New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Chipbreakers. It's now official.

Posts

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#76

What Warren Said...

david weaver

... I think was something along the lines of setting the frogs about 30 years ago (not super tight) and leaving them alone because there is no need to have a tight mouth with the double iron set correctly.

I came to the same conclusion in march, though I'm just a piker, unless you're doing something very specific with shaving depth like you might be doing with a supersurfacer, I think setting both tight is ambiguous. All you have to do is prove to yourself that you can find a situation where the cap iron is working the chip, and at the same time, a mouth tighter makes the situation better where the cap iron working the chip fails.

I haven't found any such thing. compared to my .004" mouth infill, what I've found is that once the infill gets dull, I can get the tiniest of tearout from it if I push it. At the same level of sharpness, the double iron has no similar problem.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#77

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

Mark Hennebury

Hi, i dont have the plane set up for anything special. I have just been playing around with my old planes and a bit of pine. If i was planing a finished piece of maple or figure maple, I would take a much thinner shaving.

I just took a thick shaving off of pine to show you that you can set the planes chipbreaker and throat tight enough to lift the plane. A thinner shaving will break as it is not strong enough to lift the planes weight.

There is the photo with the blade and chipbreaker assembled to show the setback, and a photo of the chipbreaker to show the micro bevel.


Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#78

This is not quite the right answer..

david weaver

...it is something where you'd say that inability to set the mouth tight may be an indicator of an improperly tuned cap iron.

The cap iron range can go from 40 to 80 degrees. If someone is tuning it about middling and taking a heavy shaving and avoiding tearout, they can indeed have feeding problems.

Since the top side of a mouth is not ever going to come in contact with a chip, it seems to me that someone with some skill can easily clean up the mouth if they want to set the mouth tight..

but there is no reason I can see to set the mouth tight, unless you are planing something tiny like faceting the end of stock.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#79

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

Mark Hennebury

By the way,

I am not suggesting that you need to set the chipbreaker and the throat that tight to plane pine. or any reasonably well behaved wood.

Just showing that you can.

If a wider throat and a tight chipbreaker is working without problems then great, thats all you need.

When you hit some difficult wood, you may need to use everything in your box of tricks.

The idea is to get the best work done in the easiest way, so whatever works.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#80

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

CStan

Agree.. in my futzing around with this since the video hit the airwaves I did have to open up the mouth but it's still pretty close, not as close as the one in your photos, but still a tight setting.

Thx.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#81

Re: What Warren Said...

Kees

Thanks David. That strokes with my experience until now. But I don't want to paint my self into a corner again with absolutisms, like I did with the capiron issue in the past. Trying to keep an open mind and all that.

At the other hand, I don't have the time to try out each and every possible variation of plane setup. I'll have to find something that works for me. So at some point I just have to protect myself and take something as fact. Like, with a close set capiron, you don't need a tight mouth.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#82

Re: What Warren Said...

david weaver

I feel like so far, I've run out of wood to try in the shop where it can be planed at all, or it can be planed by one proper design (super tight mouth infill) but not another. I have one piece of ribboned dead quartered cocobolo that absolutely refuses to be perfect, though the result is acceptable. I should try a card scraper on it.

It's going to take a lot more experience than I have, I think, to find a realistic scenario for what I make where a properly set double iron requires the mouth to be closed tight at the same time.

The problem with the quartered cocobolo is not solved with a tight mouth, it refuses to be planed perfectly period. I would never use such a piece of wood for anything other than a plane, though, and even at that, it's dead quartersawn and makes for an ugly plane (that looks like a steak knife handle from the top view).

So I'm all set, and have seriously considered dumping all of my premium planes except for one or two that I've made. All of the straw scenarios I had in my head where I needed exotic planes have disappeared (like they say in the shawshank redemption) like a fart in the wind.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#83

Re: What Warren Said...

TomD

It is used pretty extensively these days, with the pressure on other rosewoods. Guitar guys use it. It is no pleasure to sand, either bio hazard wise or gumming wise.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#84

Re: What Warren Said...

david weaver

I agree with that straight up.

It is the side grain or some sort of rift presentation that ends up showing up on guitar fingerboards, though. as long as it is cheaper than indian rosewood and especially ebony, it'll probably get more and more popular, and the face of it should make a nice fingerboard (and one that's interesting looking, too).

But the side grain is relatively easy to plane, actually everything is pretty easy to plane on cocobolo (including the knots) except for dead on quartersawn grain when it's dry. Fortunately, for the guitar folks, the dead quartersawn grain wouldn't make for a very durable fingerboard, and hopefully it is avoided to some extent.

Of course any commercial or even boutique shop is going to run it through a drum or belt sander to thickness it (or buy it pre-made), so the sanding won't be as much of an issue.

It is the only wood that I know of so far that sets me off when I sand it. when I plane it, I can smell it, but i'm not sensitive enough to be bothered by the smell without more dust, and a good sharp plane makes no dust with it. Tearout or a dull iron makes for a lot of dust if it's dry, though.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#85

Re: What Warren Said...

Kees

Yes this is funny. I have a bunch of quarted sawn beech waiting to get dry. And several old tapered single irons. That was meant to make a series of high Angle planes. But that idea is now doomed. No idea what I'm going to do with all that.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#86

Re: What Warren Said...

david weaver

Not sure what to tell you about the irons, but is the beech wide enough to make moulding planes? (like 3 1/2 inches wide or more?)

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#87

Re: What Warren Said...

Kees

Yes I have one big piece wide enough for side escapemant planes, So I think I'll go that direction. It isn't quite dry yet so I must wait anyway. The video from Larry Wiliams is excellent, so I see no reason why I shouldn't give it a shot :) .

The irons haven't been very expensive, so it's no bother.