New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

Posts

Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#1

Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

david weaver

I know the discussion here will be the most straight up that it can be of an unknown steel.

Who is buying? I just spent my wad on super blue steel, so I'm out. I haven't needed a tool for 3 years, anyway, other than a few carving tools.

The most confusing thing I've read from folks so far is the desire for some oilstone users to have a steel that sharpens easer than A2. when you use oilstones to finish an edge, don't you sort of know you're boxing yourself into using carbon steel and not too hard if you want something that's easy to sharpen and doesn't give up anything for sharpness?

(yes, I know you can get by with alloyed steels on oilstones, the question just becomes why would you want to do it when there are plenty of synthetic abrasives that take care of alloyed steel in a snap)

anyway, let's have a ridiculous argument and get mad at each other for something none of us have a stake in :b

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#2

It's new !! so what

roninkokomo

Interesting that one of our fav companies is introducing the "New and

Better" steel for tools. I really don't think I need it... I understand

their needs. A recreational woodworker will not use up a chisel or plane

iron in his lifetime. Oops... they want us to buy stuff. How do they make

that happen? Convince us that they now have something "better" than we

have. OK... maybe they do.. Does that really matter to me? Don't think

so. My Hock irons are much better tools than I am a craftsman. Easy to

hone. Retain an edge nicely. I can get hardwood so slick that a fly has

trouble landing on it. If you really want the brutal truth.... the old

Stanley irons in my metal planes were quite adequate for my work. Not gonna

go the "upgrade route" this time.... I do not deny that the new metal

may be "better". For me, I think it is a distinction that makes no

difference.

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#3

Missing the point

Bill Tindall

I got this same push back when I announced I was making a chisel from CPM 3V. "Why" was the question. "Why not" was the answer.

The market for a better chisel is not someone that already has a chisel that they are satisfied with. Of course these people are going to dismiss something incrementally better. Improvement not worth the price. End of story. But, put yourself in the shoes of someone that is buying their first set of quality chisels. If for the same price as competitive quality chisels you can buy a chisel that delivers any improvement in performance why would one not buy that chisel?

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#4

Re: I was going to wait a while..

david weaver

... rather than just responding to the first post, it looks like i'm squatting on my own thread if I do that (which I am, anyway).

But I gather the same thing from it. It's not something I need, but it's good for people who are new to buying tools.

And in terms of sharpening, if something really does hold an edge longer but sharpens as easily as something else, that's real improvement, and were I buying, I'd probably buy it - especially in a plane where you actually have to take the tool apart in some manner to get the iron out (be it wedge, lever cap, or whatever), unlike a chisel where working it over a stone is quick and easy. (granted we are talking about taking 2 or 3 minutes to sharpen something including tool fiddle time vs. 30 second to 1 minute max for a chisel).

I am also in the same boat as warren now, in that unless something is yard sale price, I won't buy anything where I don't know the composition of the steel. I don't think most people have that irk, though, and I understand why LV would pinch the data if they spent as much as they say they did fiddling with different steels. But personal rules are rules! I know what's in togo, blue steel, blue super, white #1, O1, etc.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#5

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

CStan

I really wish I had mastered everything about the craft I want to master and was down to needing edges that stay sharp forever. In thinking about all the current challenges I have in the shop, not one of them is addressed by an edge tool that goes longer between honings. Not by a long shot.

If anything, stopping to hone keeps me from plowing ahead and making some sort of error. Honing is the 'pause that refreshes' and lets me gather my thoughts.

You guys are animals -- your arms never tire, your wallets are always full, your creativity never wanes, and now your edges will never dull.

Count me as envious.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#6

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

Rob Lee

Hi -

Short answer - it extends the continuum of choices for you folks... and that's never a bad thing.

Most people will only need to buy one set of good chisels in their lifetime - and these will be good candidates. There will be a number of compelling (or not) reasons for people to consider both the products, and the material...

I'm not getting rid of my Bergs, my Mifer's, or my Narex chisels .... and I still like O1 ....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#7

Re: Not me, dude...

david weaver

..i am constantly standing around trying to figure out how I want something to look. Seems if you can figure out how you want something to look, and then if you can figure out how to mark it, you can usually get what you want.

The only time sharpening bugs me is when i'm about 95% done thicknessing the last panel for a project and the jack stops cutting....

... or maybe when some specialty plane iron or an incannel gouge poops and I have to sharpen it - one of those things where sharpening isn't frequent with the tool, nor is it easy.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#8

Re: When you throw out the holteys...

david weaver

.. I'm sure I can clear space on my shelves. I noticed you didn't mention you were keeping the holteys, which i'm extrapolating to you wanting to give them away.

You can drop them off some day that you're down here at a pens game.

