Re: Good analogy!
Sharpening jig/grinding question
Posts
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#27Which came first...
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
...the chicken slicer or the egg whisk? (all right, all right, I'm sorry; but it was such a good straight line)
Pam, you said, "The writer, who said a replica cut roasted chicken off the bone (well, what doesn't?) with aplomb, also said it was the first tool."
I agree; the first tool is lost in the mists of time - and who's to say that the primates who, even today, poke sticks in termite mounds to enjoy that lovely treat, termitoidae-on-a-stick, didn't come up with that idea first? Long before the primates we call our ancestors thought about making their own sharp-edged tools to cut up meat for the evening meal.
I'm not sure that roasted chicken dismemberment is the best test anyway; you're right on that you don't need tools other than fingers and teeth for that project. Cutting strips off a raw mammoth carcass, now, that would probably be harder.
"Earliest tool known to have survived" would no doubt be more accurate; precision matters in such things. I wonder if it was the writer or editor who committed that faux pas?
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#28Re: didn't really answer my question
david weaver
I agree with larry on all of these. I can't see how using a 6" grinder is a stone age issue. I can't think that there are any electric tools that produce a good edge faster than a grinder and two stones. Three out of four full sharpenings take about 30 seconds for me. The fourth takes an additional 30 seconds to refresh a hollow.
In five years, I've never broken a hollow ground edge. at least not to the hollow. And if it's not broken up to the hollow, it has nothing to do with being hollow ground.
A power system is much more threat to an edge than a dry grinder. If I ever grind to the edge, I do just get to it, but usually grind until just 1/2 hair short.
I used more edge when I was sharpening by hand and using several bevels, because it was always tempting to run the second bevel in a jig back hard to make sure the edge is clean.
It's my opinion that most who do all of their work with hand tools will eventually move toward a dry grinder or a high speed belt sander, or they'll possibly lean toward only the oldest plain steel tools and work entirely by hand with a very coarse stone and perhaps two others (warren?).
I never became obsessed with sharpening faster but just as sharp and clean until I dumped using my TS, planer and jointer. Wear on my plane irons and chisels is still creeping along at a slow pace, probably slower now that I don't use a guide and really hammer away at a second bevel with the 1000 stone.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#29Re: Which came first...
Pam Niedermayer
"Earliest tool known to have survived" would no doubt be more accurate; precision matters in such things. I wonder if it was the writer or editor who committed that faux pas?
Hard to say for sure, had to return that book this morning; but if it's the writer, which I consider unlikely, he should have been corrected by the editor(s). Which is why I so seldom even look at this type book, but the editor made a very good impression on Charlie Rose.
Pam
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#30Whatever, but it's not inefficient.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#31Re: didn't really answer my question
Pam Niedermayer
In five years, I've never broken a hollow ground edge. at least not to the hollow. And if it's not broken up to the hollow, it has nothing to do with being hollow ground.
I think you need to rethink your geometry.
Pam
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#32Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
david charlesworth
Bill,
To return to your original question, I can see nothing wrong with your plan at all!
The Tormek angle device is not sufficiently accurate to nail your grinding angle precisely.
I suspect that your tool holding jig may be the old design which jigs the chisel from the wrong side, the one opposite to the back. This means different thickness blades require slightly different projections to achieve the same angle. There is a new Tormek straight blade jig which registers from the correct side. Something which I suggested to the designer, Torgny Jannsen, about ten years ago.......
Best wishes,
David Charlesworth
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#33Re: didn't really answer my question
Larry Williams
"Yeah I was trying to hint that I acknowledge there are different opinions on this stuff but would prefer not to get into it."
Saving your efforts for personal attacks or attacks on my business and avoiding backing up your claims? It's that kind of trolling that keeps Konrad Sauer and some other small makers from participating in forums like this.
"Or they understand that the steel is removed more quickly using this method so one is more likely to overshoot than on a method where that is not the case, and one is more likely to underpolish since whatever level of abrasive is being used will cut deeper on a smaller surface. My O1 chisels cost under a dollar to make, but you can spend hundreds on a chisel, and some folks who are actual producers do. You have be thinking in those terms. "
I don't think you've learned to grind. If you push things when you grind near the edge you'll overheat the steel. As I said, you avoid grinding to the edge unless you're repairing damage from abuse and those times you grind at 90º to the tool.
