New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Experimenting with chip breakers

Posts

Experimenting with chip breakers

#1

Experimenting with chip breakers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

After all the discussion I thought I must do my own experimentation. The ability to plane interlocked grain is my bugbear (sorry BB :) ) in Oz. Not that all timber here is like that, but much of the West Australian hardwoods are. Hence my need for high cutting angles in the smoothers I use.

Now I posted a few segments on SawMillCreek and UK Forum recently, but no here. There were identical ongoing discussions there at the time (currently).

In brief, I had compared a Stanley #3 (using both the original blade and a Mujingfang HSS blade, ad original chip breaker) with a LN #3 with 55 degree frog (and A2 blade) and a Veritas SBUS (and PM-VII pre-production blade) with 62 degree cutting angle.

The chip breaker on the Stanley was place about 0.3mm from the edge.

The original Stanley blade was a joke. It just chattered on the Jarrah test board. The Mujingfang blade constantly choked. I even filed the mouth open!! No change.

The performance of the LN #3 was very decent, and only bettered by the Veritas SBUS as the latter had a higher cutting angle.

I have photos, but will only post them if you are deadly bored.

I really did not want to give up .....

OK, once more back into the fray dear friends, once more ...

This time with pictures.

I elected to use a Bed Rock #604. This has a LN Chip Breaker and a M4 blade honed to 13000 on a Sigma. Let no one criticise the components! :)

The chip breaker was given a microbevel of around 70-80 degrees ..


This is the Jarrah surface I am trying to tame. It looks worse here since it was last planed by the Stanley #3 in the abortive last effort.


For the first effort with the #604 - call it a baseline - I set the chip breaker at about 0.4 - 0.5mm, which is typical of my usual position.


The shavings were nothing spectacular and nor was the wood surface (I would not usually use this plane on this wood), but it was an improvement over the Stanley #3 ..



Soooo ... now the chip breaker was repositioned at about 0.2mm ...


... and I started planning, waiting for the smooth surface to appear ... but it was a major anticlimax as the mouth clogged ...


OK, here's the culprit ... the chip breaker is not absolutely flush (although I did smooth it on a fone diamond stone.


Back to the waterstones.

This is the only chip breaker in existence that is honed to 13000 grit!


The mouth has clearance ...


But in spite of all this, the plane would not make shavings!


So I pulled the chip breaker back again ..


... and took a slightly deeper shaving than before. Now you see why I do not do this with Stanley planes ...


It is not a pretty sight. Sigh.

OK, out came the LN with a 55 degree frog I used before. Keep in mind that the Veritas SBUS, with a 62 degree cutting angle, produced a better finish yesterday.


The finish is clearly better to the touch.

There needs to be a summing up of the three experimental sessions: I think that the bottom line is that I just cannot get the chip breaker effect on this piece of Jarrah. By contrast, I was able to achieve a better finish with a 55 degree LN #3, and decent finish with a Veritas SBUS with 62 degree cutting angle. Perhaps some types of wood will not respond to changes of chip breaker projection, and the case for high cutting angles remains the alternative?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#2

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

Charles

When I run a chipbreaker way down close I do, and always have, produced an excelsior-like fluff (similar to your photos) and not distinct shavings. Sometimes this results in a great surface sometimes it does not.

This seems to be true across a variety of planes - I get the same thing with a Record No. 7 with a Hock iron and Clifton Stay Set cap iron. Get virtually the same thing with an old Record 4 with a 'best crucible cast steel' cutter and stock chipbreaker and stock lever cap. Same with an ECE 50* smoother with stock cutter and chipbreaker.

The mouth is closed down really tight on both smoothers, not so tight on the No. 7.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#3

Double irons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have no problem planing interlocked jarrah with "original Stanley blade". I would not call it a particularly difficult wood. If there is chattering I would suspect a bedding problem.

Here are some excerpts from Salivet (1792). The first excerpt suggests a double iron for interlocked mahogany; the second suggests how the double iron works.



Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#4

Re: Double irons

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren, this was no ordinary Stanley blade. This was a UK Stanley blade. :O The flex is something else - hence the chattering. The HSS blade did not chatter.

Would you like to translate the French? I only speak two languages, and French is not the other one.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#5

I did the Japanese someone else can do French

Bill Tindall

The French version was not helpful to most of us. If you can read it, it would be beneficial to provide a translation. It could be a nice compliment to the Kato-Kawai publication.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#6

Re: I did the Japanese someone else can do French

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My French is kind of rough, but the gist is the same as what is being said on this forum 200 years later. Roughly, the double iron plane is not an ancient invention, it might have come from Germany, that it it used at 45 degrees. The cap iron interferes with the levering of splinters when planing against the grain and thus controls tear out. It is recommended for interlocked mahogany.