(far a the metal goes, like I said above, a choice that holds an edge longer and sharpens as easy or easier than something else is never a bad thing, even if it doesn't really solve a problem for some of us who are already pigs).

I think it might even be local metal you're using, anyway. The two places I'd have thought of in the US would've been some crucible manufacturer and the latrobe steel mill, but I gather from latrobe's literature that they are doing all or some parts of the process for crucible's powdered stuff.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#9

Of course...

david weaver

...I wouldn't be surprised if there were powder metals made in some of the other rust belt places or chicago, those are just the two names I'm aware of.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#10

Re: Of course...

Patrick Gibbons

I have too many chisels. With that said, I have many duplicates. I'm still needing a few things. I'm glad Veritas is raising the bar. I'll probably buy one just out of curiosity. I'll just have to wait and see. Somebody new to our avocation would be remiss if they didn't strongly consider the new metal. It's a pretty sorry situation when new technology is sneered at. When I started down this road in the 90's, the selection was diminishing. I own a lot of things that I wouldn't even look at now. This is a great time to be alive.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#11

Well..

david weaver

..the japanese were making good stuff the whole time.

Back in the '90s, it was just a matter of getting to it without losing an arm and a leg from someone who marked it up hard.

These days, though, we've got folks like stu who bring it to us through a chain with fewer links in it (though that wouldn't have helped in the '90s).

I wouldn't want to see LN or LV quit, either, nor any of the other boutique makers.

I do like that when LV comes out with something, they don't charge the moon for it.

As far as the chisels go, here's my logic. If you want to try one, you should get the whole set. What if you like it, then you'll only have one? Make it a pre-emptive strike instead :b

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#12

Re: Not me, dude...

CStan

I hear you brother David.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#13

Re: Well..

TomD

I don't agree that much on cost. The cost of good sets back in the 80s was not that steep. I find current prices high, but when you consider what the dollar pulls it is probably pretty fair.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#14

Re: The News

TomD

"In thinking about all the current challenges I have in the shop, not one of them is addressed by an edge tool that goes longer between honings. Not by a long shot."

The thing to keep in mind is that neither the threads, nor the ads are the truth. They are basically the news. Having worked partially in public affairs it amazed me how few people understood the idea of news. You could tell it bothered them it wasn't happy, or slanted their way, or didn't cover topics that were more important, in their minds. But no, the news is what is new. Knowing what is new is a basic human need, since I guess we all fear missing out on something that might literally get us killed, like not hearing the call to lifeboats.

In this case, these chisels are new, and they answer the question, or might, "I need chisels, what should I buy?" People buy chisels every day. The people for whom this information is irrelevant, are probably people who would self-describe as "I own chisels".

Basically none of the heat is really applicable if you are looking for chisels, and the issues are of no interest if you already own chisels. The only weirdness is that the most knowledgeable commentators normally come from the group that self-describes, as "I wouldn't take another chisel if you gave it to me free". Because who wants to hear a guy talk about his chisels if he has never even owned a set that would be the last set he would ever buy? So we have a quandry, people who need chisels don't know squat, and people who don't need new chisels and are fed up even hearing about them, but have all the info.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#15

Re: Well..

david weaver

Things were probably cheaper in the 80s because of the yen/dollar exchange. It was about 265 in 1985.

By the late 90s, it was about 130.

Back in the 80s, folks could probably go get tools and bring them back and really ream you on margin and still give you a deal you could tolerate.

I think stu has ouchi chisels for about $950 or something for a set of ten. That's like super bargain price, and probably in line with the late 90s plus exchange.

I recall someone telling me about 6 years ago that I would do well to buy a set of ouchi chisels, but the only place I knew of who had them was tomohito iida (who generally is full service in terms of offering nice packages of stuff, but has very high prices), and they were about $800. Back then, the exchange rate was 120 or so. Now they are 1400, and they might come with a doodad or two that stu doesn't throw in for free, but not $450 worth. Folks seem to like tomohito, but i'm not his target market, i'm a bargain hunter in the world of things I shouldn't be buying in the first place, but I usually get stuff cheap in relative terms.