"Or the person who knows how to use and maintain the appropriate gear could get out of the dark ages and use one of the many power systems that cuts faster than grinding and hand jigs and delivers as good an edge, without undercutting it, making parts of it rough, etc... "
Oh, you mean like a $1,400 oscillating diamond grinder:
or an $800 lap sharp:

We have them and they can't grind or sharpen many of the tools we use or make. They're no replacement for a bench grinder. We have a lot of grinding capability, we've got about 10 other grinders in the shop if you want to discuss them. "Dark ages" indeed.
Under-cutting isn't an issue with hollow grinding unless people want to pretend it is.
"...But when it comes to blades you use O1 which is a shortcut...."
Huh? Care to expand on that or is it just another attack on my business?
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#34Re: didn't really answer my question
TomD
"I agree with larry on all of these."
there are other opinions, as you should well know.
" I can't see how using a 6" grinder is a stone age issue. I can't think that there are any electric tools that produce a good edge faster than a grinder and two stones. Three out of four full sharpenings take about 30 seconds for me. The fourth takes an additional 30 seconds to refresh a hollow."
So you figure that is how the factories do it, they hand sharpen every edge?
"In five years, I've never broken a hollow ground edge. at least not to the hollow. And if it's not broken up to the hollow, it has nothing to do with being hollow ground."
I didn't bring breaking edges off into it, so you should just agree to agree with larry on that. I would like to hear you explanation of why a hollowed out edge is better. I think it can be, but there are lots of cases where it isn't or traditionally by generations of makers has not been seen to be. And since the only reason advanced for it so far is it is faster to make, except when it isn't, I don't really see that it is convincing, since there are traditional deep craft ways, and modern ways to make it flat.
"A power system is much more threat to an edge than a dry grinder. If I ever grind to the edge, I do just get to it, but usually grind until just 1/2 hair short."
"It's my opinion that most who do all of their work with hand tools will eventually move toward a dry grinder or a high speed belt sander, or they'll possibly lean toward only the oldest plain steel tools and work entirely by hand with a very coarse stone and perhaps two others (warren?)."
Personally that is where I am too. I either want to do the "old" tools though they are not mostly plain steel in my case. Or I run a belt sander, grinder, buffer, etc... Since there are options here that produce flat bevels, I would have to see your research that proves, that the hollow grinds are worth the extra trouble. I can't off the bat think of any situation where a concave bevel is something I would spend extra time on. I do see situation where a convex bevel is worth it to me.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#35Re: didn't really answer my question
David Weaver
It's more likely that you need to reread my statement and rethink it. If the break doesn't make it to the hollow, then it isn't due to the hollow.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#36Re: Efficiency
Brian Greene
I'll bite. I agree with Derek. I'll also say this. Honing Guides are not efficient. They are consistent but they are necessarily slower than freehand. Moreover, honing the full face is also necessarily less efficient than honing just the micro bevel. The only reason for micro bevels is efficiency. There is no other reason for them to exist. Less steel is in play, less force, fewer strokes and all that. I'll take it further and suggest this, as a notion to kick around, that efficiency comes with volume. The more you sharpen, the more refined become your movements; fewer missteps, more muscle memory accuracy, etc.
Please note that I'm not suggesting, or preaching, that any method is "better" than any other. Better is a scarey word in these sorts of contexts. But they are what they are in terms of efficency because that's measureable. Different people simply prefer to work different ways.
Then there is the Paul Sellers method which totally baffles me.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#37Re: didn't really answer my question
TomD
"Saving your efforts for personal attacks or attacks on my business and avoiding backing up your claims? It's that kind of trolling that keeps Konrad Sauer and some other small makers from participating in forums like this."
Really? I'm aware, as you must be that there are businesses out there, and traditions that are flat bevel oriented, and that this can be a lively topic, even when one sets out to avoid it.
