Re: Inside Joke / story
TomD
"Let's just leave it with this: I believe that there is a WHOLE lot of consumer psychology involved."
I doubt it. Right now this board has a lot of people who seem to at least partially enjoy using japaese tools. But that seems pretty recent. I can remember being only one of a few who regularly showed up here. And the last 20 years have been pretty light on the promotion of Japanese tools. In the 30+ years I have enjoyed them there was a period when they fell out of the catalogs we all enjoy. There was also a period when we didn't have the good tools we have from other sources and Japanese tools were just obviously better. But the last 10 years or more have seen a ton of new western tools made, and this has largely overshadowed a Japanese market that has nothing much new to show for itself.
I can't really remember the last time there was a major book, or even an article that was pro Japanese tools, as opposed to say reviews were they are just along for the ride.
Overall I don't really see that much promotion of them. The thing that mostly seems to make people believers is that they try them out. They almost always find them better, but they often find them strange as well. Not what they are used to. And should western tools keep improving with Japanese tool staying the same the will be a point of Singularity or even the western stuff will just fly by.
As an example. Everyone I knew who was a serious woodworker 35 years ago used a dozuki for dovetails. There were people we read of who had old tools or used things they made, but the dozuki was the only thing a person could buy, and the one we had was not designed for dovetails even. Then one day I ordered a Independence tools dovetail saw when it came on the market, and it was apparent I would never need to use a Japanese tool again. I'm not saying the IT saw was better than the custom Japanese saws, but it was really nice to use, and I bought 3. We weren't using the dozukis because of superstition, or marketing, they were the only dang thing we could get. I don't know if you were around then. But when the IT saw came out Franz Klauz bought one for each of the guys in his shop because nobody had a saw that you could just buy. What did you use during the 80s and early 90s?
There was a guy who wrote a book on doing dovetails, and he recommended using a hack saw. And he was right. Other than the fact they don't have pleasant set, they cut better than what we could buy form the LVs and GWs etc... That was the world we lived in, respected writers telling us to use hacksaws. Another writer writing in FWW, not that long ago, recommended, totally re-filing a common variety of gent's saw, and provided instructions on how to do it. Then on the on the other hand you had all these fabulous tools in Japan, and they were ready to go, never were better tools available to a more tool starved audience, what do you think would happen. It wasn't marketing it was desperation.










