he really busts his work out, and that was major to see back 30 years ago, nearly. If you don't work that way how are you really assessing the job these tools do.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#86

Drawing a conclusion

Kees

This thread becomes a bit complex, so let me try to come to a conclusion.

When you want a better chisel then the current western offerings you can do two things.

Buy some Japanese ones.

Buy some CPM 3V, hacksaw, file ang grind a chisel shape. Then find a heat treater who likes to experiment a bit. Find the best heat treating schedule. Then go out to source some flat bits of cast iron and buy the neccessary diamokd grits. Finish the chisel.

That's about it, isn't it?

In the near future the LV PM V11 is another choice.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#87

minor corrections

Bill Tindall

"Buy some CPM 3V, hacksaw, file ang grind a chisel shape. Then find a heat treater who likes to experiment a bit. Find the best heat treating schedule. Then go out to source some flat bits of cast iron and buy the neccessary diamokd grits. Finish the chisel."

There are boutique shops making and selling chisels. Just do you own if you are very cheap. My motivation was cheap. Then it was a matter of what metal to use. Turns out CPM 3V is much easier to work than O-1, a bonus.

A machine shop will inexpensively cut out the rectangles with a band saws.

The steel company works out the heat treating schedules. Knife makers long ago worked out the optimum heat treating to use for 3V and every other metal that might be useful. Every medium sized city in the US has a heat treating shop and it is cheap to do. Or mail the items to a shop recommended by the steel vendor, which is what we did. It was $50 to do 25 pounds (that is a lot of chisels) a few years back, the last time we did any.

Particle steels are rolled not cast.

An additional step is making a handle to suite your taste.

But, most important, if one doesn't like the shape and feel of a Japanese chisel, or Western chisel, the steel is irrelevant.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#88

Re: minor corrections

Kees

Well I'm glad you mostly agree with my conclusions :D

This is all very much tongue in cheeck of course. What I just want to get at, most woodworkers buy chisels from a known supplier. Japanese are on the fringe of being well known. It's not easy to find the good ones for a reasonable price. I'm glad with the offerings from Stu.

CPM 3V chisels, I don't know anyone who sells these?

When the new LV chisels catch on, they will be a runner, just because they are easilly available.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#89

Re: minor corrections

david weaver

I have to think that the reason there aren't many 3V chisels is because most people are used to working O1, and can work O1 faster with machines. And heat treating would have to be done on a separate schedule.

That and especially, most people making chisels wouldn't like to triple the cost of the steel used in their chisels on something that they want to sell to you for $60. Maybe their wholesale is half of retail, or a little more or less (which is still relevant for LV, because they bear the cost of retailing instead). If you've got $30 of budget for a chisel, burning through $10 worth of steel on one instead of $3 is a big deal.

Our odds of getting the best chisel steel in a western chisel, no cost considered, are about as good as our odds of making a perfect original chisel design in our own garages.

If 3V cost the same as O1 and worked as easily without work hardening, we'd probably have it instead of O1.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#90

A purveyor of CPM 3V chisels

Bill Tindall

jcpayne01@yahoo.com

We do agree on the merits of the LV chisel. Somewhere in the mix of metals tested by LV is CPM 3V. I would guess it is metal W, from the scoring, presuming the sample they used was optimally hardened which would leave it hard and tough. I think the chisel test will predict real world performance, so as I said at first I think they will have the best performing Western chisel in the market. And they fabricated it the way most people would want it. If I was selling A2 chisels I would be looking for another way to make money. The LV chisel would be my choice if I wasn't too cheap to buy one. But WOW what a set of these chisels will cost!

I remain skeptical that this steel will turn out any better than A2 for a plane blade because I think the sharpening test is a better predictor of plane blade performance than the test they chose to reveal data from. If the new steel was significantly better at planing wood they would be providing data of real world planing for A2 vs the LV steel. It would not take many feet of wood to reveal a significant difference if one was to be found.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#91

working porperties of 3V

Bill Tindall

It saws and files much easier than O-1. It is buttery soft in its annealed state. The heat treat schedule is no more complicated then O-1. But, the material cost is higher. But then how much metal is in a 1/2 chisel?(50 grams for the ones I made)

It is a compelling choice for home made chisel because it is so easy to work.