New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Bench build update

Posts

Re: Bench build update

#26

Re: A question for all ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'd rather use plugs than veneer - veneer does not strike me as enduring on a bench.

A bit of a search and I found Konrad's description of his end cap construction in the reconstruction of a Shaker bench. He has done something very similar to my original plan ...

Here is a photo of the entire bench top - including the end caps. The breadboard end caps are held on by way of a 1" long tenon and a few 1/4" square drawbore pegs. They are also attached to the front of the bench with 1/2 blind dovetails. The 13" plank at the back of the bench is supported by a piece of maple glued into the dado - essentially turning it from an “innie” to an “outie”. The board is held in place with two screws from the underside of the outie





Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench build update

#27

Am I the only person that sits at a bench?

Bill Tindall

Many benches, such as the one pictured, don't have a place to put one's feet while sitting on stool at the bench, my preferred position for tedious tasks. I built a stool (and discovered I was not gifted in the arts and patience of building seating furniture) sized to my bench and use it often for work at the bench. I prefer storage behind the bench, but within easy reach of the bench.

Re: Bench build update

#28

I do sometimes

John in NM

But I have an old drafting chair I use, and it has a ring around the wheels for your feet, much like a bar stool.

Re: Bench build update

#29

Why hide the bolts?

John in NM

Like hiding end grain or carcase dovetails, this has just never made sense to me. Nothing wrong with seeing the hardware on a utilitarian object like a bench. If you just don't like the look of the bolts, that's fine too, your call naturally.

Re: Bench build update

#30

Re: A question for all ..

roger lance

Derek....you are falling in love with your bench which is a good thing and nice to see in a person with so much experience who might just have regarded a bench as a simple work platform before....the dovetail would be attractive and strong enough to counter the forces generated by the vise....especially if you reinforce the cap with bolts and barrel nuts....if you cap the bolt heads, make them removable so you can get at the bolts....I really like barrel nuts....they are available at LV and Woodpeckers.....since these bolts will be on the end of your bench, you will not be looking at them that often and your characterization of "ugly" will fade....one thing to be concerned about is possible expansion contraction of the top width and attaching of the end cap to allow for this freely....generally, end caps are directly secured at the front of a bench and all other bolts are housed in a slot in the end cap that allows for movement....I know you are on this but it is worth mentioning.

Re: Bench build update

#31

Re: A question for all ..

roger lance

Obviously, this slot is way longer than necessary....but I was young and dumb....


Re: Bench build update

#32

Re: Dovetail Orientation..

Hank Knight

It appears to me that if you wanted to gain some mechanical advantage from the dovetails (which I don't think you need), the tails and pins on Konrad's end cap should be reversed. His bench is apparently still going strong, so my observation is, in all liklihood, simply overkill.

Re: Bench build update

#33

Re: Dovetail Orientation..

roger lance

Hank....you are correct....the strength from that dovetail is from glue not the orientation of the dovetails.

Re: Bench build update

#34

Re: A question for all ..

TomD

That end wheel seem a bit on the twiddly size. I get it has to sit below the surface. How big is it, have they always been that size? I'm sure it will work fine, those vises can work with relatively faint pressure.

Re: Bench build update

#35

You are not alone....

roger lance

of course, all I've got for a seat is my utilitarian plywood box....I'll have to try one of those fancy stools sometime.... :D .


Re: Bench build update

#36

Re: Dovetail Orientation..

TomD

The strength of the dovetail is from the dovetail. You want glue use a finger joint. I am perplexed at why the endcap dovetails have that orientation. Maybe it makes the vise hardware money shot more impressive, though I would have taken the opportunity to make the front of the bench look better, and to make it look as though I understood how to design dovetail joints. ATMO

Someone mentioned the Klausz bench. The dovetail on the L-vise (if that is the one discussed), is not really loaded at all. There is a threaded rod that takes all the load. The clamping action pushes the dovetail together.

Re: Bench build update

#37

Re: Why hide the bolts?

TomD

Yeah to elevate the discussion, reveal the structure. Does it strike anyone as a tad delusional to be hiding bolts in a structure that consists of one whacking large, much celebrated nut and bolt assembly? 350 dollars worth.

The fact is that most woodworkers will not remain true to their wedges and wooden screws, and depart for a roll in the chips with the Machinist's spouse. You see how they can be tempted by the parts made in bright brass; knurled adjustor wheels, and checkered thumb screws. You can put as many dovetails on the end of that bench as you like, cover as many little bolts and screws, that rampant wheel and screw cut rod assembly flies your true colours.

Re: Bench build update

#38

Removeable Bench Top *LINK*

charlie belden

Bill asked:

"Is it practical for a bench of this kind to be built with a removable top to make moving it easier?"

The answer is YES.

Admit it or not, but stuff in the shop gets rearranged. The harder things are to move in order to make working with them better, or easier, the more apt you are to work The Way It Is rather than what works better. And god forbid that you have to move from one shop space to another . . .

Frank Klausz, a very practical woodworker, has a removable top on the wood working bench he made for himself. This man goes for the simplest effective means to an end. He relies on the weifht of his bench top to keep it from moving Up and Down, and two "bullet shaped pins" in two round sockets to keep it from moving In and Out and Left and Right. That's all that's required - no movement in the X, Y or Z direction. As long as it's position, relative to the base of the bench stays fixed, it works.

Attached, at the bottom of the page, is a simple, effective way of holding a woodworker bench top onto its base - Frank's Bullet Pins and Sockets. Top can be taken on and off - no problem.