"I don't think you've learned to grind. If you push things when you grind near the edge you'll overheat the steel. As I said, you avoid grinding to the edge unless you're repairing damage from abuse and those times you grind at 90º to the tool."i
I do, I maintain a wide range of tools in my shop, from simple edges to end mills for which I use a 2x8" grinder 1800, 2x6" grinder 3600, wide belt grinder, disk grinder, KMG 2x72 , variable speed 1.5 hp, on my second KO Lee tool grinder, 1x42 LV belt sander, hand crank grinder, LV waterstone grinder powered. Lots and lots of hand sharpening tools, and portable grinders and polishers.
"we've got about 10 other grinders in the shop if you want to discuss them. "Dark ages" indeed."
Yeah sounds like an interesting thread, I am surprised with all that horsepower that you choose to grind your edges as you do. Sounds like you are taking great care of the stuff you use to make stuff.
"Under-cutting isn't an issue with hollow grinding unless people want to pretend it is."
Can you explain how it provides a superior tool in use, as opposed to a more efficient process? You are just making a claim, other people disagree. That is true in woodworking, it is true in the knife biz where hollow grind vs flat and convex edges are also argued. You have stated your claim, noted. But there are thousands of other opinion out there, lots of other businesses some have been around a lot longer than yours.
"Huh? Care to expand on that or is it just another attack on my business?"
Seems like a shortcut when I do it. I buy the stuff in pre-ground sheets, it cuts and grinds like butter, and and heat treating is as easy as it gets. I like the results. Does seem to go faster than the alternatives. In the English language, not all shortcuts are bad, some are just shortcuts, what they aren't is a seven year apprenticeship with a blacksmith who is a living treasure. Most of the guys using O1 to make blades are not hiding from the fact. You can go back and read their hesitant threads as they entered the business and tried their easiest first steps. It's cool that O1 works out so well, but you don't see a lot of masterclasses on the O1 blade.
"http://www.knifeforums.com/forums/showtopic.php?tid/868251/"
Pretty typical newbie I want to use O1 cause it's easy thread, though personally I don't take my time with the quench.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#38Re: Efficiency
Pam Niedermayer
Seems to me that when a microbevel user has to regrind the full bevel and apply another microbevel about every third sharpening, there is no efficiency to be seen, over all.
As to Sellers, an edge is defined by the meeting of two planes. In the case of edge tools, it's OK for one of those planes to be tiny, like with a microbevel. So Sellers' edges are sharp and fast, there are some real efficiencies there on those blades intended to have convex bevels.
Pam
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#39Re: didn't really answer my question
Pam Niedermayer
OK, that's just silly. If a hollow grind removes support for the tool steel edge, that edge could bend just enough to break, not necessarily at the hollow grind. The metal just doesn't necessarily follow our little rules.
Pam
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#40Re: Efficiency
Brian Greene
Pam, you raise a good point. However, would not skipping two bits of work on the primary be more efficient than addressing it every time?
My edges are sharp and the process is fast because I do a lot of sharpening. However, I frequently wonder if I am getting the best edge possible for the effort I put in. I hollow grind and lift just slightly so that I'm not riding on the back and front of the hollow, doing a small (1/32 - 1/64) micro bevel in the process. The problem with this is that you must be very aware of the angle or you won't get the edge. I often have to re-do. (There I've said it!) It's still wickedly fast which is very important to me.
Recently, I'm wondering whether, as a result of this method, I'm also creating a steeper than desireable micro, because it must be steeper than the traditional way. If so, it's solveable by starting with a shallower primary.
Having said that I'm reverting back to the traditional way (riding the back and front of the hollow) hoping to a) reduce the angle of the micro and b) make the effort more consistent. I want to see if, subjectively, I'm getting better edges, more consistently, with no loss of efficiency.
Still not sure about Sellers. If his method is valid, and I don't doubt he gets good edges, what does that say about the underlying principles of the methods we are used to? How come we are only hearing about this method now? One specific concern that the convex shape raises is that it's inappropriate for mortising, the wedging action causing splitting.
