New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

Posts

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#51

Re: Inside Joke / story

TomD

"Let's just leave it with this: I believe that there is a WHOLE lot of consumer psychology involved."

I doubt it. Right now this board has a lot of people who seem to at least partially enjoy using japaese tools. But that seems pretty recent. I can remember being only one of a few who regularly showed up here. And the last 20 years have been pretty light on the promotion of Japanese tools. In the 30+ years I have enjoyed them there was a period when they fell out of the catalogs we all enjoy. There was also a period when we didn't have the good tools we have from other sources and Japanese tools were just obviously better. But the last 10 years or more have seen a ton of new western tools made, and this has largely overshadowed a Japanese market that has nothing much new to show for itself.

I can't really remember the last time there was a major book, or even an article that was pro Japanese tools, as opposed to say reviews were they are just along for the ride.

Overall I don't really see that much promotion of them. The thing that mostly seems to make people believers is that they try them out. They almost always find them better, but they often find them strange as well. Not what they are used to. And should western tools keep improving with Japanese tool staying the same the will be a point of Singularity or even the western stuff will just fly by.

As an example. Everyone I knew who was a serious woodworker 35 years ago used a dozuki for dovetails. There were people we read of who had old tools or used things they made, but the dozuki was the only thing a person could buy, and the one we had was not designed for dovetails even. Then one day I ordered a Independence tools dovetail saw when it came on the market, and it was apparent I would never need to use a Japanese tool again. I'm not saying the IT saw was better than the custom Japanese saws, but it was really nice to use, and I bought 3. We weren't using the dozukis because of superstition, or marketing, they were the only dang thing we could get. I don't know if you were around then. But when the IT saw came out Franz Klauz bought one for each of the guys in his shop because nobody had a saw that you could just buy. What did you use during the 80s and early 90s?

There was a guy who wrote a book on doing dovetails, and he recommended using a hack saw. And he was right. Other than the fact they don't have pleasant set, they cut better than what we could buy form the LVs and GWs etc... That was the world we lived in, respected writers telling us to use hacksaws. Another writer writing in FWW, not that long ago, recommended, totally re-filing a common variety of gent's saw, and provided instructions on how to do it. Then on the on the other hand you had all these fabulous tools in Japan, and they were ready to go, never were better tools available to a more tool starved audience, what do you think would happen. It wasn't marketing it was desperation.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#52

Re: Inside Joke / story

david weaver

Yes, they're about the same price from stu. Cheaper than some. Some of the retailers over here are more proud of them, but there's no reason to patronize them.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#53

Re: Inside Joke / story

CStan

I think you are hopelessly naive if you doubt the significant role consumer psychology plays with regard, especially, to Japanese tools and more generally to the boutique tool market overall.

In fact your denial itself is likely an artifact of consumer psychology.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#54

Re: Inside Joke / story

CStan

Other than objective edge longevity, which is way overrated IMO, all of this to some degree or another depending on the consumer becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy as soon as the credit card is charged.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#55

Re: Inside Joke / story

david weaver

Charles, what exactly is your objective here? Is it to prove to people you have a better answer on something opinion related, or is it to try to convince everyone else they've never had a critical thought or the ability to make a cost/benefit decision?

The same things you rail about with japanese or boutique tools could be said about everything you could buy. It could be said about food, it could certainly be said about expensive furniture, which would be easily described as no more functional than cheap furniture and a total sham foisted on people who like things someone else tells them are worthwhile.

I don't think anyone on any of these forum sites has any idea why you want to overlay your tool preferences on everyone else. I'm baffled by it, but other than being tired of seeing the same posts over and over and over and over, I don't care much.

Why is it that you feel like people really want your specific opinion that badly such that everyone has to see it over and over and over?

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#56

Japanese steel and PM V11 *LINK*

Kees

I have just rerad Derek´s test of some chisels, a year ago. He tested several PM steels and some old fashioned carbon steel ones. The strong point of his test is how he tested the amount of wear. Instead of looking at micro photographs, which don´t really tell you much, he tested the sharpness through paring end grain pine. That´s a real sharpness test, just like how Kawai-Kato test sharpness with force transducers in their planing machine. Dereks test is a lot cheaper of coarse!

His conclusion was that the PM chisels where a bear to sharpen and needed diamonds. On the chopping test they really didn´t outclass the Japanese chisel, which was easy to sharpen to a very sharp edge and kept on to that edge for a very long time.

I have similar experience with chopping a lot of dovetails in Jatoba. My older Berg chisels needed to be resharpened after every pin, the Koyamaichi's easilly hold up for a drawerside. I polished the edges after each side just to prevent catastrophic failure of the edge, but they sure were still reasonably sharp.

