New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Wood kitchen counters

Posts

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#26

Article

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

A. Far more research has been done in the last 7 years since the article was written so before it's relied upon, it should be updated and brought current. People rely upon "old science and results" at their own risk.

B. The article itself recites that the team's findings have been disputed by other researchers (discounting the school childrens' project confirmations). Before making a value judgment on the continued validity of the 2005 results, I'd have to see the other studies mentioned together with more current research.

C. But most importantly, the UC Davis team was concerned with cutting boards, not primary countertops, upon which no research was done, nor does the study indicate whether the wood boards used were raw wood, or partially (or fully) finished with any of the compounds being discussed in this thread. We don't know, therefore, whether the results mentioned in the article have any application to wood countertops at all. Merely inferring that "wood is wood" without more information is neither sound reasoning nor good science.

Easy example: Is it a surprise that some organisms find linseed oil coatings a tasty feast? Apply it to part of a fully shaded deck and watch how long it takes for various green and black molds to colonize the deck surfaces with the linseed.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#27

Re: Article

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It sounds like you don't have any idea at all what could be wrong with the UC Davis report. I think that current research finds more danger in living in a sterile environment than one brimming with bacteria and fungi.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#28

Counter top mineralogy

Bill Tindall

Much of the Indian stuff is the result of India crashing into Asia. Made some gneiss rock. (ha, ha) I love telling them, "that's not granite". Look see the Kyanite crystals, etc, etc. Eyes glaze over. There is a distributor north of Greenville, SC. Visiting their slabs is like a geology field trip.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#29

Re: The problem..

david weaver

..in general for the overall population is being introduced to something you're not used to and especially if a large amount is introduced at one time.

I thought the study was saying that there were nasties in the wood, but they generally don't replicate and they confine themselves to the netherregions in the wood, so the study itself doesn't seem to indict the countertop (admittedly, I didn't read it because it'll never affect my lifestyle either way).

I did read an interesting study last year that mentioned that most of the diarrhea and vomiting issues folks have dismissed as a "24 hour flu" were actually mild cases of food poisoning. Have you ever heard of an actual flu virus that is transient and gone in 24 hours?

So, I'm sure that there are problems, but to me they are not big enough to warrant scorched earth operating room standards in any part of my house.

I have also learned as the spouse of someone who works in a health care environment where there are a lot of people recovering from catastrophic wounds or accidents - that seeing a lot of what really are very low percentage probability events, just because the volume of them comes through you, creates a very skewed view of how safe things are or aren't. Pretty much any time I mention that I want to do something, my wife can come up with a patient who came through the clinic as the result of some activity that's either the same or similar. I can't get through to her that she sees the outliers most of the time, and my odds are pretty good.

So what I'm saying is if there is an attorney like earlier in this thread, one who specializes in this kind of thing, they will tend to view the problem as what's in front of them rather than as .01% of wooden countertop users.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#30

Re: Article

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Well, Warren, it sounds like you chose to take the article as the final word on the issue of the cleanliness of wood countertops, which is, of course, your prerogative, even though the team stated that the results should NOT be so applied.

I do hope that you clean your counters in the same way that the UC Davis team cleaned their test boards.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#31

Re: Article

John in NM

"A. Far more research has been done in the last 7 years since the article was written so before it's relied upon, it should be updated and brought current. People rely upon "old science and results" at their own risk."

Well, lay it on us. I'm sure we will all be interested to see this new pool of work. We all rely on "old science and results" daily, the risk is not in the age but in the correct interpretation.

"B. The article itself recites that the team's findings have been disputed by other researchers (discounting the school childrens' project confirmations). Before making a value judgment on the continued validity of the 2005 results, I'd have to see the other studies mentioned together with more current research."

Who? The Cliver article in the link is widely cited, I've never seen much of a rebuttal of it. However I've not looked for one specifically, I would be interested in seeing other research on the subject. I will take the liberty of pointing out that you are indeed making a value judgement of the 2005 results, just not in so many words. Say what you mean.

