New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

Posts

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#51

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown *LINK*

Larry Williams

What's kind of amazing is how the Kawai and Kato video is being expanded to cover things they never mention and apparently didn't look at. Everything I saw involved only a 40º bed angle or angle of attack. I didn't see any comparison of different cutting angles, did you?

There were mentions in the various threads of different cutting angles. Both Derek and Steve Elliot reported better results with high angle planes than close set cap irons. I'm inclined to think Steve was pretty diligent in his comparison. Mark Hennebury mentioned the depth of cut on a Super Surfacer, which presumably was developed using the Kawai and Kato work, is increased by tilting the blade to a steeper cutting geometry. Hmmm.

A couple times Warren seems to state that he gets results from cap irons set at even greater distances than Kawai and Kato found effective. In the past I've asked Warren to explain what he's doing only to get a reply that it's like trying to explain which gear to use in a sports car. I found that less than helpful.

In a related thread on another forum, Jeff Burks, posted this:

I'll add one more 19th century source.

The top iron is mentioned in The Panorama of Science and Art Vol. 1 1825 - Sir James Edward Smith.

Smith said:

Planes are generally about three inches and one-eighth deep; the jack-plane is sometimes rather more, and the smoothing-plane is mostly rather less. The blades of planes are, in many cases, made double, a simple expedient of remarkable utility in planing cross-grained stuff. The addition made to the blade for this purpose, consists of a piece of iron of the same breadth as the blade, with its lower end very thin, and of the same shape at the edge as the edge of the blade. This piece of iron, usually called the top-iron, is connected by a screw with the blade, at any necessary distance from the edge of which it can be fixed. The top-iron, the edge of which should never extend below the sole, is fastened upon the front or steel side of the blade, and the space between its edge and that of the blade, determines the thickness of the shaving. It is always necessary to make the top-iron fit the blade so correctly that no shaving can get between them; for this end, it is arched a little towards the lower end, and the concave side of this arch being turned inwards, the screw necessarily makes the edge fit closely the level surface of the blade. The top-iron is generally employed in the jack-plane, and almost alwavs to the trying-plane, the long-plane, and the jointer. To the smoothing-plane, and the various sorts of moulding planes, it is not used.



In a following post, Jeff Burkes added a link to the same text in the 1815 edition of Smith's work and it's below.

There's little 18th Century documentation--surprisingly little for a topic that's generated a lot of pages of stuff on a number of woodworking forums. Nary a ripple in the literature of the time when double irons were introduced. So this 1815 source is pretty early and the jack plane was double iron but not the smooth plane??? The most heavily cambered iron of those mentioned was also the one that's double iron?? Matching cambers on both the iron and the cap iron so that it can be placed within .004" of the edge? It seems kinda fiddly to me for people who did their heavy planing with jack or fore planes. What's the secret here????

I've looked at a lot of old planes. I can't remember a single one with a blunt cap iron like Kawai and Kato show. Has anyone else seen old cap irons configured this way?

This thread started about the "reach" of the Kawai and Kato video. I wonder what they think of it being used to rewrite 18th Century history and to compare things they apparently didn't even try. That video has certainly developed a long "reach." Maybe stretch is a better term.


Smith's The Panorama of Science and Art Vol. 1

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#52

Re: Your irony is misplaced

TomD

I was not thinking of the Profs, they are no doubt doing what they should as far as supporting Japanese industry or understanding, technology etc...

The irony is that it took info from a power tool study to inform us of what was before our eyes. That is a pretty fair example of irony. I have three kids who periodically ask about irony, as the meaning of the word in popular culture fairly commonly crosses over with coincidence. You know it might be ironic if a truck carrying paper was in a crash between two trucks carrying paper clips. It would more likely be a coincidence if two paper truck rammed into each other, but I can hear it described as ironic.

From a practical perspective it doesn't mater how the info gets out, but I'll take a laugh were I can get it. It wouldn't make any difference to my repair bill if my paper truck where sandwiched between two paper clip trucks, but it would make a better story. The things I saw on Mulberry Street.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#53

David Barnett

Did he mention if he's dead or not? 


Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#54

Re: I have to agree

TomD

Other than the fact that some of our sub blades are already that shape, I have to admit that what has hitherto been described is not grabbing me.

But the real reason is that it sounds like hard work. I may be missing the point, but from what I know about planes you ram a heavy shaving through them with a close set breaker it is hard work. A super surfacer is a power tool, and the rate at which the board surges through is impressive. But that ain't me any more than I can rip a 1/8" kerf through a maple board, well actually I have Japanese saw that does do that, but anywho. As I mentioned when this tape first went up, for the Japanese, this is in the family, and I would like to know how they rough plane difficult woods, and why the quality sub blades on their planes don't have this form. Though some of the plate ones do. Machine tools will do stuff like cut with positive rake blades, etc... that work in their particular environment, not much fun in ours. So I plan to sit back and hear what comes out of this for a while longer.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#55

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#56

Re: Reports of Jeff's death are exaggerated

Pam Niedermayer

That's just plain wonderful. Last I'd heard was a couple of years ago, and was told at that time he was very sick.

Pam

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#57

Re: Irony - 101

TomD

Maybe I am at such a loss because with two Classical scholars of renown in the family, asking a question like "so what are the roots of Irony in ancient greek drama...?" Could net me an answer that should come with course credit. :)

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#58

Re: Reports of Jeff's death are exaggerated

Bruce, a MN Galoot

his most recent posting on the oldtools list was May 25, 2012

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#59

Re: Reports of Jeff's death are exaggerated

Pam Niedermayer

You have no idea how happy I am to be wrong in this case.

Pam

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#60

Re: Reports of Jeff's death are exaggerated

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't know if Britain has a Living Treasures program, but he should be in it.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#61

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

david weaver

Larry, I realize you have a lot of skin in this, but I think it's just as big of a reach to not assume that the appearance of a second iron has an awful lot (or everything) to do with mitigating surface quality issues.

I haven't seen any double iron planes that old that look fresh and clean that i could tell what they might've been set up like. But even at 45 degrees, they are plenty functional.

I just can't see any reason why the maker's would've gone to the expense of creating an entirely separate second iron, drilling and tapping it, putting a threaded nut in it and slotting the iron. The only reason I could think of that someone would really do that, especially when it makes it less easy to get a plane to feed, is because it did something superior to the surface of the wood.

While it's not easy to find some literature where someone says "we created the double iron and here's exactly why - to control tearout", I can't see anything that professes superiority of single iron planes, either. You can only guess then why they almost completely replaced single iron planes with the exception of economy lines where price was king.

But I know this much about a bailey bench plane, there is nowhere that I can find a piece of wood in my shop that my much more expensive steeper pitch plane can outdo it, and in most cases I can't get the steeper pitch plane to match the results.

Regardless of the details, if a single plane can do all for someone stepping into the hobby, then that's just more money for tools they'll need a lot more later than they'd need 5 smoothers and 3 jointers, etc.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#62

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

Larry Williams

Not as much skin as you might think, David. For years we've had a slide show we do and one of the slides is a double iron next to a dollar bill. Based on Steve Elliot's work we've been saying you need to have a cap iron set in the range of .004" from the cutting edge to get significant effect. We've given Steve's web site as a source and encouraged people to go read what he has there. Steve has had information about Kawai's and Kato's work on his web site for a long time.

I do have a problem when I read stuff like Warren saying this is what was done in the 18th Century. As Don often says to me, "Show me your evidence." I haven't seen it in either period texts or the old tools.

I'm also frustrated by comments like, "Knowing the resources that a company can and will apply to optimizing a mechanical device(Supersurfacer) I can believe that a 40 degree bed angle and 30 degree blade bevel must be optimum for dealing with a wide variety of hard and softwoods." Now there's an assumption for you and buried in all this scientific method talk. How is this "known?" Was the research made available? Is it just a coincidence that it happens to be just how the typical Japanese plane is configured?

Maybe I need to get the translation of the Kawai and Kato paper to see their definitions, intended limits of the study, hypothesis and what they used for control.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#63

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

david weaver

You guys are a lot more into it than I am. I only care if it works today, and care to take it no further than suppositions other than that.