(i never did buy the ouchis, i couldn't find them cheap anywhere, and I found some nice white #2 chisels in the interim...bargain hunting, I guess I generally get whatever hits the bottom of the ocean floor)

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#16

I did not sneer

Ron in Kokomo

But ...I am also a golfer and I get just a little suspicious that the club makers come out every year with clubs that are better than last years. It is not the quality of my clubs that keeps me from shooting par.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#17

Re: I did not sneer

TomD

Golf is a lot different from the serious end of the hand tool world. There virtually isn't a serious end of the golf spectrum. I work with serious score oriented stroke play pros, but not touring type pros. And it drives me crazy keeping them focused when they play so many outings that are not stroke play and the whole scoring thing goes out the window.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#18

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

Curt Putnam

Well, I'm the new-ish guy that needs good chisels. I'm highly tempted by the O1 chisels that Veritas has just released. But before I jump, I want to play with some LN and Blue Spruce chisels. I would throw some Japanese chisels into the mix but I don't think there are any stores stocking comparable brands within a 100 mile radius of LA (east & south quarters - not sure about Craftsman Studios.) Whenever it was pre-'06 that I tried the LN chisels I was unimpressed because they felt as they they were not there. Well, in those days, I thought I knew something. Now I know better. If LV shows up at WIA - Pasadena with their QR tail vise (Benchcrafted is a no-show) and the new chisels they could really damage my budget which is aimed at chisels and bench stuff for now.

Derek Cohen has said that the new steel is as easy to hone as is A2 and lasts about twice as long. That being the case, it seems to me to be foolishness to settle for something lesser for bench & mortise chisels. When the time comes that I decide to buy new plane blades (I am hugely impressed with the 2" O1 LV iron & CB) I will undoubtedly try the new steel.

I would not expect a wholesale adoption. There will be an initial rush - as for any new, long awaited product. Then there will be a slow, steady penetration over time unless something newer and better comes along.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#19

Steel and Tools

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Don't forget the obvious - that steel and tools are two separate items. If you are already stocked for tools, then you will not be planning to add more, regardless of the steel composition of the new tools.

On the other hand, you may decide the new tool is an upgrade, or the new steel is an important time saver.

I do not plan to replace all my blades with PM-Vlll just because it is better (and it is). That would be silly. However, the next time I purchase a blade, it will definitely be made of PM-Vlll steel. It would be silly not to do so.

I only have first hand experience of one PM-Vlll plane blade, which is used in a Veritas Small BU Smoother. This was put through a great deal of testing about 12 months ago. On the basis of this I can state that, using Pro Shaptons, the PM-Vlll blade honed about as quickly as an A2 equivalent, and lasted about twice its duration planing abrasive Jarrah boards (yes, I stood there counting shavings).

I have not used PM-Vlll in chisels. The PM-lll was a late entry into the chisel testing conducted nearly 2 years ago. Steels included M4 and 3V, and the PM-Vlll was chosen above these. I did, however, use the steel with a 25 degree bevel to shoot Jarrah endgrain later on. It held up very well. According to Rob Lee it can be used at 15 degrees ... which would make for an interesting paring chisel!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#20

Re: I did not sneer

CStan

Damn good analogy. I play with a set of Titleist DCI 990s that cost a thousand dollars for eight irons in the late 1990s, which is about the same price you'd pay today for a set of "this season's" irons by any big maker. They're great irons and can be had on EBay for about $150 - $200 per set. These are cast stainless steel and the grooves can be refreshed without messing up the plating like on a set of forged irons.

The Japanese tool aficionados have a corollary in golf - some swear by the soft forgings from Miura and they command high prices. I've hit them and they are buttery, but the skill is still with the golfer. You won't score better unless you're swinging better. Period. A banana slice or a duck hook might feel better off the Miuras, but you will still be in the rough.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#21

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

CStan

I'm curious - do you not have any chisels now at all?

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#22

Re: Steel and Tools

CStan

I think I read somewhere that Ian Kirby has been using the same set of Blue Chips for over twenty years, something like that. I'll try to find the source. I suppose there is something to be said for sheer familiarity with one's kit -- good points, bad points, quirks and inconsistencies.

This is not to say that a Lee Valley shouldn't innovate. They should and I'm glad they do. I'm a customer.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#23

Shut your festering gob, you nit!

James Watriss

Your type really makes me puke! You vacuous, toffee nosed, malodorous PERVERT!

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#24

Re: I did not sneer

david weaver

We share theories on golf clubs. I do have a newerish driver, but it is 4 generations old now, and I got it cheap.

My irons are mizuno mx 23s, and they are forged, but I don't care that much about that. I cared about them not having much offset and being cheap (they were about $150 used).

I also don't go out and buy expensive balls made to be compressed by 120 mile an hour swings, either, because no matter how many years I swing a golf club, I'm 20 miles an hour short of that on a good day.

Repeating the same swing and following the hogan principles (as I am a lifetime hook fighter) is plenty entertainment and challenge enough. I do see a LOT of brand new clubs at the range, though, with guys who should've spent their time and money figuring out how to not do the same things 20 handicappers have done for the last 75 years.

Re: Might as well start the LV PM-V11 Thread

#25

Re: Shut your festering gob, you nit!

david weaver

Finally, someone read the last sentence :)