Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown *LINK*
Larry Williams
What's kind of amazing is how the Kawai and Kato video is being expanded to cover things they never mention and apparently didn't look at. Everything I saw involved only a 40º bed angle or angle of attack. I didn't see any comparison of different cutting angles, did you?
There were mentions in the various threads of different cutting angles. Both Derek and Steve Elliot reported better results with high angle planes than close set cap irons. I'm inclined to think Steve was pretty diligent in his comparison. Mark Hennebury mentioned the depth of cut on a Super Surfacer, which presumably was developed using the Kawai and Kato work, is increased by tilting the blade to a steeper cutting geometry. Hmmm.
A couple times Warren seems to state that he gets results from cap irons set at even greater distances than Kawai and Kato found effective. In the past I've asked Warren to explain what he's doing only to get a reply that it's like trying to explain which gear to use in a sports car. I found that less than helpful.
In a related thread on another forum, Jeff Burks, posted this: Smith said:
I'll add one more 19th century source.
The top iron is mentioned in The Panorama of Science and Art Vol. 1 1825 - Sir James Edward Smith.
Planes are generally about three inches and one-eighth deep; the jack-plane is sometimes rather more, and the smoothing-plane is mostly rather less. The blades of planes are, in many cases, made double, a simple expedient of remarkable utility in planing cross-grained stuff. The addition made to the blade for this purpose, consists of a piece of iron of the same breadth as the blade, with its lower end very thin, and of the same shape at the edge as the edge of the blade. This piece of iron, usually called the top-iron, is connected by a screw with the blade, at any necessary distance from the edge of which it can be fixed. The top-iron, the edge of which should never extend below the sole, is fastened upon the front or steel side of the blade, and the space between its edge and that of the blade, determines the thickness of the shaving. It is always necessary to make the top-iron fit the blade so correctly that no shaving can get between them; for this end, it is arched a little towards the lower end, and the concave side of this arch being turned inwards, the screw necessarily makes the edge fit closely the level surface of the blade. The top-iron is generally employed in the jack-plane, and almost alwavs to the trying-plane, the long-plane, and the jointer. To the smoothing-plane, and the various sorts of moulding planes, it is not used.
In a following post, Jeff Burkes added a link to the same text in the 1815 edition of Smith's work and it's below.
There's little 18th Century documentation--surprisingly little for a topic that's generated a lot of pages of stuff on a number of woodworking forums. Nary a ripple in the literature of the time when double irons were introduced. So this 1815 source is pretty early and the jack plane was double iron but not the smooth plane??? The most heavily cambered iron of those mentioned was also the one that's double iron?? Matching cambers on both the iron and the cap iron so that it can be placed within .004" of the edge? It seems kinda fiddly to me for people who did their heavy planing with jack or fore planes. What's the secret here????
I've looked at a lot of old planes. I can't remember a single one with a blunt cap iron like Kawai and Kato show. Has anyone else seen old cap irons configured this way?
This thread started about the "reach" of the Kawai and Kato video. I wonder what they think of it being used to rewrite 18th Century history and to compare things they apparently didn't even try. That video has certainly developed a long "reach." Maybe stretch is a better term.
Smith's The Panorama of Science and Art Vol. 1






