New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Sharpening jig/grinding question

Posts

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#51

at least sharp enough

Bill Tindall

I don't doubt that people can detect, or even in cases benefit, from the highest levels of edge refinement. But for someone climbing up the learning curve of making stuff, this is not a useful target. And, as you found, these extremes of sharpness and/or bevel fretting are usually not necessary or practiced by many professionals making a living from their tools.

BTW, I too am a power grinder and two "stone" person. But, I don't try to surface plane figured woods or any other "demanding" task. All I can say is that it works for my kind of woodworking.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#52

Very well said.


Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#53

Re: You could be plenty sharp to finish plane...

David Weaver

.. I haven't encountered anything that a normal person would use in projects that doesn't plane well with my two stone process. I can get shavings in the range of 3 ten thousandths pretty easily (not I'd ever do it working something, but it shows room to spare for regular work) from my "quick" maintenance method.

My usual second stone is a stone with particle size just under a micron. I haven't gotten edges a whole lot sharper no matter how much time is spent on them.

The only thing I have that goes beyond that on a regular basis is what I shave with, and it doesn't go much beyond that.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#54

Re: Flat bevel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Warren, if you mortise a plane or something out of hard maple, you will see tiny chips in the edge if you look at it with light and magnification.

Well, yesterday I dug out a piece of hard maple and made four mortises and looked at the edge with a 30X loupe. No chips.

Then this morning I got the bright idea that maybe if I were rough with the chisel I could witness the chips. I "bashed" the chisel, hit it without holding the handle, levered it, twisted it, rootshed it, but still no chips. Next I tried levering it hard across the rough bottom of the mortise and in just seconds I had chips all across the edge. So a rough scraping action will chip the edge; not much of a surprise.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#55

Re: Flat bevel

david weaver

Perhaps four mortises isn't going to do it, if you continued to work the chisel it would ultimately become more dull because of tiny chipping, though, and not because of a pronounced wear bevel and rounding of the edge like you'd see on a plane iron.

I would never scrape the bottom of a mortise with the chisel as you did - I know you were only doing it to try to damage the edge.

The last time I can remember getting chips like that was opening a mortise on a plane iron with a small 1 inch ps&W laminated framing chisel with a 3 pound steel hammer. That's an example of accelerated failure, but it took little time to chop the mortise and remove those chips (the edge was hollow ground), perhaps 30 seconds to run across a ceramic 1000 stone and then a 15000 stone and palm the edge on the three steps back to the bench.

Warren, you do understand that the entire comment about chipping generally has to do with someone bringing up abrasion resistance as a desirable quality in chisel steel, right? And the discussion is about how an edge fails in regular use when it does, and not how you can avoid having the edge fail by sharpening it before it does. If you worked enough mortises to get the chisel to feel dull (not by abuse), then you'd find chips under your loupe, maybe, unless your eyesight is bad.

I get the sense that often when you're talking, you feel like nobody else knows how to use tools, that your critical eye toward what others are doing ignores context (as in, I could've protected the edge of my framing chisel, but it would've taken twice or three times as long to remove the plane mortise in maple), or that you generally have concluded no matter what, you're going to come up with something that's "more right". So more power to you with that.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#56

Re: Flat bevel

Pam Niedermayer

If you worked enough mortises to get the chisel to feel dull (not by abuse), then you'd find chips under your loupe, maybe, unless your eyesight is bad.

Right, find what I say you will unless you're deficient. Really?

Pam

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#57

chisel wear

Bill Tindall

Chisels get dull by either deforming or chipping, which depends on the steel and heart treatment of the steel. I have reached this conclusion from the examination of many worn edges on a variety of steels. For example, I never see chipping on 3V because it is too tough to chip at the hardness it was heat treated to. I always get chipping with a M2 chisel I made from a jointer blade. Indeed, wear resistance is an irrelevant metric for chisels.

If some form of dullness is never observed it just means that the tool gets sharpened before one of these failure modes shows up. (Which may be a reason to sharpen before one has to; but I lack the discipline to do that. But Warren is beginning to slowly have an impact on my sloppy ways.)

Many prefer deformation as the failure mode as a somewhat deformed edge can be coaxed into straightness on a fine stone without removing much metal.

