Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
That said, I'm all ears. What's the fix?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
That said, I'm all ears. What's the fix?
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
Have I somehow missed the upshot of the Kato videos? Super-close chipbreaker, mouth doesn't matter nearly as much so open her up?
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
Kees
Maybe that's the next skilllevel? Close set capiron plus tight mouth. I'm interested in Warren's opinion about this. I do know that our Dutch capiron "guru" who has been advocating the proper use of this thing since years, advices an open mouth.
Some points relevant to this discussion:
In a Bailey plane it still is a good idea to move the frog back so the iron gates proper support from the sole.
In wooden planes there is always the problem of mouth wear when you use the plane a lot.
Despite my capirons now pretty damn well fitted, I still got chocking problems when I had a mouth of 0.2 mm in a Bailey with Ray Iles iron. Now I filled the mouth open to something like 0.5 mm and the chocking is gone completely.
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
Opening the mouth in some manner, depending on the style of plane (Primus, Bailey, etc.), has always worked for me too.
It's my understanding that Kato demphasizes the importance of a very tight mouth. I think everybody who has toyed around with this lately has confirmed this. Have I imagined it all?
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
Kees
Yes i wonder if the tight mouth in't an exercise in futility when the capiron is doing its work.
But. Proof me wrong.
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
Seems the 'new' best route is to get the frog out of the way and let it support the iron only. Then maybe move it back in a little if necessary.
Chipbreaker gemetry
David Charlesworth
The video shows that a tight mouth is not necessary for the chipbreaker effect. My point was about the oft repeated misinformation for regular planes.
I have seen countless planes in woodworking classes which do choke. The cause is always apoorly tuned chipbreaker edge or paint etc on the front edge of the throat.
CB edge must mate with blade and for a standard Bailey, the top surface must not be steeper than 45 degrees to the blade. It is good if this surface is polished. The edge of this surface is now at 90 degrees to the sole.
I have planes with 4 thou" mouths which I have used for 20 years. I can set the edge of the CB as close as I like and there is no choking.
A good crossectional drawing of the throat, CB and blade will show all.
best wishes,
David Charlesworth
Re: chirp
Larry Williams
David,
I understand the ruler trick and its goals. The issue is that the wear bevel on the flat face of the iron must be addressed at each sharpening. The time saved on the flat face of the iron when using the ruler trick is more than taken away by having to remove the flat face wear bevel by all the work to remove it by working only on the bevel. One has to remove a lot of steel from the bevel.
If I were condemned to that, long before I honed the bevel enough to remove the flat face wear bevel I'd be looking over my shoulder see if my planer or sander was plugged in. In a work shop setting and I'm stuck having to get other's planes working I always wonder how many woodworkers have thrown up their hands in frustration and given up on hand planes.
While I do understand the ruler trick I also see how it's applied out there. I know there are a huge number of low angle, bevel-up, A-2 ironed planes out there that don't work anymore. The ruler trick is just one of the factors in this but it is a contributor. People seem to have gotten the message they can avoid a little work on the flat face of a plane iron but don't seem to understand the trade-off is a lot more work on the bevel.
confirming this observation
Bill Tindall
I had a plane that choked with the blade holder(chip breaker except it was set back so far it was only a blade holder) set well back. It was suggested that I polish it and indeed that cured the problem. Of course it still didn't do anything useful because I didn't know how to set it.
Re: Chipbreaker gemetry
CStan
David, I certainly see your point but by "choking" I meant choking between the breaker and the mouth not the chip-jamming one sees when the breaker is poorly mated to the cutter. In the latter instance the mouth opening does not matter and I agree with you.
Re: The Baby and The Bathwater
CStan
I don't disagree with a word you wrote.
I do wonder, however, about why somebody would apply the Ruler Trick to the already flat iron of a premium bevel up plane. Or maybe you only do this to vintage irons that don't have flat backs.
Help a brother out with the logic.
Re: Chipbreaker gemetry
Mark Hennebury
I posted these a couple of days ago on a previous thread,
The shavings wont choke if set like this, you can make this so tight that it will squeese the shaving a little , but as you say, it wont choke up.
45° bed and 34° bed
The higher the bed the tighter it gets and the more you have to file from the throat angle to open up the chip clearance.


Re: chirp
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
While I do understand the ruler trick I also see how it's applied out there. I know there are a huge number of low angle, bevel-up, A-2 ironed planes out there that don't work anymore. The ruler trick is just one of the factors in this but it is a contributor. People seem to have gotten the message they can avoid a little work on the flat face of a plane iron but don't seem to understand the trade-off is a lot more work on the bevel.
