New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

Posts

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#26

Hero

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think you are the hero here, David. You are the skeptic who became convinced, the guy who used high angle planes and now suggests the double iron yields a finer surface. It was a lot easier for me to learn to use the double iron forty years ago; there were not all these gurus around telling people it would not work, so when there were problems I assumed it was my fault. I was five years without tear out before I found out that anybody thought the cap iron did not work.

People can praise the video all they want, but guys like you and Kees saying you learned this technology and it works on a practical level is what is most convincing.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#27

difference is in setback distance

Chris Friesen

I think for me the takeaway is that the chipbreaker/chipbender/cap iron needs to be *very* close to the edge for it to make a difference.

This implies a mouth that can handle the cap iron that close to the edge without clogging, and also a cap iron that is very closely mated against the blade otherwise it'll just jam up.

Most older planes I've seen are not anywhere close to being able to handle either of these without some work.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#28

Boy, you boys are weird.


Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#29

Re: difference is in setback distance

Charles

I've spent a bit of this afternoon toying with this. I tuned the cap iron on a No. 4 to a tighter tolerance and set it really close on a freshly honed iron (so close you could barely see any land on the iron between the end and the cap iron). The results were not good until I moved the frog back a quarter turn of the screw. Then the results were very, very good. The sound of the shavings coming off was even different. This was on a WWII era Stanley No. 4.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#30

Re: It's just that easy..

Charles

You're a good dude David. High angles still work. Close cap irons don't always work, that's why we have scrapers - the ultimate high angle cutting tool and the first and most basic tool to ever be put to wood.

It wasn't all for naught.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#31

Heros and Villains

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Warren

I echo your sentiment that it takes courage to challenge ones belief system, and David in particular must be commended.

I do not recall exactly when the video was made, or whether it was the source of data that "confirmed" existing beliefs. However for many years my view has been that the chip breaker (I will now no longer use the term "cap iron") had to be extremely close to the edge of the blade - within .1 or .2mm - or otherwise it was ineffective. With this in mind it has always appeared too difficult or too much trouble to go to. Consequently, it was ignored. The chip breaker was just seen as a cap iron, that is, something to stiffen a blade.

The discussions we have had here over a period of months mark an evolution in the way we think about the chip breaker. We are no where close to the end of the journey.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#32

Re: difference is in setback distance

david weaver

Shavings sort of straightened out off of the cap iron? When a shaving straightens out on me, that's when I get a good action from the cap iron, but still get a very nice shaving.

I haven't set the mouth tight on any of the planes I've tried this one (it shouldn't be necessary, right?), all are set now basically so that the frog is dead even with the ledge on the casting.

I didn't ever get into a situation where I got those straight shavings before this whole debacle. I just didn't know how close I was, on either side of it, and doubted the practicality of figuring it out.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#33

Re: difference is in setback distance

TomD

So are you saying David, that the point when the shaving no longer curls, goes straight up, etc.. Is the point at which the best result occurs? That's what happens with the Japanese planes. You need a number if your plane is designed so you can't adjust the breaker on the fly.

Separately, is anyone else struck by the irony that the a'ha moment for breaker function that is typical of Japanese hand planes, came when the hand tool group studied a power plane, when the exact same evidence was all over the place for decades with hand tools?

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#34

Re: Cap Iron Effect - Breaker vs Brake

TomD

"By that they mean using the forces generated by the shaving being bent to hold down the fibers ahead of the blade tip."

That is a good description. I think many people have pondered that the shaving is not in fact broken in many cases. Most evidently for me in the Japanese planes where the shaving goes vertical, limp, and is beautiful quality, and yet something is happening. So it is more a mater of breaker cs braker.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#35

Re: difference is in setback distance

Pam Niedermayer

You bet, didn't seem to make any difference how often or how many of us said the sub blade (with or without landing) was to eliminate tear out. Sure glad the community now has a hero they will listen to.

Pam

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#37

Re: difference is in setback distance

Charles

Yeah, maybe a little straighter... definitely needed a wider mouth to make it all work.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#38

Jeff failed to discover the Cap Iron Effect

Bill Tindall

Someone should send him the video link. I do like his pictures.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#39

nomenclature, and its importance

Bill Tindall

I had a supervisor that was a sticker for language to the point that he could be annoying. One day he said "it is important to speak correctly to think correctly". The comment was in relation to someone calling something by an incorrect name relative to its function. The wisdom of his comment stuck in my mind.