I suppose if the bevel angle is sufficiently obtuse abrasive wear might be a failure mode.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#58

Re: Flat bevel

david weaver

try it and let us know what you find. Mortise properly (no scraping the edge), chop dovetails properly, etc, until you have an edge that you feel isn't sharp enough to do what you want it to.

Do the same thing with plane iron. Cut with it until you feel like you would sharpen it.

Then look at the two under a loupe (you won't even need to look under a loupe to see the wear on the plane iron edge, you can see it with the naked eye if the iron had a good polish at the edge to start). There may be a scratch or two on the chisel, but there will not be a pronounced wear bevel like you'd have on the plane.

So, try it, let us know. It's only as important as you want it to be because it's no more practical to know how a tool wears than it is to just have good tools that perform well for you and to like and use them. The wood doesn't know if you know why the edge will fail, and it doesn't care, so it's up to you and your curiosity to prove or disprove what I said above.

From an overall standpoint, it does matter if someone decides they want to find a super wear resistant steel to make chisels over a hand forged high carbon steel. The wear resistant steel will be a bigger nuisance to sharpen, so before someone decides they want to make a chisel with the most wear resistant steel they can find, they ought to figure out if it's abrasive or adhesive wear that's causing the chisel to feel dull after a lot of use.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#59

A reminder about civility

As Wayne Miller of Badger Pond used to say, this is here because it has to be somewhere - that is, not pointing at anyone in particular.

I sure didn't know my question was going to trigger such a wide-ranging discussion; it's been interesting to see how many different issues the sharpening task can raise. By and large, this group's great about discussing, disputing, and analyzing ideas. I suspect there are about a million paths leading to the mountain peak of sharpness, and the conversations about the pleasures and hazards of these paths are often illuminating. Bill Tindall even took a minute to write me a side message encouraging me to try freehand sharpening again, and I appreciate his efforts to convince me and acknowledge that I do need to re-examine my sharpening practices.

Some - a few - of us have let the vigor of the discussion push into uncivil responses. In my observation, two things trigger rudeness here: you (this is an abstract "you") think someone's said something that attacks you personally; or you think someone's said something that's wrong, wrong, wrong and bullheaded to boot, and you need to Correct It Right Now.

If you find your emotions getting riled, please do take a breath and reconsider before you post a hot message; maybe step away from the computer and come back later, when you can respond more calmly and with the respect that is typical of this community.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#60

Re: A grinder and two stones..

eliotandmax

I'm fairly new here. Which grit grinder and which grit stones.please? I have an assortment of water stones; they are, 250. 1000. 4000. 8000. Nortons.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#61

Re: A grinder and two stones..

david weaver

Any dry wheel grinder that's, say, 6" high speed or 8" low speed.

And the 1000 and 8000 of the stones you listed are what I'd use.

I've been using a 1000 shapton and a 15000 shapton for several years. That's about the biggest gap I'd want, and the shaptons cut fast for a stone of that grit as long as the steel isn't high speed steel. I wouldn't make that gap maybe with older style stones.

But the 1000 and 8000 nortons you have will give you every edge you'll ever need for woodworking short of working some carving tools, maybe.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#62

Re: A grinder and two stones..

eliotandmax

I read your post a couple of times and noticed that you excepted HSS. What't the problem with it? The plane iron I just sharpened is something with a rather high hardness( I think Rockwell 82 -or was it 62?) And it was cryo -hardened. I did have a hard time sharpening it on my stones. I even started at 250 and couldn't get anywhere. Tried a Tormec , which also took forever. Finally took it over to the wheel I use for turning tools.That took a few seconds! Then finished with all the Nortons I have, up to the 8000. I happen to have some old honing blocks that I picked up at an antique shop years ago -- I think for razors -- and finished up with those. I believe it's really sharp. The only way I have to test is the old thing about shaving hairs off my arm; is there a better test? Oh, I forgot. I also have two so-called 'Spider' ceramic sharpening "stones"( One is labeled 'fine' and the other 'super fine'). I always end with these. I believe these give the best edge but don't know that much.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#63

Re: A grinder and two stones..