It is roughly the same as what was said by Peter Nicholson 20 years later.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#7

perspective

Bill Tindall

Figured mahogany and walnut were widely used in period furniture so it is clear that craftsmen of the day knew how to plane it with the tools available. Apparently the French article shows that it was done/could be done without resorting to a high angle plane. (always wondered how they did that) D. Charlesworth recently confirmed the observation with cherry. Well, that covers the most widely used furniture woods and therefor the validity and value of the approach. Curious that this technology got lost in the western world for all this time.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#8

Re: perspective

Charles

I don't think this technology got lost at all.

I've read more than a couple of references dated 1950s and later (Charles Hayward, Robert Wearing, Joyce, et al.) that mention moving the cap iron "as close as possible" on difficult stock. This presumably means close as you can without stopping the iron from ceasing to cut which probably nets somewhere around the measurement(s) recommended in the Japanese video.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#9

Re: perspective

Charles

should have said, 'stopping the iron from cutting"

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#10

I'm on it!

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

This is funny as hell, that old French is like speaking with a speech impediment, with all those s replaced by f...

I'll get back with the translation later today ;)

DC

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#11

Re: perspective

Chuck Nickerson

When instructing beginners, especially long-distance, "close as possible" isn't particularly helpful.

.1 mm? Now that's helpful. So perhaps what was lost was the effective teaching of the technology.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#12

The translation

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Very quickly done, but accurate as far as I can see. Old French punctuation is weird, and very abundant ;)

Comments/explanations in italic...

Here goes:

Hard mahogany is of two kinds: one striped (fig. 3), and the other bird's-eye, fig. 4 (note: this is what my translation source tells me, although I suspect here the author refers to quilted or other type of figure, as I haven't heard of bird's eye mahogany before). Mahogany is in general yellowish-red when freshly worked on. It turns brown in a short time, then almost black. One should abstain from waxing excessively or even worse oiling it, if delaying the browning of the wood is desired.

In woodworking, the wood is farily hard, is very good because it stains less (???) and keeps its polish better. But when used in appartment doors, like the English do, it spreads in the rooms a darkness that inspires sadness (weird, but that's what the guy says...), which the French sense of elegance should have difficulty adopting unless fashion dictates otherwise, which may happen sooner than later as public buildings all paneling and moldings are painted in mahogany (I assume the painting is in a figurative sense here). A coating of lime turns it purple.

The wood has brown and even black stripes. Sometimes knots (crotch?) give it a shimmer, which is quite attractive. It planes wonderfully, but care must be exercised with figured stock, where it must be scraped (which is what “raboter a petit fer” means IMHO) or planed with a double iron plane, otherwise when we think we are almost done planing severe tearout occurs. The wood turns fairly well, but one must master his chisel in order to keep the grain down (???). The most beautiful wood shows dark veins on a pale background; however, one must have ample experience with the wood to determine how beautiful the wood will turn with age, as when it is freshly worked there are few hints as to how it will turn out.

Bird's eye mahogany (see above) is quite rare. It sells for a lot more (text ends here).

Second part:

When walnut is planed against the grain, or is curly, it has to be worked with a toothed plane, a low angle plane or a double-ironed plane. The toothed plane is just a regular plane in which we put a special blade with an infinity (???) of grooves, it is sharpened like any other iron and produces small curly shavings. This approach is excellent for gluing, or veneering, on all kinds of species, small sheets of precious wood. The low angle plane, is a tool in which the iron is bedded at less than 45 degrees, the standard inclination (never heard of one used for difficult grain, unless they mean a skewed blade, but this doesn't appear to be the case). Finally, the double iron plane, its invention not very old, and apparently comes from the Germans, is none other than a tool in which two irons are put together back to back, but this double iron is bedded at a regular angle. The bottom iron, being very inclined (bevel angle?), takes a lot of the wood, like all planes and jointers, but in this mode it would tear out a lot if the shavings were to enter the throat at that angle. The bevel of the top iron, lifts the shaving and forces it from the inclination at which it was started. But the two irons must not be even; the bottom one should be a little bit ahead. The less the difference the fewer tearout produced, to the point where one can plane oak branches, even almost green ones; this is the most difficult test that can be done, as nothing planes as badly as “log” wood. We hope our readers will forgive us this disgression, which applies to walnut no more than any other species.

