New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

Posts

Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#1

Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

wilbur

According to the stats that Vimeo gives me, the Kawai-Kato video has had over 1,600 views since it went up. This is not counting views of the video from Mark Hennebury's site at http://www.solidwoodmachinery.com/

I think that's pretty good. :D I thought you guys might want to know the impact of your efforts.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#2

Thank you

Bill Tindall

I will pass this information on to Professors Kato and Kawai. They had no idea their work would be of interest to woodworkers like us. The may not have known there were woodworkers like us. I am sure their work was motivated, and likely funded, by industry needs.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#3

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

Kees

And don't forget the discussions! Overhere of course, but also on woodnet, sawmillcreek, ukworkshop and to be sure I started the discussion on woodworking.nl. There is even discussion on the oldtools list, allthough overthere they don't yet quite understand this is something to tryout, not to be theorised to death (I'm ducking now...).

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#4

Ellis Walentine

We're going to excerpt the discussions...

Ellis Walentine

... for our September column in Woodworker West, too.

Ellis

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#5

Re: Reality check

TomD

It is awesome. The world hasn't changed though. Presumably the people who reported perfect results without breakers before this research was discovered still get the same results. You can't improve on perfection, and breakers may not come at any more of a reasonable cost in added fiddle factor after the research has come to light, than before.

The flip side is the research didn't invent breakers, only those with a complete disrespect for full time professionals would have dismissed breakers outright, the facts were already out there for individual users to examine.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#6

Re: We're going to excerpt the discussions...

Bill Tindall

I have the from from the publisher if you want to use any of the copyright pictures from the Kato technical paper we translated. (took over a month to get it!) It is routine to get permission to republish a picture from technical journal.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#7

Re: Reality check

wilbur

"It is awesome. The world hasn't changed though. Presumably the people who reported perfect results without breakers before this research was discovered still get the same results."

True, but my bet is that the vast majority of people who have seen the video since Bill, Mia, et al., got it for us don't fall into that category. In which case, it could be world changing for them.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#8

Re: Reality check

TomD

Seemed to me there was a consensus 2-3 weeks ago that breakers were not necessary. That is what Harrelson/Inomoto said, at the plane seminar. C&W has it on their website. Everyone was gaga googoo over bevel up planes a year or so ago. Maybe it was David who mentioned he never had a problem planing curly maple without a breaker. What has changed? We have a video that shows pretty much the standard set-up for breakers, for ever, seemed pretty ignorable till now. Did the wood all of a sudden take a turn for the worse?

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#9

Re: Reality check

david weaver

Here's my perspective on it, bullet point because I'm feeling especially lazy:

* if I were finish planing curly maple out of a power planer and it had no tearout, single iron plane, no problem

* if I were finish planing curly maple with a thick shaving because I had to do 5 panels of it (this was the case a couple of years ago), and the surface I started with had moved a little before I got to smooth plane it, then I would want to be able to take that thick shaving with a plane that was "tearout" proof

* probably about 2 years ago now, I built a 55 degree infill to do that, and acquired a nice 65mm 47 1/2 degree japanese smoother from a dealer in japan. The infill obviously is a little more bullet proof than the japanese plane, either will work OK (still keeping in mind I didn't find trouble running a standard 8/10 bu plane over something that was fresh out of a spiral head planer).

* Cost me $275 and about 65 hours or so to build a nice simple tight infill plane (I bought the iron and lever cap).

* the benefit of this is the realization that I didn't have to spend that kind of money to work over hand dimensioned wood where constant sharpening and thinner shavings isn't an option

* cap iron makes it so that no matter how dull the plane gets, I can take a 3 thousandth or so full width shaving and not get tearout. Not the case with an 8/10 bu plane, and if someone says it is, then maybe their wood isn't as heavily figured as mine.

Bonus is that the surface is brighter than it was out of my infill. I still like the infill plenty, though, but there have been a lot of people lamenting the need to spend money on a premium smoother to use figured wood. Answer now is that it's not necessary at all, their common bench plane is fine for it with a little fiddling, even if they need to start with a fairly heavy shaving like a hand-dimensioner would.

Apparently a lot of people weren't in "the club", just like me, because I have received a lot of PMs from people who have been both happy that they don't need to buy a new plane and sad that they can't justify a new plane.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#10

Re: Reality check

TomD

"Apparently a lot of people weren't in "the club", just like me, because I have received a lot of PMs from people who have been both happy that they don't need to buy a new plane and sad that they can't justify a new plane."

Oh believe me, if this thing becomes the new thing, there will be a new plane along to capitalize on it. Maybe a cap iron set to modify all those latest things BUs, or a plane with an adjustable breaker in some particularly complex form.

I'm calling patent on all forms of after market devises that modify bevel up planes including but not limited to modified blades, lever and screw caps, etc...

