Re: Article
John in NM
"A. Far more research has been done in the last 7 years since the article was written so before it's relied upon, it should be updated and brought current. People rely upon "old science and results" at their own risk."
Well, lay it on us. I'm sure we will all be interested to see this new pool of work. We all rely on "old science and results" daily, the risk is not in the age but in the correct interpretation.
"B. The article itself recites that the team's findings have been disputed by other researchers (discounting the school childrens' project confirmations). Before making a value judgment on the continued validity of the 2005 results, I'd have to see the other studies mentioned together with more current research."
Who? The Cliver article in the link is widely cited, I've never seen much of a rebuttal of it. However I've not looked for one specifically, I would be interested in seeing other research on the subject. I will take the liberty of pointing out that you are indeed making a value judgement of the 2005 results, just not in so many words. Say what you mean.
"C. But most importantly, the UC Davis team was concerned with cutting boards, not primary countertops, upon which no research was done, nor does the study indicate whether the wood boards used were raw wood, or partially (or fully) finished with any of the compounds being discussed in this thread. We don't know, therefore, whether the results mentioned in the article have any application to wood countertops at all. Merely inferring that "wood is wood" without more information is neither sound reasoning nor good science."
Quite the contrary, that is the least important point. Given the discussion of how one must look below the wood's surface to find bacteria, I will speculate that the wood is effectively unfinished. I would expect their published articles (rather than this synopsis) outlines their prep methods, as they do refer to comparing new and used wood surfaces. I have not read their full articles, usually journal articles are not available without a subscription.
The results of this article are quite applicable to wood counter tops. How the wood is finished is a wrinkle to be sure - and indeed, I will bet the heavier a plastic finish is applied, the less sanitary the surface will be. "Wood is wood" is hardly an inference. It is a rather sloppy way of saying that material properties may be considered fairly uniform in similar applications. You are correct in that it is not good science - but the Cliver article does appear to me to be good science - and one of his conclusions is that the sanitary properties of wood are fairly uniform regardless of species.
"Easy example: Is it a surprise that some organisms find linseed oil coatings a tasty feast? Apply it to part of a fully shaded deck and watch how long it takes for various green and black molds to colonize the deck surfaces with the linseed."
Doesn't surprise me in the least, in fact I would certainly expect it based on how microbes are used in cleaning up oil spills and biotic action can be a real problem in long term storage of diesel fuel. I would be more surprised if mold growth occurred months later - after the oil has polymerized. However, this has no relevance to the discussion of wood properties, so while it might be an easy example, it is neither a scientific or a good one. Sorry.