New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Wood kitchen counters

Posts

Wood kitchen counters

#1

Moses Yoder

Wood kitchen counters

Moses Yoder

I am designing my kitchen remodel so I can figure out what it costs. I started this a while back so I think I have to finish the estimate before I go on to my clock. I went through the on-line estimator at Home Depot to calculate the cost of granite counters and came up with $6800. Truth be told, I want the total remodel to cost about that much or maybe a little more, not more than $10K. I discussed it with my wife and we can get wood butcherblock tops in cherry for $13 per square foot, about 1/6th the cost of the granite. I can get them CNC routed so I can do neat stuff with them like dovetailing the mitered corners and adding maybe a granite inlay where we set the dishes to dry etc.

When we finish wood counters now at my day job, we use Arm-R-Seal finish. It is a film finish though and my kitchen is going to be a Shaker style and arts and crafts type. Wood wille be select clear brown hickory for the frames and rustic knotty hickory panels, finished natural probably with a 10 sheen. The glossy Arm-R-Seal finish just isn't really going to fit I don't think. I finished some cutting boards with mineral oil and beeswax combo, and am thinking of doing the same on our kitchen counters. I am wondering how you think this would hold up to dirt and water, but am thinking I don't really mind if the counters show they were used over time. So I am wondering what you think of wood counters with just a light wax finish, or what you recommend for finish.

I know I could do cement counters that would be bomb proof, look great, and cheap. My wife refuses to even consider them; she is adamantly opposed to the idea of cement for some reason. We have a beautiful cement counter in our showroom and she refuses to even look at it.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#2

Re: Wood kitchen counters

david weaver

Just my opinion, but I would go with a lower gloss version of something that you know that works well.

With endgrain presented (even if not) there's always going to be something like blueberry pie filling or some other such thing that gets on the counter and you might not like the stain from it.

If customers are happy with the gloss arm r seal, then I might go for a lower gloss version of it or run felt and FF pumice or something similar over it to tone it down.

I don't mind stains on countertops, but usually there's one or two that occur and that penetrate that you really wish you didn't have.

I have only ever finished one countertop, and for a friend - it was 8/4 maple side grain. We used shellac under WB lacquer. That's how he wanted it, that's how we did it. It still looks great, but it looks little too commercial to me, and his wife requested granite in the one high-stain high use spot around the sink (so it was really only a half job).

I'm not a fan of the granite movement that seems to be approvable for people to take out a bank loan on. Makes no sense to me for someone to spend a lot of after tax income on such a small area, and it seems there there is no income too low these days for someone to say "i'm getting granite in my kitchen". I like the way it looks, but $7k for a counter top is toxic retirement-delaying gick.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#3

Re: Wood kitchen counters

TomD

It is hard to say on the wood. I'm that somewhere there are some country counter tops that have been worn down from centuries of use, and it all played out fabulously. But I think in general it would be a disappointment. I know wooden bowls are ok, and wooden kitchen tables.

If it was me I would do a very organic top, of really clean wood, and probably disc sand a lot of wear into it, and make it nearly one piece and use the oil and wax. I think people would think that is upper end. I would not have any knots.

Or I would engineer it totally with an epoxy finish, so it looked good all the time. Boatbuilder approach, zero movement.

Third option would be to use scrap granite. There is a lot of this around cheap in the form of surface plates, and doubtless other stuff. My local tool store sells 12 x18 pieces of granite for 40 bucks, I am sure there is a cheaper local source in the US, Grizzly tools maybe. You can glue those into islands, or inserts. These are 2 inches thick.

The trick with wood is to think really architectural, industrial, not just an alternative to existing treatments. People see through wooden options like framed tile counter tops that just say cheapness. But give them something they haven't seen before and they may be impressed.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#4

$90/ ft with your connections?

Bill Tindall

Unless you are choosing some exceptionally exotic rock that price is way high, at least by our local standards. You should be able to swing an architect/builder price from some shop for a third less.

We had two cherry food preparation tops in previous house which I oiled from time to time and they became very dark. Held up well for 20 years.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#5

Re: $90/ ft with your connections?

TomD

I don't think the problem is whether the wood will hold up, I think the problem is whether the cook wants to do the maintenance, is bugged when putting a bill or cookbook on the surface, and it comes back wet or oily. It's like having HCS knives vs SS. Some people would consider the stainless knives to be crap, and would be willing to put up with the many characteristics of HCS knives, others would rust them out in the dishwasher, and go ape when they left iron marks everywhere. It's like metal vs wooden planes. I think while metal is obviously fully functional and more modern, it doesn't hold a candle to wood. Someone else would not have their brain working that way. I think wooden planes have actual net advantages, I am not too sure naturally finished wooden kitchen surfaces really do. I think they probably aren't legal in most commercial kitchens (?), while wooden planes are absolutely necessary in certain woodworking settings.