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#11

Re: Reality check

wilbur

The video does show that good results can be obtained without a chipbreaker, even against the grain, if the shaving is sufficiently thin enough.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#12

Maybe I'll go to ebay..

david weaver

...with standard bench planes that come with a certificate that the second iron works "like the ones in all of the forum comments".

I'll sell them for 3x whatever the planes otherwise sell for in completed auctions (and still somehow fall short of some turbolister sellers).

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#13

Re: Reality check

Kees

I am not exactly sure what you are arguing for or against now, Tom.

For all those people who don't have expensive new planes, this new turn of events is a godsend. It finally makes their humble Stanley #4 or wooden coffin smoother performing the way it was designed to be. Of course the information has always been there, just not very explicit. And their have been enough naysayers to the virtues of the capiron to make the most stuborn tinkerer doubt himself. You mention Larry Williams, he is a prolific figure and it turns out he is plain wrong about the capiron.

For me the eye opening thing was about the numbers. I saw 0.1 to 0.3 mm mentioned in the video. So I meassured my fine tuned chipbreaker and found 0.4mm. At that moment I realised that I had to go closer and suddenly everything clicked.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#14

Ellis Walentine

Still pondering this one

Ellis Walentine

I'm well aware of rights issues, Bill, so not to worry there. I just haven't decided the best way to get the information out there. My usual format for our News & Views column is short quotes from people about a particular topic. Here, the quotes aren't as important as the findings of the topic itself. This is looking more like an article, written by me, referencing the study, probably with a couple pictures, and punctuated by some of the more enlightened discussion of the findings that have appeared here since you broke the story. Still pondering....

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#15

Re: Maybe I'll go to ebay..

Bob Lang

. . . or a new jig (patent pending) that allows the user to calibrate the cap iron to edge distance in thousandths complete with a digital readout and special screwdriver.

Bob Lang

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#16

Re: Reality check

Charles

Well said.

All of the woodworking authors whom I have enjoyed reading over the years have never dismissed the chipbreaker as ineffective and not worth a bother. They all (that I've enumerated in another post), to a man, recommend in their writings to move the breaker 'as close as possible' on figured/difficult stock.

Otherwise, I only read that breakers were ineffective on the various woodworking forums, usually in posts by makers of planes that did not include breakers, by owners of these same planes, and avid historical re-enactors. This is not to say that a breaker-less plane does not work effectively, or cannot work effectively, for they do. But it is a logical fallacy to make the leap that 'because my plane with no breaker works, this means you don't need a breaker at all.' Not so fast. I can emulate a breaker-less plane by simply leaving it attached but moving it well away from the cutting edge and stopping the mouth down really tight. In other words, I have flexibility to use the breaker close, or in essence not at all. I would ask the somewhat rhetorical question 'why wouldn't I want this flexibility?' - exact historical reenactments notwithstanding.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#17

Cap Iron Effect and where do we go from here

Bill Tindall

No doubt the video and accompanying publication and discussions were a revelation to many as evidenced by Forum traffic and interest in publishers to make the information even more available. We have communicated this information to Professors Kato and Kawai and they are pleased that we have found the information useful. The video was made to teach and it seems to be partially(see below) successful in this role.

I like to understand how stuff works. What I got from all this is a fundamental understanding of the forces generated on the wood fibers by the plane assembly and the forces generated on the blade tip by the wood. This information, of course, was the objective to these studies. This information will aid me in setting up a plane and understanding wear and sharpening.

From some Forum discussions it appears that some people didn't grasp the fundamentals from just viewing the video. As a result some still don't understand that the optimum shaving bender setting depends on the physical properties of the wood and shaving depth, at least. The professors must have recognized this same problem for they wrote a follow up publication targeted to teaching, where they discuss in more detail how to set the shaving bender based on observations of the shaving. We may make this publication the next priority.

As a next step someone needs to write a description of how to set up a plane to take advantage of what Kato and Kawai call the "cap iron effect". By that they mean using the forces generated by the shaving being bent to hold down the fibers ahead of the blade tip.

As best I can tell until Mia translates some from each paper we have papers on the study of plane blade metal, sharpening, bedding angle, throat opening, plane sole, coating blades with an abrasion resistant coating, and something about chip formation that from the pictures looks to be something dealing with what Lee calls Type I, II and III chips.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#18

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

david weaver

This is what my meltdown of beginner vs. non-beginner was about. Someone who is picking up a plane for the first time, or perhaps is doing their first project forwhatever reason may have trouble with this concept.

As they read, they find reason to buy a high angle plane, they buy it, it works on the first try.

But when they are no longer a beginner, and even perhaps when they are still one but with just a tiny amount of touch, then they'll have no issue with this if they can be taught to trust their hands, eyes and brains.

I'm a beginner in some respects, but I could've gained a lot by being directed toward this 3 months after I started. Like a lot of other people, either the writers who point to this aren't "cool", or I just missed the message because it's subtle.

