Re: An even bigger issue
CStan
Well said.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: An even bigger issue
CStan
Well said.
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
He obviously had bought the tight mouth stuff hook, line, and sinker since it apparently never occurred to him to open the mouth a touch to relieve the choking caused by a close cap iron. He threw close cap iron settings out with the tight mouthed bath water.
File it under: "there's a new definition of a tight mouth" and it's however wide it needs to be to let a shaving through when the cap iron is set close. Just open up the mouth and don't worry about it? I'm starting to think so. Anybody else?
(Message Deleted by Poster)
whoops....
Bill Tindall
that would be $30/100 for disks.
Re: I think you're right. To quote myself..
CStan
I think flush to the back of the mouth for maximum support and let all the adjustments be to the cap iron unless the stock says otherwise. Of course, with the Primus moveable mouth and lack of a frog, even this is a non-issue with regard to smoothing - you can have a tight mouth and support all the way to the sole of the plane.
chirp
Larry Williams
Contrary to what you might think, David, I view all this as positive. Anything that can move people away from 12º bedded, bevel-up planes with A-2 obtuse beveled irons that have suffered the ruler trick is a very good thing. I see the results of all that every time we do a workshop. I'd much rather see an old Baily with a high carbon steel iron come out of people's tool kits. The Bailys are easy to get working and people can learn to deal with cap irons how ever they choose. I cringe when a bevel-up comes out because I know I'm probably facing a 15 to 30 minute struggle just to get that plane functioning passably (and temporarily) well and I never go beyond medium India with a quick strop on the irons. I try to do that cheerfully and without editorial comment but it's not an easy thing to do.
We've decided to quit teaching workshops and, while bevel-up A-2 ironed planes weren't the primary reason, they were certainly high on the list of reasons.
I'm quite comfortable putting our planes up against the Baily pattern planes set up however anyone wants but it has been difficult going against the constant drone and volume of the pitchmen, youtube videos, and hyped "versatility" we've been facing.
Maybe I'll have time to finish the reply to a previous thread on this topic and maybe not--we'll see.
Re: chirp
David Barnett
As I said just this week in other posts ("Death knell of single-iron planes?), after considering what Joel wrote about in his thread with David Weaver, in no way would I think your planes are not superior. I respect Joel's experience and judgment fully in that regard. And I still don't get the 'ruler trick', nor is it something I'd ever do to one of my planes.
"I'm quite comfortable putting our planes up against the Baily pattern planes set up however anyone wants but it has been difficult going against the constant drone and volume of the pitchmen, youtube videos, and hyped "versatility" we've been facing."
I'm surprised bevel-up planes have that much following. I do see many recommend them as a first plane, though, and wondered if that was wise. I like mine for some tasks but don't find them a panacea at all. For other tasks I've found them utterly frustrating.
At any rate, I can't imagine Bailey bench planes being any competition for your planes whatsoever. Two entirely different animals. Besides, the more people who have successful experiences with Bailey planes, the more people who'll likely seek out premium performing planes, and Lord knows, your's are lighter, more beautiful, and according to those who've used them, as good as it gets.
Re: chirp
david weaver
Plus, there are people who:
* need to have a more expensive plane than a bailey or millers falls because they are just used to prestige and premium buying
* and an important issue, there are folks who do feel that it is important to support artisans who make good quality products and who keep a craft alive
I wouldn't be averse to buying a wooden single iron plane still if I weren't fascinated with making my own planes in general.
But the old adage that was floated implicitly everywhere - that you'll need an expensive plane to work figured wood should be dead as a doornail. Strangely enough, my own venture into all of this was only 3 months ago. I had already "solved" the tearout problem with a single iron infill made in house. When I suggested to people that they could build a good plane like that on the first try in about 65 hours with just hand tools, surprisingly, their eyes crossed.
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
david weaver
That's completely inaccurate. It's about who can get a good surface, and observing the shavings in anything other than a very fine cut is an indicator of what's going on.
Re: It's a poor craftsman than blames his tools
TomD
Wood is good so there is always that.