And if you haven't thougt about it already, think about how you're going to level your bench since floor are seldom flat AND level. Shims will work - for a while - but leg levelers work better and longer. And if they're easier to set, and adjust as necessary, you're more apt to check the top for level and do some adjusting of the legs if warranted. Bench tops don't state flat - if what they're sitting on ISN'T. If you use the Back to the Bench Index link on the attached page and go from there to #18 in that index, there's a great leg leveler - that can be adjusted from ABOVE rather than from below, while laying on the floor - with two wrenches . . .


Bench Top To Base Connection

Re: Bench build update

#39

Re: Why hide the bolts?

Pam Niedermayer

In a workshop the bolt holes would collect all sorts of nasty and inconvenient stuff. Maybe if one installed bolt hole blowers? :)

Pam

Re: Bench build update

#40

Re: Removeable Bench Top

TomD

Shims work great, I have the same stack under my South Bend Heavy ten for years, aluminum, doesn't squirt out. If I was sure I would never move the bench (hasn't moved yet so I need a lot of reassurance apparently), I would cast epoxy pads. I hate levelers. Maybe if I had anodized aluminum legs, with levelers built by a really persnickety machinist, to the standards of a bench rest rifle, a set-up I can't afford...

Re: Bench build update

#41

Re: Pretty thread

TomD

Pretty thread, in the sense of the arc of all the posts in the index.

Re: Bench build update

#42

A pretty good ovolo molding. 


Re: Bench build update

#43

suggestion

Bill Tindall

If you add one of the rubber things that make the seal in a garden hose connector to the vice handle it won't make that annoying clank when it drops, and not pinch the fingers if the handle careless slides through while holding onto it (or am I the only clutz to do this "experiment"?

A box for a stool sitting next to a lathe! Something wrong here.........Have no fear, if I can make a stool (thank god for Epoxy) anyone can.

Re: Bench build update

#44

That's a good idea....

roger lance

I'll have to check into those hose fittings next time I'm in the local hardware....my fingers too have suffered from the handle slipping down on them while I'm distracted with whatever is in the vise....as far as the lathe goes, turners have a kind category for guys like me....utilitarian turners....which means I'm really not that accomplished on a lathe....but, you're right I need to add a proper stool to the list :D .

Re: Bench build update

#45

utilitarian turners

Bill Tindall

As the label is used in the local club, and I suspect this usage is standard, utilitarian turners refers to what is turned, parts vs art, not with what degree of skill. Some new folks came to town and advocated starting a turning club. I thought this idea was bizarre given that we already had a woodworking club. But they persisted and started a hugely successful club anyway. It was at the organizational meeting that I became acquainted with the term "utilitarian turners". These were the kind of turners that they were not. I soon learned that these turners were artists, and artist wanna bees, and that the medium they worked in was wood(more of less) and the tool of the trade was a lathe. The best of them could turn a vase and sell it for hundreds of dollars but couldn't make two spindles the same or use a skew. Different worlds. Being largely deficient of artistic skills, and having the good sense to know it, my turning remained utilitarian, but not shabby.


Re: Bench build update

#46

Love is a bit strong ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Building a new bench was low on my to-do list when I began. There are a couple of pieces of furniture I have been champing at the bit to build. However I also knew that I could no longer keep using the old bench. As the build has progressed, so I have begun to enjoy it.

I do believe that the effort and time taken is the same whether one does a good or poor job. Since I'm doing it, I'd like to make it good.

I am still unsure whether a combination of dovetails at the sides and a pinned mortice and tenon will be strong enough to resist being pulled apart by the forces exerted by the vise. My logic says it should be as one should not apply much pressure. Still, others indicate that it is better to over-build, using bolts in addition to the above.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench build update

#47

Re: utilitarian turners

roger lance

Now that's a beautiful bed....if you turned that, you are an accomplished turner....I guess I'm admitting to being a scrub....I've also found that the guys in turning group are very enthusiastic and active in their clubs....more so than woodworking clubs....maybe its because a turner can start and finish a project in a short period of time compared to us flat workers.

Re: Bench build update

#48

Re: Love is a bit strong ...

roger lance

Derek....I did use the term "love", but I didn't think you were going to elope or anything :D .....you should attach that end cap with dovetails and the pinning you propose and see how things go (I think you will be fine....it will hold)....and if it doesn't, then you can reinforce the cap with bolts and barrel nuts which are easy to install after the fact.

Re: Bench build update

#49

Force on the cap.....

roger lance

Derek....Your use of square dogs that are slanted at each other at 2 degrees is the "secret" to why you will not have to exert much pressure on stock clamped between dogs....those dogs are acting to force the stock down onto the bench top....just a little tightening will deliver great downward force and secure the work....I've never had to get physical with my tail vise and you won't either....for plane work or whatever....the dovetails and pinning will work.

Re: Bench build update

#50

Re: utilitarian turners

TomD

Bowlism, I'm all for it, is none the less the possible blind spot to the fact that a curve on a bowl and a curve a spindle are just as artistic. For some reason vessels get a lot of the play. But spindles are often more difficult. Of course "art" the act of staking out a particular commercial trademark and specialty, is not easy. Porcupine quills, burn marks, etc...

I don't much like the "Utilitarian" tag myself. The spindles on your bed are not particularly utilitarian. They should be competently "decorative". They could be drop dead beautiful which is art of a kind. But by your usual standard of what can I knock out fastest with least skill and effort, they are, well... Perplexing.

In the modern world there is actually far greater utility to discovering you can create a unique effect with a torch and a weldment chipper, than there is in making lumpy spindles that are more prone to break. The person pursuing the spindles is probably doing it for love, the person in the art world is also after an ego stroke, and maybe a check.