There is another test on Dereks page about the paring/planing ability of these steels. The Japanese one again took a very sharp edge early on on the test, but didn´t hold it quite as long as the others.

In other words, the Japanese really manage to create some very good chisels with simple tool steels. They are easy to sharpen, get freakingly sharp and hold an edge for a long time. The ability of PM steels to hold an edge for longer time seems especially aparent in a paring/planig situation, not so much when chopping.

The new PM V11 stuff from LV looks promissing. If it really lives up to the testdata from LV in their sales brochure on the web, it´s going to be a succes. I agree with Bill that the planing data with MDF and almost zero clearance angle looks a bit suspicious. I am very curious how this stuff will hold up in real life. I´ve never liked the idea of the PM steels, because they seemingly need a new sharpening regime with diamonds. So now LV comes with a PM steel that's reasonably easy to sharpen, they might have a winner.


http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselBladeTesting-5Steels.html

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#57

data to disagree with your conclusion

Bill Tindall

I am going to convince you that this statement is not correct......"Instead of looking at micro photographs, which don´t really tell you much,"

Derek tested the way he did because he didn't have the equipment to take microphotographs. Not surpprising, given that a good scope for this kind of work can be north of $30,000.

What is now 10 or more years ago driven by my unwillingness to spend hundreds of dollars for a set of good chisels a friend and I set about to make chisels.(they wound up costing less than $5 each) This activity was novel at the time because chisels were typically forged and we had no metal experience. I contacted Crucible Products, as well as some knife makers, provided the properties I was looking for -toughness at high hardness, abrasion resistance irrelevant- and the particle steel CPM 3V was recommended. It could be ordered in thickness perfect for a chisel which we intended to cut from the steel plate like some knife makers were doing, rather than forge. Now cutting a chisel from plate is common, but it was not at the time we were doing it.

At the time I had access to a well equipped microscopy laboratory run by a woodworker. During the steel selection process I made chisels from what I had at hand and as well I evaluated the chisels I owned with a chopping test similar to what LV used, but hand driven. My test was "real world" simulating dovetailing in walnut. (the lab has since bought a microscope better equipped for metal surfaces and our recent photographs of coated plane blades are much better)

Results:



The first picture is a Sorby chisel. It can be clearly seen that the edge failure was from deformation of the edge, a result of the chisel being insufficiently hard. It was this kind of failure that led me to search for better chisels.

The second picture is from a chisel made from M2. Here it can be clearly seen that failure is from microchipping of the edge. There is no deformation. This chisel is hard enough to resist deforming but it is not tough enough and it microchips at the edge. This is a less desirable failure than deformation. If it chips metal is lost and lots of grinding to be rid of the chips. A deformed edge can be straightened more or less on a fine hard stone. But the deformation on the Sorby was beyond hope.

The advantage CPM 3V provided was the ability to harden this steel to a high value to resist deformation without loosing toughness that would lead to chipping.

Summary of photographs- by examining the edge after testing one can determine the failure mode. Knowing the failure mode one can then either adjust the heat treatment or choose a different steel with more favorable properties. Based on the photographs we took it was clear that for chisels one wants a steel that can be hardened to the highest possible degree while maintaining toughness. We sharpen our CPM 3V mortise chisels at 25 degrees and have no fear of breakage because this steel is too tough to break.

From our work I could have predicted the LV results for O-1 and M4. O-1 was not(maybe can not) be hardened sufficiently high to resist deformation. M4 lacks toughness and it chipped in their test. (compare the LV photographs to those above) Toughness data are provided in the Crucible Products technical information and elsewhere.

Today there may be a better steel than CPM 3V for chisels. Metal X in the LV testing looks to have the properties of 3V. Given the way the metals were scored we don't know how much better PMV11 was than metal X, but I have no doubt it was some better by their testing. The advantage of 3V is that it is sold for knife making and it is readily available in reasonable quantities, and sizes. And it is very easily worked with hand tools.

I believe it is a simple matter to choose steel for chisels if one is not hung up on ancient sharpening technology. Go to the literature and pick a particle steel with high toughness at high hardness. A $65 diamond plate and $15 of 1 micron diamond powder seems a small price to pay for enabling the selection of the best steel for tools.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#58

comparing apples and oranges

Bill Tindall

"In other words, the Japanese really manage to create some very good chisels with simple tool steels."

There are at least two ways to achieve properties-forging, or formulation and fabrication.