Apparently wood is a pretty hot trend in some auxiliary kitchen surfaces.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#6

Cherry

roninkokomo

I much prefer it to granite. I think if you saturate the end grain with mineral oils and beeswax and re treat it every years. You should be fine.

Ron

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#7

Re: hard maple.......

George in early Summer Lowell, Mich.

even side grain is indestructible. It is a light color though, which may not work with your color scheme.

Work safe,

George

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Ikea

Jim in Burlington ON

I would never install wooden tops unless the house really suited them. Ikea sells very economical wooden counter tops. The price you were quoted for granite is way high.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#9

Re: Ikea

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

The IKEA countertops are a disaster. As soon as you remove the saranwrap, they begin the drying process, and self-destruct. They are not properly seasoned, and the glue is inadequate, especially if you need a cutout to install a sink or stovetop.

Sugar maple butcher-block from Bally Block is a lot more stable, and will serve you many years.

For a finish, I would use WaterLox original (not the new low VOC stuff that California shoves down the throat of the rest of us). Easy to apply, easy to repair, plenty of protection without the high refractive index (look of plastic) of polyurinate. When I say "protection" I mean it has the right balance of flexibility and toughness and resistance to water and stains and knife cuts.

The main problem I have with granite is that, like a porcelain sink, it much too easily chips your china and crystal and much too easily dulls your knives. Granite is for surface plates.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#10

Re: Ikea

Edward in Vancouver

I've got almost 40 linear feet of Ikea Beech countertop in my cafe. That doesn't include the eight 24" round and 24" x 24" table tops I made for the cafe 5 Years now and no issues with warping.

A couple of problems with wood countertops at home, though. The first is, "selected" family members will treat the countertop as a cutting board, and cut directly on it.

The second is, the area around the sink. At work I treat the tops with the Ikea stuff, which I'm pretty sure is beeswax and mineral oil, but that sink doesn't get as much abuse as the home kitchen sink.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#11

Re: Ikea

TomD

Is the beeswax and mineral oil well priced?

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#12

Re:Sellected family members

TomD

Wow, shivers. I have a few of those family members. Originally I was just thinking of the commitment level of the principles. But others in the family are the type who would feed it into the gas stove if they just needed a little more output...

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#13

wet and oily not necessary

Bill Tindall

I tried the mineral oil and indeed "wet and oily" was the result. So, in spite of all the persons that have said it doesn't work, for 40 years we have oiled the surfaces of our "butcher blocks" with corn oil or similar. When exposed to air it partially sets up and doesn't leave the surface oily.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#14

Moses Yoder

Re:Cutting on the counter

Moses Yoder

I am at a stage in my life where I am trying to think differently from normal people. I understand if I put a toxic finish on the counter you wouldn't want to cut on the counter because it would make my food toxic. But if I just have the beeswax and mineral oil, why wouldn't I cut directly on the counter? Because it would leave marks?

I find it amusing in the kitchens we build the owners mostly put in 60" Wolf ranges for 6K or something outrageous then they don't have time to cook so they stop by McDonalds on the way home for dinner. Or they pop a pre-made pizza in the oven. I would rather die than live like that.

I am liking Sir Duffield's idea of the waterlox finish maybe buffed and waxed, but then I wouldn't be able to cut directly on the counter.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#15

some practical experience

Bill Tindall




This top is maple and 20 years old.

In each of the last two houses we lived in I glued up butcher block tops for food preparation that flanked the stove on each side. We use these surfaces for food preparation- everything from cutting up animals (did a lamb in this surface last night) to kneading bread to chopping vegetables. For heavy duty cutting and chopping we add a cutting board to the top, which I run through the thickness planer every 10 years of so.

Depending on what has been done the tops are scraped(after kneading), wiped, or washed with dilute bleach( animal disassembly). When they look dry they get coated with what ever cooking oil is at hand.

The first house had cherry tops. They darkened to almost black.

I wish I had a Viking Stove for my home made pizza making but we don't have gas where we live. Many crusts have been prepped on the top in the picture.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#16

PS

Bill Tindall

for other kitchen activities we like our rock (in this case Indian Gneiss, few of the rocks used for tops are granite) tops. Looks good, easy to maintain, impervious.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#17

Re: Cherry

Patrick Gibbons

When dry, tung oil is food safe. Walnut oil is also and it cures as well, unlike many oils. Mineral oil isn't the only option.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#18

Second the Waterlox

Bob Hackett

Asian boatbuilders have been using Tung oil for centuries to seal and protect wooden boats. Hard to argue with long term success like that.

Cherry will darken noticeably in any sunlit areas leaving you with two tone counters. If you don`t seal it completely any alkaline liquid that penetrates the wood is likely to leave a deep stain.

Beech and Maple are more durable and proven performers in the kitchen, bakery and butcher shops around the world.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#19

I tend to like rock too...

