New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Sharpening jig/grinding question

Posts

Sharpening jig/grinding question

#1

Sharpening jig/grinding question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I am not hoping, here, to re-open the discussion of freehand vs. jigged sharpening. I happen to like using a jig.

My current jig of choice is the Veritas Mk. II guide, which sets the bevel angle with great precision. The trouble comes if the chisel/plane blade is sharpened at an angle slightly different from the angle to which I've adjusted the blade in the guide. I've been sharpening several blades that had been seriously abused by past owners, and had to regrind the bevels, which I did on a Delta wet wheel grinder (no longer made) similar to a Tormek, using a Tormek angle-setting gauge. When I went to hone the blades, I found myself honing the heel of the bevel; raising the brass roller to the micro-bevel setting got me sharpening the edge, so the angle difference was very small, but enough to make a problem.

I'm thinking: if I intentionally overshoot the correct grinding angle by a couple of degrees and then hone to the angle I want, I'll wind up with a two-part microbevel initially. I see no hazard in this and plan to try it with the next blade refurbishments, unless someone sees a problem I'm not seeing - ??

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#2

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

TomD

I'm having a little trouble with the words here. So say you want 26 degrees. and you initially power grind to 24, then proceed to the LV duplex of honing at 26 after having set and ground at 25, you now have three angles on the blade. No I don't see any problem other than the usual problems that occur with hollow grinds or double bevels, that do not deter many people from their use. Is that what you were getting at?

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#3

Yes, that's pretty much it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks for explaining it more specifically. That's what I had in mind.

Over time, the bevel would presumably settle in at 25 degrees.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#4

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

Larry Williams

"...No I don't see any problem other than the usual problems that occur with hollow grinds or double bevels..."

Can you explain what these are?

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#5

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

Brian Greene

Your experience is not uncommon, that is the blade is just off a smidge from a specific angle. The problem is easily overcome in one of three ways: regrinding which is unnecessarily wasteful; putting up with the result until, as you say, it settles in; or, don't use the set up jig for the MkII but, rather, eyeball it, mark the blade with ink (Sharpie), take a single stroke to see where you are cutting, adjusting as necesssary with the wheel for the roller in the 12 o'clock position.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#6

TAANSTAFL

wilbur

Can I take another stab at describing what you're seeing?

It sounds like the goal is to take a beat up chisel, use your Delta wet wheel grinder to grind it at, say, 25º, transfer the chisel to the Veritas MkII for honing, also set for 25º, and then see the metal wearing away nicely on the edge and the heel of the bevel as it would if you were freehanding the honing.

What you are seeing instead is that after grinding, the Veritas MkII's version of 25º is a little off the Delta's version of 25º, since the metal is being removed from the top part of the bevel only.

If that is the case, my vote is to go back to your grinder and set it for a slightly shallower angle than wherever you had it. That way when you go from the grinder to the honing guide, you'll only be working the cutting edge, and over time the entire bevel will match the angle that the honing guide is setting, until you feel the need to grind the chisel again.

The other alternative is to use the coarsest, most aggressive method you have of sharpening with the honing guide. Something like 80 grit sandpaper. But although I've done that at times, I think it's still easier to use a grinder.

Eventually you'll have to grind away the metal at the top of the bevel, regardless of what you do. The problem with the overshoot/undershoot method is that you'll be removing that top part of the bevel with your honing, and as I mentioned before, it's a lot easier to do that with your grinder than with your honing guide.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#7

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

TomD

There are a category of issues that get fervently argued that have to do with the starting with some sort of rhetorical box. In this case bevel angle. If a person believes that a 25 degree bevel angle is straight from god, then there are variations that occur in various characteristics if you say have a main bevel of 5 degrees and a secondary bevel of 25 degrees. Could be good as with a certain knife, or piecing chisel format. Might be a weak edge if one was planning at dragging it through the wood at a 55 degree angle. Same deal make a hollow grind with a 1/4" stone (extremes are just for purposes of visualization, The arguments take flight at much tighter variations like 8" grinders, or bevels that diverge by only a few degrees).

There are a lot of variable, like are we talking about ease of sharpening the bevels , or durability, performance, etc...

In Bill's case, I don't see the issue if the angle divergence is fairly tight. If for some reason he has a big divergence, then I think it isn't a boutique question, it is just a the question of sharpening with secondary bevels which gets hotly argued all the time.