To begin I suspect the manufacturer of the steel used in the premium Japanese chisels would disagree that they are "simple", implying ordinary. Second, the Japanese chisels are then forged from this steel in a way that imparts additional desirable properties.

The alternate universe is to cut a chisel from a rolled steel plate and simply heat treat it. In this case the chisel properties are entirely determined by the steel manufacturing process with additional heat treatment to achieve hardness. (cryo treating is baloney)

Sophisticated chisel fabrication process vs sophisticated steel formulation and manufacturing process-different universes.

That said, if you don't like the feel of a Japanese chisel the properties of the steel are irrelevant, and visa versa for western chisels. With the availability of high performance steel now one can have equivalent chisel performance with any style of chisel one might desire. Furthermore, since these new steels can be fabricated into chisels with a hack saw and file anyone can made a chisel as good as money can buy.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#59

Re: data to disagree with your conclusion

Kees

I can't see the pictures? Just red crosses.

I don't think we disagree so much at all! A good chisel is not just about material selection. You showed that you can turn 3V in a very usefull chisel by paying attention to how the edge fails and adjusting the heat treatment. The Japanese blacksmiths turn simple carbon steel into very very capable chisels, out performing most any Western made one, through carefull selection of the steel, handforging, dedicated heat treatment and loads of experience of coarse. It's just a fact that attention to the details can greatly increase the quality of the endproduct.

About the photography (pitty I can't see your photo's) I think you wouldn't need these micro photographs. You can feel how an edge fails. Chipping or folding are catastrophic enough. They are very obvious in the photo's. But when an edge just quietly wears away, the photo won't tell you much. We could see on the Kawai/Kato pictures how the wearpattern didn't really corolate with how much force was needed to push the blade though the wood. Granted, that was in a different situation with a plane blade with capiron.

About diamond sharpening. My totally subjective opinion is that I hate diamond plates. They wear out too fast and they have that feel of fingernails across chalkboard. And loose diamonds are easy to bring into the shop but almost impossible to get rid of again. They contaiminate everything around and won't go away. I am very happy with my waterstone setup and won't change anytime soon. That's one reason why I am excited about that PM V11 stuff. Of course everybody is allowed to have a differnet opinion :D

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#60

Re: comparing apples and oranges

Kees

That still leaves the sharpening situation. Not everyone likes diamonds.

I did mean simple in "not much additives" not like in "ordinary". I think that is one of the strengths of the Japanese steel, the high purity of it. And then they manage to use a fabrication process that results in very durable chisels that are still easy to sharpen.

I still don't see a modern steel that has the same amount of strength while still being as easy to sharpen.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#61

Some people`s reasoning stumps me

Bob Hackett

Some folks here keep pointing to their sharpening gear and making that the decisive point in all their edge tool selections. Seems like a "cart before the horse" type of philosophy to me.

Why are there so few of us that first look at what material will produce an optimal edged tool for a particular job and then adjust our grinding/sharpening gear to deal with the most difficult to sharpen edge we have in the shop? If the gear I have in the shop will handle the most abrasion resistant HSS then I can be sure it`ll handle any less abrasion resistant materials (like O1) with ease. Even the most over the top obsessive sharpening guys I know have far,far less stones (and money invested in them) than edged tools in their shops.

Letting the stones you have in your shop or the sharpening technique you`re presently comfortable with continue to limit your tool choices just seems counterproductive, inflexible and a weak excuse for not upgrading as far as I`m concerned.

How`s that for a shot across the bow? :)

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#62

Re: Some people`s reasoning stumps me

Kees

Well I have invested in good quality waterstones and I am now setup for a cOuple of years. I am not going to change for every kind of new steel. Combine that with my love for vintage tools an then you get a very resonable discission.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#63

Proposed amendment to Kee`s post

Bob Hackett

Shouldn`t that line in your post read "Easily sharpened with the equipment I presently own".

Some time ago Bill convinced me that he could go from a 60 grit grinding wheel directly to 1 micron diamond on CI and get a really good edge quickly so I tried it and it works just as he said it would. One wheel, one plate, one size of abrasive. Hands down the quickest, least expensive, most uncomplicated way to get an edge I had come across so far and I can still quickly sharpen my old laminated blades on that same diamond loaded CI plate.

If you have a different definition and approach to "simple/easy" that can accommodate as broad a range of steel I`d like to hear it.

BTW-I don`t like waterstones and especially oilstones (though I own at least a half dozen of each) so please don`t mention them in your reply. ;)

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#64

Flaw in Woodcentral Web site/PIC added

Bill Tindall

When it takes a while to compose a post the pictures don't post.