When I saw the video, my first thought was that someone could say "maybe it's the wood they used". It could start as easily as that.

But I've been shocked how well the standard stanley style gear has worked on planes I considered to be a little less than desirable to use in anything that could tear out.

The 19th century wood smoothers I've used (later 19th century) have been less impressive - from cap irons that don't appear to have any stone marks on them but still are in rough shape to actually be used, to instant jam ups in planes where the planemaker decided to not finish the job and make a plane that could feed without the user doing a lot of work to the plane itself.

That said, you guys can argue about the history, it's too hard for a non-enthusiast like me to find. I still have more planes that I want to build - single and double iron.

I'm just glad to actually see the .004-.008 number, I never knew how close I was to making the whole thing work.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#64

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

For me, the magic number is around 0.3 - 0.4mm, so I concur. However, based on my experiences, I would not consider this as an adjustment that a beginner would be likely to do, as you suggest.

The irony is that this chip breaker technique was apparently not part of Bailey's design when he patented the "cap iron". He conceived it as a way to stiffen a thin blade.

Here is a link to his patent: http://www.google.com/patents?id=EZwAAAAAEBAJ&pg=PA1&dq=patent:72443&as_drrb_ap=q&as_minm_ap=1&as_miny_ap=2009&as_maxm_ap=1&as_maxy_ap=2009&as_drrb_is=q&as_minm_is=1&as_miny_is=2009&as_maxm_is=1&as_maxy_is=2009&source=gbs_selected_pages&cad=2#v=onepage&q=patent%3A72443&f=false

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#65

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

david weaver

This is clearly only my opinion....

I see the patent, but I don't think that something that LB was adding as a "plus" feature means that he didn't also intend to have the cap iron used to actually mitigate tearout if that was already an understood function of all cap irons at the time. He couldn't patent the idea of the second iron to mitigate tearout if that was already common, and so there would be no reason to go into detail about part of its function that is common to all second irons.

In his case, he's just explaining that his modifications also allow the use of a thin iron without chatter.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#66

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David

As much as I support the chip breaker effect, and see the Bailey design as a natural in this regard, I think that you are s-t-r-e-t-c-h-i-n-g! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#67

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

david weaver

Well, I've got to infer something about why it's there at all (the cap iron), and it's not the first one. It's not like I can send the guy an email and ask him for clarification.

I've always understood patent descriptions to be used to clarify the aspects of what you're patenting, so that a violation could be defended. If the device is being used to mitigate tearout, but all second irons are, then there's no great reason to mention that aspect in the patent as there would be nothing defensible.

The patent date is decades after several spotted writings in google describing the second iron's ability to deal with figured woods.

I just don't see bailey's change as anything other than a feature that allowed him to use very thing irons more successfully than he woudl've with the old woody cap iron design that has a slight flex over its entire length.

As far as how good the patented chipbreaker actually is at preventing chatter compared to a new design, I don't know, it's been a while since I applied a LN or hock cap iron to a stock stanley iron, partially because I like the way the stanley stock cap iron feels under tension of the lever cap a lot more than I do a flat design.

Should we take from your reading of the patent that you don't believe that bailey was interested in the cap iron being suitable to mitigate tearout?

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#68

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Should we take from your reading of the patent that you don't believe that bailey was interested in the cap iron being suitable to mitigate tearout?


Hi David

It seems more likely that Bailey, like many who have read this discussion on these pages, is inclined to argue that tearout is controlled by the stiffening of the blade by a "cap iron". That is what his patent is saying.

In spite of the evidence of the video, the visual documentation I have done, and the many anecdotal reports such as yours, there are a number of the Ubeaut (Oz) forum members who continue to believe this (there has been discussion there as well).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#69

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

david weaver

They believe that stiffening the blade is the key to tearout mitigation?

It helps to have a stable plane, but all one has to do is use a heavy iron on a bench plane to generate tearout to figure it out.

I still think my guess is correct. I don't see bailey making the leap to think that the stiffening of the iron is generating a good surface, but rather that the stiffening method he created allows the use of a thinner iron and still no chatter.