With plane blades what experiments I have done indicate one can do with a far smaller clearance angle than 20 degrees, as little as 5 degrees has worked for me. So in Bill's example, one could just skip to 30 degree, in this case a sharper edge, and then the whole issue would go away because even a 5 degree lower primary would still be 25 degrees, presumably acceptable to even some in the flat bevel society, and the micros would be more obtuse.

I didn't see the point in going into all the details he was, if he was just asking about secondary bevels, that is a simpler question. So I am assuming he is looking for an overlooked issue he might not have read 500 threads on. Which is why I threw out the bit at the end, just to be sure.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#8

Sharpening jig/grinding answer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I seems to me that the problem lies in your concept of a honing guide and, how it is used.

A honing guide excels at creating and honing a micro secondary bevel. It is, for example, never intended to hone the full face of a primary bevel or even the expanded area of a secondary bevel. It is possible to set it up to hone a full face, whether this is flat or hollowed, but you would have to ask yourself "why would I?". This is the rationale behind freehanding a blade, but not in using a honing guide. As soon as the secondary bevel wears, one should increase the honing angle slightly, and create a new micro secondary bevel. This way the amount of steel to be removed is miniscule each time.

Looked at this way, it matters not what angle the primary bevel is, since you are going higher when you hone. It also does not matter what angle the primary bevel is - whether 20, 25 or 30 degrees - since it does not relate to the secondary bevel. Consequently, you could grind a significantly lower primary bevel than usual, one that runs little chance of creating a conflict with the accuracy of the built-in protractor of the honing guide.

The advantage of a honing guide like the LV (both Mk I and II) is the in-built adjustment for a secondary bevel. This can be altered a couple of times, increasing each level by 1 degree.

Get the primary bevel (far) out the way and concentrate on forming a micro secondary bevel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#9

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

Brian Greene

Excellent addition to what I said about eyeballing the primary, if it's off a lot from what was ground. I see too many people spending way too much time doing stuff to the primary bevel that doesn't need to be done. The action is at the secondary or micro bevel.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#10

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

Pam Niedermayer

Do you think ignoring this will make it go away? .....Nah, didn't think so. :)

I honestly disagree that honing guides are intended/work well with microbevels only. Honing guides don't much care whether you're working on the entire bevel (-to-be) or not; and honing guides differ so much from each other, I don't see how you can make this claim. Perhaps you've found them easier to use for microbevels?

Pam

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#11

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

Brian Greene

My point is very simple, the primary bevel doesn't do any work. After it's been shaped, by whatever means, most efficiently with a grinder of some sort, there is no point in refining it further.

I freehand 100%. I go from grinding the primary, when necessary, usually on a coarse wheel, to the micro bevel. If it's a new blade, I don't do anything to the primary except clean away the lacquer coating. Then straight to the micro.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#12

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

Pam Niedermayer

The primary for all my Japanese chisels, and since I like this sort of consistency, I've extended the philosophy to my western chisels, does an enormous amount of work. I have no, nada, zero microbevels, hollow ground bevels, ruler tricked back bevels, etc.

I certainly do not dispute that your methods may work best for you, fine, have at it; but to make sweeping generalizations about bevels and chisels is uncalled for. I certainly do not require you to adhere to my methods.

Pam

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#13

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

In my opinion, with just one exception, honing guides are best suited to sharpening via micro secondary bevels. It is inefficient - with non-laminated blades - to hone the full face of a bevel.

Only the Sharp Skate is designed to hone full faces. And this was really developed with laminated Japanese blades in mind, an alternative to side-to-side freehand sharpening.

When one freehand sharpens a non-laminated blade, either one creates a hollow grind and uses this as a template to hone, or one lifts the blade when honing. Both methods create a microbevel. The first method does so without a secondary bevel, while the second method relies on it.

All these methods have one thing in common: reduce the amount of steel that needs to be removed in sharpening. The reason that this is not considered necessary with laminated blades is that the layer of hard steel is thin already, and the soft backing layer abrades relatively easily. The point is, here too one is only honing a small section of the bevel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#14

Full bevel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We use the full bevel when making mortises. Also any other time when we ride the bevel.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#15

My Method

Brian Greene

My comments presume a micro bevel. I'm not trying to overgeneralize or be preachey. This is how I do it. It very definitely works. Your mileage may vary.