Pam Niedermayer

And how about all the other stones you have and use, David? Or are you a different David Weaver from the one on sawmill creek?

Pam

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#64

Sorry, I don't run your tests on command. Bill?


Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#65

Two most useful sharpening tools you can buy

Bob Hackett

That would be a high power magnifying lens and good lighting. My lenses happen to be held by an eyepiece,like the jewelers use.

These simple tools will not only give you tons of real world feedback about what is really going on at the edge of any tool (where the real work is being done) they will also quickly let you know when it`s time to stop working and resharpen any edge.

Only you know the type of work you really do and things like the species of wood you favor or are working at the moment. We don`t know because you haven`t told us. Without this type of information we can`t begin to give you definitive answers.

I would suggest that one of two things happen; either you start narrowing our focus by giving us more information or do what most of us have done and answer these questions thru your own personal experience. Having us hand you answers to what we THINK might be your problem is a quick fix. You don`t learn or retain much that way and this approach is just as likely to lead you toward dead ends and increased frustration caused by chasing non-existent problems/conditions.

On the other hand, taking a bit of advice after asking focused questions and providing pertinent information here, preferably after checking out the archives, and then using that advice as a jump off point to experiment and find out what your real needs may be under different applications is by far one of the most underrated yet important skills you can develop in any trade,craft or hobby.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#66

Re: A grinder and two stones..

david weaver

I have more stones than you can imagine, perhaps 60 or 80 and *no* junk stones. I have several power sharpeners, too, including two sanders, a kalamazoo belt grinder, the LV grinder and a tormek.

I won't even pretend that more than a dry grinder, single 1000 (or so) stone and a finish stone is necessary. The rest of the stuff is a matter of curiosity and discretionary spending.

In fact, I'm quite sure I could do all of my work with one single hard arkansas if I culled a few of my tools that don't like arkansas stones.

The reality is, of the stones that I have, I don't use more than two at a time when using them for woodworking, no matter how many are floating around the house in drawers, etc. The exception to that is only for japanese tools that are allowed to actually get dull, and then I will use no grinder and 3 stones, and perhaps a fourth for a smoothing plane.

I like to play with them (the stones and the sharpening devices), but I like to play with and what's necessary are two different things. I wouldn't by any means have any japanese planes if I were just going with what's necessary, because i could put together a smoother, truing plane/short jointer and a jack with $30 of O1 and shop cutoffs.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#67

Re: A grinder and two stones..

david weaver

The spydercos you have are well regarded everywhere. They are a strange bird in the world of stones because they're intended to be used dry and without flattening, but I know of at least one world-class (and then some) craftsman who thinks really highly of them and uses them as his regular stones.

HSS (and by that, I mean M2 or more resistant than that to abrasion) likes to have a friable abrasive, like you'd have on a grinding wheel or a softer stone. Most stones that release grit slowly, unless the grit is diamond, load with HSS or don't cut it fast enough. Just my opinion. I have two, er....three HSS planes. I sometimes sharpen them with stones (having ground them accurately so that I don't have to work a lot of metal) and the shaptons work fine, but I wouldn't want to have only HSS tools and hard stones.

high hardness A2 cryogenic steel cuts slower on a stone than something like a vintage high carbon plane iron, but it's not a problem for any modern stone to handle A2 and high carbon, regardless of the hardness. It's the true high speed steels that favor something different if you have to sharpen them all the time.

I personally don't like HSS for planes that are intended to leave a finish surface, and I don't use them unless it doesn't matter or unless I am dimensioning an infill out of cocobolo or something (which isn't often).

I'd rather avoid them until at least the time that 3v becomes popular and cheap.

The razor hones you have (i'm assuming that's what they are) could be in a range from 4000 grit all the way to probably 15000 grit, and they can wear on the surface or be used with a lather, unless they have a label or print on them that says to use them with oil. Since they don't release grit, even the 4000 stone can become a very fine polish stone with use. If you have one that says "swaty" on it, it'll be very fine. If you have one that's a yellow color and says "Frictionite" on it and american hone, olean NY, I would think about setting it aside and not using it on tools (because they are worth a lot of $$).

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#68

Re: Sorry, I don't run your tests on command. Bill

david weaver

I don't know who commanded. It's just a matter of mentioning that intentional disagreement for the sake of nothing productive can certainly be squelched by a little bit of experimentation.