This thought keeps coming up relative to the thing that deflects shavings. When working correctly it most certainly doesn't break chips nor is its proper function to break chips. "Chip breaker" is misleading in terms of function. "Cap iron" or "double iron" doesn't provide any clue as to its important function, but at least it isn't a misleading name.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#40

Re: nomenclature, and its importance

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well Bill, I thought the same, but chip breaker is the traditional name.

Alternatives are Shaving Bender, or Chip Bender. I prefer the latter.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#41

Your irony is misplaced

Bill Tindall

There is nothing in the translations to date that suggest that Kato and Kawai were not fully aware of the cap iron effect before starting their work. To repeat once again, the reoccurring theme in Kato's papers is gathering data to enable planing machines to work as well as hand planing and to get better edge life from the machine blades(which are probably tedious to renew).

Additionally, they were professors at a technical university charged with teaching teachers how to teach woodworking skills. Some of their efforts and publications are geared to teaching, for example the video. It is their teaching material that you all are seeing and the material should be judged by its value in teaching, not new discovery.

The value of their teaching can be judged by each of us personally, with no value added by bickering over its novelty or utility.

To summarize- The visualization of the cap iron effect at the micron level of observation is certainly novel. For me it was helpful in understanding the cap iron effect and the mechanics of of torn grain formation. So, I thought it should be shared. The staff at College of Redwoods thought it pretty cool too.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#42

correction

Bill Tindall

Jeff failed to photograph the cap iron effect.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#43

Re: difference is in setback distance

david weaver

Charles, I'd imagine that someone with your skill and experience probably would not set the chipbreaker that tight often because it's generally not needed and you know it better than most folks.

I don't know what my opinion is of it yet, I think it is to set it close but not too close (like at the far end of what the study says is OK - it's not like I've measured any of the settings), so that if I do need it to mitigate tearout (like in a heavy shaving for the first passes on a board that just came off of a rank jointer plane cut), it will do it. But otherwise, with a 2 thousandth or less shaving it doesn't probably do much. It is like disaster protection in that setting.

I noticed that only with fairly coarse shavings does the shaving straighten up totally like I queried you about yesterday, but when it does, it's sort of a safety cut - nothing bad will happen no matter whether you are on the first panel and paying good attention or on the 5th and fatigued and subject to doing something like setting a deep shaving and misreading a board.

We have totally beaten this subject to death, but I definitely have learned something from it - something permanent not subject to the whims of the next lineup of bloggers.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#44

Re: difference is in setback distance

Charles

Still fiddling with it David... I was very pleased with the results from yesterday.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#45

Re: Medium = message

wilbur

To you and many others, descriptions like "gnat's whisker" would be well understood. But there are other people who wouldn't be able to make heads or tails of those descriptions. I think that I'm one of those. Looking back at my previous experience with chip breakers (and this is looking through the memory fog), I did try placing the chip breaker as close as possible to the edge, and didn't get good results. I think this is because I did set it as close as possible to the edge, which was too close for optimal results.

In this case, a description like "put the chipbreaker to within 0.1-0.3mm from the edge, depending on the wood" becomes more helpful than comparisons to insect anatomy.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#46

I have to agree

Bob Hackett

This study shows the process of planing in a way we probably have never seen it before, out in the open and under very tightly controlled circumstances with close observation of exactly what is taking place down where the cutter is working the wood. The mechanics of this were brought to light in Leonard Lee`s book on sharpening but this study brings the chip breaker/shaving bender to the forefront.

Seems funny to me that we are willing to experiment with all kinds of different things like ruler tricks, micro bevels, exotic tool steels, sub zero heat treatments, wear resistant coatings, etc. Yet I don`t hear anyone talking about modifying their chip breakers/shaving benders to duplicate those used in this study yet even when the ability to reduce tear out has been clearly demonstrated and doing so may actually have a "self sharpening" effect on the iron.

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#47

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#49

Re: correction

Pam Niedermayer

Jeff is dead now, I think; but his pages are still incredibly valuable. So far as I know, they're still hosted online. In case they're not, I've saved a copy of most of them. I've never noticed these pages, though. Thanks, Derek.

Pam

Re: Reach and impact of Kawai-Kato video

#50

Reports of Jeff's death are exaggerated

Steve Elliott

Jeff Gorman has been participating in a thread on UK Workshop within the last couple of days, though he didn't mention where he was posting from.