Derek Cohen has, I think, explained it very well below.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#16

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

TomD

The LV is brilliant because it minimizes the problems of a sharpening jig by making it easier to acquire the bevel, and making the secondary a micro step and repeatable. I suppose the main problems of micro bevels are that they tend to consume material faster which is fine for cheaper chisels, and also they weaken the edge. Both of these problems is made less severe by ensuring that the step between the angles is as small as possible, and is as repeatable as possible. The LV could even have a half degree step making the differences pretty minor.

I suppose a further part of the problem with all this is that while folks think they are efficiency minded, they are still only creatures of half measures. If one wants to see what efficient chisels look like, one need only look as far as the turning field where blades are removable. and there are other examples. But to the extent that chisels are modeled after arty old designs and can be used up expensively, a concern for traditional methods that go with their use seems reasonable. It does no more harm to a Japanese chisel to micro bevel it as Krenov suggested than to any other. Just as a Krenov cabinet could be adapted to casters for making it easier to move around, but the insult, and impact on value are a consideration.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#17

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

TomD

"The reason that this is not considered necessary with laminated blades is that the layer of hard steel is thin already, and the soft backing layer abrades relatively easily. The point is, here too one is only honing a small section of the bevel. "

There is some truth to that, though the main examples, the Japanese blades are so hard that they take extra time to sharpen anyway, assuming one had to remove the same amount of material, which is hard to say. In any case it is more efficient to sharpen these tools with jigs or micro bevels also, once one is on the stone. But it has certain drawbacks which are the real reason not to use them.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#18

Re: Tradtional Archery

TomD

It is kinda funny how the same issues come up over and over in different activities. I've have enjoyed archery all my life, and I like it in any form, but mostly enjoy what is called traditional archery which is archery up to the 70s before the compound bow was produced. There are almost an infinite gradation of slots that one can enjoy in archery.

Primative archery is sticks and stone, sinew, and hide glue. That would be roughly equivalent in attitude to really extreme hand tool only woodworking, though I guess it would really be stone age woodworking, and in fact can be.

Then traditional is sorta like hand tool woodworking with modern instances of old tools so kinda through to Lee nielsen.

Then recently the popularity of Olympic bows caught on among tradtional archers. These days made with CNC and carbon fiber. These would be equivalent to stuff like Rali planes, or maybe some of the better LV gizmos, and maybe Jointmaster. Sstill hand held and drawn but all gageted up.

Then one has one's power tools, in archery and woodworking.

Basically interesting to see how people see themselves in terms of challenge, practicality, spirituality, and self-empowerment. A clinical psychologist would be useful at times like this. :)

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#19

Re: Full bevel

david weaver

well, not all of us do.

Those of us who learned to cut mortises from robert wearings book (either directly or by someone else telling us after learning wearings method) do not.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#20

didn't really answer my question

Larry Williams

You said, "...No I don't see any problem other than the usual problems that occur with hollow grinds or double bevels..." and I asked what those were.

I can think of three so-called problems I see mentioned:

1. "It wastes steel." Those who think this don't understand that grinding is done only to reduce the size of the honed bevel unless some damage is done to the edge through abuse.

2. "There's a risk of over heating the steel." Yes, there is that risk but there's also risk in using a table saw or even using a sharp chisel. Reduce that risk by learning what you're doing and maintaining your equipment.

3. "Hollow grinds weaken the edge." If so, it's negligible. I've used hollow ground edges daily at work for more than 30 years and broken two tool's edges. Once was prying with a carving gouge when I knew I shouldn't and the other was tuning up a vintage craftsman-made plane for a guy in a workshop. The iron was made from a file and I have no idea what was done in heat treating that iron but it was the most brittle and coarsest grain steel I've ever seen. I had trouble with it crumbling during honing and once I had what looked like a good edge, it shattered on first contact with wood.

Are there problems other than these?

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#21

Re: didn't really answer my question

TomD

""You said, "...No I don't see any problem other than the usual problems that occur with hollow grinds or double bevels..." and I asked what those were."

Yeah I was trying to hint that I acknowledge there are different opinions on this stuff but would prefer not to get into it.

"I can think of three so-called problems I see mentioned:

1. "It wastes steel." Those who think this don't understand that grinding is done only to reduce the size of the honed bevel unless some damage is done to the edge through abuse."