Chatter elimination isn't tearout elimination, though.

But like I said, it's only my opinion.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#70

Historical evidence

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is some historical evidence from a man who was a cabinetmaker in London in the 1790's.


Here is some historical evidence from a man who was a planemaker in Philadelphia in the 1760's

You have long claimed that 18th century cabinetmakers did not want double iron planes. "Show me your evidence."

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#71

Re: Medium = message

AlanWS

"Set the cap iron about as close to the edge as the thickness of a shaving or two" would be a way to put it.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#72

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

Kees

Hi Larry,

Nice to see you in this thread. I was lately reading the article on your website again about double irons. Of course you can put whatever you want on your own webpage, but may I suggest a few corrections?

You're writing about a 1/32" (0.8mm) between capiron and cutting edge and conclude that won't work too well to prevent tear out. Yes indeed, because we're talking about 0.2-0.4mm as the sweetspot.

Then you proceed to argue that the mouth is too tight for the capiron.Yes of course. Close mouths and capirons don't mix. Luckily with close set capiron you don't need a tight mouth.

Then there's the supposed feeding troubles with capirons. But you don't mention how the shavings straighten out when the capiron is in the right spot, thus solving feeding problems much better then the wrinkly shavings from a high angle plane.

And then you forget to mention a couple advantages of the double iron plane.

The capiron works. it works very well, and it is highly practical in daily use. It removes or prevents tearout, while still leaving a high gloss surface on the softer kinds of furniture wood.

It makes the plane much more universal. You can take thin or thick shavings with one and the same plane. You can plane soft woods and hard woods with the same. On a small piece of quarter sawn jatoba I went from rough sawn to finish ready, within a couple of minutes with just one simple Nooitgedagt wooden blockplane.

When you have the capiron in the sweet spot you can plane even with a rather blunt edge, without introducing tear out. That's a nice safety net.

And in todays market double iron planes are cheap!

Overall when you add all the plusses and minusses you will see clearly that the double iron plane is to be prefered over the specialised single iron ones. No wonder they completely blew them of the market in the 19th century.

When will we see the first Old Street Tools double iron plane?

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#73

Re: Historical evidence

Larry Williams

I think you're putting words in my mouth, Warren. I've been pretty careful to preface my thinking about this with "I believe" and especially careful to always give reasons why I believe what I do.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#74

Re: Historical evidence

Gary Roberts

Debating the finer points of semantic arguments is worse than splitting infinitives.

Now that I got that off my chest, I love those two excerpts from plane makers. What seems to be missing in this discussion is the roles both marketing and the speed, or lack thereof, that change was accepted by the crafts people of the day.

It behooved the Philadelphia maker to offer the newest and best from the Old World to the New World in order to compete. Note also the focus on the use of the double iron for problem woods. Highly figured woods were in vogue at this time and so any gadget that could help the craftsman do his job could be a surefire sell.

Overseas, change often occurred at a much slower pace. Not only did tools cost a great deal, but the tendency was to rely on tradition rather than to embrace change. But the cost of iron and steel meant the makers had to produce slimmer blades. Cap irons overcame the problem of the thinner blade. The West had not adopted the Asian style of a short, thick blade, opting instead for a long and expensive blade form. Did the cap iron serve a purpose of breaking the chip, reducing flex and vibration? Of course it did.

It's my thesis that it all began as a cost saving move. Do I have proof? Nah. It's an educated hunch.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#75

Re: Historical evidence

Kees

"It's my thesis that it all began as a cost saving move."

Why then was a double iron always more expensive then a single iron?

I've been browsing google books a lot lately. Mostly Dutch and German books but also a couple of English ones. All the 19th century books describing the use of these tools, tell us the double iron planes were better for curly and crossgrained woods. And they all know how to use the capiron: very close to the edge. 18th century books describing the use of double iron planes I haven't found yet.

It's my thesis the double iron plane was invented because they saw merit in an adjustable angle plane. Move the capiron close and the plane emulates a high angle one, move it further away and it is perfect for taking thick shavings on less demanding wood. They were probably very pleased to see the double iron plane also improved surface quality when compared to high angle single iron planes.