Sorby chisel (since sold the set)

M2 home made chisel


Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#65

Chisels don't quietly wear away.

Bill Tindall

At least not the ones used for chopping as in the LV test or practical application like removing dovetail waste or mortising. They chip or they bend, more or less and will need to be sharpened from chipping or bending not abrasion loss of metal.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#66

that was the conclusion I came to

Bill Tindall

But then I never had any of the problems Kees has with diamonds. If I did I might change my mind about their employment.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#67

Modern steel

John in NM

There are plenty of modern steels that are quite as easy to sharpen as Japanese chisel steels - you just need to use diamonds. I could just as easily tell you that I refuse to consider Japanese chisels because I can't sharpen them on the oil stones I already have (no idea if that would be true or not, just turning your reasoning around).

That you can't sharpen a chisel with your existing stones may quite reasonably influence your purchasing decisions, but that does not invalidate the whole question for the rest of us, who may well be at a point where a sharpening method upgrade is overdue :D

I agree however, that if the LV offerings can pair edge life with universal ease of sharpening, they'll have a winner - how could they not?

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#68

Re:  PM V11 and LV sharpening mastery + the truth

TomD

"The new PM V11 stuff from LV looks promissing. If it really lives up to the testdata from LV in their sales brochure on the web, it´s going to be a success. I agree with Bill that the planing data with MDF and almost zero clearance angle looks a bit suspicious. I am very curious how this stuff will hold up in real life. I´ve never liked the idea of the PM steels, because they seemingly need a new sharpening regime with diamonds. So now LV comes with a PM steel that's reasonably easy to sharpen, they might have a winner."

One thing to keep in mind about LV was that they solved the sharpening problem 30 years ago. The LV jig with the degree bumps will sharpen any steel I have come across on pretty much any decent stone, in no time at all, with none of the danger of power, and none of the mess of diamonds, should that not be your thing, or with diamonds. And there are other protocols like power and buff that have been in wide use for ever also.

The new PM V11 does not promise to be easier to sharpen, it promises to be the same beast as always with A2, but with less resharpening. IE a complete looser for the average user. The problem for the average joe is not the cycle time. The problem is that he either does not sharpen and perceives that he doesn't want to deal with any "hard to sharpen" steels. Or he sharpens badly, and correctly perceives that he will not get a good edge if the steel he sharpens is hard to sharpen since detecting sharpness and success at sharpening are made more difficult the slower a steel is to come up.

It is probably also the case that if he lives in NA he is not using very hard to cut woods, so further reason not to care about cycle time. O1 is perfectly pro on pine, red oak, cherry, and walnut. Most of america's famous woodworkers make/made their money off of walnut, which is very easy to cut. Most amateurs like cherry. Historically Mahogany (?).

Market resistance is why most sellers either sell O1 or sell both O1 and HSS. All the stuff Bill talks about, HSS, power sharpening, diamonds, stock removal tools, have been around as long as I can remember. 30+ years, it has just never been possible to get people interested in them. PM V11 could be a catalyst to get people up to the next level, it is easy to get there if they want to. Or it can simply be the steel that proves/further confirms LV products are world class in their own way, if you want to go there. But O1 will outsell then 10-1, or whatever. At a practical level, not much rides on it, but it is always nice to see people go to the next level, and have the satisfaction that comes from it.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#69

Re: Chisels don't quietly wear away.

TomD

Is that based on the idea people are prying on them?

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#70

more picking on Kees

Bill Tindall

Before the discovery of their abrasion friendly steel LV was busy evaluating "water stones" for sharpening abrasion resistant steels. If you have ever pursued the fools errand of sharpening your M2 jointer blades on typical "stones" you can appreciate the abrasion resistance of this steel. LV provided data to show that some of the water stones they offered did well on M2. If M2 does ok CPM 3V would be even easier, and M4 more difficult. Additionally, there are Japanese tools now made with similar abrasion resistant steels that they must be sharpening somehow, if not with diamond abrasives. So, it would appear that even those wedded to water stones can enjoy the benefits of higher performance steel in cases where there was some benefit to do so.

While on the subject of M2, it is curious that LV chose to divulge M4 in their evaluations. While this steel is common in lathe tools and highest performance knives it certainly is not common in plane blades and chisels and many would not have heard of it. M2 is lots more familiar to people and it would have seemed to be a better steel to use as a bench mark in the evaluations.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#71

Re: Some people`s reasoning stumps me

TomD

I suppose it depends on whether your stones cost you 10K and you spend several years of hard graft learning how to use them. And whether the results you get are better than most people here can imagine.

Not a self-description by the way.

