New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Wood kitchen counters

Posts

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#51

The way we operate "show me the proof"

david weaver

Part of this is just a cultural jab we make at each other on here. Hopefully Mark doesn't take it to heart. You can say whatever you want to say on here, but if someone doesn't like it, that's the first thing we all say, right? "Show me proof of that".

There are definitely some who say it more than others, but it's just a cultural thing here, and not a personal insult like it can seem when you think you're otherwise just sharing information someone might find useful.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#52

Re: What is the advantage of rock salt and vinegar

Schtoo

Common salt (sodium chloride) and vinegar (acetic acid)?

Can you say "hydrochloric acid'?

Granted a very mild concentration, but still there's likely something to it and the parts have less effect than the sum of them.

Not swinging one way or the other. I use bleach after soap and water to wash chopping boards...

Stu.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#53

Re: Except...

TomD

"Butchering has hardly enjoyed a long history of "gentleman's interest" as woodworking has done :D"

Prove it!

There were a lot of books seemingly made for the trade during the period There are a ton of shoemaking books, for instance and they in no way resemble Ornamental turning texts.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#54

Re: Except...

John in NM

Yeah, I don't doubt there is material out there... the idea of a "gent's cleaver" just struck me so funny :D

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#55

Well yes....

John in NM

I suppose the trick is in how one says it, and perhaps acknowledging that it could have been said a bit better if they miss the mark :D

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#56

Thanks, Mark.


Re: Wood kitchen counters

#57

Re: Except...

david weaver

Having grown up in the rural areas, which is where most people were 200 years ago, I can vouch that more than half of the population was involved in agricultural pursuits (at least in my area) and they did the butchering themselves - all the way up to WWII, and even after that for a lot of folks who didn't have much money but had some land.

What they used to sterilize their cooking boards, I don't know. I do know that they used knives and tools that most of us would consider unusable, because they didn't want to spend the money for better stuff.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#58

This forum is misnamed

Bob Hackett

Something like "The department of derailment" might be more appropriate.

Someone asks a question about wood countertop construction and when we finally arrive at the end of the thread we are having long arguments on how to verify if the combination of vinegar and salt is, in fact, a historically effective disinfectant included in the formal, cross generational, training of butchers. :D

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#59

David Barnett

Play-by-play Dielectical Nonsequiturization

David Barnett

A question posed was whether oil or wax,

Might keep a wooden counter looking clean,

To hide not deep and brutal cleaver's whacks,

Just kitchen use that one might call routine.

Mandell branches into sanitation,

Your trusting wood is "dangerously wrong".

Wood deserves a blanket condemnation?

From what I've read, that's prematurely strong.

Then on we go to vinegar and salt,

A standard thoughout history, Mark states,

But Warren wants some proof, he spots a fault,

Then Mark withdraws -- that argument abates.

From Waterlox we range to abattoir,

That's how we Wood Centralians chew the gras.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#60

Try hanging out on the coast of Maine

Bob Hackett

with my brother Bill who has a PHD in volcanic geology.

As a person who hold a PHD of his own in Downeast humor people within earshot of our discussions tend to either move closer or move away quickly depending on who`s doing the talking at the moment.

I have to admit that spending time with Bill is one of my favorite ways to spend summer days and has been the inspiration for many of my better blog posts, articles and short stories. He`s "wicked fun" to be around and a real good sport when it comes to putting up with a smartass like me. :D

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#61

I`m speechless

Bob Hackett

And that`s a rare thing, just ask my wife.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#62

UFFDA!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

and other Norwegian phrases my father used to utter! I am utterly in awe!

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#63

David Barnett

Free-ranging topics...

David Barnett

...foster creative discourse, but the sausage-making's there for all to see, isn't it?

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#64

Even though some will wish they hadn`t. :^)


Re: Wood kitchen counters

#65

The microbiology of it all

Bill Tindall

A high salt content turns osmosis on it head and the bug guts spill out, not in. Soap accomplishes the same fate.

Many nasty critters can not survive in low pH. Think picked meat (in fact I have some pickled heart muscle aging as we speak.

However, there are bugs that can weather high salt (no idea if any are toxic) and others that thrive at low pH. But, none can stand a dose of chlorine bleach.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#66

Re: The microbiology of it all

TomD

"Think picked meat (in fact I have some pickled heart muscle aging as we speak. "

Should we be concerned?

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#67

Good question but not mine.....

Bill Tindall

......they belonged to a lamb and a deer. After a couple of weeks with some spices they have become quite tasty