New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

WIA in 2012

Posts

WIA in 2012

#1

WIA in 2012

roger lance

This particular forum doesn't talk much about WIA but its been announced for two venues....at the end of October in Pasadena, California....and in early November in Cincinnati (I believe)....everyone thats been seems to have had a good time....any interest for this year in this group??

Re: WIA in 2012

#2

yep

ron in kokomo

I am really hoping to go to the Cincy one. I have read eagerly about them and have wished I could attend.

Re: WIA in 2012

#3

Absolutely!

Chuck Nickerson

Being Southern California based, I'm looking forward to the Pasadena show.

With luck I'll make them both. For those who travel to Pasadena, I've started

a list of WW-related side trips.

Re: WIA in 2012

#4

Re: WIA in 2012

wilbur

I've had the great good fortune to go to all (!) of the WIA's so far. It's completely worth the trip, and I will be going to one or the other location this year.

Re: WIA in 2012

#5

WIA 2012

Michael Brady

I'm curious about why one hand tool forum would be less interested than another one in an event like Woodworking in America. Having attended WIA, I can't imagine that any regular reader or poster here would not find the classes and marketplace very eye-opening. Having the two venues this year will give a lot more people access.

Wilbur would concur that the opportunity to meet fellow forum contributors in person is just as rewarding as the organized parts of the event. Perhaps more so. I've even spied Ellis there a couple of times. One challenge that has not been completely met is how to know connect at the show with others from your favorite forum. Hopefully, that can be addressed this year.

Re: WIA in 2012

#6

should be easy to accomplish

Bill Tindall

I used to attend a national meeting where the people attending had "communities" among themselves. Each community (in the case at hand, Forum participants) would designate a place for an evening mixer. It could be a hotel room or something more formal. If there are rooms at the event that are otherwise unused in the evening, perhaps these rooms could be used.

Re: WIA in 2012

#7

Re: WIA in 2012

Hank Knight

I was fortunate enough to attend the first WIA in Berea, KY. I enjoyed it thoroughly. I haven't been able to attend any of the subsequent ones, but I understand they get better each year. I completely agree with Wilbur, they are well worth the effort and the cost. By the way, one of the highlights of my Berea trip was running into Wilbur in the hotel lobby and having lunch with him. You meet all kinds of interesting folks there, not to mention gorging on quality woodworking topics, tools and lore. I'd love to make it to Pasadena this year and combine WIA with visits to the Greene and Greene shrines.

Hank

Re: WIA in 2012

#8

WIA *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been to two WIA conferences. Certainly enjoyable, but I don't think I am as enthusiastic as you, Mike. The market place has some good vendors, but lots and lots of useless gadgets. I don't think I saw a single bench plane that I would consider using even if I got it for free. It is frustrating to talk to vendors who are constantly suggesting that you don't know what you are talking about. There was a discussion of Lee Valley chisels at the conference on this forum on January 10. The speakers at WIA are worthwhile. Below is a link to a report Ellis made of the conference in 2009, with pictures of posters to this forum.

I would more highly recommend the Williamsburg conference. The work presented is generally somewhat more sophisticated. And there is much better audio visual display. You sit in an auditorium with a large screen above the stage and there are three cameras trained on the work. You can often see the stuff better than if you were doing it yourself. And the Williamsburg conference is cheaper. $325 for a reception, three breakfasts, every afternoon beer and snacks and one dinner, for a Sunday afternoon to Wednesday afternoon conference. The WIA conference is 395 for a 2 1/2 day conference with two lunches, $445 with one dinner added. The lodging rates are also cheaper in Williamsburg.


Ellis's report

Re: WIA in 2012

#9

In addition....

Bill Tindall

There is the SAPFM summer meeting in Winston Salem and IWF is in Atlanta this year and IWF is but a nominal fee.

WIA has always struck me as pricey for what is largely a vendor show. For the cost of attending two of these events one could take a week class some place. I will guarantee that a week in Headley's shop class will move one up the learning curve much farther and one will leave with a piece of furniture to show for it.

Re: WIA in 2012

#10

Re: WIA

Michael Brady

"I don't think I saw a single bench plane

that I would consider using even if I got it for free." -Warren

Warren, once I read that I knew I needn't read further. Sorry that Konrad Sauer, and Ron Breese aren't up to your standards. But you are right, WIA is not the place for you.