There is a big divide in what is consumed by someone who can only tolerate something that works the first time with minimal user intervention and someone who has worked 30 years and either by chance or by reading has found favor in a method. The people in that divide aren't being served, because we're being blasted for suggesting that it's worth peoples' time to play a little with something that sometimes will give you the same result as the "easy expensive" method, and sometimes better with skill.

And there's always seems to be a post-discussion pattern of a few people (not always the same people) saying "this is nothing new, I already knew it, so did lots of other peole", but when someone asks, it seems to be only warren in this case sticking up for it.

productive: "this is an option for you, and here's how you do it, if it doesn't work the first time, keep trying, here's the virtues that it provides".

Non-productive (paraphrased): "this is not a new topic, i haven't said anything about it before because you should just know".

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#19

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

Charles

I think I'm beating a dead horse at this point but my point is this: I don't believe that I have a source in my woodworking library (as it were) that doesn't mention using the cap iron to minimize tearout. So, there's nothing confusing at all - at least in the resources that I have.

It is only on the internet where the cap iron is found to be addressed with derision. So, to the extent that your hypothetical beginner gets all of his or her information regarding cap irons (breakers) from internet blogs and forums then he or she should be excused for being confused. There was no such confusion amongst the list of authors I've already mentioned in other posts.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#20

Ellis Walentine

I think the difference...

Ellis Walentine

... has to do with the scientific method at work here, explicating and quantifying a behavior that was always there and often talked about in the literature, as you say, Charles. The comparative videos and the idea of filing the edge of the cap iron at a tiny steep bevel, and the quantification of the setback distance were all enlightening to me. I've never really had great results with cap irons in the past, and now I know that it is species related, and the ideal setback distance from the edge falls within a much closer range than I'd realized.

Ellis

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#21

Re: I think the difference...

Charles

I agree. The references I have, which I'm sure are some of the same you and everybody has as well, basically mention a range from a sixteenth down to the aforementioned 'as close as possible.' At a sixteenth, the cap iron may not be doing much except possibly in the rankest of cuts. I don't recall anything about a microbevel on the leading edge of the cap iron but I do definitely recall several of the sources mentioning polishing the entire curved front of the cap iron to a high shine and of course making sure it's a fit to the iron to prevent clogging. I also seem to recall a recommendation to wax the business end of cap iron which I've actually never done.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#22

Re: my beginner and non-beginner meltdown

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think the problem with the double iron plane has been arrogance. People who were beginners have insisted that they were experts. Some have insisted that they knew more about planes than 18th century cabinetmakers.

I would give David Weaver credit for being open to the idea that he might learn something by experimenting some more. Here is the exchange that signalled the start of the forum's present interest in double irons.

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/9/md/read/id/446436/sbj/warren-an-update-on-double-irons/

and

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/7/md/read/id/447020/sbj/what-is-a-double-iron/

Here is an exchange from just 5 months ago:

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/24/md/read/id/443879/sbj/difficult-woods/

And one from 2007

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3107/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/6032hEjqaujq3xj624q1337880673/spage/1/sanc/117565/sbid/3107/md/read/id/117564/sbj/i-don-t-think-so/

The archives have recently gotten harder to access.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#23

Medium = message

wilbur

"I would ask the somewhat rhetorical question 'why wouldn't I want this flexibility?'"

If flexibility was the be-all and end-all, then all of us would be walking around with low angle jacks as our only plane. :D

Even though this information may not be "new", this video does present the information in a format that wasn't available before, and it may be convincing to someone who previously hadn't been convinced by the information that was already available. Some folks do have trouble with descriptions of cap iron technique that talk about setting the cap iron as close as possible. They may want a number to shoot for. Other folks may be more visual learners, where this video will show in seconds what paragraphs will fail to do for those people.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#24

Re: It's just that easy..

david weaver

..warren, to find two posts where I said exactly the opposite things both to you, and in general. Two months ago when I couldn't generate any tearout, I did think that it wouldn't be very hard to dig through the archives where I was "arguing with warren" and getting all foul minded over the whole thing - proving myself exactly wrong or mostly wrong in the process.

But I have no reputation to keep, even if I don't like to be wrong any more than anyone else likes it.

I secretly try stuff that I argue with folks about, and figure that if I get to the point where I think my time in the hobby is too important to rehash things once in a while to see if i've changed, even if other things haven't...then I'll find another hobby.

I can only apologize for being so long winded in the interim. If most folks think I'm a tool, that's OK, I don't need to be prom queen.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#25

Re: Medium = message

Charles

When reading my favorite woodworking authors (mostly Brits) I've never really seen them express a measurement of less than 1MM as anything but a 'gnat's whisker,' 'just a breath,' 'close as you can,' 'a scant shaving,' usually stuff like that. I'm sure there are a few exceptions.

Seeing how close the guys in the video set the cap iron helps. It does. It still is not new news though - the general concept that, set very close, a cap iron has efficacy. Even as empirical as the videos and paper try to be - even they acknowledge it's a trial and error thing which brings us back to 'as close as you can.'