Cheers,
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#41Re: didn't really answer my question
david weaver
I don't understand why a hollow grind is "extra trouble". The wheel on the grinder is good for years, it takes very little time to make two or three passes on the wheel, cool the edge with the palm of my hand. I have a kalamazoo belt grinder, too. I use it on cambered irons, but it is not better for sharpening chisels or smoother irons than a grinder.
I'm not aware of a factory that puts a good edge on a tool. Not even razors are shave ready, and, yes, someone does sharpen and strop those by hand at the factory - they still come up short presumably due to budgeted time to do the job.
Closest I've gotten to to factory sharp *good* is japanese tools, I'm assuming the blacksmith or apprentice runs them across stones, not something automated. That said, a laminated tool with a wrought iron back is designed to be sharpened differently than a western tool that is entirely hardened. Plus, even though they are sharpened, they are not to a level where a cabinetmaker would use them to smooth, even if they're not heavily lacquered.
What I don't follow at all is how creating and maintaining a hollow is somehow a sacrifice. It is, instead, the fastest way to work precisely up to a bevel and still not hit the end of the bevel. You can do the same thing with a belt grinder if you maintain two bevels, but it is not faster than a grinder and two stones, especially if you consider that the hollow is ground once per four heavy sharpenings, and less than that if the use is light.
Nobody contends that a hollow grind is stronger than a flat bevel. At the same time, I've seen folks time and again descdribe how the edge is weakened, but I've never seen anyone say they broke the edge of a tool because of a hollow. If it's not weakened to a state that makes a practical difference, then there's no sense even saying that. It just confuses beginners.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#42Flat bevel
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I thought I would give some notes about the flat bevel, David. I stopped using a secondary bevel around 1976 and stopped hollow grinding in 1981, so I am having trouble remembering all the reasons. I try for consistency. I try to keep the tool sharp within a very narrow range through gentle use and frequent sharpening. I want the tool to be roughly in the same condition every time I sharpen and have the same feel every time it hits the stone. I don't want to be thinking that it has been three times since I hollow ground or since I made a bevel at another angle, and have to adjust accordingly. I am after intimacy here, and limit the number of tools I use regularly. The work on the coarse stone is not excessive because the tool is not very dull.
David, on January 11 you wrote, I've not seen a lot of plane iron type wear on any of my chisels, it's always deformation/chipping right at the edge that sends me back to the stones. I don't get chipping or deformation on the edges of my chisels, whether made in 1830, 1880, 1930, 1980, or 2008. I have no explanation for this.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#43Re: Flat bevel
david weaver
Warren, if you mortise a plane or something out of hard maple, you will see tiny chips in the edge if you look at it with light and magnification. If you do not, then I would assume that you are diddling through the process, or you're not using a chisel to do that to begin with.
That comment was probably in response to someone who was discussing the need for wear resistance in chisels. I don't see the need for wear resistance. I think you're confusing how large of chips I'm talking about, and if you don't see them, it would be because you've never had the occasion to use a chisel heavily or perhaps you've not looked closely at an edge under some magnification. Perhaps I should've described the size of the chipping earlier. If anyone is looking at the edge of a chisel and seeing nicks with the naked eye, then either the chisel is garbage or the user is abusing it.
I guess I don't follow how you can't keep an edge in the same shape with a hollow grind. There are two routes you can go with a hollow, I can tolerate either of them, they are both quick, and the second would not decrease the "intimacy" you're talking about, nor would it keep you from frequently touching up your edges frequently enough to never notice the "chipping" i'm referring to above (you know them already). The two methods:
1) add a couple of degrees manually (no guide) to the primary bevel and sharpen the edge of the chisel
2) reference the hollow against a stone and do the same thing you'd do with a flat bevel - sharpen only a single bevel, and refresh the hollow as needed.
I assure you that in general use for joinery and other such things, your edges are no sharper than mine, no more quickly arrived to, and nor are mine any less "intimate".
I don't, however, care how hard a chisel is with the method that I use, nor what steel. And I don't have to have great stones to get a very good edge regardless of the hardness of the steel. To me, that's a lovely benefit.