Re: WIA in 2012

#11

Re: WIA

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Michael, I was a little too strong. I was kind of reacting to your suggestion that everyone interested in hand tools needs to be at the conference.

I think the market place is very helpful for those who are buying tools from catalogs or online. It is really worthwhile to hold these things in one's hands and see them in use before buying. And conferences like this are helpful for seeing other woodworkers in action, the pace of their work, their posture and attitudes.

I have tried the Sauer and Brese planes; I use a different type of plane.

Re: WIA in 2012

#12

Michael Donaldson

Re: WIA

Michael Donaldson

I am jumping into this conversation late, and don't really know anything about WIA nor any other conference. But I did note the reference to Sauer and Brese hand planes, so I looked them up....holy cow! Those may be some of the most magnificent hand tools I have ever seen. At around two grand per plane, I can assure you one will never find it's way into my shop, but those are pieces of art. I am blown away.

Re: WIA in 2012

#13

Re: WIA

Pam Niedermayer

those are pieces of art. I am blown away.

Sauer's are beautiful. Pieces of art? I don't know, probably; but my enchantment with infills blew away when I first used a Japanese smoother, fell in love post haste. I expect Warren has his own preferences, as do most of us. Or, spending lots of money doesn't guarantee happiness.

Pam

Re: WIA in 2012

#14

Re: WIA

david weaver

You can certainly take a stab at making one at some point if you're thinking that you need a change of pace from woodworking.

Might not come out looking as polished as konrad or ron's, but you can make a plane that is very pleasant to use, especially if you work a lot of hardwoods (not like walnut and cherry at the lower end of the hardwood scale).

Re: WIA in 2012

#15

Re: WIA in 2012

david weaver

Cincinnati is not that far from me, and for the first time in years, I don't have work commitments that would get in the way. And now that I don't, rather than putting it out of my head as something I don't want to do because I can't due to work, I put it off to the side because it's just something I'm not interested in.

The idea of spending several hundred dollars to go somewhere when I could be woodworking or making tools (which is what I really want to do, anyway) to get information that generally is available in more detail and for better reference elsewhere.

Well, i guess I couldn't see a reason to go other than to look at the new tools, and I'd rather make the tools and build my own skills at this point.

If I want a social aspect, there's already a local club here that includes people who make a living working wood, it's near free, and it comes with a cadre of discounts to just about anything around here, and with suppliers who custom saw wood and bring it to the club.

I just can't see enough from WIA to get me excited, and I'd hate to be there day 1 wishing I was woodworking instead of looking at other people talking about it, and thinking about what $400+ could do for me (it could buy super choice wood and materials to make a long panel plane. A plane warren could never tolerate, but one that I'd love to have).

Just a different perspective. I don't need tools, and the classes there aren't what I want to learn. I think, too, that the wood itself (and metal) has an awful lot to teach someone who is working it, when that someone knows what they want to learn and pays attention to what they're doing. Not a spiritual thing, but a tactile sense of personal learning that you can't get by falling asleep in the back of a lecture.

Re: WIA in 2012

#16

Re: WIA

TomD

I don't think the polishing would be the hard part.

Some planes are just right. I have an infil block plane that will do stuff no other block plane I have will. It is always hard to separate the form from the person who made it and might be able to make a Rali plane sing.

Re: WIA in 2012

#17

Re: WIA in 2012

Michael Brady

I go back to my original question of why this forum would not be as enthusiastic as some others about an opportunity like WIA. I now have some answers based on the subsequent posts.

Those that have attended WIA and found it lacking have answered for themselves. To those who haven't gone and yet have reached conclusions I would suggest considering going and experiencing what is offered. You may not find the tool seller's area of interest, but it is an assemblage of makers that you won't see anywhere else. The classroom sessions, though lacking any kind of real hands-on experience for the attendee, is again populated by a group of presenters unequaled in any other venue. For those who favor period furniture there are some good events and organizations around the country. This is not confined to that discipline, although the SAPFM group plays a big role there. The chief focus is hand tools, their use, the sources for them, and instruction by some of the notable professional teachers, craftsmen, and artists.