"C. But most importantly, the UC Davis team was concerned with cutting boards, not primary countertops, upon which no research was done, nor does the study indicate whether the wood boards used were raw wood, or partially (or fully) finished with any of the compounds being discussed in this thread. We don't know, therefore, whether the results mentioned in the article have any application to wood countertops at all. Merely inferring that "wood is wood" without more information is neither sound reasoning nor good science."

Quite the contrary, that is the least important point. Given the discussion of how one must look below the wood's surface to find bacteria, I will speculate that the wood is effectively unfinished. I would expect their published articles (rather than this synopsis) outlines their prep methods, as they do refer to comparing new and used wood surfaces. I have not read their full articles, usually journal articles are not available without a subscription.

The results of this article are quite applicable to wood counter tops. How the wood is finished is a wrinkle to be sure - and indeed, I will bet the heavier a plastic finish is applied, the less sanitary the surface will be. "Wood is wood" is hardly an inference. It is a rather sloppy way of saying that material properties may be considered fairly uniform in similar applications. You are correct in that it is not good science - but the Cliver article does appear to me to be good science - and one of his conclusions is that the sanitary properties of wood are fairly uniform regardless of species.

"Easy example: Is it a surprise that some organisms find linseed oil coatings a tasty feast? Apply it to part of a fully shaded deck and watch how long it takes for various green and black molds to colonize the deck surfaces with the linseed."

Doesn't surprise me in the least, in fact I would certainly expect it based on how microbes are used in cleaning up oil spills and biotic action can be a real problem in long term storage of diesel fuel. I would be more surprised if mold growth occurred months later - after the oil has polymerized. However, this has no relevance to the discussion of wood properties, so while it might be an easy example, it is neither a scientific or a good one. Sorry.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#32

Ellis Walentine

Knock wood

Ellis Walentine

Hi Moses,

I just installed a birds-eye maple counter top as part of my recent kitchen remodel. I must say that I used Minwax spar urethane -- four slightly thinned coats wiped on and sanded between coats. I normally hate the plastic look that urethane imparts, but this stuff sanded out smooth as a baby's butt, and it offers the protection from abrasion that I wanted. I normally prefer Waterlox for functional surfaces for all the reasons others have outlined here. But, since we have a lot of stoneware, I knew that the soft Waterlox film would be scratched up in no time. Plus, we made the decision that we would not use the countertops as cutting surfaces, because we wanted a more refined appearance than just an oiled butcher block look. So far, I'm very pleased with the look and feel of the tops, and the varnish protects them from iron/tannin interactions, moisture, food stains, etc. and makes them easy to clean with a soapy sponge.

Everybody's mileage varies on this one, but I vote for a film finish in every case, unless you want the funky utilitarian look.

Ellis


Re: Wood kitchen counters

#33

My wife rolls her eyes...

John in NM

When I point out the alteration mineralogy in our porch table top. I wish I'd seen such a clear example when I was in college, the subject would have made a lot more sense :D

What amazes me is how cheap this stuff is now. Industrial diamond has come a very long way in 30 years.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#34

Amen

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Such an easy ( and beautiful) way to increase food safety.

:)

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#35

David Barnett

The Cliver article w/tested species *LINK*

David Barnett

"Cutting Boards of Plastic and Wood Contaminated Experimentally with Bacteria"

Cliver's work is also covered in:

http://www.amazon.com/Principles-Sanitation-Science-Series-ebook/dp/B001QCXWAG

Quoted from the review by Scott Martin, Dept. of Food Science and Human Nutrition, University of Illinois Journal of Food Science Education Volume 5 Issue 2 April 2006

"Topics covered include those that are required for a food plant sanitation course: government rules and regulations, biosecurity, microorganisms, food contamination, employee hygiene, HACCP, quality assurance, cleaning and sanitizing, sanitation equipment, pest control, and chapters that cover specific food types (low-moisture food, dairy, meat and poultry, seafood, fruit and vegetables, beverage, food service) and management and sanitation. The topics are well-described and clearly explained. This text could be used to supplement courses that deal with specific topics such as meat science or fruit and vegetable processing. The appropriate chapters could be employed in discussions of sanitation in these facilities. I highly recommend this text."

