New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Experimenting with chip breakers

Posts

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#51

Re: How does a toothing plane work to prevent tear

TomD

While SD is dead on, they are used by some people mostly to reduce tear out. One example of this is building Osage bows. Osage is a wood that can really pop chunks. And to make matters worse, bows need to be perfect. Not only look good, but as the saying goes, "a bow drawn is 7/8 broken", so any error in the grain equals a broken bow. Other than sidecut, there can not be any grain run-out in a bow at all. So popping chunks is going to cost you. In most cases they are probably planing materials to prep for lamination, so in that case you have the dual benefit of not tear out, and a prepped glue surface.

I guess it works because the shaving has very little integrity. The shaving looks like excelsior. It would be very difficult to get the plane perfectly lined up with the grain, and any cutting across the grain will result in very short chip segments. Kinda like sanding vs planing.

Whether this is just the influence of bow maker Dean Torges, a very able woodworker, I don't know. Could all these woods be just as easily planed using higher end techniques, maybe. But for the case in point there might be little advantage.

I have seen the same thing with musical instrument makers.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#52

Re: perspective

TomD

+1

There is this myth, that enters the field mostly with the Stanley type tripe, that the breaker's main purpose is not related to the cut, but as a base for adjustment, or a means of stiffening those thin blades. But breakers have been around for a long time, pre those needs. They only work if in some proximity to the edge. And with planes like the Japanese ones, you can make adjustments cut by cut on the fly. It takes studies to light the fuse for some people. But that is more a mater of their learning style than anything else.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#53

Re: Granularity

TomD

I guess maybe one should distinguish types of tear-out. A plane that creates a rough surface is not minimizing tear-out in the same way as a finishing plane designed to eliminate micro tears that affect wood optics. We are talking mega tears here. Of course, mega tears can be impossible to get under and affect the finish. So that could be part of it. But it is a different granularity of tear out than one is discussing in the case of a finishing plane.

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#54

Re: perspective

Charles

I honestly thought just about everybody had accidentally set a breaker too close at least once in their life, causing the plane to basically stop cutting, and thereby proving to themselves the breaker is there for more than just extra mass - it can affect the cut. And like you said, breakers have been paired with thick irons long before Stanley thinned them down as a 'favor' to us (think Ohio Tool Co and Auburn planes).

Re: Experimenting with chip breakers

#55

bridger

Re: perspective

bridger

how about this for an approximation to get a new user in the ball park:

for maximum performance of a smooth plane set it up thus- a mouth about the size of the thickness of the shaving, the chipbreaker set about as far from the edge as the thickness of the shaving and the cutter as sharp as you can get it. make sure that the mouth has relief above the sole, and that it and the leading edge of the chipbreaker are smooth. the exact amounts will vary from application to application.

the rest is general plane mechanics- well fitting frog, flat sole, etc.

Bridger