I agree with your overall point, but it is also part of your life long cycle time to select, buy, maintain, new tools. I just turned 53, and you never know at this point how much time you have. It is less necesarry, and less rational to change everything up at this age. It isn't rejecting the new. The reality is that most people forming this discussion are tools nuts. One feels compelled to keep up with the zeitgeist of the tools nuts. But I also know three things. Whatever they come up with they will likely not be enamored with in a year or two. Shaptons anyone?. Whatever they have probably does not work better than what I have (i'm being polite); their time would be better spent working with the tools and learning how to use them, or if that isn't an issue, making stuff.

I suppose another reason is that if you have been around long enough, you know how this movie comes out. The methods we currently use are not ultimate methods. Those methods are there, and they are not difficult to find out about, and are supported by all the big labs and industrial producers out there. So if you want the art methods, they are pretty much set in stone, so to speak, and if you want the fast methods, they are power based. It seems mostly a hobby interest to play with the stuff we already know has been superceeded.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#72

Where were all you sages back then.....?

Bill Tindall

If the search function works one can find a question I posed on Badger Pond that got a friend and I involved in "better" steel. I don't remember how long ago Badger Pond was active but it has been a while. I asked how come we used long edge lived steel like M2 for jointer knives and not hand tool blades? The response from the experts of the day was, and still continues to be in some quarters, for example Chris Schwartz's Blog, "these steels CAN'T be sharpened to as high a degree as carbon steel". We now have ample evidence, even scientifically validated evidence, that this claim is baloney. Yet the myth persists even today in some parts. The facts are that few were willing to challenge these myths with experiments to reveal the utility of these metals and abrasives. And even today many won't accept the results and even dismiss the efforts to investigate these areas.

Without doubt in the tool rooms of machine shops the properties of higher performance steels and the means of abrading them was well known. But this information has only recently been infused into the ultraconservative woodworking community. I now have references to using diamonds on tool steels that date to the 1940's. But I never met anyone using this information to make their life easier in a wood working shop until most recently.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#73

Re: Modern steel

TomD

"There are plenty of modern steels that are quite as easy to sharpen as Japanese chisel steels - you just need to use diamonds. I could just as easily tell you that I refuse to consider Japanese chisels because I can't sharpen them on the oil stones I already have (no idea if that would be true or not, just turning your reasoning around)."

You can sharpen them with any method including power that applies to any other tool. What stands out most about a lot of the promoters of other methods (not directed at you), is they don't actually seem to have tried any of this.

"That you can't sharpen a chisel with your existing stones may quite reasonably influence your purchasing decisions, but that does not invalidate the whole question for the rest of us, who may well be at a point where a sharpening method upgrade is overdue :D"

And you can sharpen A2, which is what we are told the new PM stuff will be like, easily, on waterstones, oil stones, sandpaper, power or buffing. But again, the mythologist around here seem to start their scientific inquiries, by resolutely not learning the old methods or how to do them well, so their miracle breakthrough methods do seem miraculous to them. Machinist have been sharpening nasty HSS on a dry grind wheel with a buff or arkansas stone wipe for maybe 100 years. The problem is that a lot of people do not want to use dry grinders for whatever reason. It's not the diamonds that are getting the job done, it is the dry grinding. The diamonds are great however, but there aren't really any points in them unless you have carbide to handle. If you are dry grinding, you might as well buff, it is faster and cleaner, maybe cheaper, and the catalog stores have been selling the gear for 35-40 years.

"I agree however, that if the LV offerings can pair edge life with universal ease of sharpening, they'll have a winner - how could they not?"

Except they say it is A2 with a better cycle rating, which is fabulous, but will not make people feel better about sharpening it on the numbers, we can hope for a wave of acceptance due to the marketing wave.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#74

Re: Proposed amendment to Kee`s post

Kees

Well I like my waterstones a lot! :)

Of course I am only writing about my personal opinion here. You can read that I am very fond of the 5 koyamaichi's I have. They did cost me a bunch. But they make up for it with great service and they are compatible with my stones. The rest of my handtools is all vintage. Some over 200 years old. And still going strong.

I think there are loads of woodworkers who just don't want to go to diamonds. Either because their current sharpeng system is still going strong. Or just because of not being familiar with it. Diamond sharpening isn't exactly mainstream yet. Good substrates are not readily for sale. I think that coild change it, when a big firm like LV would start selling ready made dimand sharpening packages.

You guys are all ueber geeks of course and not representative for the rest of the woodwork market.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#75

Re: Flaw in Woodcentral Web site/PIC added

Kees

Thanks Bill. Very nice pictures and very clear.