New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Sharpening jig/grinding question

Posts

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#76

David Barnett

You bet, Bill. Glad you like yours. *LINK*

David Barnett

That would be the rugged little BelOMO 10x triplet loupe, which outperforms just about anything out there at half to a third the price, and although that price has doubled since I first got mine, it's still, by far, the best bargain anyone's going to find.

BelOMO is the Belorus branch of Zenit, the venerable Soviet-era camera and optics manufacturer. Their military and aerospace optics were second to none and this loupe, the "flagship" of their line, attests to that reputation.

It is, simply put, a wide lens, wide field folding hand loupe of exceptional optical quality and triplet design. No, it's not as aplanatic and achromatic as some high-end Zeiss or Bergeon loupes (german and swiss, respectively), but it doesn't sell for $100 or $200+ either. You can certainly find cheaper loupes all over the place, but they simply don't compare -- sharp to the edges, color correction good enough for gem work.

Although I own and used a Zeiss for judging competition gem cutting (faceting), I used the BelOMO while doing my own cutting, as it was easier on my eyes, with a larger, brighter image and with a more forgiving focal range. It's also convenient to slip a finger through the loupe shell and keep it in my hand for quick and constant inspection, how I hold it when sharpening saws and other hand tools, as well.

Now that I have two boom stereomicroscopes, surgical binocular loupes and so on, I use it less than before for demanding goldsmithing or stone-setting processes, but it's still the handiest thing for most other uses. As I've said before, I have at least one in each crafts venue; the micromachining room, the woodworking shop, jeweler's bench, enameling and glass casting station, and so on. Couldn't do much without 'em.

Although you can now get BelOMO loupes in higher (and lower) magnifications (they're all the same price -- around $30), the 10x is perfect for sharpening and tool inspection, and also for punch setting if you don't have one of those sexy Starrett magnifying machinist's hammers.

Amateur Geologist is the N. American supplier for BelOMO. They also offer nice lanyards for a couple dollars more, and although I don't use lanyards, they're nice if you have just one loupe.

As for "good lighting", as Bob suggests, I've got some ideas on that, too, but it can wait.


Just look at the size of this lens

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#77

David Barnett

Funny you should compare it with your B&L *LINK*

David Barnett

...but of course Bausch & Lomb is still the standard by which other loupes are compared. Amateur Geologist offers a comparison package where they'll send you the BelOMO 10x (around $30)and the B&L 10x (which sells for around $50) for side by side testing for sceptics. That's $65 for both.


Side by side picture says a lot in itself

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#78

Re: We have been discussing this topic for years

TomD

I don't know where those ideas came from. Machinists have been razor sharpening HSS and carbide for a long time. The first good chisels I owned back in the early 80s, were HSS japanese ones from Masterpiece tools, nothing new. I guess sometimes science is just a way of proving out what guys in the shop have been doing for half a century.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#79

Re: You bet, Bill. Glad you like yours.

Bill Tindall

Now that I own one I can say from experience that I agree with every point made. It is bright and large field. Not only is it indispensable for assessing sharpening progress and problems but it also finds employment in splinter removal.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#80

Re: A grinder and two stones..

TomD

They should be hair popping sharp, which means that when you shave your arm, you should see some hairs popping way off. I don't know that it is consistent for all hair types but you should see it sometime, if the edge is xtra sharp. The first step in hair sharpening on stone one is normally to feel for a wire edge. This works great but essentially requires oversharpening through the grit.

There are better ways though. One is based on just going through the process if you sharpen your tools through the various grits, you will get the results you want. Of course you don't want to have to work blind, so I use two test that have worked for barbers through the ages. You sharpen on your base stone to get rid of the initial dullness. This step forms the initial acute edge but does not polish it. When this needs testing you lick your middle nail, and press your finger and thumb together for stability. Then you take the blade and with the edge facing you and at a low angle to the nail you see if it will catch on your nail. This is non-destructive, and can be repeated all the time. This way you can examine the edge to see if the first stone has done it's work. Once you are sure you are done with the first stone, you go on to the next. Once sharpening on the second stone is done the edge should be razor sharp and ready for use. One performs a similar test this time on the tip of a wetted finger. If the edge catches it is razor sharp. This test is normally done with a razor, so care has to be taken when doing it with heavier, and various shaped tools. It isn't so much the testing, it is the swinging into place of the tools, or the dropping of them. I haven't ever had a problem, but maybe some close calls.

For normal work a two stone resharpening process is fine. But if you want to use a whole lot of stones (for the resharpening process, all methods use at least one other stone for basic shaping and taking out of chips etc...) then the two stages method falls apart, neither the finger method, no the hair method is sufficient. To use multiple stones one really needs to use optics. Since using extra stones is not going to hurt anything, one may be of the impression one is really getting it done, but it is hard to prove.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#81

Re: A reminder about civility

TomD

I think a third thing one should consider is that nobody has a professional editor here. I spend at least as much time editing as I do composing, I am embarrassed to say. But I don't have unlimited time to consider every phrase from the point of every person who has ever posted here, or may ever post here in the future. One thing I am particularly prone to is formating my points in me/you terms. I then go through the text to take out all the "yous" so it won't sound like I am putting words in people's mouths. But I don't always remember or get everything.

I once read that Margarette Thatcher was seen as confrontational because her handlers had convinced her she would sound authoritative if she spoke with a lowered voice. This lead her to finish phrases with a raise in tone. This is interpreted by others as a cue asking them to enter the conversation, but she had not finished. So she would end up raising her voice to finish her point. This looked like she was tring to talk over people for no reason: Even the pros have a hard time interpreting the cues that would set someone off. It isn't always a shot. Sometimes we just don't say it the way someone else wants to have it said.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#82

Re: A grinder and two stones..

Pam Niedermayer

And as I was accused above, I have gobs of stones that serve no practial purpose other than recreation.

David, that wasn't an accusation. Geesh. I was asking for clarification of the potential hypocrisy of recommending a grinder and two stones, which always sounds like what a poster does himself, and the claim to owning a lot of stones (and talking about them as if you actually do own piles of stones). You've clarified that. I'll report back if I detect other hypocrisies. :)

Pam

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#83

Re: We have been discussing this topic for years

Pam Niedermayer

When I first asked on Badger Pond why tool steels were not used for hand tools I was told with great authority that it was because these steels could not be sharpened to a keen edge.

Bill, what are you saying here? How about a list of tool steels? Cause I always considered O1 and W1 as tool steels; but it sounds as if you don't.

Granted we've had many discussions about A2, M2, and HSS in which several have claimed they're impossible to sharpen, that O1/W1 we can get way sharper; but I don't recall segregating O1/W1 from the "tool steel" designation. Maybe a case of memory loss?

Pam

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#84

Smarm?! Hey, Bill, is this what you had in mind?


Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#85

Re: A grinder and two stones..

eliotandmax

Well, I keep learning stuff here! I said I can get sharp enough to shave these hairs. But there's no hair popping! No popping! The finger nail thing is often what I do, but I don't find it sufficiently rigorous. As for trying it out on a finger, that seems daring! I guess I'll try it. Thanks for your responses.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#86

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

Charles

Love it - it's a classic and pretty much a debate stopper.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#87

Razor hone questions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

David,

If you wouldn't mind answering razor hone questions, would you e-mail me? Thanks.

Bill Houghton

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#88

Sent you an email, Bill