Smarm without the intention to find the truth isn't very productive.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#69

David Barnett

Good points, well stated. Diplomatic, even.


Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#70

We have been discussing this topic for years

Bill Tindall

You may be new to this discussion but it has been going on for years. Search my name for the past 10 years on this forum and Badger Pond and you will find numerous discussions remarkably similar to your post, and with the same skeptical response. Everything you say in this post is confirmed by our research in this area. For about 10 years we have made these claims about the different wear and hence, the different steel properties desirable for chisels vs plane irons. By in large this information has been dismissed, or ignored, except by Lee Valley, and a few boutique tool makers. While they keep their research findings to themselves as a competitive advantage, you can bet that they are weighing the properties of toughness, hardness and wear resistance in selecting steel for their future tools.

We are making some progress. When I first asked on Badger Pond why tool steels were not used for hand tools I was told with great authority that it was because these steels could not be sharpened to a keen edge. Mumbo Jumbo about grains and the like were offered by way of explaining the conclusion. We showed that was a false conclusion and demonstrated that diamonds sharpened these steels to as high a degree as traditional steels( see Steve Elliot's website and research in this field). Aluminum oxide is not an effective abrasive for vanadium and tungsten carbide is the true answer as to why many of the tool steels could not be sharpened by traditional means. A little science and research turned out to, in fact, be beneficial in this traditional field. Now it is quite accepted to use tool steels for plane irons.

We have yet to accept that chisels can also benefit from the properties of higher performance steel. However, I think the advantage here, except for the tiny market of mortise chisels, is lesser than with plane irons. Carbon steel makes an excellent chisel. Personally, I think it makes no sense to make a chisel from A2.

By the way, I scrape the bottoms of mortises. CPM 3V is too tough to chip and hence I don't see this kind of dulling, scraping or not. If a chisel fails by chipping it is not sufficiently tough.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#72

Re: A grinder and two stones..

eliotandmax

I will try to figure out what these honing stones are. In the meantime I'm just going to reflect on what an incredible source of knowledge you have!

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#73

recommend that lens again.......

Bill Tindall

You encouraged me to buy some sort of East European (I think) hand lens that I love even more than my cherished B&L from geology class. Others should own one too.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#74

Re: Two most useful sharpening tools you can buy

eliotandmax

I'm not sure if this post is reply to some of my questions or to the original poster.

I'm really mostly a turner. I turn hollow vessels something like those of David Ellsworth. I used to sell them at the Sansar Gallery in Bethesda, MD, before Ms. Sing retired. I started asking question here because I decided to make a Krenov-style hand plane. I made one years ago in a class with David Fink and found it to be my best plane. Also, I've always been fascinated by sharpening. I thought I knew a few things until I got over here, where I can see that I'm just a beginner-- even though I'll be 73 in a few weeks! To tell the truth, I don't use hand tools much. My most ambitious project was a large double trestle dinning room table of select mahogany -- a wedding gift to my son and new daughter of the second kind( perhaps someone here will guess now that I am a mathematician.) The hand work consisted of only two things: hours of surface smoothing the top using hand scrapers and chopping two long slanted mortises in the cross beam for the holding wedges.

I do appreciate all your help here. I hope my questions are appropriate to this site.

Re: Sharpening jig/grinding question

#75

Re: A grinder and two stones..

david weaver

Everyone has something that fascinates them, I guess. To me, it's the feel and results of different stones, and what they do to an edge. And how useful of a tool an edge is (whether it's scissors, pruning tools, kitchen knives, tools, razors, whatever...)

I don't know why it's fascinating, but to me it is, and I have the discretionary $$ to play with them. And as I was accused above, I have gobs of stones that serve no practial purpose other than recreation.

I think having a couple of stones and being very familiar with how to use them is more important than searching for stones that will do some particular trick. You can likely get the trick out of the stones you have already if you have anything decent (and it sounds like you do).

It's pretty nifty you ran into razor hones, though! Most of them are not worth any serious $$, but once in a while you'll find a rare one, or one that's not rare but known to produce a great edge on a razor, and they bring big $$.