There was this video of Pat Moore dancing on water in a Grumman canoe that looked like it had been portaged from 10 thousand feet, off the float of a Twin Otter, and with a shovel for a paddle. That performance was in my mind today as I was looking in the display cases at LV at their bevel up planes. I was thinking how well they, and pretty much every other known plane works for me. I was wondering just how much is the user, the pace, the sharpening, the reading of grain, the sellection of wood, etc...
The average guy showing up at a seminar with a BU plane and the ruler trick, is not going to get hurt falling off his rung low on the ladder. He may also be an expert, of course, or a super fast learned. But on average... So coming soon to a seminar near you, Mr Chipbreaker. Don't forget to pack some screw drivers.
Re: And bigger still
TomD
Making stuff like guitars you can be using wood that cost like 1-2K a bft or something. So one uses not necessarily the cheapest or stupidest approach, but the one that will never wreck a piece of wood, ever. The other reasons mentioned are also good, but loosing wood is not a good thing at these prices. So a belt or drum sander, while sometimes a little frustrating could easily pay for itself.
Re: You're so right
TomD
""If the equipment cost of getting an acceptable surface is hundreds or thousands of dollars (cost of fancy plane) for the pragmatic woodworker a $250 tear-out free air driven random orbital sander will be the path taken, or even a $1000 ($500 used) drum sander."
Even small luthier shops have taken to the drum sander and not just for surface quality, of course, but to thickness fairly thin stock. Many still use planes, but drum sanders are frequently seen nowadays."
And the other reason there is that traditionally american luthiers were not woodworkers. I'm talking traditionally post 1970, not in Martin's day. So they are all about jigs, and since the price has come down, they like machines. A lot of what people use in woodworking is what they think is required in order to fit in. They are just copying what they see. And also the initial point of attraction was say when they saw a Roubo bench. So self-selection occurs.
""Hence, if this rediscovery proves efficacious in the hands of what I will call "pragmatic woodworkers" this is where the benefit will be most important, not with the persons that already have high end skills and equipment."
Absolutely. There will always be those who will find special reasons to own high-end planes, whether it be performance or even fetishism, and I certainly don't begrudge them that, nor do I begrudge artisans with the admirable skills to make such planes. I also doubt this fanfare for the common plane will have much effect on owners or makers of hand crafted planes."
It's always a moving target. When I started out in the late 70s, the planes of the day were not for real. I remember getting a block plane home from LV, I think it was a record, and finding the adjustable mouth was not machined correctly it took a huge dive across it's range. The plane was not usable, and back then we just ate it. So today we have planes like those chinese ones RC is selling. He had a video out on one of those (not sure the CB settings) taking a fantastic shaving. So what is a cheap plane today? One thing I used to rage on about here, in the past, was how planes should be like any other woodworking tool, the money should go into the blade, and the budget for the rest does not need to be any higher than the budget for the handle on a chisel. I am making several planes at the moment for specialty uses related to making bamboo fly rods. I also have some ideas for a Morgan Mill like device. The specialty planes are going to use tool bits, and the total all up cost for these pretty sophisticated tools will be about 6 bucks each.
"Is period and historical authenticity important to me? Do I want to wear breeches and puffy-sleeved shirts? Then I'm going to be attracted to wooden replicas of early planes. Do I just want to make nice stuff? Then I can get by for less. Again, clearer understanding has refined our decisions, which is what really matters, what's really been gained."
I'd say that is a false choice. For a long time what it meant to use western planes was that you made your own like Cecil Pierce, or you used reconditioned ones as promoted by Mile Dunbar in his various tool books starting back in the 70s. For the most part I didn't have much success finding good enough old tools, so I made mine. It was only recently with C&W that this became regarded as a high end thing. Wood is certainly arguably better than metal, and one of those benefits can be lower cost.
When you look at woodworking tools as a business, it is mostly about stuffing tools in the stockings of newbies. People spend when they are new to an activity. And it is probably also a reality that most of those newbies don't have that long to live. But tools shouldn't be solely measured but that yardstick. Occasionally
Re: Onother vote for the Pinto
TomD
what fun could you have with a ferrari on the average american road.
I don't think the need for luxury planes will change at all. The need has always been illusory, as many threads have covered.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjMaY7wWNj0&feature=channel&list=UL
This is pre-breaker madness. It is high angle blade stuff. This kind of thing used to be the province of Japanese planes, probably mostly because there were the only people whose work needed it, not because the planes were so good, though that too.
