New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Experimenting with chip breakers

Posts

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#26

Re: what you do as a beginner and then later

david weaver

Maybe part of the problem with this (aside from the comments I made elsewhere that are probably not that well received) is that most of the people doing writing are doing it to bring beginners into the hobby.

There has to be some point where a lot of people decide they've gotten enough from WN, SMC, here, Pop wood, fine woodworking, etc. and they become bored and look for something more specific and challenging. I know all of us could use our time better than talking on forums, but we do it anyway.

At any rate, teachers who starting with teaching the beginners who apparently (from the comments of instructors and tool makers) have a ton of trouble just getting functional sharpness...

... maybe some of the more knowledgeable folks who do understand the initial (as you describe, set it tight and then move it back as you can), and the later ( as warren describes, a reflexive initial looser set based on knowledge of what's going to happen, anyway ) just choose not to be involved with anything other than satisfying a later curiosity. Especially if it can't be described in 5 words or less. ("get a higher angle plane"), ("get a harder chisel set"), ("buy an expensive marking knife")

And there are others (I would be in this group) who always thought setting the cap iron as close as you need to to completely mitigate tearout on a functional basis was tedium, because I only did it three or four times a year, and then didn't like the feed pressure of the plane - only to learn the feed pressure is normal if you need the CB working close, and tedium goes away with repetition.

Long winded way so far of saying that maybe it didn't get as much play in the current era because it's not suitable for immediate consumption by beginners. Beginners are the easiest sale, and probably have the largest monthly budget allocation on tools.

I was talking to someone about a year ago who asked me what they should buy to sharpen, and I said "a cheap grinder, a medium stone and a fine stone, doesn't matter what any of them are - and some cheap ebay leather if you'd like". And they said that I was intentionally giving them bad advice because LN cautioned against using any high speed grinder in a video. (why would anyone use an extra thick very hard iron and forego power grinding? Anyone perhaps other than a beginner?)

So if someone comes out teaching beginners and says "the steeper the better", and they are attached to pop wood, LN, whatever...then why would the person who has 30 years of experience even bother with it?

I often wonder why folks like warren even read these boards. It's not like he's going to change something he does, and he's not selling services to any of us. He probably doesn't learn much or anything, either.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#27

Re: perspective

Mark Hennebury

I'm with Charles on this one. "I am surprised by all of the surprise" Like has been said wood hasn't changed , physics hasn't changed. The main principles of cutting wood have been know for hundreds of years the question is: why the disconnect with this old knowledge? May be several reasons.

(1) traditionally this information was for tradespeople and passed on from master to apprentice, not so these days.

(2) People who cut trees down with a handsaw understood how to sharpen handsaws. Not neccessary today.

(3) People knew how to setup handplanes, because they didnt have wide belt sanders: handplaning wasn't a hobby.

With the industrial revolution skilled workers gradualy became irelevent, replaced by machinery: the fine skills and understanding of cutting tools, replaced by brute horsepower. The information has been out there all along its just irelevant these days. It means something only to the few hobbiests who value it enough to search it out. it is no longer taught, in schools or apprentiships, both because it is uneccessary and there is no continuity of knowledgable teachers to teach it.

Hundreds of years of woodworking knowledge did not progress into the moden age: it changed and was replaced by new technology and much was lost. If you take a real look at things you will see that all cutting tools whether hand tools or machine tools can easily be understood if you understand a few basic ancient tools namely: adze, handplane, buck saw, auger bit. Thats about it. If you understand wood structure, moisture, and these few tools the rest is easy.

If you look at these tools, and see the limitations of the age in which they were designed and made, and can extraplotale that into what could be done to improve them today you would see that many of of tools are badly designed.

Hand tools for instance can be made with the same "less then perfect design", simple keep copying the old designs because they are for hobby tools. Kind of like a Harley verses a Ducatti. A Harley is a fun, more about how it makes you feel bike and a Ducatti is an ultimate performance bike. Performance wise they are very different machines. (I dont own either, just trying to make a point.) If you look at a cabinetmakers handsaws, and ask yourself why are the teeth the shape they are, you will probably realize that its because they have always been that shape. You know when they were originally designed hundreds of years ago and they only had crude hand files to shape the teeth and that was the best that they could do.

They are not that shape because someone studied the most efficeint tooth pattern and tested it at Japanese univesity so that all cabinetmakers could have the most efficient hobby saw. The Kato study was done for industry: Just so happens that companies were making industrial version of the handplane and some of the information works for hanplanes.

Many tools are designed to be easily manufactured and to work good enough, thats it. Most hand and power tools could be vastly improved using the knowledge that was pioneered in the past and the technology of today.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#28

There is the problem.....

Bill Tindall

I have never heard of any of those people. Even if I did a library in E. TN isn't going to have a copy of whatever they wrote. Up until the invention of Badger Pond/WoodCentral I was self taught for there was no other option. Didn't keep me from making furniture, lots of it. Motivation is the mother of invention. When a plane didn't work I bought a belt sander and got on with it, more or less.

So how does this "lost" information get rediscovered and disseminated where it can find its way to places like E. TN.? It has to be "push" not "pull". I can't ask about stuff I don't know about. The people that know must be willing to teach, a rare talent in most fields.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#29

I'm not 100% sure on that one

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I guess it might instead refer to using shorter planes to work small problem areas, but I have no way of determining for sure. None of my translation guides make any mention of the term, it for sure is old French...