Lastly, the opportunity to meet these experts and fellow attendees that you may know only through forums like this one, is great. When you add all of that up, the price is less daunting, and even forgotten in what you can take away in new knowledge and experiences.

Re: WIA in 2012

#18

Ellis Walentine

I'm with you, Michael

Ellis Walentine

I can't give you a definitive answer to your question, but I have attended all the Woodworking in America shows (except the Chicago design show) and I have always enjoyed myself. Of course, for me it's like a reunion, as I can count almost all the vendors and presenters among my friends, not to mention the editors and staff of Popular Wooodworking and their new publisher, Kevin Ireland, who was a colleague of mine at Rodale Press in the 90s. There's another affinity for me, and that is that I was on the original team that created the first WIA show in 1995 in Ft. Washington, PA, under the auspices of American Woodworker magazine.

As far as the quality of the tools, people and knowhow at the show, I must concur that it is top notch. Japanese tools are underrepresented, and I understand Warren's comment about the old American tools that are there for sale, but there are still plenty of good and important tools and makers there, and I never fail to learn something, even if my budget doesn't allow me to buy much.

As for getting together there, I am perfectly amenable to organizing a luncheon or dinner for WoodCentral folks so we can get better acquainted and share our experiences of the show. Somebody say the word, and I'll be on board.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: WIA in 2012

#19

Re: WIA in 2012

david weaver

I understand why other people would like to go, and why other people have liked going.

But those reasons are problems that I don't need to solve or answers to goals that aren't mine (like meeting the presenters, I think I'd rather pick up the phone and talk to george wilson for a couple of hours to get ideas on materials and design, or spend a week in his shop picking his brain and learning).

Same with warren, though warren's never extended the invite. I'm a lot more curious about how warren solves problems than I am about a session on a new way to lay out a mortise and tenon, or the next new guy on the scene who is selling a soup to nuts woodworking course aimed at beginners.

I guess that's the real issue. I have plenty of problems that I want to solve (and I know what they are), such that I don't feel the need or want to go to a bunch of "maybes" right now, even were it 10 miles down the street and a tenth of the cost.

That's not a slight to what WIA is.

But I think if I were going to go somewhere for three days and make a social event out of it, I'd rather play golf.

I think there are a lot more people like me, but they are too polite to talk.

Re: WIA in 2012

#20

I'd go if it didn't cost so much....

Bill Tindall

I don't go to gun shows either. Something about paying to see vendors selling stuff just don't seem right. I don't need to pay to visit Highland Hardware.

I ran this kind of show one time. Admission was free. Vendors got charged what it took to run the show. Attendance was a record, the vendors left pleased and at the time it was the most financially successful show ever done for the non-profit that sponsored it.

As far as the presentations, I have seen some of the same presenters at the summer SAPFM meeting and the class size is 25 people, enabling more interaction with the presentation. To take a specific example, at the SAPFM meeting we got to see the Headley contingent with the Winchester desk, as well as several other pieces and an in depth discussion of drawer construction and several other topics. I have dozens of photographs taken as close as required from that presentation. It was one of 5 seminars for the meeting. The cost was half. For the price of this show we got Headley to bring the desk to a club meeting and spend a day with us.

For the price of that show we can get many people to visit the club for a presentation. For $125 I get to spend a whole day with Will Neptune and 7 other woodworkers in March. For $900 I spent a week in Headley's shop and came home with over 100 photographs, pages of notes, a host of better ways of making stuff learned hands-on and a Federal wall cabinet.

By comparison the value just isn't there for this pricey show compared to other opportunities. But then, I'm frugal.

Re: WIA in 2012

#21

Correction

wilbur

"IWF is in Atlanta this year and IWF is but a nominal fee.

WIA has always struck me as pricey for what is largely a vendor show."

If you only want to go to the vendor part of WIA, it was about $10 or so to get in. The full entrance fee gives you entry into the talks.

I would also say that the characterization of WIA as largely a vendor show is inaccurate as well. I certainly spent some time in the vendor area, but most of my time at WIA was spent at the talks themselves. People who registered for the flu conference also seemed to spend most of the time at the talks rather than the vendor area.

From my point of view, it was worth every penny.