John in NM

Can't remember the sq foot price, but my impression was it was about 20% more than custom laminate, well worth the price I thought. Can't remember ever having any of the troubles people list with stone, stuff is about as good as it gets for a counter top.

I love going and talking to the salesmen, their knowledge of rocks is slim to none, so I hear some really funny stuff (funny to a geologist anyhow :D )

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#20

In general...

John in NM

Cured resins tend to be inert and non-toxic. Of course you should use something with which you are comfortable, but just because a liquid finish contains a petroleum distillate does not make it toxic in perpetuity.

Personally, I would go with the Waterlox. You could try one of the Sutherland Welles tung oils, I believe they are un-thinned (no personal experience with them though). Of course, the thinners are part of what makes Waterlox so easy to use.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#21

Sanitation

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Gents:

I'll jump in here because of the issue that is becoming of increasing importance, which is food safety and cross-contamination during meal preparation. With the increasing incidence of bio-contamination of all types of food, animal and vegetable, food preparation surfaces need to be readily capable of proper cleaning and disinfecting between uses, especially multiple uses, to prevent cross-contamination. This means that any surface you use and any finish you apply must hold up the those cleaning procedures. Last year's wide-spread outbreak of serious illness and deaths from listeria-contaminated Colorado cantaloupes, continuing incidents of Campylobacteriosis, and the current pending recalls of raw tuna and bagged salad greens for salmonella are confirmations that this issue is not going away.

Using a wood counter-top that is not fully sealed and capable of taking the use of chemical disinfectants, including chlorine bleach, in a kitchen is subjecting your families to the real risk of serious illness. If you want wood counters, please make sure that they are fully sealed, not used as cutting boards, and that everyone using them uses supplemental food preparation surfaces that can be properly cleaned.

Borrowing a line from an old safety program, "The life you save may be your own."

I've seen any number of internet posts about the safety of wood for food preparation surfaces. The issues coming out that I'm currently dealing with as an attorney are indicating that such "information" is not only wrong, but dangerously wrong.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#22

Re: Sanitation *LINK*

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Are you saying that these guys have it wrong?


http://faculty.vetmed.ucdavis.edu/faculty/docliver/Research/cuttingboard.htm

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#23

Sanitation

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

UC Davis has a great reputation, but that article is now 7 years old. Part of the variables in the factual background of food safety is home cleaning procedures on the work surfaces. To prevent cross contamination, separate work surfaces need to be used for different operations, not just meats segregated from vegetables, but also vegetables that will be eaten raw as opposed from those cooked. We don't run around the house disinfecting every door knob, but we have 9 different cutting boards in our kitchen, and for a given meal, three or more may be used. They are then cleaned and put away

Separate cutting boards are easy to clean and make safe, whatever they are made from, although it takes a bit more than a little dish soap and water as mentioned in the article (don't forget that that scrubber sponge is also packed with bacteria after only a few uses - soak it in Clorox-water at least twice a week!). However, you can't just change your counter tops. It's one thing to use your counters to place and hold things (glassware, dishes, etc., and those cutting boards), but it's quite another to turn them into food preparation surfaces. I've yet to see a pretty wood counter that does well with daily applications of bleach after the cooking is done. Consider, if you will, how appetizing is that salad that you made on the counter where the cat just walked after using her litter box? Toxoplasmosis, anyone?

This whole issue is an evolving area with lots of research ongoing. In the mean time, the stats from the C.D.C. show that people are getting sick in increasing numbers and severity from food-borne pathogens. I lost my father to listeria encephalitis in 1993, before anyone really understood what happened to him.

The choices are, as always, up to each of us.

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#24

Re: Sanitation

John in NM

How does the age of the article diminish the result?

Re: Wood kitchen counters

#25

Re: Ikea

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

The problem I had with my oak IKEA countertop was not warping, it was end checking at the glue joints. The problem was exacerbated by cutouts I had to make near the ends to install a cooktop and a sink. It was for an efficiency kitchen, so the cutouts were very near the ends of the countertop. There is also a good possibility that IKEA has cost-reduced their manufacturing of these since you installed yours. Mine had specific instructions (in small print on a sticker on the bottom of the plastic wrap, not in the instruction manual) to not remove the plastic wrap until after the counter had been installed. That was an absurd requirement, since I had to extensively modify the top in my shop before installing it in the apartment. When it started end checking, I reinforced all the open joints with dominoes and filled the checks with epoxy. Then I sealed all surfaces, top, bottom and especially the end grain where it was exposed in the cutouts, with WaterLox. This stopped the checking until I could get it installed. Regrettably, a couple months later, the cooktop failed, and the replacement was just a little larger than the original. I could not use the WaterLox Original in the apartment (because of the VOCs) to reseal the end grain where I enlarged the cutouts, and new checks opened up around the cooktop. I have had to fill them with the silicone seal that I used to set the new cooktop.