By why shouldn't one pay 4K for an infill, if one wants to. Nothing has really changed, except that the level of plane performance is converging. Back say 85, I believed that only wooden planes, and maybe japanese blades could perform like this, but it became clear early on that all plane preferences were eventually going to become essentially personal. Probably it was LN that first showed me something I didn't expect to see.
When I wrote Leonard Lee in the 90s, and said that as much as I liked their stuff, that the store didn't sell one pro grade plane, chisel, or saw, he pretty much agreed (there were a few things at the margins). But now competitors that were selling sub Kuntz stuff are selling Sweatheart or the derivative Chinese stuff. Haven't used it for decades, but it seems to be pretty good.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: chirp
David Charlesworth
David,
Why an intelligent man would not get the ruler trick, is most perplexing.
Removing metal from the place where it wears and polishing an area of metal at least 50 times smaller than before.
Massively increasing the probability that the crucial area will touch a slightly out of flat stone.
What is not to get?
Best wishes,
David Charlesworth
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
David Charlesworth
The notion that a tight mouth causes choking is one of the great myths circulating recently.
Choking is caused by incorrectly prepared chipbreakers.
Tight mouth has nothing to do with it.
best wishes,
David Charlesworth
The Baby and The Bathwater
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Contrary to what you might think, David, I view all this as positive. Anything that can move people away from 12º bedded, bevel-up planes with A-2 obtuse beveled irons that have suffered the ruler trick is a very good thing. I see the results of all that every time we do a workshop. I'd much rather see an old Baily with a high carbon steel iron come out of people's tool kits.
I have now collected together all my BU planes - LN, LV and a Marcou - and used them to anchor the yacht. Obviously they are crap. After all they are BU and have A2 blades (well, many do), and some even have a ... (wait for it) ... Ruler Trick!
Dear Larry, just what is it I should have known was wrong about them before I confined them to the deep? They seemed to work well. The high angle smoothers left a glistening surface in interlocked hardwoods that my common angle Stanleys (with good aftermarket blades) just screwed up. Perhaps I was seeing it all wrong? The low angle Jack is ... was ... fantastic on a shooting board. Never had a problem shooting endgrain in some of the hardest woods with a 25 degree A2 blade. Not so much as a chip over several years. But you're right - It seems to have reached its expiry date now. It has been retired.
I dislike my own sarcasm. However your post - and many like it over the years - really irritates me. Your dislike - even hatred - of BU planes over the years simply ignores the thousands of happy users. They are not going away. They do a job, and they do this job magnificently. Especially for the newcomer to hand planes, they are a gift: easy to set up, easy to use, and wonderful results from the outset. Your post comes across to me as an attempt to deflect attention from your single-bevel designs.
Dear all, lets gets some perspective here. The euphoria is wonderful, but there are elements of crowing by some (as though some great victory has been won - was there a war? I wasn't aware before now). I find this distasteful.
I use BU and BD planes pretty equally. I also have made a number of single bevel planes, and these work as well as I could desire. They do the job. I am also not rushing to toss these out. Larry, I see you selling many more planes in the future. No need to convert them to double iron. They have a wonderful reputation. I look forward to a time when I can try one out.
I shall be keeping my BU planes. They are equally wonderful.
What I am excited about is that I foresee more time using my (Stanley and LN) Bailey-pattern planes. I have already demonstrated (in pictures and print here) how the performance of my high angle LN #3 improved significantly on highly difficult grain. I have confirmed this several times in recent weeks. However this does not mean that I plan to convert all my planes to Bailey-pattern types.
I shall also continue building planes, some of which I shall now use a double iron on, some not. It depends on their target. I find this option exciting.
Premium planes are here to stay. They were created to work well and look good. Both these aspects bring pleasure. Neither has changed because the cheap Stanley can be made to work better than it did in the past. I still find a Stanley plane to be poorly built, for example, the fairies have not done anything to improve the adjustment system overnight. I do not think that Konrad, Wayne, Ron and Raney, amongst others, will be losing any sleep.
Neither should those that own these planes.