For enhanced sanitation solutions, NYT quotes Dr. Gerba in "Using Gadgets to Zap Germs"*:

“Cutting boards are just terrible,” Dr. Gerba said, by way of example. “There’s 200 times more bacteria on a cutting board than a toilet seat.”

Handheld UV wands are now available to use on food preparation surfaces besides cutting boards (best on non-porous), such as the Verilux CleanWave Sanitizing Wand.

http://www.verilux.com/uv-products/uvc-sanitizing-wand

Although I can't provide attribution on the fly, the most recent work I've read upholds and validates Cliver's findings as of 2009 or 2010, as I recall.

*http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/02/garden/using-gadgets-to-zap-germs.html?pagewanted=all


Cutting Boards ... Contaminated Experimentally

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#36

Re: The Cliver article w/tested species

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

the interesting take away for me as it pertains to Moses's original post is that the aplication of oil or the un-named proprietary finish had no effect on limiting water absorption or bacteria recovery.

On a personal note I wish other cleaning methods had been evaluated. I have never cleaned my wood cutting boards or my wood prep table with bleach. I have always used a mixture of white vinegar and coarse salt and scrubbed it with a stainless steel pot scrubber.

Robin

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#37

According to Dr. Cliver

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You may have wasted a lot of salt and vinegar, Robin; a little soap and water should be enough for your wood cutting boards.

I clean my wood carving board the same way (soap and water followed by rock salt and vinegar), and won't be changing my routine.

Of course, my clients can't risk what folks at home do. Their cutting surfaces are not wood and "boards" are run through a sterilization process to 240°F after each lot of vegetables is processed, all in accordance with their HAACP plan, and all food contact surfaces are cleaned with hot water and bleach at the end of each day.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#38

What is the advantage of rock salt and vinegar?

Tom Colligan

. . . in cleaning wood, as in a cutting board? Would it help an old tool just bought off the 'bay? :) Thanks, Tom.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#39

Re: sanitation

Edward in Vancouver

A few notes regarding sanitation taken from almost 30 years of foodservice experience in three continents.

1) Whatever the local health inspector says, is what I follow. If the H.I. gives my maple cutting boards (reserved only for carving roast beef at buffets) the "hairy eyeball", they go in a storage locker.

2) A nylon cutting board is my choice in terms of cost, sanitation, and maintainence. Basically, I toss the thing in a commercial; d/washer and be done with it. When badly scarred, it goes through the thickness planer, and when badly stained (beets!) it gets pickled overnight in bleach and then run through the d/washer.

3) A counter top is not a food preparation surface . A food prep surface may be a cutting board, mixing bowl, device (food processor, mixer, etc) that is easily sanitized. Lord knows how many staff I've given uh... scoldings to... who've used the countertop as a mixing bowl or cutting board.

4) That being said, I have over 14 linear feet of wood countertop in my commerciial kitchen. A minimum of two inches of wood thickness provides a stable surface to thump and bang stuff around. Commercial s/s tables are flimsy, and laminate topped mdf prone to chips and flimsy-ness as well as sagging and moisture absorption in commercial settings.

In short, I like and use wood countertops but will not use wood cutting boards in a commercial setting.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#40

Re: Salt and Vinegar

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Have been the standard way butcher's blocks have been cleaned for centuries. The vinegar is, naturally, an acidifier which creates an environment in the wood that odors (actually microbes) don't like. Salt has been used for thousands of years as a preservative for meat and still is, and the course salt worked like scoring powder to remove muscle fibers (meat) from the wood grain. This cleaning regimen for butcher's blocks and wood cutting boards was adopted and used in health codes for restaurants and commercial food preparation firms for many years. May still be in places.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#41

Re: Salt and Vinegar

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Salt and vinegar have been the standard way butcher's blocks have been cleaned for centuries

Do you have any documentation for this statement?