So, here you go :)

DC

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#13

Re: The translation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"But when used in appartment doors, like the English do, it spreads in the rooms a darkness that inspires sadness..."

French feng shui! I wonder how long it would have taken L'Academie to accept "le feng shui" as a French phrase.

Interesting digression, down in the discussion of walnut, on the subject of double irons. The writer seems quite clear that it's a chipbreaker/chipbender in function, and discusses the effect of the setback of the top iron on tearout. So it looks like this issue was addressed 300+ years ago, with much the same answer as modern experience. I guess that demonstrates wood is still wood.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#14

and.....

Bill Tindall

"I guess that demonstrates wood is still wood."

and the laws of physics haven't changed. That would be upsetting.

Too bad the Australians were deprived of this advantage with their wood.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#15

How does a toothing plane work to prevent tearout

Bill Tindall

Having never sen or used one it is unclear how it works to mitigate this problem.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#16

Re: I did the Japanese someone else can do French

TomD

I'd translate if anyone actually cared. That did though set me off on a quest to find a way to have two windows open side by side (snap feature), and the text sized to scale in each window, which seems to be somewhere you can't get from here.

I think a kludgy way to do it is to open a second window and reply bubble, then size that small and let it hover over the text with in this case the French, but come on...

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#17

Re: The translation

TomD

French sense that it could not be stylish until the French say so. And apparently the beauty of dark real wood in England will not be the vanguard of that style change it will be painted faux effect in French public buildings. Presumably at those times mostly urinals. Rock on!

My take:

"... a darkness that inspires sadness, and that French gallantry and elegance would be at pains to adopt, at least until fashion dictates otherwise..."

Awesome! An e-books maybe, but all the gatekeepers of French publishing were 100% onside, one would imagine...

It is kinda interesting. Today we know what an earlier piece of furniture should look like, if we are educated in the mater, but we are incapable of being that person above whose world view would actually demand it. Allegiance to the past maybe, but rarely if ever authentically in it.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#18

Re: How does a toothing plane work to prevent tear

Sgian Dubh

"Having never sen or used one it is unclear how it works to mitigate this problem.

Bill, toothing planes were mostly used to aid veneering and their role was to score the surface of the groundwork to give the glue something extra to key to. It was normal practice to cross hatch the surface prior to applying the hide glue. Here's a picture of a toothing plane-- looks like a wooden coffin smoothing plane with a vertical iron, or near enough vertical. It's been many a year since I used one of these planes, but they were handy for their job.


The image came from http://www.bobstoolbox.com

The blades are toothed in a similar way to a modern version seen at Lie-Nielsen's website here: http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?sku=212

These toothing planes do prevent tearout in a sense, but what they leave behind is a surface more akin to one that's been rasped which, to get smooth ready, for example, to polish, requires working through ever finer abrasives. Slainte.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#19

Re: perspective

Kees

I was leafing through "Wooden planes and how to make them" from Perch and Lee. Mine is published in 2001. In chapter 7 I find this sentence:

"The cap iron should be set according to the type of planing to be done. For rough work, the edge of the cap iron should be about 1/16" back from the edge of the blade. For finish work, with the blade set to take a fine shaving, it may be as close as 1/64". When wood with akward grain, such as curly maple, is being worked, a good rule is to set the capiron as close to the edge as possible. As always, experience is the best teacher."

So, the knowledge was there all the time on my cupboard! I just didn't read or understand it.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#22

Re: the picture of it working was worth a 1000 wor

Kees

Yes I guess so. And I was probably brain washed by all the internet guru's who claimed chipbreakers didn't work :D

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#23

Re: The translation

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks for the translation, Denis. One thing I had a different idea about was the raboter a petit fer. I was thinking it meant planing with thin shavings, which would also work in this context. I have also seen rabot a très petit fer and I think rabot a grand fer as well.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#24

Re: perspective

Charles

I disagree somewhat. As close as possible is closer than 1MM; seems no sense in quoting a measurement finer than the smallest increment on the rules commonly used in woodworking at that time (given metrication of Great Britain).

I think you literally move the cap iron "as close as possible," possibly until it ceases cutting altogether and then move it out from there. The overall point, of course, being that a closely set cap iron is not new advice or something that was ever lost, at least not in my opinion.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#25

Re: perspective

Charles

Add that to the list of texts that use the exact same phraseology. Beyond the footage that shows this stuff actually works I'm surprised by all of the surprise. Ernest Joyce, Bernard Jones, Charles Hayward, Robert Wearing, Vic Taylor, the reference you quoted and more I'm sure - this has been de rigueur in British woodworking manuals for a while.