New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Chipbreakers. It's now official.

Posts

Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#1

Chipbreakers. It's now official.

Kees

See Chris' blog on popular woodworking.'

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog/reconsidering-chipbreakers-as-not-totally-evil

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#3

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

CStan

Great performance from a Groz plane, huh?

Interesting.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#4

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

Kees

Yes, what's next? Great performance from a Kunz plane? Oh wait, that one was in the list too.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#5

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

ralph johnson

what i get form all this is, it use to be who could get the thinnist shaving, and now it is who can get the best looking shaving. What ever happen to to just making somthing out of wood

R.J.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#6

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

CStan

Sounds like the only problem he had was with a premium plane. Go figure. All appearances suggest he's not in anybody's hip-pocket.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#7

Thank you

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thank you to all involved in helping to bring about this reconsideration of the double iron plane.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#9

Or the price of premium planes down?


Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#11

Groz and Kunz now 'go-to' planes?


Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#12

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#13

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

joel moskowitz

All this means is that a chipbreaker, properly made and set correctly works wonders, and a single iron plane, properly made and set correctly also works wonders. In wooden plane days, where a plane mouth wasn't adjustable getting the latter to work correctly was harder than the former. Today with the quality of tools we have available either method can work depending on what floats your boat. However unless you take the word "correctly" to heart, neither method will work.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#14

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#15

Re: Price Per Shavings Index (PPSI)

CStan

Laughing.. thanks!

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#16

Re: Factor in price, however...

CStan

It's a good point.

ECE is *mostly* the answer.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#17

An even bigger issue

Bill Tindall

If the equipment cost of getting an acceptable surface is hundreds or thousands of dollars (cost of fancy plane) for the pragmatic woodworker a $250 tear-out free air driven random orbital sander will be the path taken, or even a $1000 ($500 used) drum sander.

Fact- there are acres of surfaces that are going to be prepared buy some means by woodworkers making stuff who are concerned about the result and not the means. Any equipment or technique that lessens the cost or lessens the learning curve to successful surface preparation is going to increase adaptation of this equipment or technique. Hence, if this rediscovery proves efficacious in the hands of what I will call "pragmatic woodworkers" this is where the benefit will be most important, not with the persons that already have high end skills and equipment.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#18

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#19

Re: Factor in price, however...

CStan

...I can't think of a reason why they aren't the best of both worlds frankly......in a smoother, you can have a high angle, adjustable mouth, plus a capiron equipped plane, all sliding on slick wood.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#20

Do you anticipate....

Bill Tindall

the Consumer Protection Agency will require plane manufacturers to provide "CPS" data on hand planes ?

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#21

Chris is an honest guy

Kees

Of course, I had a good laugh about this.

But I applaud Chris for his honesty to simply post about how he was wrong and now very happy to see a new direction his planing can go.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#22

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#23

Re: An even bigger issue

Kees

Don't forget the sandpaper cost! These fancy ROS pads are expensive. It's easy to blow 20 euro per project on sandpaper alone. A good plane is an investment for life

But i think most ROS lovers wouldn't dream of using a handplane. Too much work, too difficult

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#24

Well here is one that's dreaming......

Bill Tindall

And at 30 cents a ROS disk I don't use but a couple of dollars per project on disks. (about $30/1000 wholesale Klingspor)). Planing is much faster than sanding and I can do it on the bench without dust collection.

Re: Chipbreakers. It's now official.

#25

Re: Well here is one that's dreaming......

joel moskowitz

hand planes are fun - I love them but I don't expect the mass of shops to give them a second thought even with the "cap iron reawakening" IT still takes a lot more skill to plane anything well than it takes to feed a timesaver. And frankly unless you are making reproduction furniture and using historical methods is part of the whole package you are going to be using a timesaver or a good ROS. And considering the overwhelming majority of furniture uses sheet goods which can't be planed sanding makes more and more sense.

The cost of the tool means little in the context of the larger picture of running a production workshop. Where I see hand planes in a modern shop is for correcting purposes - something a sander cannot do.

(remember I am talking about commercial shops here)

Hobbyists do things because they are fun and in many cases the higher end production tools that are needed to make a living in a competitive shop aren't justified.

And it's a big pond and many perfectly great ways to get the job done. As for high end and low end planes - well you can go to the store for a bottle of milk driving a Pinto or a Ferrarri. They both will do the job fine. One happens to cost more but might make the driving more fun.