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#42

Absolutely Not

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Just anecdotal stories from my grandfathers and grand uncle, one, who was a successful butcher in New York and learned his trade from his father and grandfather "back in The Old Country," from the other grandfather and his brother who were sheep ranchers in Wyoming and also ran a side business of processing game taken by "them Eastern Dudes", and, lastly, from conversations with a retired health department inspector who was going to be testifying as an expert witness for my client in a Federal litigation.

So, Warren, please feel free to go dig up documentation to prove my information to be bogus, and have a nice day. :)

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#44

Re: sanitation

Tony - Memphis

I took classes at the Culinary Institute of Memphis. His counters were oak strip flooring made for tractor trailer floors! Quite druable and nice and heavy. He kept bottles of bleach solution around to clean them. He made the point that the health inspector loved the setup. I don't recall if he used cutting boards or not.

I took a cooking class from a local chef that sold us on a product called Chop Chop Mat or somethign like that. Basically, it is a thin sheet of ??? plastic. Its great because after you chop, you can roll the edges up to pour into a pot or pan. It then can be washed in the dishwasher. They are meant to be tossed after a few years. Ours have held up quite well.

Ellis, your counter looks beautiful.

Tony

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#45

Re: Absolutely Not

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We have had lots of guys on this forum insist that the way their grandfathers or their uncles worked wood was how it was done in the 18th century. Anecdotes from one's grandfather do not support statements about centuries of standard practice.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#46

Re: "standard"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is hereby withdrawn as I very much doubt that any document such as you demand exists; especially since the butcher's trade and practices were handed down, father-to-son, master-to-apprentice, over all those centuries through practical, hands-on experience rather than reading it in some book or manual.

Hence my statement can be neither proven nor disproven by extrinsic evidence, and in your mind, Warren, must, therefore, be false, right?

Nice friendly group on this board.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#47

Re: "standard"

TomD

I wouldn't worry about it. For some people the claim they know how something was done historically would be pretty exciting as a side issue. Not necessarily as aggressive as it sounds. During the 18th century there were books on almost everything, and there may well be much earlier books also, if woodworking is any measure. The info is probably out there.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#48

Re: Second the Waterlox

TomD

With asian boats it might be more the wood than the oil...

One thing with oils like walnut is that if they come with antioxidants then they won't dry properly. Vitamin E is a common one.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#49

Except...

John in NM

Butchering has hardly enjoyed a long history of "gentleman's interest" as woodworking has done :D

But getting to the dis-infecting question, vinegar has a noted and demonstrable antibacterial effect that at least one study has shown to be enhanced by the presence of salt and reduced by the presence of glucose. I've only read the abstract of that study, not having a subscription to whatever journal in which it was published.

Given vinegar's long use in the preserving of food, I would imagine that the antibacterial properties were well known to butchers, though I have not gone looking for historical references either. I would guess a history buff could find one fairly easily. Kinda smells good too :D, though lemon smells better - I believe citric acid has a similar effect combined with salt. I'll have to remember to use it on the cutting board next time we whack a bird :D

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#50

Friendly group...

John in NM

I would bet I'm partly to blame for this, and for what it's worth I'm sorry about it. With the earlier postings I felt the line between objective and subjective information was being needlessly muddled, and yes, I do tend to find that a bit irritating. It probably shows.

I would say that you are probably quite correct that vinegar and salt has long been used as a cleaning product by butchers. Before bleach and other modern disinfectants, they would have had to use something, and the stuff does work. Funny how humans have figured out what works over the years, often long before it can be explained through a verifiable theory.