Or they understand that the steel is removed more quickly using this method so one is more likely to overshoot than on a method where that is not the case, and one is more likely to underpolish since whatever level of abrasive is being used will cut deeper on a smaller surface. My O1 chisels cost under a dollar to make, but you can spend hundreds on a chisel, and some folks who are actual producers do. You have be thinking in those terms.

"2. "There's a risk of over heating the steel." Yes, there is that risk but there's also risk in using a table saw or even using a sharp chisel. Reduce that risk by learning what you're doing and maintaining your equipment."

Or the person who knows how to use and maintain the appropriate gear could get out of the dark ages and use one of the many power systems that cuts faster than grinding and hand jigs and delivers as good an edge, without undercutting it, making parts of it rough, etc...

"3. "Hollow grinds weaken the edge." If so, it's negligible. I've used hollow ground edges daily at work for more than 30 years and broken two tool's edges. Once was prying with a carving gouge when I knew I shouldn't and the other was tuning up a vintage craftsman-made plane for a guy in a workshop. The iron was made from a file and I have no idea what was done in heat treating that iron but it was the most brittle and coarsest grain steel I've ever seen. I had trouble with it crumbling during honing and once I had what looked like a good edge, it shattered on first contact with wood."

It's not the thirty years you spend, it is what you spend them on. Most people don't care a lot about details in most things. And care a lot about details in some thing. So for instance you write lyrically about the benefits of beech, and have spent a great deal of time researching "unimportant" differences among traditional plane makers. But when it comes to blades you use O1 which is a shortcut. I personally like O1, It's like arguing over MP3s, vinyl, or cds. Somewhere someone cares a lot.

"Are there problems other than these?"

Yeah...

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#22

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

Pam Niedermayer

When one freehand sharpens a non-laminated blade, either one creates a hollow grind and uses this as a template to hone, or one lifts the blade when honing. Both methods create a microbevel. The first method does so without a secondary bevel, while the second method relies on it.

Seriously? Again, you've constrained my actions. I neither create a hollow grind nor lift the blade when freehanding, western or eastern chisels. So, how about a third or fourth option for me to use? I think this may be a case of how men and women comprehend when arguing. I talk to Jack and list three reasons why he should/not do certain things, five minutes later I ask him what I said, he can't remember. So know this: however tedious this gets, whenever you constrain me to your two ways of doing something, I'll complain.

Now, what did I just say? :) Doesn't having it in writing help at all?

Pam

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#23

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

Pam Niedermayer

But to the extent that chisels are modeled after arty old designs and can be used up expensively, a concern for traditional methods that go with their use seems reasonable. It does no more harm to a Japanese chisel to micro bevel it as Krenov suggested than to any other. Just as a Krenov cabinet could be adapted to casters for making it easier to move around, but the insult, and impact on value are a consideration.

Oh, I like this. Thanks, Tom.

Pam

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#24

Re: Tradtional Archery

Pam Niedermayer

Primative archery is sticks and stone, sinew, and hide glue. That would be roughly equivalent in attitude to really extreme hand tool only woodworking, though I guess it would really be stone age woodworking, and in fact can be.

I was thinking about the stone age a couple of nights ago, while scanning this new book called "A history of the world in 100 objects." The first object they claimed was from 1.8 million years ago, a big old rock with a planed off edge, presumably for cutting meat off bones. The writer, who said a replica cut roasted chicken off the bone (well, what doesn't?) with aplomb, also said it was the first tool. Can't possibly be so. I mean, what happened to sticks and bones, which must have been first. Of course they most likely didn't survive, but still....

Pam

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#25

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding answer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

My comments are made with Bill's original question in mind. There are exceptions to every rule, and clearly you are one of the exceptions since you fall outside his topic.

Bill wrote, "I am not hoping, here, to re-open the discussion of freehand vs. jigged sharpening. I happen to like using a jig.

My current jig of choice is the Veritas Mk. II guide, which sets the bevel angle with great precision. The trouble comes if the chisel/plane blade is sharpened at an angle slightly different from the angle to which I've adjusted the blade in the guide".

My first post was about the aim of a honing guide (creating micro secondary bevels). My second post was the freehand alternative, but intended to reinforce the objective of efficiency I outlined earlier (of creating micro secondary bevels). You wish to talk about honing full bevels, which is not efficient. That is a topic for another place and time.

Regards from Perth

Derek