Regards from Cape Town
Derek (on a three day flying visit)
Re: chirp
Kees
I don't think anyone ever questioned the quality of your planes.
The only thing I've taken issue with is the article on your website where you are dismissing the capiron with the false arguments.
Re: Half the time, Tom, ...
TomD
I just make classical guitars. I agree with all your points just adding colour.
Rod wise. I'm making job specific planes to make roughing forms, and 60 degree forms, though the latter may be tough since the scraping effect may be to high, and going to a multiple blade version is more trouble than it is worth. I'm also making rounders to match various culm sizes. After that I am moving on to trying to create a planemaker's Morgan Mill. Clever device designed to plane strips in place, but also designed to work in the hands of non-woodworkers. I.m going to take a shot at a home made version for people who can set planes and sharpen. That would keep 2K in the bank.
Right now, though I need some interns. I am adding jobs to the list way faster than I am getting anything done.
Re: The terrorist aesthetic
TomD
I bring this article up every now and then. Harpers '87. It's all about defining the other guy's arguments as being in the past, and defining one's own views in terms of the future, in order to gain an argument without actually making one. So we are going through this stage of re-evaluation, and some people are pressing the point a little. It will all pass, and probably actually reverse itself. I have hinted at it several times, there are reasons to flip the whole breaker vs single blade thing, as the the cycle progresses, and it will doubtless happen at some point.
Meanwhile it can get a little testy, as people with vested interests, and possibly standing a little higher on the ladder than the rest of us, have some frustrating moments:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mGS2tKQhdhY
Re: chirp
TomD
Actually if that is the original article, it is probably prescient as much as anything else, and sounds pretty much true to me. 4 main sections:
1) The first section on history sounds unlikely and doesn't really make any argument. So I experienced cognitive dissonance reading it, but that's healthy enough. I don't really see how if one is trying to save metal that adding a breaker with attendant machining is saving anything. I might be easier to sharpen a thing blade. Not sue it is true they did not how grinders back then, sounds reasonable their sharpening tools were not what we have today. Etc...
2) Next is mostly the long list of things that are wrong with breakers, that if you simply flip it over it shows a fair knowledge of all the arguments made to date, though in the negative, but the positive is there. Not so impressive if it went up in the last few days.
The arguments here are mostly preferences, or claims, to which there is a flip side. In the world of planes it is clear there is a split on these issues.
3) Then there is the stuff on single blades which sounds mostly true, glancing through it.
4) Then the final section of three paragraphs is mostly just driving home the point, but other than the problems of clogging that exist for some planes, the rest does not strike me as true, but again we are in the minor points here.
There are several failings that beset this kind of piece:
1) A historical perspective or influence is all very well, but it does not mean anything today. In the day they may have added chip breakers to cure cancer, fine, not too valid. But if today there are valid reasons, drive on with those.
2) There is a tendency to ascribe the worst case to the competitive idea, but not to one's own. Planes with breakers have CNC beds, thick blades and can be very sharp. That kind of performance base is not limited to single blades
But overall I would give the article two thumbs up, it is no more an advertorial than anything else, and makes some solid points.
Re: Yeah, I love my Primus, too
TomD
As long as it has a Japanese blade in it...
Re: It's a poor craftsman than blames his tools
TomD
I swear I amended "than" to "that" (seriously). Bleepin' keyboard. 
Re: The Baby and The Bathwater
TomD
"I dislike my own sarcasm. However your post - and many like it over the years - really irritates me. Your dislike - even hatred - of BU planes over the years simply ignores the thousands of happy users. They are not going away. They do a job, and they do this job magnificently. Especially for the newcomer to hand planes, they are a gift: easy to set up, easy to use, and wonderful results from the outset. Your post comes across to me as an attempt to deflect attention from your single-bevel designs. "
I suppose one could simply take his point at face value. I stopped doing seminars myself, and it is incredible what one runs into. My initial reaction to the comments was dissonant, but maybe this really is happening over and over. Without some power tools, I sure don't want to run into too many A2 blades in need of some major work. Larry is the guy who encourages competitors because he has too much work, so I don't know to what extent darker motives are at play. Nobody has to love BUs.
Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.
CStan
Pretty strange that moving the frog back a smidgen (still tight by any standard mind you) has always cured the problem for me.