Larry, there are two separate issues here, and you have managed to morph them into one.
There are BU planes and there are BD planes, and the Ruler Trick has a different meaning for each of them.
My understanding of the ruler trick for BD planes is that it assures one of a flat face/back of the bevel. Personally, I prefer to flatten the steel here, rather than use the ruler trick, but I do recognise it works as intended. Whether it creates more work is 50:50. The ruler trick removes very little steel, and even so, one does not have to remove it by grinding the primary bevel each time you hone a blade. You simply repeat it. It is repeatable. I choose not to use it on BD planes because I do not need it. I do not find it necessary. For a beginner, however, it can be a boon. I would use it, on the other hand, on old blades where flattening the back is uneconomical in time. That is what I imagined the ruler trick was originally developed to do.
Then we come to BU planes. The ruler trick here is actually intended to extend their edge. The work done by Steve Elliott on wear bevels demonstrated that wear occurrs exactly where the ruler trick would remove it. And so I add a ruler trick now to my BU blades. I cannot say that it improves blade life, but I also cannot say that blade life was degraded before the ruler trick. Call it precautionary. Call it what you will, but do not call it degrading.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: The Baby and The Bathwater
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Charles
I have responded to a post of Larry's above with the reason.
In a nutshell, Steve Elliott's research demonstrated that a wear bevel occurs at the back of the bevel (some refer to this as the face - you know what I mean). This can be removed with micro back bevel. In this case, the Ruler Trick. The RT is shallow, about 2/3 of a degree, and the cutting angle is left unchanged as is the clearance angle. The amount of work involved in creating the RT is also minuscule, taking less than 15 seconds.
As used here, I think of the rule trick as akin to honing a Japanese blade. There is a hollow at the rear of the Japanese blade, be it chisel or plane. Some imagine that, with repeated sharpening, the hollow will reach the edge of the blade and create a hollow on the bevel. Of course it never does this since the hollow is actually very shallow and enough is removed at its edge when the back of the blade is polished (at the same time the bevel face is polished).
Hone the secondary bevel on a BU plane blade, and most of the micro back bevel is removed. Add the RT back in again. 15 seconds.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Chipbreaker geometry
David Charlesworth
Mark,
Those were great drawings.
David
Re: The Baby and The Bathwater
CStan
Hell, I'm going to try it on a spare iron and see what happens. Not much to lose - nothing that 60 grit won't undo.
Thx.
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
Mark Hennebury
The Kato study never had any reference to mouth, for or against , it simple wasn't part of the study.
That in no way infers that it is not of any value.
Re: chirp
David Charlesworth
Larry,
I am mystified as to what you may be finding?
When I resharpen I work on the bevel, on a coarse stone, until I get a wire edge. I then polish the tip at about 2 degrees steeper on an 8000 polishing stone (Japanese).
Next ruler trick on flat side. I now do at least 20 short firm strokes across the polishing stone. This removes the wear bevel. I now check visually and carefully to be sure the wear bevel has gone. If it had not some more strokes would be used.
My blades stay very, very sharp, and the many students who spend time here also enjoy sharp edges.
Something must be going wrong for the people who you meet.
best wishes,
David
That was also my understanding and conclusion.
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
As a practical matter, however, everybody has had to open the mouth to make this whole thing 'work' and having done so still experienced apparently markedly better results than they had been experiencing prior to opening the mouth.
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
Mark Hennebury
No, not everybody.
You can close the throat up tight enough to squeeze the shaving without it choking or binding.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
That's fine but did doing so change the results on the surface of the wood?
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
Can you take a shot of the breaker setting that went along with the tight mouth?
They must be working the back..
david weaver
They must be working the back on the ruler trick for far too long.
I've never seen a plane in that condition, though, but at the same time with the veritas planes, I don't even know of a reason to use the ruler trick - they are so dead flat to start, and anyone with a decent stone can work the wear off the back in 15 seconds on a finish stone.
I don't know what "ruined" means, either, to imply that the back bevel has become so steep or long such that it can't be worked at all? Or that the plane doesn't cut?
What I'm curious about, is that I know I have far more than 2 degrees of room on the leading edge of my cap iron on my "cheap" plane. I'm pretty sure I could use the cap iron set close with a decent even back bevel.
Re: It doesn't seem..
david weaver
..it never seemed to me like Larry has done stuff to promote his pocket.
It's more about being right. Winning the argument. All of us like to win the argument.