Maybe Mr. Schwarz, who had Roubo translated, could help on that one?

DC

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#30

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

roger lance

Derek....I wanted to let the tread develop before asking your opinion of the Sigma Power 13000 (and 6000 if you have one)....I know you like the Sigma 1200 and I got one from Stu....but I'm really interested in your impressions of these other stones. Thanks.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#31

Rabot de bout...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Hard to read, but is seems that a "rabot de bout" refers to a short, high angle plane, which would be perfect to work problem areas. I get this from a pdf scan of Roubo's book:

http://toolemera.com/bkpdf/roubonypl.pdf

Look for the page titled "Outils propres au corroyage du bois et la manière de s'en servir", 22nd page of that file if I counted well...

Makes a lot more sense than a low angle plane :\

One mystery solved?

DC

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#32

Re: what you do as a beginner and then later

Charles

David, what you wrote makes a lot of sense.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#33

Re: perspective

Charles

You had to go an invoke Ducati motorcycles... I rode a friend's bike this past weekend (not a Ducati) but I got back to the house stoked to buy a motorcycle. I started browsing EBay, looking at old Honda CBs but it didn't take me long to run a search on Ducati.... I want one.....always did.....

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#34

Re: There is the problem.....

Charles

I don't know Bill, I live in West Tennessee (Memphis) and the main library has all of the authors I mentioned.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#35

yes and if you scale it......

Bill Tindall

I live closer to Windsor Ontario that I do to Memphis so you library is not very handy. Population Memphis-millions Population Mole- tens.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#36

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)



Derek....I wanted to let the tread develop before asking your opinion of the Sigma Power 13000 (and 6000 if you have one)....I know you like the Sigma 1200 and I got one from Stu....but I'm really interested in your impressions of these other stones.

Hi Roger

I am not an expert opinion on waterstones. All I can say is that the Sigma make sharpening some really hard, abrasion-resistant steel (such as M4 and 3V) an easy chore. They work as easily on O1 and A2. They get the blades sharp.

The 1200 Sigma is probably a little faster than the 1000 Pro Shapton. I can't say for sure. When lapping backs of O1 blades, the Shapton was able to create a mirror shine where the Sigma could not (but that is not a measure of sharpness). The 6000 Sigma by far eclipses the Shapton 5000, and the 12000 Shapton and 13000 Sigma are very similar - until you need to polish the tough steels. On O1, and possibly even A2, you may not see much difference.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#37

Fer = iron

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Many examples, such as 'chemin de fer', literally 'road of iron', meaning a railroad.

Wiley

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#38

Re: yes and if you scale it......

Charles

Interlibrary loan is your friend.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#39

Re: what you do as a beginner and then later

david weaver

Glad someone could make sense of it, I just reread it and it looks like I ran in circles and I can't remember what point I was trying to make. Short on sleep, I guess.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#40

Re: Fer = iron

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wiley, raboter a petit fer means literally planing with small iron (blade). In context it is offered as an alternative to a double iron plane for interlocked wood. The possibilities we can think of include things like scraper, high angle, small mouth, and thin shavings. Since I had also seen rabot a tres fer, plane with very small iron, and I think, plane with large iron, I took it to mean a very light cut. In England at the time "more iron" meant heavier cut, "less iron", lighter cut.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#41

It makes sense, but

Chuck Nickerson

somebody's got to talk to beginners in a way they can understand.

I don't even care if they get some of my money.

My first introduction to woodworking (mid 80's) was just awful.

I was told to "get this blade sharp enough that I'd use it".

Next lesson would be after I had accomplished that.

60 hours later I was done with woodworking for 20 years.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#42

Now I'm with you (with red face)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

My apologies, Warren, for my grammar school comment. You were way ahead of me, and referring also to Denis' query in his translation.

Your thought, that planing with a 'small iron' or 'short iron' likely refers to the projection of the iron, i.e. cutting depth, makes a lot of sense. When the writer is referring to bedding angle or cutting angle in this text, he spells it out, as in '45 degrees', or he qualifies the amount of 'inclination'.

Thank you for posting this French account.

Wiley

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#43

Help on this issue.......

Bill Tindall

As luck would have it I had lunch with someone whose inlaw lives in Europe and they are a professional early French language/literature expert ( they my be a professor or something). If it would be of help if one of you sent a well formulated question I can have it sent on to this person for an opinion. They likely won't know anything about wood working.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#44

a petit fer

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wiley, here is a sentence from Hulot (1775) which sheds light on the phrase a petit fer


It is talking about a moulding plane. A rough translation of the first part of the sentence is:

Work with a small iron (a petit fer), by which the workers mean that very little iron protrudes below the bottom surface of the tool...

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#45

Re: Help on this issue.......

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In this case we know what the words mean, but the problem is discerning what the idiom meant to 18th century woodworkers. See discussion with Wiley below.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#46

Sounds about right

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Question, where do you get these documents? I'm curious...

DC

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#48

Neat!

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Could you direct us to the titles you've found (French or other) so far?

My only worry is that this could become a reading black hole :D

DC

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#49

Re: perspective

Mark Hennebury

Ducati's are not hard to look at.

Something very nice about machines built for performance.

And you only go this way once.