We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Cost saving from the maker end, not from the customer end. The higher the price of crucible steel, the harder to stay in business. Reduce the width of the iron and you get chatter. Add the cap and you fix chatter.
When 19th and 18th C texts are read, there is no mention of the precision angles we obsess over today. Most often, the workman is recommended a basic angle to shoot for when sharpening By Hand on a large grindstone, followed by a whetstone. There was simply none of the angle craziness we subject blades to back then that we subject ourselves to today.
Wait a second Gary, I don't quite follow your reasoning.
The plane iron wasn't made by the planemaker. He bought it. So it was a cost for him, not just for the planebuyer. I don't understand how buying a more expensive iron was a cost cutting exercise for the planemaker.
And then, the expensive part of the plane iron was the steel bit. The double iron has exactly the same amount of steel! The rest was much cheap iron. Now, the easy and cheap way to increase the strength of the blade against chatter would have been to add more iron to make the blade thicker. But no, they decided to use that amount of extra iron to make an extra blade, cut a slot, make a screw and a nut and braze it together. I really see no amount of cost cutting in that exercise.
And when I am talking about an adjustable angle plane, i didn't mean the sharpening angle. I ment the pitch of the blade, th cutting angle. And the woodworkers of that time were very well aware about planes with a higher pitch, versus low angle planes
We shouldn't forget with all our reasoning, that the double iron plane was a huge succes, despite the higher price. The cheaper 50 degree single iron planes were still available all through the 19th century, but the woodworkers obviously didn't want them.
Apologies for my not being clear. I meant that the cost savings was for the blade maker. Whether or not any savings were passed on to the plane maker is up for grabs as there are few records to refer to.
Well, the double iron uses exactly the same amount of cast steel, and with the thick capirons of that time, about twice as much iron as the single iron. Add to that the screw and the nut. Plus the wear on the files and threading tools. Add all that together and I don't see where the blacksmith exactly cut any costs.
Remember also, it wasn't the blacksmith who was responsible for the chattering iron. When the planemaker would complain about these chattery single irons, the blacksmith would tell him to do a better job and make a proper bedding.
Overall I don't inderstand why it is so difficult to accept that the double iron was being regarded as a great invention, hapilly embraced by the woodworking community.
Because we don't find big advertisement campaigns in the newspapers of these days, I conclude that the word spread by mouth. The best kind of advertising possible. But also only possible when the users are really happy with a new product. (of course this is just a guess on my part).