But chisels aren't the only thing to be sharpened, planes are included, too. You will see significant wear on the iron if you are dimensioning your wood by hand and doing so in quantity, and the hollow does the same 1, 2 above, except the edge of a good plane iron will need touch up because of the level of wear, and not because of impact.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#44Efficiency rarely a consideration on this Forum
Bill Tindall
We don't have many discussions about the least amount one can get by with in sharpening, nor the most efficient path to get there. This information is to be found in shops trying to earn a living at it. What I see in these shops is an inexpensive grinder whose purpose is to quickly remove metal and a stone or two for edge refinement, freehand, and sometimes something for polishing the edge. Gigs, expensive grinders, multitudes of stones, complex routines are the training wheels for amateurs, those who require consistency in sharpening research, or persons on the book and lecture circuit. I could add, persons that get a significant part of their satisfaction in woodworking from sharpening. It is undeniable that the ability to split a hair or plane a 10m x 5 micron shaving is an admirable feat, worthy of achievement, if that is the where satisfaction lies.
Proclaiming best to this diversity is as pointless as saying my ancient Mazda is best for getting milk from the store compared to my friends Porche. I go to the store for milk. He goes to the store to drive to the store, and get some milk.
Anybody who regards sharpening as an annoying interruption to making stuff will soon discover what is adequate and most efficient, if they do much of it. I have a shelf full of training wheels I no longer need and steps I no longer use. It consists of jigs, stones, grit sizes, and routines I no longer find essential to make and fit a drawer.
The main useful purpose for having these discussions is to encourage those still on training wheels that it is possible to wean from them as experience is gained, and to be wary of buying expensive stuff that will one day sit, unnecessary, on a dusty shelf.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#45Re: didn't really answer my question
david weaver
I'm having trouble figuring out how most of that response has anything to do with sharpening woodworking tools quickly and precisely, and how any of it would have to do with practical use of woodworking tools.
I'm also still absolutely and completely baffled how anyone could construe the use of a hollow bevel as not taking care of tools. I just can't even comprehend how someone who has actually used the tools could come to that conclusion.
Where does the discussion of O1 come into this? I don't get it, there must be some prior history there that I'm not aware of.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#46"Riding" hollow bevels on flat sharpening media
Bill Tindall
Situation- All my experience is abrading hollow ground edges on either fixed diamond plates or some substrate charged with diamond powder. And I only pull the edged tool toward me- pull, lift, reposition and pull again.
In this context the tool will tell you when you have the optimum angle of tool to abrasive surface. If the angle is too shallow the heel of the hollow will drag and the tool will chatter across the surface. If the angle is too steep the bevel will not be sucked onto the flat surface. The tool will be teetery on its tip and you will loose control of the angle. When the angle is ideal the bevel is sucked into registration with the abrasive surface and the tool rides smoothly across it. A klutz can feel when it is right.
The resulting refined edge will be essentially the same angle as what was ground on the grinder. If the grinder didn't provide a straight edge it will be apparent after a few strokes and one can return to the grinder (crowned wheel) and grind away the revealed high spot.
Mother nature has provided for this process to be so accommodating it can be quickly learned by most anyone willing to try it. The resulting edge is adequate to make stuff.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#47Re: A grinder and two stones..
david weaver
... thank you for that post returning to reality...
A grinder and two stones.
I pinged a couple of professional hand tool woodworkers yesterday when this came up. For chisels and planes, they both use a dry grinder and two stones.
I doubt anyone on here has better edges than they do, and I would suppose that all of us who use our stones properly and have even a few concsious thoughts about the feedback of the tool after sharpening probably are in about the same place for sharpening (as in, our edges are all about the same level of sharpness).
A person with a grinder and two stones and a week's worth of skill will have an edge that lacks nothing, and that is no less sharp than any other method.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#48Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
Sgian Dubh
I feel impelled after recently scanning through a few 'sharpening' debates of one sort or another in a variety of woodworking forums to post a link to this hoary old sharpening chestnut of mine. Enjoy, or not, as the case may be, ha, ha. Slainte.
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#49Re: the scots
david weaver
...they're as hard to read as they are to understand when you're listening!
Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question
#50LV's plane blades, as shipped are sharp.



