New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

Posts

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#26

Re: I did not sneer

TomD

I used to make clubs for a bunch of folks, but at the time there were some who would not buy from me because they preferred to buy brands, sometimes I would sell them Pearless/Palmer. This was a brand that Arnold Palmer endorsed, and perhaps because Palmer was a lifelong club maker, he sold his heads to home builders also. That was a peek behind the curtain because he sold the heads for 6.95 each. Sets sold in retails stores (8 clubs) were 695 and 995 with carbon shafts. Best quality shafts at the time were 9 dollars (better than what the clubs came with), and grips were say 2 dollars and up. That was before china got into the game. so basically you could make a championship set at around 15-20 dollars a piece.

At the time the stainless heads were cheap like that but sold for more in the stores, while the forged blades sold for about 25 dollars a head , but would only pull in about 450 a set.

I can remember thinking how crazy some of the component drivers were. Huge heads in carbon fiber, weight ports, all this kluge junk. At the time, mid 90s, the brand stuff was at least fairly elegant. Funny thing, they adopted all the junky stuff from component makers about 20 years later. They are pretty desperate to come out with new stuff every year.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#27

Re: Shut your festering gob, you nit!

Curt Putnam

If you really want what is in the last sentence, I suggest that a political forum would be a better choice.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#28

Re: Shut your festering gob, you nit! *LINK*

Rob Lee

Well.... I have a stake in it....! :D

Cheers -

Rob

BTW - Site is now active....


PM-V11 Website

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#29

Re: If you have a stake..

david weaver

...you're not allowed to argue or get mad, then. It's only allowed where it makes no sense to waste the time doing it :)

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#30

the brass weight..

david weaver

The brass weight in an size about 4 times as large as it is in the test would've been a great april 1 offering. For those users who want to remove all variables from the sharpening equation, offer a "16 pound brass weight, optimally determined based on the olympic shot put".

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#31

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

joel moskowitz

"I really wish I had mastered everything about the craft I want to master and was down to needing edges that stay sharp forever. In thinking about all the current challenges I have in the shop, not one of them is addressed by an edge tool that goes longer between honings. Not by a long shot."

This is a really excellent quote. About 20 or 30 years ago you really could buy chisels that didn't work very well. These days as long as you stick with well known retailers, at minimum pretty much anything you buy will be decent to pretty good. What I tell customers is that if you buy the chisel that fits well in your hand everything else will fall into place. In my own case I don't really use the chisels in my tool box that have the longest edge retention. I use the ones with the second longest edge retention, but feel the best and livest in my hands. Now I didn't make a conscious decision about that, it just seems that when I need to use a chisel it's the latter chisel set that gets used.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#32

Re: I did not sneer

CStan

Used clubs are like last season's Prada - can be had for cheap.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#33

can you believe that there are people

Bruce, a MN Galoot

who can pick up that 16 lb weight and toss it 75 ft?! I can barely carry it that far.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#34

Don't read too much into that, Curt

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It's a great sport that hones debating skills and brings joy to people's lives! It must because we do it with amazing regularity here.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#35

Re: can you believe that there are people

david weaver

They made everyone try the 12 pounder in gym class in high school. I think I threw it about 24 feet. At my age, I don't think I'd want to try to do anything other than drop the 16 pounder.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#36

I too subscribe to your rule

Bill Tindall

I want to know what tools are made from. Of course given a small piece of it knowing what its made from is a trivial pursuit for a lab that does metal analysis. For the price of a chisel to cut up and a couple hundred dollars any curious person or company could know.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#38

Re: I too subscribe to your rule

david weaver

That reminds me of a story..

When I was in college, a professor of mine (materials science, I took it as an elective) had access to a spectrum analyzer or some piece of equipment that tells you "what's in that thing".

They were running different colored glass through the thing to find out what made it a certain color, and when they got to the red dishes (I think these were corning or something), he was surprised to find cobalt (as in, you'd expect the dish to be blue).

A year or two later, he was with a group touring a corning factory, I think in NY, and their guide boasted "we have a trade secret on what we put in our glass to make red kitchenware, nobody will ever guess what it is". He blurted it "It's cobalt!". The woman got short with him thinking maybe he was an ex employee sharing information or something, and wanted to kick him off the tour until he explained how he knew that.

So when this whole thing came up, and I said I'd not buy steel if I don't know what it is (which is easy to say when you don't need anything), I figured if I really wanted to know, I'd call that professor and ask if I could get a chisel run through the lab.

I'm sure if you figured out about what the alloy was, even if it was proprietary, Rob probably wouldn't say "yeah, that's the alloy" :b

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#39

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

CStan

Do we know the name of the firm that will be making the steel Lee Valley uses?

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#40

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

david weaver

Personally, I don't, but I'm guessing it's Latrobe Specialty Steel.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#41

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

CStan

Not a Japanese firm? Knock me over with a feather....

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#42

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

david weaver

I think hitachi does powder metals, but unlike the blade steel issue (where hitachi actually makes plain steels designed for use in blades, vs. american mills that make die and punch steels that we substitute for blades), there seems to be more commonality in powder metal so far.

Of course, that doesn't mean we won't abandon something good here down the road, the same way we abandoned good file and blade steel in the last 100 years. Though we never made any blade steel here that was as good as hitachi white #1 or blue #1, there was no demand for it.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#43

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

Rob Lee

Hi Charles -

Part of our criteria for for branding a product "Veritas" is the extent and nature of domestic (US and Canada) content.

That kind of excludes Japan in this instance...

Of course - the Japanese (Chinese, Koreans, Swiss .....) can (and do) all make high quality steels.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#45

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

CStan

Thanks for the information. Sounds good to me.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#46

Re: Inside Joke / story

david weaver

Don't forget the austrians!

Rob, you probably weren't watching the last discussion, and why Charles asked about the Japanese.

There was a relatively one-sided debate on here not that long ago where (Charles can tell me if I'm wrong) Charles contended that the difference between the Japanese steels used in tools vs. stuff like Records "tungsten vanadium" steel was a marketing and storytelling difference, and not a composition/performance difference.

Any of us who thought the hitachi specialty blade steels offered better performance than the O1s and chrome vanadiums are now (and presumably going forward) subject to Charles asking if improvements come from japan.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#47

Re: Inside Joke / story

CStan

Well, that's certainly a version of it...

Let's just leave it with this: I believe that there is a WHOLE lot of consumer psychology involved.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#48

Re: Inside Joke / story

CStan

Based on these boards, one certainly could be forgiven for thinking that nobody in the world is producing any steel worth having other than the Japanese.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#49

Re: Inside Joke / story

david weaver

That's a different thing than saying that the japanese blade steels are better than O1 and the chrome vanadium type stuff that is offered by most western makers.

I have no trouble doing work with a $3 iron from home depot. But that doesn't change that the japanese higher quality (and more expensive) blade specific steels are better in ever aspect except price.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#50

Re: Inside Joke / story

TomD

Price wise they aren't actually that expensive. What would LV tools cost if they not only had good steel but they were hand made or small series made. But the blue steel laminated factory made replacement blades are probably the same price as the average fab offering from folks over here.